underhyped horror books … if you want nightmares!

i feel lucky that i’m always stumbling into the coolest book recs … and then i’m mad that i don’t have enough people to chat about them with!!

so this is a plea from me to you: read these horror books! they’re both fantastic and both don’t get enough hype in my humble opinion. i love when i read a horror story that’s fresh and interesting, and both of these premises immediately had me hooked.

jackal is a trippy, theatrical, social horror adventure. Black girls have been disappearing into the very spooky woods for decades, but nobody else seems to have noticed or be investigating.

wrath becomes her asks how far would you go to preserve someone’s memory? and what’s the best way to do so - is revenge justified? what are the necessary desecrations you must make to survive? it’s a morally complicated piece with rich character work.

#lemon8partner #lemon8bookclub #horrorbooks #horrorbookrecs #underhypedbooks

2025/6/18 Edited to

... Read moreHorror literature has a wealth of lesser-known titles that are just as gripping as mainstream bestsellers. For instance, 'Jackal' by Erine Adams confronts social issues through a horror lens, exploring the terrifying stories of missing Black girls, while 'Wrath Becomes Her' delves into themes of grief and vengeance, offering a complex blend of emotional depth and suspense. Exploring these books not only enhances your reading experience but also supports diverse voices in the genre. Whether you prefer traditional slasher horror or narratives that intertwine social themes with psychological horror, these books will offer a fresh perspective. Moreover, engaging with underhyped horror literature encourages a richer discussion about representation and innovation within the genre, providing a fulfilling reading journey for both casual readers and dedicated horror fans. Don't miss out on these stories that deserve the spotlight!

Related posts

Scary books that will chill you deeply
These scary book recs are so chilling, you’ll want to watch a Disney movie to still your nerves. Forget Stephen King. This collection of horror and dark thriller book recommendations has some very chilling titles that will scare you oh-so good! Perfect for your TBR list! #horrorbookrecommendati
Thriller Book Recs 2025

Thriller Book Recs 2025

542 likes

A bookshelf filled with various books, with a hand holding two books in the foreground. The text overlay reads "sapphic horror," and a grim reaper emoji is visible. The image promotes sapphic horror books.
A hand holds the book "House of Hollow" by Krystal Sutherland, rated 5 stars. Descriptive text highlights it as "dark, delicious, and disgusting," featuring "sisters that are violently devoted to each other" and "liminal, otherworldly spaces."
A hand holds the book "The Merry Dredgers" by Jeremy C. Shipp, rated 4 stars. Descriptive text mentions a "mysterious meditative cult within a bizarre once-abandoned amusement park," celebrating "sisterly love" and being "weird, clever, and whimsical."
sapphic horror books to chill your bones
These two spine-tingling stories will NOT disappoint. House of Hollow brings fungal horror to life in new, twisted ways. You’ll be able to smell the rot in your nightmares. The Merry Dredgers was not only spooky - but really funny, too! The wry narration and sarcasm really carried this one fo
Steph 📚💫

Steph 📚💫

1386 likes

A cozy scene with a person's legs under a blanket, a black and white cat, and a TV playing a movie, with the overlay text 'DON'T WATCH THESE MOVIES' as a sarcastic title for the movie recommendations.
The movie poster for 'PET,' featuring a woman trapped within a heart-shaped, geometric structure, with the tagline 'A FASCINATING PSYCHOLOGICAL THRILLER' and 'A LOVE STORY.'
A DVD collection cover for the 'I SPIT ON YOUR GRAVE' series, displaying three separate covers for 'I SPIT ON YOUR GRAVE,' 'I SPIT ON YOUR GRAVE 2,' and 'I SPIT ON YOUR GRAVE VENGEANCE IS MINE.'
Unless you want nightmares🔪
okay maybe not nightmares per say BUT these movies really make you sit back and think “who comes up with this kind of stuff?” *all movies available on prime or for free, with ads on tubi* ❗️trigger warning : these movies do deal with sexual assault, murder & over just completely twisted
Rae🌱

Rae🌱

2174 likes

This image introduces a list of underrated fantasy books to add to a TBR, featuring a Kobo e-reader displaying "nicole's library" on a grey textured surface.
A Kobo e-reader displays "Ash Princess" by Laura Sebastian, described as a trilogy with a love triangle, an imprisoned princess reclaiming her throne, and suitable for fans of Red Queen.
A Kobo e-reader shows "Angelfall" by Susan Ee, a trilogy about a girl teaming up with a fallen angel to save her sister during an angel apocalypse, featuring romance and plot.
Underhyped Fantasy Books
I haven’t seen these books talked about.. have you read any of these? #fantasybookrecommendation #booksoflemon8 #lemon8bookclub #readersoflemon8
moodreadswithnicole 📚💭

moodreadswithnicole 📚💭

45 likes

Scary horror books that gave me legit nightmares
These horror books made it hard to sleep. #horrorbookrecommendations #horrorbookreview #horrorbooks #horrorbooktok #scarybooks
Cat Mystery Author

Cat Mystery Author

48 likes

Under Over and Appropriately Hyped Books
Sorry not sorry. #overhypedbooks #booktok #bookrecs
Jaimee 🧚‍♂️ 🐉 🩵

Jaimee 🧚‍♂️ 🐉 🩵

1586 likes

Jeet Kune Do Nightmares...
The big Jeet Kune Do controversy, JKD vs JKD Concepts. Why does that exist? See www.PSDTC.com for more #jeetkunedo #jkd #junfan #junfangungfu #junfanjeetkunedo
RonKosakowski_TFW_PSDTC

RonKosakowski_TFW_PSDTC

1 like

A hand holds a bookmark against pillows, with text overlay "this book will HAUNT YOU" and a ghost emoji, setting a spooky tone for the book discussion.
The front cover of "Fever Dream" by Samanta Schweblin is held, with text overlays indicating a 4.5-star rating, its title relevance, and a brief plot summary.
The back cover of "Fever Dream" is shown, featuring a quote from the book and a recommendation to read it in one sitting, with yellow flowers in the foreground.
do you like books that give you nightmares?
i love books that make me question absolutely everything, and fever dream (by samanta schweblin) is the perfect example. there are no chapter breaks and it’s pretty short (and VERY trippy), so i highly recommend preparing yourself to read it in one sitting. then come back here and tell me ALL of
Steph 📚💫

Steph 📚💫

361 likes

I’d die to read these books again
I think I might have a *slight* book addiction. 😅 Like, I can't walk past a bookstore without going in, and my TBR pile is threatening to take over my entire apartment 🙈 There's just something magical about getting lost in a good story, you know? It's like hitting pause on the real w
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

556 likes

Best fall books for spooky season
I can’t be the only one that loves fall and can’t wait for summer to end. These are just some fall books I highly recommend you guys start purchasing/picking up from your local libraries to get ready for fall. I have a list of books I haven’t read that I want to get to this fall as well so if y
Spookyrevioos

Spookyrevioos

81 likes

over/under/appropriately hyped books 📚
have you read any of these?? if so, what did you think?? #lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookwormsoflemon8 #readersoflemon8 #readingaesthetic #bookrecommendations #BookReview #currentlyreading
Lauren 🪴📚😻

Lauren 🪴📚😻

811 likes

No you’re not Dreaming, the NIGHTMARES are back 😈
#basketball #hoops #ote
YNG Dreamerz

YNG Dreamerz

1656 likes

A computer monitor displays the Steam store, featuring a 'Turn-Based RPG Fest' and 'Warhammer 40,000 Rogue Trader'. Overlaid text highlights 'Steam Horror Games Under $20', with a keyboard and microphone on the desk.
The monitor shows characters from 'Five Nights at Freddy's'. Text identifies it as a singleplayer survival horror game available for $4.99, with a plushie and microphone on the desk.
The monitor displays a scene from 'Devour', showing a character interacting with a glowing figure. Text identifies it as a co-op survival horror game available for $9.99, with a plushie and microphone on the desk.
😱Steam Horror Games Under $20 💀
It’s that time of year! So excited to play some scary games. 😨 🐻Five Nights at Freddy’s: A horror game where players take on the role of a night security guard at Freddy Fazbear's Pizza, a family-friendly restaurant. The player must survive five nights by monitoring the movements of animatro
FloresMagic ✩₊˚

FloresMagic ✩₊˚

112 likes

These nightmares are getting to much 🤣
#couples #funny #relationship
Lemon8er

Lemon8er

68 likes

Horror books to keep you out of the woods…
#horrorbookrecommendations #paranormalthrillerbooks #horrorbookrecs #horrorbookcommunity
lex 🖤

lex 🖤

187 likes

A flat lay of four book covers, 'The Soulmate', 'The Off-Limits Rule', 'The Temporary Roomie', and 'It Only Happens in the Movies', on a white knitted blanket. Blue text reads 'UNDERHYPED BOOKS'.
The cover of 'The Off-Limits Rule' by Sarah Adams on a white blanket, featuring a woman and man with salon equipment. Blue text highlights 'SINGLE MOM', 'FUNNY', 'BANTER', and 'BROTHERS BEST FRIEND'.
The cover of 'The Temporary Roomie' by Sarah Adams on a white blanket, showing a man and a pregnant woman. Blue text highlights 'PRANK WARS', 'FAKE DATING', 'ENEMIES-LOVERS', and 'FORCED PROXIMITY'.
under hyped books you need to read! 🤩🌟
some of these books have had a moment, but definitely not enough for how good they really are. my reviews: ✨ the off limits rule here’s a series of emojis to explain how I felt when reading this: 🫧🤍🫶🏼🥺🦋 this was the cutest shit ever. all of you who are hating on this book can have your
kalees reads

kalees reads

21 likes

An open book showing text from 'Crying in H Mart' with a red sticker overlaying 'UNDERHYPED BOOKS you'll never see online'. The text describes H Mart as a place where people gather, searching for a piece of themselves.
The book cover for 'The House in the Cerulean Sea' by TJ Klune, featuring a house on a cliff. A pink star indicates a 4.4 rating, with text describing the book as comforting and making the reader feel soft and different.
The book cover for 'Crying in H Mart: A Memoir' by Michelle Zauner, with a red background and white noodles forming an 'H'. A pink star shows a 4.5 rating, and text describes it as raw, lyrical, and true.
3 underhyped books I will always recommend
The underrated books that changed little pieces of me…. I’m that friend who will quietly shove a book into your hands and say, “Just trust me.” 😌 These books didn’t come with hype. No huge marketing campaigns. No constant TikToks. But they stayed with me way longer than a lot of "trendy&
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

46 likes

little nightmares
#littlenightmares #nailart #nailartist #pressonnails
ty

ty

2632 likes

A woman and a white tiger stand on a cliff overlooking a lush jungle with waterfalls under a dramatic sky. The text overlay reads 'Books that aren't talked about enough'.
A stack of books, with 'Tiger's Curse' by Colleen Houck on top, featuring a white tiger's face. Text describes the fantasy series about a girl and a shape-shifting tiger.
The book cover for 'The Wake Trilogy' by Lisa McMann, featuring a white cloth floating. Text describes the series about Janie Hannagan, a girl who can enter people's dreams.
Books that aren’t talked about enough
What books do you think are under hyped? #underratedauthors #books 📚 #lemon8bookclub #Lemon8Diary #booktok
✨📚CulliferBooks📚✨

✨📚CulliferBooks📚✨

15 likes

books I want to buy 🛍️
here are a few books that stood out to me when i visited Target’s book section! I have these on my list to get soon and maybe go back for! let me know your thoughts on these if you’ve read any! 💌 #lemon8partner #lemon8bookclub #targetbooks #bookhaul #targetfinds2023
Alli Beachy 🤍

Alli Beachy 🤍

88 likes

Black Authored Horror Books
Black-authored horror has a way of getting under your skin without relying on spectacle. These stories sit in dread, grief, rage, and paranoia. This list leans into horror that feels heavy. The kind where the fear isn’t just what’s happening on the page, but what it says about power, survival,
Bunni

Bunni

184 likes

Black Horror Books 🎃
I know it's fall but these books takes place in the summer. Read at your own risk 💀 . . . #blackhorrorbooks #horrorbookrecs #halloween2025 #spookyreads #blackbooks
ireadblackbooks

ireadblackbooks

252 likes

Spooky Books Recs Not Trending on BookTok
It’s still spooky season, so more spooky book recs! I went a little haywire with this one with some non traditional spooky books. I get so tired of seeing the same books recommended over and over again. So here’s some weird but still scary books for you to check out! If you can’t read t
quinnireadssome

quinnireadssome

279 likes

Do you like books that give you nightmares?
One of Us Knows will definitely have you grabbing the pages! #booksbyblackwomen #blackhorror #blackauthor #blackgirllemon8 #horrorbook
Ebbie 😇

Ebbie 😇

14 likes

Your State’s Horror Book
From haunted houses to eerie wilderness, every state has its own chilling tales that will keep you up at night. Whether you’re a horror enthusiast or just looking for your next spine-tingling read, we’ve curated a list of horror books set in all 50 states. Get ready to dive into this nationwide tou
Melilina🍓

Melilina🍓

704 likes

I read 10 books in one day?! 🫢📚
I read for 24 hours straight (!!!) and finished 10 books! ‼️🚨The full vlog of my day is now live on my YouTube channel! 🚨‼️ I’ve attempted (and failed) this challenge twice before, so I’m happy to report that third times the charm! In 24 hours I was able to read 10 books (I had already starte
Bethany Taylor

Bethany Taylor

513 likes

Democrats' nightmares will last more than 3 years
Democrats your nightmares will last more than 3 years
nikoalexopoulos

nikoalexopoulos

0 likes

Dog’s Reaction to His Sister Having Nightmares
GamjaChip 🥔

GamjaChip 🥔

2230 likes

I really didn’t expect this horror game to be made
Game name: "Substitute" Platform: Steam Game introduction🎮: - A legend about a ghost in the campus swimming pool It triggered a series of dramatic stories Game advantages and disadvantages🎨: - ✔️Junji Ito style horror visual novel game ✔There are multiple branch endings to choo
Jing.game

Jing.game

119 likes

Under hyped contemporary romance books that deserve more hype 
Drop your under hyped book recs in the comments #romancebookrecs #romancebookrecommendations #contemporaryromance #contemporaryromancereads
Contemporary Romance Books

Contemporary Romance Books

4 likes

Poetry - Diary Entry # 2. I Have Nightmares.
#poem #nightmares #story #love
DiariesBornDead

DiariesBornDead

1 like

A title image for "Cute Annotations On books" featuring a hand-drawn magic wand with the text "For the ones who still believe in magic" and sparkling stars on a white background.
An open book page with various sections of text highlighted in yellow, blue, and green, adorned with hand-drawn blue hearts and butterflies around the text.
An open book page from "A COURT OF MIST AND FURY" with text highlighted in purple and yellow, decorated with hand-drawn yellow stars. Two highlighters are visible on the right.
Annotations books ✨
Just do it You gonna love it 😍 #astheticbooks #annotating #read #reading #readingaesthetic
Ivonne Evangelista

Ivonne Evangelista

321 likes

Teacher Nightmares
I love telling my horror stories! #teacher #specialeducationteacher #spedteacher #teacherhumor #teachercomedy
primarilyfunny

primarilyfunny

0 likes

A person wearing a white mask is shown with text overlay 'Books so dark I wudn't look another human in the eye for a full 24 hrs after'. The Lemon8 logo is visible.
A person with a mask features the book 'Darker Than Fiction' by Winston Thomas, about real historical atrocities including T*rture and C*nnibalism, with a red skull cover.
A person with a mask features 'The Butcher's Wife' by TJ Law, a thriller about a woman tracking her husband and a brutal killer, with a dark silhouette cover.
Very good dark books
Here are some unputdownable dark reads for your TBR! #crimefiction #mysterybooks #scarybooks #crimebooks #bookrecommendations
Cat Mystery Author

Cat Mystery Author

22 likes

Fantasy books that I think are under hyped
Sword and Verse: Unique world building, great romantic subplot, and non-stop adventure ✨ If you like high fantasy, but want something a bit short, this book is for you. There is another book in the series but can function as a standalone. Servant falls in love with the prince plot Cruel beauty:
Vanessa Reina

Vanessa Reina

3 likes

No Nightmares Here
My husband & I were just discussing, that happiness comes from the inside - despite any and all outside circumstances 😌 #fyp #stoic #philosophy #mindfulness #innerpeace New York
HolySpiritWithin777

HolySpiritWithin777

0 likes

Stacked with screams—my latest horror book haul
A tower of terror just landed on my shelf. From cursed motels to sunken nightmares, this haul is packed with every flavor of fear. If you’ve read any of these, drop your favorite scream scene below. If not… maybe don’t read them alone. 👁‍🗨 Let the haunting begin. 💀 Titles in the stack: – Ap
The Reading Coven

The Reading Coven

84 likes

Black Summer horror books part 2
see full video on tiktok 🩷 @ireadblackbooks Books mentioned: The Good House - Tananarive Due Thunderland - Brandon Massey The Blonde Dies First - Joelle Wellington Hide and Seeker - Daka Hermon Camp Lanier - Sylvester Barzay *check content/trigger warnings* #blackhorror #horrorb
ireadblackbooks

ireadblackbooks

159 likes

Overhyped, underhyped & appropriately hyped books!
#bookrrcommendations #books #reading #lemon8 #lemon8bookclub
Bliss📚🫶🏼

Bliss📚🫶🏼

4 likes

You won’t be able to sleep after these books🖤🤌
If you want to give your nightmares nightmares, l've got you covered. • Yellowface by R.F. Kuang is a nauseating deep dive into publishing and power. What happens when a white author steals a Chinese author's manuscript ... and publishes it under her own name? • It'll cause you phys
(☆Boo𝙺diaries(☆

(☆Boo𝙺diaries(☆

16 likes

Overhyped, under hyped & right amount hyped books!
Overhyped: - The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides - The Local Woman Missing by Mary Kubica - A thousand Boy Kisses by Tillie Cole Appropriately hyped: - The last Letter by Rebecca Yarros - The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins Reid - The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah Un
K.

K.

18 likes

A hand holds open a book on a bed with a brown blanket. White text overlays read "OVER, UNDER, & APPROPRIATELY hyped books pt. 2." A green arrow points from "hyped books" downwards. The Lemon8 logo and username are in the bottom left.
The book cover for "Beware the Woman" by Megan Abbott is centered on an open book. White text overlays read "OVER HYPED" at the top and "so many people raved about this one, but I found it confusing and super slow" at the bottom. The Lemon8 logo and username are visible.
The book cover for "The Shadows" by Alex North is centered on an open book. White text overlays read "OVER HYPED" at the top and "the characters felt flat, the plot was hard to follow, and the ending was a let down" at the bottom. The Lemon8 logo and username are visible.
over/under/appropriately hyped books 📚
time for round 2!! books I thought were over, under, or appropriately hyped on social 🤷🏼‍♀️ honestly it was hard for me to pick over hyped books because if I don't like them I usually just DNF them, but these were two that were so highly rated I figured they would get better in the end (the
Lauren 🪴📚😻

Lauren 🪴📚😻

26 likes

CHRISTIAN TIPS TO STOP NIGHTMARES‼️
After years of struggling with nightmares, here are tips that has helped me overcome them! Would you like night prayers? What teachings would you like to see next? Let me know in the comments 😊 Save and come back to it when needed:) Join me in my ministry for brides in waiting 💕 #ch
Shalom

Shalom

35 likes

See more