Knitting This Yarn Felt Like Using Dental Floss 😭🧶

Knit vs Crochet Test

Continuing my knit vs crochet swatch series using Cotton Kings Sultan Shadow (Red) and wow… crocheting this yarn is a dream but knitting with 2.75mm needles felt like I was stitching with dental floss 😅

I dropped so many stitches and still need to master fixing dropped stitches properly — twisted stitches and holes everywhere lol.

Crochet granny stitch though? PERFECTION ❤️

This is actually one of my favorite yarns ever — I even made a hexagon cardigan with it and wear it all the time.

Which do you think shows this yarn better: knit or crochet?

#KnittingVsCrochet

#YarnReview

#CrochetVsKnit

#FiberArtist

2/22 Edited to

... Read moreI’ve been experimenting with different yarns over time to find the best fit for my knitting and crochet projects. The Cotton Kings Sultan Shadow yarn, especially in the striking Red color, stands out because of its smoothness and color vibrancy. When I tried knitting with this yarn on 2.75mm needles, it felt unusually thin and slippery—almost like working with dental floss. This made controlling stitches more difficult, and I often dropped stitches, leading to frustrating holes and twisted loops. Fixing these mistakes was a bit tricky, but I’m learning patience and new techniques as I go. On the other hand, crocheting with the same yarn was a pleasant surprise. The texture allowed my hook to glide smoothly, making granny stitch patterns look beautifully defined and consistent. It’s clear that this yarn lends itself more naturally to crochet, which might be ideal for crafters looking for standout stitch definition in their work. From my personal experience, a yarn’s interaction with the chosen needle or hook size dramatically affects the ease and outcome of your project. With Cotton Kings Sultan Shadow, using slightly larger knitting needles might ease the knitting process by providing more room for the stitches, potentially reducing dropped stitches. The versatility of this yarn truly shines when you consider projects like the hexagon cardigan I made, which I wear often. Its durability and comfort make it a favorite for shaping cozy, visually appealing garments. If you’re deciding between knitting or crocheting with this yarn, consider your comfort with handling fine, slippery yarns and what final texture you want. Crochet seems more forgiving and showcases the yarn’s color gradients beautifully, but with some practice and possibly adjusting needle size, knitting could yield lovely results too. Have you tried this yarn or a similar one? I’d love to hear what your go-to stitch is and how you manage tricky yarns in your projects.

4 comments

Patricia's images
Patricia

I love crocheting with this yarn. I'm with you on the feel and dropped stitches, I get that when I knit with it too. I also think it just looks better in crochet. 😍

See more(3)