When Someone Calls My Favorite Book “Mid” 🙄📚

2025/9/8 Edited to

... Read moreIt's incredibly relatable when you recommend a book you absolutely adore, only to have someone label it as "mid"—meaning average or mediocre. This reaction can feel disheartening, especially when a book holds deep personal meaning or has had a significant impact on your reading journey. But this experience also highlights how subjective reading preferences are and how diverse opinions enrich the book community. When a book is called "mid," it often reflects the reader's taste or expectations rather than an absolute judgment on the book's quality. There are many reasons why someone might feel a book doesn't resonate with them—pacing, character development, writing style, or even genre preferences. However, this divergence of opinions creates vibrant discussions among readers, encouraging us to articulate why certain stories move us and why they might not connect with others. Defending your favorite book can be a fun and uplifting experience. It offers a chance to highlight what makes the book special to you—be it the emotional depth, unique narrative voice, compelling characters, or a fresh perspective on familiar themes. Sharing these reasons can open others to giving the book a second chance, and it also strengthens your engagement with the reading community. Moreover, labeling a book "mid" sparks wider conversations about broader literary tastes across platforms like #BookTok, #BookishHumor, and #BookCommunity. These spaces foster passionate storytelling around books that might be underappreciated or misunderstood, creating connections among bookworms who cherish diverse narratives. At the end of the day, it’s important to remember that reading is a deeply personal experience. What feels "mid" to one person could be life-changing to another. Embracing this diversity not only enriches our understanding but also helps us celebrate the multifaceted nature of literature. So next time someone calls your favorite book "mid," take it as an opportunity to champion the stories that moved you—because every beloved book deserves its defender.

Related posts

Mid Way Through Book Review 📚🩷
So here are my honest thoughts on the book so far: 📚The biggest win for the author is that she easly transitions well between timelines. Throughout the book she jumps timelines often giving us background information on each character she does this seamlessly! I’m also a squirrel and get confused
Deja Emani

Deja Emani

71 likes

A hand holds a thick white book vertically, with text stating 'The most I've ever cried during reading was because of this book.' A sand dollar shadow is visible on the wall.
A hand holds the book 'Bright Side' by Kim Holden, featuring an orange cover with a woman's face. Text on the image warns about crying and includes a five-star rating.
A hand holds the back cover of 'Bright Side' by Kim Holden, displaying the book's synopsis about Kate Sedgwick and Keller Banks, and asking 'Have you read this one?!'.
MOST EMOTIONAL BOOK EVER :,)
Thinking about this book lowkey still makes me tear up 😭 The synopsis for this book is pretty vague/short so I remember going into it honestly thinking I wasn’t gonna like it. (I also didn’t love the cover) I was so wrong!!! I read this in like 2 days and bawled my eyes out multiple times. I
KENNEDY ♡

KENNEDY ♡

743 likes

The cover of the book "There Are Moms Way Worse Than You" by Glenn Boozan, illustrated by Priscilla Witte, featuring a giraffe standing next to a fallen baby giraffe.
An open book showing a cartoon hamster holding a baby in a blanket on the left page, and text on the right page stating that hamster moms sometimes eat their newborn pups.
An open book showing a cartoon ant in a beach chair with a drink on the left page, and text on the right page mentioning that Dracula ants will suck their babies' blood.
Mom guilt?? Look at this book!
I got this book as a gift from my mom because she knows the struggle! She knows that I think I can be a better mom alllll the time! Do you relate? Look at these examples in the book of animals and their “parenting” skills. #momguilt #moms #momlife
JustJessie13

JustJessie13

4378 likes

A hand holds several books with light-colored spines. Overlay text reads "MY FAVORITE BOOK BOYFRIENDS (PART 4)" and "(may contain mild spoilers)". Lemon8 logo and username are at the bottom.
A collage for Cade Eaton (Heartless) featuring a cowboy hat, a guitar, a man with a child in a hot tub, a man on horseback, and a couple. Text highlights his traits like "grumpy cowboy with a big heart."
A collage for Aaron Warner (Shatter Me Series) with images of an eye, a red rose, a dove, a couple kissing, and a man writing. Text describes his "passionate love" and "soft spot for animals."
fav book boyfriends
i could make a hundred parts to this omg (cade eaton, aaron warner, johnny kavanagh, loren hale, aiden crawford, nate hawkins, luke ryder, jacob maddox, alex volkov) who’s your favorite book boyfriend?? #lemon8bookclub #readersoflemon8 #bookboyfriend #bookwormsoflemon8 #bookrecomm
mads

mads

1391 likes

If you only read 1 self help book
Love a personal development book. All of these I read in the past 3ish years. ❤️The Big Leap I swear by this book it has changed my perspective more than any book I’ve ever read. Whenever I catch myself being a hot mess it’s the best book to go back to remember how crashing out isn’t helpful.
J Hope

J Hope

1416 likes

Pov you need a therapist-book recs
Some of my favorite books 📚 #books #bookrecommendations #femininerage #booktok
Rachel🫶🏻📚

Rachel🫶🏻📚

995 likes

A hand holds five books titled 'The Mistake,' 'Love & Other Words,' 'The Risk,' 'Wildfire,' and 'Flawless,' against a dark background. The image is titled 'MY FAVORITE BOOK BOYFRIENDS (PART 3)' and includes the Lemon8 logo.
A collage for Russ Callaghan from 'Wildfire,' featuring a man holding a golden retriever, a couple at a picnic table, a person in a 'STAFF' shirt, and book quotes. Traits like 'shy n sweet' and 'plays hockey' are listed.
A collage for Jake Connelly from 'The Risk,' showing hockey players, a bowling pin, couples kissing, and a Harvard pennant. Character traits like 'determined + confident' and 'hockey player' are highlighted, along with a book quote.
my fav book boyfriends
i could make a million parts for this 😭 lmk any book boyfriends you wanna see!! I haven’t read the risk, love & other words, or fourth wing yet but they were requested!! #lemom8bookclub #readersoflemon8 #booksoflemon8 #bookwormsoflemon8 #bookboyfriend #bookrecommendations
mads

mads

2577 likes

A collage of book covers including 'Play It As It Lays' and 'Bunny,' with the text 'women vs. the void or: books with unhinged female protagonists' overlaid. The image features various titles recommended for their themes of female struggle and existential turmoil.
Two book covers, 'Brutes' and 'Severance,' are displayed with their genres (literary fiction, science fiction) and page counts. Summaries describe 'Brutes' about girls orbiting a missing preacher's daughter and 'Severance' about a woman photographing an abandoned New York.
Two book covers, 'One's Company' and 'Penance,' are shown with their genres (literary fiction, crime, mystery). Summaries detail 'One's Company' about recreating a TV show and 'Penance' about a journalist investigating a girl's murder.
unhinged & existential book recs
One of my absolute favorite subgenres is unhinged female protagonists (antagonists??). I love books about nearly-feral teens showcasing the trials and absolute mania of girlhood, inner female struggles metaphorically manifesting into the paranormal, or the existential turmoil of being a woman in
molly

molly

541 likes

A hand holds the book 'Horror Hotel' by Victoria Fulton & Faith McClaren, featuring a skull-like hotel. A Nintendo Switch and strawberry pillows are in the background. Text overlays 'Mid-Book Check In 40% chapter 10' and Lemon8 user info.
📖💭 let's talk horror hotel! | a mid-book check in
**SPOILERS AHEAD** i have so much to talk about with this book lol the characters are: Chrissy (the psychic spirit seeing one), Chase (honestly to me just an asshole but has a crush on Chrissy), Emma (very nonchalant one that has a crush on Kiki), Kiki (very sensitive & melodramatic)
ciara janaé ꨄ︎

ciara janaé ꨄ︎

34 likes

A bookshelf filled with manga and anime figures, with pink text overlays reading "Some of My favorite Panels from" and a white arrow indicating to "SWIPE."
A person's hands holding the yellow cover of My Hero Academia Vol. 1 manga, featuring Izuku Midoriya and All Might.
A manga panel showing a young Izuku Midoriya looking up in awe at a giant villain, with a yellow sticky note saying "He's just a baby."
Favorite MHA VOL 1 Panels
Some of my favorite my hero academia manga panels from vol 1 💛❤️💙 #mha #my hero academia #lemon8bookclub #manga #mangaaesthetics
📚Jo Lee Reads📚

📚Jo Lee Reads📚

13 likes

Book Journaling
So I’ve been trying to get back into tracking and journaling about the books I read. I’m not the biggest fan of using goodreads and have slacked off when it comes to tracking the books I’ve read and finished. I wanted something I could customize myself and really have fun with and make it my own! N
Kkandherbooks

Kkandherbooks

271 likes

💭Best Self-heal Book Mindset Growth✨
Following 5 Books is a must-read for personal growth, self-heal, mindset change. Book Review:Why, What I’ve learned, Suitable for who? 1. Atomic Habit-James Clear ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ At first glance of books cover I fall in love with it! After reading, I found it is practical and gem-like. Amazing
Jane

Jane

654 likes

My Favorite “Booktok” Books
5 books that i found through booktok that i love Books: 1. My Year of Rest and Relaxation 2. The Atlas Sox 3. Conversations With Friends 4. The Idiot 5. Boy Parts #booklover😌🤎 #booktok #lemon8bookclubchallenge #followformore #reading
monica

monica

615 likes

The image displays the red and blue cover of 'The 48 Laws of Power' by Robert Greene, with the overlaid text 'My Favorite Book Right Now'. The book is a national bestseller.
The back cover of 'The 48 Laws of Power' is shown, listing all 48 laws, including 'Never outshine the master' and 'Always say less than necessary'. A summary of the book's content is also visible.
An open page of 'The 48 Laws of Power' features 'LAW 3: CONCEAL YOUR INTENTIONS'. The judgment section, emphasizing keeping people off-balance by not revealing intentions, is highlighted.
⚠️ This book is dangerous and here’s why…
My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: The 48 Laws of Power 📖 Genre: Nonfiction 📄 My Favorite Quotes: So many. 💭 My Thoughts: This book is the realest, most educational book I have ever read. ⭐ Star Rating: 20/10 #booktok #bookaesthetic #bookrecommendations #BookReview #bookshelf
OLIVIA 🧸😇🐚👸🏽🌷

OLIVIA 🧸😇🐚👸🏽🌷

68 likes

An iPad displays "My favorite iPad apps" on a pink gradient screen, with a pink cup and candle in the background, indicating a list of preferred applications.
The Notion app is shown with a digital planner, calendar view, and pages containing book quotes and self-growth quotes, used for organizing notes and tracking progress.
The Canva app displays various templates for creating posts, including Valentine's Day designs and a 2024 planner, highlighting its creative uses for social media.
My favorite iPad apps 🌸
I use all of these apps every day, i use Canva daily to make post for all my socials . I use a Notion on a daily basis to keep all my notes organized and to keep me on track. Zinnia is my favorite app. I use it to journal and keep track of all of my goals. Zinnia also can be used as a journal . I u
𝒮𝒽𝒶𝓎𝓁𝒶☆

𝒮𝒽𝒶𝓎𝓁𝒶☆

16.9K likes

the best self-help book
Alan Watts was a British philosopher who helped introduce Eastern philosophies like Buddhism and Taoism to Western audiences. He wrote and spoke about topics such as self-awareness and the interconnectedness of life, making these complex ideas easy to understand. Have you read any his books?
BATE by Rana

BATE by Rana

181 likes

A black and white image shows a man embracing a woman, with overlaid text describing a scene where a man calls a woman "baby" during her severe allergic reaction, highlighting dialogue and her internal thoughts about the unexpected endearment.
when her enemy calls her baby
and then he stays by her bedside all night in the hospital🫠😫😭 OUT JUNE 1. Save to your TBR today so you don’t miss it! 💖 #lemon8bookclub #bookwormsoflemon8 #enemiestolovers #fakedating #romancebookrecommendations Brooklyn
Farrah Colson 📚✍️

Farrah Colson 📚✍️

62 likes

One of my favorite tropes ever ☺️ when he calls her
BABY #brothersbestfriendbooks #bookrecs #friendstoloverstrope #slowburnromance
Charlie Lennon Romance Books

Charlie Lennon Romance Books

311 likes

When she finally calls the man who saved her…
Little does she know, he’s been obsessing over her for days *Not an audiobook yet BUT Threads of Sin and Thrones releases July 12th 💙 #angstyromance #romancebookrecommendations #spicybookrecommendations🔥 #mustread
Kate Dove

Kate Dove

117 likes

My ‘Sell My Soul Book’ - Atomic Habits
Atomic Habits by James Clear Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 📒Notes:Book I would Sell MY SOUL to read for the first time Tiny Changes, Remarkable Results. 👍Pros::After reading, I jog for 30mins a day, In ONLY 30 days, I HAVE LOST Almost 10 POUNDS!!! Good Mood, Regain the confidence, my life has changed s
Jane

Jane

23 likes

A Bible with a floral cover and a gold tassel bookmark, with text overlays "My Bible Study NOTES" and "BOOK OF JAMES", indicating a study on the Book of James.
An open Bible showing highlighted sections on "WISDOM" and "PRINCIPLES OF FAITH" from the Book of James, detailing practical, divine, and Christ-like wisdom, and total commitment to Jesus.
An open Bible with highlighted sections outlining "HOW TO GET CLOSER TO GOD", including humbling oneself, resisting the devil, purifying the heart, and recognizing worth from God.
Book of JAMES Bible Study Notes 🤎
⭐️ WISDOM: 1. It is practical. God’s wisdom relates to our lives in even the most difficult trying times. 2. It is divine. God’s wisdom goes beyond common sense. 3. It is Christ-like. When we ask for wisdom, we are asking to be more like Christ. - By “wisdom”, James means the ability to mak
Ashley 💐🌞✨🫧

Ashley 💐🌞✨🫧

731 likes

5 things i wish i knew before writing a book 📖
Doing something new is scary but rewarding! I learned and gained a lot from writing a book… but there a few things I wish I would have known before hand. 1. Hire a cover artist early (or any artwork you want done)! Artists book out far ahead of time. There was one I reached out to last year tha
hannah hamrick

hannah hamrick

124 likes

Little T.J Maxx book haul moment
Books + TJ Maxx prices = instant happiness. -Nothing heals the soul like a TJ Maxx book haul 📚☕ #book shopping 🛒 #tjshaul #book haul #📚books #Lemon8Diary
Yaya

Yaya

367 likes

A hand holds a BL manga titled "Send Them a Farewell Gift for the Lost Time," featuring two male characters on the cover. Overlays read "Currently Reading" and "Break-up to Make-up," with a pink heart and star graphics. A Lemon8 watermark is visible.
LATEST BL MANGA : WHEN BREAK-UP ENDS HAPPILY 🫶
My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: Send Them A Farewell Gift For The Lost Time 📄 Plot: Tsukushi ends up breaking up with his workaholic boyfriend, Toui. However, shouldn't a break-up mean you stop seeing each other and going to his house whenever he calls? 📖 Genre: BL romance, modern d
Cozywulfe | BL Reading Diary

Cozywulfe | BL Reading Diary

39 likes

Book Bestie Application
I started my account because very few friends in my life are readers, but I’ve quickly found a community on this app that even love the same sub genres I do. I can’t wait to meet more of you all. In the last year what's a book you didn’t think you’d like but wound up loving? *** ☁️ All
geekycleary

geekycleary

39 likes

😾How do you clap back when someone calls you fat?
Here are some comebacks that pack a punch! 💥 "Not like you, though! You and your ego together still barely weigh a pound." "So skinny, huh? Must be that you can’t afford food at home?" "I’m just having fun being chubby. You, on the other hand, seem dead serious about being
Yaya✨

Yaya✨

286 likes

book recommendation on data bias and inequality
One of my favorite books on inequality that I've ever read was "Invisible Women" by Caroline Criado Perez The book explores how data bias neglects women's needs Perez uncovers instances where women are overlooked in areas like city planning and healthcare due to incomplete dat
BATE by Rana

BATE by Rana

29 likes

A collage of book covers, including 'Haunting Adeline' and 'Twisted Games,' with the overlay text 'BOOK MEN AND THEIR GIRLS NICKNAMES.'
The cover of the book 'Fourth Wing' by Rebecca Yarros, featuring a dragon design. Overlay text asks 'XADEN? YES VIOLENCE?'
A book cover displaying a blue eye with tree branches and water, labeled with the overlay text 'AARON? YES LOVE?'
book men and their girls nicknames
which bookish nickname is your favorite? Personally I love how Rafe calls penny queenie 😭😭 #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

1213 likes

A shelf of romance books including 'Neon Gods,' 'The Wall of Winnipeg and Me,' and the 'Off-Campus' series, with a Harry Potter Funko Pop figure on top. The image is titled 'ROMANCE BOOK RECS' and includes the Lemon8 handle @chloe_palmieri.
A collage of hockey romance book covers, featuring titles like 'The Deal,' 'Behind the Net,' 'Pucking Around,' and 'Icebreaker.' The image is titled 'hockey romance' and includes the Lemon8 handle @chloe_palmieri.
A collage of football romance book covers, including 'The Wall of Winnipeg and Me,' 'First Down,' 'Plays Well With Others,' and 'The Cheat Sheet.' The image is titled 'football romance' and includes the Lemon8 handle @chloe_palmieri.
Romance Book Recommendations!!
follow me on instagram & tiktok for more bookish content! 📖🤭🌈🤩 these are just a few recommendations in some of my favorite tropes!! hockey 🏒: the entire off campus series by elle kennedy behind the net by stephanie archer pucking around by emily rath icebreaker by hannah grace foot
Chloe Palmieri

Chloe Palmieri

396 likes

When he calls you a good girl…
GOOD GIRL!!! (A D) ✨When We Break✨ by @Kristen Proby performed in dual style narration by @Stephanie 🎙️Voiceover Artist and @Connor Crais. Irish accents too!! #booklover #bookrec #smalltownromance #bookish #bookloveroflemon8
TiffanyPReads

TiffanyPReads

183 likes

A hand holds Fredrik Backman's book "Beartown" with a purple and blue cover, featuring a snowy town. Text overlay reads "Convincing you to read FREDRIK BACKMAN based on my Favorite Quotes." Other books are blurred on a shelf in the background.
An open book displays page 9 with a highlighted quote about adults feeling drained and fighting through everyday worries, emphasizing the unknown number of days we can carry on.
An open book shows a highlighted passage about Peter reflecting on human nature in hockey, questioning the concept of being a "good team player" and the selfishness often hidden within groups.
Favorite Quotes
Book review of 📚Beartown Fredrik Backman ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I almost don’t have any words. There’s a reason Backman is probably my favorite author and it’s because of his ability to validate feelings through his stories. Everytime I read one of his novels, I feel understood and like I just got o
Amanda Courtney

Amanda Courtney

71 likes

january book releases 🤍
what new releases are you excited for? #booktok #bookstagram #readersoflemon8 #bookrelease #fantasy
✰ ꜱᴋʏᴇ ☾

✰ ꜱᴋʏᴇ ☾

35 likes

Mid book review!!
So far y’all, I am loving this book! I had no idea Soledad had so much strength and spice and sassiness in her; and let me tell you, I am here for it!! Kennedy Ryan is such a gifted writer. She really allows her characters to come to life and I believe it is because they are all so relatable. I
Ashley Janeece

Ashley Janeece

153 likes

The book 'Wildfire' by Hannah Grace, the second in the Maple Hills series, is displayed with three highlighters and text indicating a review of the book.
The book 'Wildfire' is shown with a 5/5 rating and descriptive tags like 'Romantic Comedy,' 'Mental Health Rep W/ Family Problems,' 'Forced Proximity,' 'Secret Dating,' and 'SPICY.'
A page from the book 'Wildfire' is shown with highlighted text about a character's humorous dialogue regarding cuddling and sleeping, overlaid with 'WTF?' and a laughing emoji.
Book Review: Wildfire
Book name: Wildfire (2nd book out of 3 in the Maple Hills series). Author: Hannah Grace Genre: Romantic Comedy Intro: It’s about this pair of college kids, Aurora and Russ, they have a one night stand. They then go to camp, thinking that they will never see each other again but they do— a
Rachal Sullivan

Rachal Sullivan

258 likes

WHEN THE ROMANCE CALLS
booktok;)

booktok;)

157 likes

A stack of four books titled 'Final Offer,' 'Twisted Games,' 'A Court of Wings and Ruin,' and 'Iron Flame,' with the text 'Finishing Book Series... Part One' overlaid.
A white mug with 'YOU'RE PURRFECT' and a cat design, sitting on a wooden coaster, with a stack of books in the background.
A laptop screen displaying a 'Next Read...' spinning wheel with book titles like 'Love on the Brain,' 'Twisted Games,' and 'Iron Flame,' to help decide the next book.
Finishing Book Series…
I can’t be the only one who starts book series and never finishes them!! I have so many series left unfinished so I’m attempting to finish all of them by the end of summer☀️ which ones are your favorite and which series do you recommend? All Genres welcome!! Pens & Highlighters I used on slid
Selena🎀

Selena🎀

27 likes

this book BLEW my mind (non-fiction)
Non-fiction Book review for When McKinsey Comes To Town by Bogdanich and Forsythe Rating: 8/10 This book is an investigative report of McKinsey and Company, one of the biggest consulting firms in the world Each chapter explores the hidden and heavy influence that McKinsey and Company has h
BATE by Rana

BATE by Rana

19 likes

A hand holds the front cover of the fantasy novel "The Shadow of What Was Lost" by James Islington. The cover depicts figures with staffs against an orange sun, with birds flying. Text on the cover includes a quote comparing it to "The Wheel of Time" series.
The same book cover is shown, with overlaid text indicating it's an "Epic Fantasy" and "Book one of three." A "Swipe" graphic is in the corner, and bookshelves are visible in the background.
The back cover of "The Shadow of What Was Lost" is displayed, featuring a synopsis about Augurs, Gifted, and the character Davian. It also includes positive reviews from various publications and publishing details.
What I’m reading to get me out of a book slump📚
🗡️Title: The Shadow of What Was Lost ☀️Author: James Islington ☀️Book 1 of The Licanius Trilogy ☀️Genre: High Fantasy When I saw this book at Barnes and Noble it caught my eye because I was looking for a book to read after reading the Throne of Glass Series, which was absolutely life alterin
Moon_Beam

Moon_Beam

10 likes

A person holds the book 'It's Not Summer Without You' by Jenny Han, reading outdoors on a patio with a pool in the background. The text overlay says 'READING MY FAVORITE BOOK OUTSIDE'.
A close-up of the back cover of 'It's Not Summer Without You', showing the covers of the first and third books in the series. Text indicates the first book has been read and this is the second.
The back cover of 'It's Not Summer Without You' is shown, displaying the book's synopsis. The text overlay reads 'A LITTLE ABOUT IT'.
Reading my favorite book outside
#sogood #thesummeriturnedpretty #reading #favorite #books
🎀🎧Braelynn🎧🎀

🎀🎧Braelynn🎧🎀

22 likes

See more