When Hyped Books Disappoint

2025/9/1 Edited to

... Read moreWe've all been there—excitedly diving into a book everyone's raving about, only to realize halfway through that it's just 'mid' and not living up to the hype. This widespread feeling is humorously captured in popular memes like "Me after reading the latest 'must-read' and realizing it's mid," reflecting the collective disappointment many readers experience. These moments highlight how social media trends, especially on platforms like #BookTokMadeMeDoIt, can create unrealistic expectations. The frustration arises because hype often sets a high bar, sometimes fueled more by viral popularity than actual literary quality. Readers investing their time and emotional energy into these books expect to be enthralled but end up feeling let down, questioning the collective judgment of the community—"IT'S JUST EVERYONE KNOWS EVERYBODY IS SO STUPID AND THEY ALL"—expresses that humorous disbelief shared among readers. Conversations in online #BookCommunity spaces reveal that this experience, while disappointing, is also a bonding moment for readers. Sharing which #OverhypedBooks failed to deliver can be cathartic and helps others manage their expectations. It also underlines the value of critical reading and personal taste over mass recommendations. Some readers find joy in the #BookishHumor around these situations, turning the letdown into a lighthearted joke rather than a cause for dismay. Ultimately, the best approach is to embrace the diversity of opinions and remember that not every book will resonate with you. The #ReadersLife is full of surprises, and sometimes the most anticipated reads become stepping stones to discovering hidden gems that truly suprise and delight. So next time you pick up a "must-read" and it’s just mid, you’re not alone—welcome to the shared reader experience.

Related posts

An overhead shot displays three books on a dark surface with a plant, featuring "My Year of Rest and Relaxation" and "A Certain Hunger." The image is overlaid with the text "books with UNHINGED WOMEN," introducing a selection of books about female rage and unhinged characters.
The book "My Year of Rest and Relaxation" by Ottessa Moshfegh is shown on a white bedsheet, accompanied by text describing it as a raw depiction of depression where a young woman attempts to sleep for a year. It is rated 4.5 stars.
The book "A Certain Hunger" by Chelsea G Summers is displayed on a white bedsheet. Text describes it as a story about a food critic who is a serial killer, leading to her conviction, and calls it "the most unhinged book."
books with unhinged women🤪
books about female rage and unhinged women? sign me up!!! 🙋🏻‍♀️ these are probably my top book recommendations of that topic! these are all super different and unique from each other plot wise and I enjoyed all of these in different ways. Something about reading about an unhinged, unapologetic m
Alli Beachy 🤍

Alli Beachy 🤍

2795 likes

A hand holds a drink over a background of autumn leaves. Text reads "BOOKS THEY DON'T WANT YOU TO READ" with emojis of a dizzy face, stacked books, and a no entry sign, indicating controversial or forbidden literature.
The book cover for "Nineteen Eighty-Four" by George Orwell is displayed on a white textured background, surrounded by descriptive words like "Terrifying," "Prophetic," and "Bleak," with a summary box below.
The book cover for "The Satanic Verses" by Salman Rushdie is shown on a white textured background, accompanied by words such as "Daring," "Dreamlike," and "Controversial," with a summary box beneath.
Books they don’t want you to read
Ever heard of "banned books"? They're the ones that sparked outrage, controversy, and even fear. Some were considered too dangerous, too radical, or too revealing. But here's the thing... they're also often the most thought-provoking, eye-opening, and downright fascinating reads
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

2926 likes

📚 Books I’m Scared to Read 🫣
Less that I’m scared to read them, more that I’m intimidated to start them 😅🫣 Whether it’s because they’re really long books/series, or because they’re insanely hyped up, these are my daunting physical TBR books… - #lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge #Lemon8Diary #letschat #tbr
carmen 📚

carmen 📚

655 likes

Duology Books that Deserve more Hype
I love these duology books and I don’t see them hyped enough! If you’re looking for a smaller commitment than reading a long series here ya go! They all fall under the fantasy realm with some being spicy like Blood Orange and Nectar of the Wicked 😉 #BookReview #bookrecommendations #lemon8book
Arlyn

Arlyn

70 likes

Criminally under hyped dark romance books
#dark romance #books #booksoflemon8
Heather Deneice 🖤 | Bookish

Heather Deneice 🖤 | Bookish

83 likes

This image introduces a list of underrated fantasy books to add to a TBR, featuring a Kobo e-reader displaying "nicole's library" on a grey textured surface.
A Kobo e-reader displays "Ash Princess" by Laura Sebastian, described as a trilogy with a love triangle, an imprisoned princess reclaiming her throne, and suitable for fans of Red Queen.
A Kobo e-reader shows "Angelfall" by Susan Ee, a trilogy about a girl teaming up with a fallen angel to save her sister during an angel apocalypse, featuring romance and plot.
Underhyped Fantasy Books
I haven’t seen these books talked about.. have you read any of these? #fantasybookrecommendation #booksoflemon8 #lemon8bookclub #readersoflemon8
moodreadswithnicole 📚💭

moodreadswithnicole 📚💭

45 likes

over/under/appropriately hyped books 📚
have you read any of these?? if so, what did you think?? #lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookwormsoflemon8 #readersoflemon8 #readingaesthetic #bookrecommendations #BookReview #currentlyreading
Lauren 🪴📚😻

Lauren 🪴📚😻

813 likes

The image displays four books, two light purple and two light yellow, standing upright with a black ribbon on one. Overlay text reads "BOOKS THAT I AM TOO SCARED TO READ," introducing a list of intimidating books.
Features the book "Haunting Adeline" by H.D. Carlton, with its dark, skull-adorned cover. A list of tropes includes "Stalker," "Dark Romance," and "Possessive MMC," accompanied by a user's note about trigger warnings.
Displays the book "Archer's Voice" by Mia Sheridan, featuring a blue cover with dandelions. Tropes like "Small Town," "Tortured Souls," and "Friends to Lovers" are listed, with a user's comment about the book's hype.
books that intimidate me
books i’m too afraid/can’t bring myself to read — have you read any of these? if so convince me 😭 — save for later 🫶 #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge
mads

mads

14K likes

An under-hyped book….
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This was an easy 5 star read for me - A cozy read - A broken relationship - A brand new friendship - Quaint little town And did I mention???? - A fuzzy spider named Ralph who constantly smiles This book stole my heart. #underhypedbooks #fyp #BookReview #lemon8bookclub
shannell fisher

shannell fisher

239 likes

Short books (that will leave an impact) 📚
If you're looking for some quick but powerful reads, here you go! These books are short but will leave a mark long after you finish them. Whether you're in the mood for a love story, some deep reflections on life, or something a little magical, here’s what I’m loving lately: 📚 How Not to
Lee | Booktok

Lee | Booktok

455 likes

Under Over and Appropriately Hyped Books
Sorry not sorry. #overhypedbooks #booktok #bookrecs
Jaimee 🧚‍♂️ 🐉 🩵

Jaimee 🧚‍♂️ 🐉 🩵

1606 likes

A bookshelf filled with various books, with a hand holding two books in the foreground. The text overlay reads "sapphic horror," and a grim reaper emoji is visible. The image promotes sapphic horror books.
A hand holds the book "House of Hollow" by Krystal Sutherland, rated 5 stars. Descriptive text highlights it as "dark, delicious, and disgusting," featuring "sisters that are violently devoted to each other" and "liminal, otherworldly spaces."
A hand holds the book "The Merry Dredgers" by Jeremy C. Shipp, rated 4 stars. Descriptive text mentions a "mysterious meditative cult within a bizarre once-abandoned amusement park," celebrating "sisterly love" and being "weird, clever, and whimsical."
sapphic horror books to chill your bones
These two spine-tingling stories will NOT disappoint. House of Hollow brings fungal horror to life in new, twisted ways. You’ll be able to smell the rot in your nightmares. The Merry Dredgers was not only spooky - but really funny, too! The wry narration and sarcasm really carried this one fo
Steph 📚💫

Steph 📚💫

1400 likes

an underhyped fantasy series you need to read
The Mirror Visitor Quartet was big on TikTok a few years ago, but I hardly see anyone pick it up or talk about it anymore 😭 This series follows Ophelia, our quirky and smart main character who can travel through mirrors and “read” the history of objects when she touches them, and Thorn, our math
Maddy

Maddy

492 likes

Books That Deserve More Hype
Some of my favorites that people don’t talk about nearly enough! 1. Windy City Series by Liz Tomforde This series is so so good! 5⭐️ all around. One of the romance series I can’t stop thinking about! 2. Cane Brothers Series by Meghan Quinn How are these not talked about more!? Amazing roman
Khloemyers

Khloemyers

1314 likes

An open book showing text from 'Crying in H Mart' with a red sticker overlaying 'UNDERHYPED BOOKS you'll never see online'. The text describes H Mart as a place where people gather, searching for a piece of themselves.
The book cover for 'The House in the Cerulean Sea' by TJ Klune, featuring a house on a cliff. A pink star indicates a 4.4 rating, with text describing the book as comforting and making the reader feel soft and different.
The book cover for 'Crying in H Mart: A Memoir' by Michelle Zauner, with a red background and white noodles forming an 'H'. A pink star shows a 4.5 rating, and text describes it as raw, lyrical, and true.
3 underhyped books I will always recommend
The underrated books that changed little pieces of me…. I’m that friend who will quietly shove a book into your hands and say, “Just trust me.” 😌 These books didn’t come with hype. No huge marketing campaigns. No constant TikToks. But they stayed with me way longer than a lot of "trendy&
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

47 likes

Books that don’t get enough love on Booktok🥺
Okay so after looking at my bookshelf I’ve come to realize I really only have read popular booktok books😬. I have plans to change that. Anyyyywayyy, these are some books that I have read that I feel like they could use more love and hype within the booktok community: A Photo Finish by Elsie
Angelina🫶🏻

Angelina🫶🏻

201 likes

A close-up of several book spines with a white overlay stating "3 FANTASY ROMANCE BOOKS YOU NEED TO ADD TO YOUR TBR." The spines feature intricate designs, including an octopus, letters, and dragons.
A hand holds the book "The Secrets of Jane Forgotten" by Charlotte Mallory, featuring a dark cover with a skull and red roses. Text overlays highlight themes like "Morally Gray MMC," "Pirates," "Dark," and "True Enemies to Lovers."
A hand holds the book "Fourth Wing" by Rebecca Yarros, which has a gold cover with a circular design and a dragon silhouette. Text overlays point out themes such as "Disability Rep," "War College," "Forced Proximity," and "Dragons."
Fantasy Romance Books to add to your TBR
Fantasy Romance Books to add to your TBR All these books are New Adult fantasy romance! Secret of Jane by Charlotte Mallory Blub: My village is aflame, and a deadly legend becomes my captor. I’m to appear before the most elite faction of mercenaries and warlords, commanded to answer for
Kaylee

Kaylee

739 likes

A hand holds a stack of three books, with the text "UNDER-HYPED BOOKS" prominently displayed above them.
A hand holds the book "Maggie Moves On" by Lucy Score, featuring its cover and a synopsis about house-flipping sensation Maggie Nichols.
A hand holds the book "Still Beating" by Jennifer Hartmann, displaying its cover with a heart locket and a synopsis about Cora Lawson's ordeal.
Books That Deserve More Hype!!!
Here are some books that are not talked about nearly enough… 1. Maggie Moves On by Lucy Score I love absolutely everything that I have read by Lucy score. This book doesn’t get enough hype! 2. Still Beating by Jennifer Hartmann This dark romance/thriller will have you on the edge of your s
Khloemyers

Khloemyers

432 likes

An open book on a white bedspread displays an illustration of a man and a woman in a bedroom, with the text "books i will always defend" on the left page.
A hand holds the book "Wildfire" by Hannah Grace, featuring a cabin illustration. Annotations highlight "one night stand," "golden retriever mmc," and "healing," along with a quote from the book.
A hand holds the book "Shutout" by Avery Keelan, depicting a couple kissing. Annotations indicate "brothers best friend," "soft only for her," and "roommates," accompanied by a quote.
underrated romance books
like/save for later <3 🔥wildfire: everyone says this book is boring compared to icebreaker but i loved it so much, i thought it was such a sweet love story. i loved both the fmc and mmc & side characters. he’s so soft n sweet but has a dirty mouth ugh i love russ sm. idk what it was but
mads

mads

1289 likes

A white bookshelf displays various books, including "May A Divine Awaken" and "This Land Is Our Land." The shelf also features a green crocheted dinosaur and a LEGO-style dinosaur figure, adding a playful touch to the book collection.
A hand holds the book "This Land Is Our Land," featuring a cover with a person looking at a glowing sky. An overlay describes the plot: tensions over immigration, a white supremacist path, and real aliens invading. Sunflowers are visible in the background.
A hand holds the book "May A Divine Awaken," depicting a young person with vitiligo in a uniform on the cover. An overlay explains the story: a soldier with vitiligo discovers hidden powers and uncovers family secrets. Sunflowers are in the background.
underhyped books you should read!
i went through my goodreads and picked out a couple of books that somehow have fewer than 200 ratings!! you all need to pick them up and fall in love with them, because they deserve to have more eyes on their pages. which one intrigues you more? #lemon8partner #lemon8bookclub #under
Steph 📚💫

Steph 📚💫

27 likes

books i read in january: part 1
i finished 15 books in january!!! all of these are really good reads. i’m definitely on a thriller kick & these books did not disappoint. the only book that wasn’t quite a thriller was “the girls in the stilt house”, but still a really good read. it has notes of mystery, but not really thrillin
aude jones

aude jones

826 likes

A stack of popular books including 'Hidden Pictures', 'A Study in Drowning', and 'Powerless' is shown with overlay text that reads 'POPULAR BOOKS THAT I DO NOT RECOMMEND'.
A hand holds the book 'Powerless' by Lauren Roberts, rated with three stars. The accompanying text criticizes the book's 'dislike to lovers' trope, cringe banter, and derivative plot, expressing disappointment.
A hand holds 'The Silent Patient' by Alex Michaelides, rated with three stars. The text criticizes the book's plot twist, stating it ruined the story and overshadowed the main character, leading to a disappointing read.
save ur time & money on these books 😬
OMG these books were my absolute favorites!!! [EXTREMELY LOUD INCORRECT BUZZER NOISE] Seriously though, I really disliked all of these. I won’t say I hated them (except maybe Hidden Pictures) but I do have strong negative feelings about them, mostly because a lot of them were extremely hyped up
molly

molly

356 likes

Booktok books that are worth it
#booktok #bookaesthetic #recommendations
Kathryn

Kathryn

717 likes

underhyped horror books … if you want nightmares!
i feel lucky that i’m always stumbling into the coolest book recs … and then i’m mad that i don’t have enough people to chat about them with!! so this is a plea from me to you: read these horror books! they’re both fantastic and both don’t get enough hype in my humble opinion. i love when i read
Steph 📚💫

Steph 📚💫

19 likes

The image features a stack of books with the overlay text "BookTok books I don't like." It includes decorative book and sparkle icons, along with a Lemon8 watermark.
The book cover for "The Silent Patient" by Alex Michaelides is displayed on a pink fuzzy blanket. The image includes a 2/5 star rating and comments "SLOW" and "PREDICTABLE."
The book cover for "We Were Liars" by E. Lockhart is shown on a pink fuzzy blanket. The image includes a 1/5 star rating and comments "boring" and "main girl is so annoying."
popular books I don’t like 🤷🏻‍♀️
Here are three popular books I just didn’t care for. Most of them were okay just way too overhyped which led to me being dissappinted. 😕 Let me know your opinions on these books, and also any other popular books you don’t like. ❓❔ #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #bookrecommendations
elyssa🎀📚

elyssa🎀📚

707 likes

Three books, Mistborn, A River Enchanted, and Powerless, are displayed on a gray background with text overlays indicating an 'OVER HYPED, UNDER HYPED & ACCURATELY HYPED book' and a 'SWIPE' arrow.
The book 'Powerless' by Lauren Roberts is shown with a pink box stating it's an 'OVERHYPED BOOK' due to feeling like other books, having unflushed parts, and an unliked writing style.
The book 'A River Enchanted' by Rebecca Ross is displayed with an orange box stating it's an 'UNDER HYPED BOOK' that is good and atmospheric, encouraging more readers.
How hyped do you think these reads should be?
My take on the over hyped, under hyped, and accurately hyped trend. My over hyped book: Powerless by Lauren Roberts. I feel like I’ve said this in several posts now at this point but this book I just WAY too overhyped. It says great for fans of red queen and the hunger games… But this is just a
SB Allred

SB Allred

111 likes

Dark romance books for your tbr 🖤📚
#darkromancerecommendations #darkromancebooks #darkromance #booktok #darkromancerecs
Ty ❤️‍🔥

Ty ❤️‍🔥

4511 likes

A stack of books with white pages visible, against a gray wall with white text that reads "Books that are Under Hyped" and star doodles. Lemon8 user tags are at the bottom.
A hand holds three books from the "Windy City Series" by Liz Tomforde: "Caught Up," "The Right Move," and "Mile High." Text describes the series as interconnected standalones about Chicago sports teams.
Three books from the "Cane Brothers Series" by Meghan Quinn are stacked on a white stool. The books are "Not So Meet Cute," "Meant to Be," and "A Time Coming." Text describes the series' tropes.
These books deserve more hype!!! 😤
Want to add a new series to your TBR, but tired of getting the same recommendations? If that sounds like you, @Khloemyers has got your back with this collection of under-hyped book recs! 🤩 Have you read any of these? What other books/series do you think deserve more hype? Let us know in the co
Lemon8 Book Club

Lemon8 Book Club

176 likes

The image features Tate McRae lying down, with a stack of books and a blurred background. Text overlays announce 'SO CLOSE TO WHAT' ALBUM AS BOOKS, indicating a book-themed interpretation of the album.
Tate McRae performs on stage, surrounded by a crowd. Book covers for 'Hollow Heathens' and 'The Fabric of Our Souls' are displayed, corresponding to the song titles 'REVOLVING DOOR' and 'I KNOW LOVE'.
Tate McRae performs on stage, kneeling and holding a microphone. Book covers for 'Reckless' by Elsie Silver and 'Nightshade' by Kerri Lake are shown, linked to the song titles 'IT'S OKAY I'M OKAY' and 'DEAR GOD'.
Tate’s New Album As Books✨🎤📖
I’m scared of the person I’ll become blasting this album in the car on my way to work. 🤣🤣 If you haven’t listened to this album, WHAT ARE YOU DOING?!?! Miss Tate McRae didn’t disappoint. Every single song is amazing!! ✨💋 #books #bookaesthetic #bookrecommendations #reading #tatemcrae
linds

linds

101 likes

I’d die to read these books again
I think I might have a *slight* book addiction. 😅 Like, I can't walk past a bookstore without going in, and my TBR pile is threatening to take over my entire apartment 🙈 There's just something magical about getting lost in a good story, you know? It's like hitting pause on the real w
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

559 likes

BOOKS THAT DESERVE MORE HYPE 🤩
Who else loves discovering underhyped books? Check out this great post from @emmalouisebooks who shares some of her favorite less-popular reads. I’m definitely guilty of putting together my TBR list from the books I see constantly on Lemon8 and TikTok, so it’s always refreshing to see new
Lemon8 Book Club

Lemon8 Book Club

204 likes

An open book with the title 'BOOKS THAT MADE ME SOB' in bright pink and yellow text. A hand with black and pink French tip nails holds the book, which rests on a white textured surface.
A hand holds the book 'LEAVES MAY FALL' with a dark forest cover featuring green leaves. A '5/5' star rating is at the top. The text describes it as a heartbreaking, top-tier found family fantasy.
A hand holds the book 'City of SALVATION' by Marie Maravilla, with a dark cover featuring a skull, snakes, and a black rose. A '5/5' star rating is at the top. The text praises its deep romance and relatable characters.
Books that made me sob
Guys I’m a huge baby when it comes to books making me cry. But a book can’t just make me cry for it to make it to this list. These are just books that had me sobbing so hard I was hiccuping. These are books I would get tattooed on my heart. There are certain topics that hit me extra hard and these
Spookyrevioos

Spookyrevioos

99 likes

please read these fantasy books!
what underhyped fantasy book would you recommend? if you’re tired of seeing some of the same book recommendations over and over, i’ve got you covered. the ballad of perilous graves, beasts of prey, and the darkening are just a handful of books that don’t get as much attention as they should!
Steph 📚💫

Steph 📚💫

359 likes

Romance books I love
I normally don’t read romance books but I got into a bit of a fantasy runt lately so I started buying a bunch of romance books and started reading them in between all my fantasy reads. Here are some that I’m absolutely obsessed with and would recommend everyone pick up: 💙It Happened One Summ
Spookyrevioos

Spookyrevioos

103 likes

A bookstore display featuring a 'bookTok Trending' banner and 'Trending Books' sections. Shelves are organized by 'Young Adult', 'Cowboy & Western', and 'Paranormal' genres, showcasing various popular titles like 'Keeping 13' and 'Muscles & Monsters'.
A bookstore display with a 'bookTok For You Page' banner. Shelves feature numerous books including 'The Gravewood', 'Heartless Hunter', 'Bloodmarked', 'Girl in Pieces', 'We'll Always Have Summer', 'Six Crimson Cranes', 'Scythe', and 'Wolf Girl'.
A bookstore shelf displaying various books, including 'You Could See The Sun', 'Radiant Curse', 'Family of Liars', 'We Were Liars', 'Seven Faceless Saints', 'The Giver', 'Skyhunter', 'Dragonfruit', and 'Love at Second Sight'.
Books To Buy At Books•A•Million 📚🫶🏼
Is there any better feeling than wandering the aisles of Books-A-Million with a coffee in hand? ☕📖 I stopped in today to see what’s currently trending, and the selection did not disappoint 🛍️📚 #trendingbooks #booksamillion #booktok #bookstoread #booktok
Justine Marie Carter | Inspo ✨

Justine Marie Carter | Inspo ✨

287 likes

Books to Read to Form Heathy Habits with Self
✨Living Courageously Great book on doing things even if you feel you aren’t ready. Doing things “afraid”and living in courage! ✨Living Beyond Your Feelings Great book on triggers. Living beyond what you feel like doing or not doing. Controlling your emotions so they don’t control you.
Iambrittshanice

Iambrittshanice

164 likes

Overhyped, under hyped & right amount hyped books!
Overhyped: - The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides - The Local Woman Missing by Mary Kubica - A thousand Boy Kisses by Tillie Cole Appropriately hyped: - The last Letter by Rebecca Yarros - The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins Reid - The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah Un
K.

K.

18 likes

Books I’m Hyped About: Black Authors Edition ✨📚
Recently, I have been paying more attention to the “new/ upcoming releases.” Although I am typically not a “Booktok” girlie, we have some pretty exciting books releasing this year! I purchased Honey + Spice,recently— so to find out there will be another book in the series makes me so happy! A
Meg 🫶🏾

Meg 🫶🏾

117 likes

See more