Seeing the title and cool typography, I kindof assumed that this is something that inspired Harry Styles when he wrote his hit song, Watermelon Sugar.
Many people are aware of the confusion around when Harry revealed the hidden, suggestive meaning of the lyrics!
So I read to see if it examined anything related to that.
🤧Spoiler alert::
Nothing was explained.
And this book is not fun in the way the song sounds.
This book has the most confusing, inexplicable plot I have ever read. It is about a society where everyone builds everything out of "Watermelon Sugar" and there is a huge landfill of "Forgotten Works".
What exactly is watermelon sugar, that it makes such a good building material? What does a "forgotten work" look like exactly? How does this unremarkable, annoying, selfish main character have two women fighting over him? What motivates ANY character in this book for these plot points to happen?
I heard someone say that a lot of 'substances' would need to be required to write or enjoy this type of literature.
Anyways, I can't stop you from reading this but I don't recommend it. Please just go read a OneDirection fic on Ao3 and you will enjoy it more. It is under 200 pages if that helps, but the writing style is this "bland on purpose" type of thing that did not work for me in this instance.
... Read moreOkay, so I totally get where you're coming from with 'In Watermelon Sugar'! It sounds like a total head-scratcher, especially when you go in with certain expectations, like thinking it might have a sweet, pop-culture vibe. It's truly disappointing when a book doesn't live up to what you imagined, and it's even worse when the plot feels like a tangled mess.
It’s funny how a title can mislead, isn't it? 'In Watermelon Sugar' by Richard Brautigan is actually a pretty famous example of experimental fiction from the 1960s. It’s known for its surreal, almost dreamlike quality, where the world is literally built from 'watermelon sugar.' This means the book plays with language and structure in ways that can feel really disjointed and confusing if you're expecting a traditional narrative. Some readers actually find this challenging style, with its "chaotic typography and fragmented text," to be part of its charm, seeing it as a commentary on society or a unique artistic expression. But for many, like our original reviewer, it just doesn't click.
If you've ever picked up a book that leaves you utterly baffled, you're definitely not alone! Sometimes, understanding the author's intent or the literary movement it belongs to can help, but other times, a book just isn't for you, and that's perfectly fine. If you find yourself staring at pages wondering 'What even is happening?', here are a few things that might help, or at least help you decide whether to keep going:
Adjust Your Expectations: If you know a book is experimental or non-linear, go in with an open mind, ready for something unconventional. Don't expect a clear beginning, middle, and end.
Do a Quick Background Check: A little research on the author or genre (like surrealism or absurdism) can provide context and might unlock some meaning. You might find out if the "unremarkable, annoying, selfish main character" is intentionally designed that way.
Read Interpretations: Sometimes, reading analyses or discussions online (like on Goodreads or literary blogs) can shed light on what others took from the book. It’s like having a guide for a maze!
It's Okay to DNF (Did Not Finish): Life is too short to read books you genuinely dislike. If it's pure agony, put it down and pick up something you'll actually enjoy. No one is judging your reading choices (except maybe well-meaning literary snobs, but who cares!).
Look for the 'Feeling': With some experimental works, the goal isn't always a clear plot, but rather to evoke a certain mood, atmosphere, or feeling. Try to experience it rather than analyze every detail.
If you're craving something that does have those sweet, catchy vibes that remind you of a Harry Styles song, you might want to try contemporary romance, feel-good fiction, or even some well-written fanfiction on Ao3, as suggested! Books like 'Red, White & Royal Blue' by Casey McQuiston, 'The Love Hypothesis' by Ali Hazelwood, or even older, quirky reads like 'Where'd You Go, Bernadette' by Maria Semple could offer a more straightforwardly entertaining experience.
Ultimately, reading should be a joy, not a chore. If a book doesn't resonate, there are millions of others waiting for you to discover. Your reading journey is personal, so curate it with stories that truly make you happy!
Thanks for the review.