My First DNF of the Year: A Love Letter to Whiskey

My first DNF of the year and honestly… that’s okay.

A Love Letter to Whiskey by Kandi Steiner is a fan favorite for a reason, and for so many readers it’s a 5-star, emotional ride. For me, it landed at about a 2.5—and I made it 57% in before deciding it just wasn’t for me.

And here’s the thing: DNF’ing a book is not a bad thing! I love reading too much to force my way through something that isn’t connecting. Not every book will hit the way you expect, even when it seems like it should be right up your alley.

There’s value in knowing when to say “thank you” and move on to something that will resonate more.

Have you ever DNF’d a popular book? What was it?

#bookishalgorithm #dnf #lemon8books

3/31 Edited to

... Read moreDNF, or "Did Not Finish," is a term many readers use when they decide to stop reading a book before completing it. It's a practice I've learned to embrace because reading should be enjoyable, not a chore. When I reached 57% of "A Love Letter to Whiskey" by Kandi Steiner, a book well-loved for its emotional depth and slow-burn romance, I realized it just wasn’t connecting with me the way I expected. This book touches on heavy themes like complicated family dynamics, alcoholism, and friends-to-lovers romances — subjects that usually engage me deeply. That said, not every story will resonate with every reader, and that's perfectly okay. Recognizing when a book isn't for you can enhance your overall reading experience by allowing you to redirect your time toward books that truly captivate you. For example, some readers cherish the nuanced portrayal of high-school-to-senior-adulthood transitions featured in this novel, while others might prefer a faster pace or different narrative style. Personally, giving myself permission to DNF has been liberating. It relieves the pressure of finishing something just because it's popular or critically acclaimed. Instead, it encourages me to curate my reading list based on what genuinely resonates with me emotionally and mentally. If you find yourself struggling with a book, ask: Is this enriching my reading journey or draining it? It's all about balance. Have you ever DNF’d a highly praised book? How did it impact your reading habits? Sharing these experiences fosters a supportive reading community where everyone feels comfortable exploring what truly suits their taste. Remember, your relationship with books is personal and flexible — and that’s where the joy of reading truly lies.

Related posts

A love letter to whiskey has my ♥️
This book single-handedly removed me from my book slump 🫶🏻 #booktok #bookish #bookstagram #readersoftiktok
Amanda 📚 💄

Amanda 📚 💄

4 likes

A white book titled "A Love Letter to Whiskey" by Kandi Steiner, 5th Anniversary Edition, rests on a dark textured blanket. Overlay text reads "MY HONEST BOOK REVIEW" and "Rating: 4.5⭐️", indicating a book review.
Rating A Love Letter to Whiskey 🥃 ⭐️
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️🌶️ A Love Letter to Whiskey follows B Kennedy and Jamie over the span of a decade. They meet in high school where Jamie dates B’s best friend. Despite their relationship, B and Jamie build a best friend bond theirselves. As the years go by there are times when fate brings them togeth
BookishWitLani ✨

BookishWitLani ✨

539 likes

The book cover for 'The St. Ambrose School for Girls' by Jessica Ward features a silhouette of a building and trees against a pink sky. It includes a quote from Lisa Gardner comparing it to 'Mean Girls meets We Were Liars'.
15th DNF of 2026
Her writing style is hard to get through and there were alot of grammatical errors that just made some parts completely nonsensical.
Christina

Christina

35 likes

DNF Fantasy Series
These Fantasy/Romantasy series are extremely popular, but I just couldn't finish them. #fantasybooks #dnf #books #readin g #booktok
Mae⚔️📚✨️

Mae⚔️📚✨️

36 likes

A person stands in a library aisle, holding a tote bag that says 'support your local library.' Text overlay reads 'i READ 12 BOOKS in may AND DNF'D ONE...', surrounded by star and flower graphics.
A collage titled 'My Favorites' displays four book covers: 'A Sorceress Comes to Call,' 'Babel,' 'Dreams Lie Beneath,' and 'Seek the Traitor's Son,' categorized as Gothic Fantasy, Dark Academia, YA Fantasy Romance, and Dystopian Sci-fi/fantasy, with star ratings.
A collage titled 'Honorable Mentions' features four book covers: 'Nettle & Bone,' 'Rites of the Starling,' 'A River Enchanted,' and 'Red Queen,' categorized as Dark Fantasy, Romantasy, and YA Fantasy, with star ratings.
2 five ⭐️’s and 1 DNF, lots of good reads 📖
May was so good to me! Despite a few disappointments I read some of my fav books last month! Did we read any of the same books? #maytbr #readsofmay #readingwrapup #fantasybookrecs #booktokbooks
Alexzandra📚✨🐉

Alexzandra📚✨🐉

97 likes

I hope there’s no DNF’s this month🤞🏽
#booktok #junehopefuls #bookcousins #bookwormsoflemon8 #books
MangosNhotsauze📚

MangosNhotsauze📚

23 likes

The front cover of the novel "AWAY TO ME" by Patricia B. McConnell, featuring a house and trees against a vibrant yellow and orange sky. A quote from Sy Montgomery is visible at the top.
13th DNF of 2026
Nothing about this story held my interest. #AwayToMe #PatriciaMcConnell
Christina

Christina

11 likes

16th DNF of 2026
I just could not get into it. Maybe some other time
Christina

Christina

2 likes

The book cover for 'A Love Letter to Whiskey' by Kandi Steiner, featuring a crumpled white texture and elegant script, with a 'Book Review' title and five stars.
A glass of whiskey with ice, being poured from a bottle, overlaid with a quote about a whiskey stain being permanent like ink.
Two silhouettes of people sitting on a beach at sunset, looking out at the ocean with a surfboard beside them.
A Love Letter to Whiskey Book Review
Absolutely incredible! What a journey! Such a realistic portrayal of wrong timing & the ups & downs of love. A perfect description of love sometimes being our most fatal addiction! Wow is all I can say! Definitely going down in my favorites! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 #alovelettertowhiskey #b
Squarebear

Squarebear

119 likes

A disappointing DNF
I wanted to absolutely LOVE this book! I mean Harry Potter meets Gilmore Girls! What’s not to love?!?! The concept is there! But I DNF’d for these reasons: 1.) too many people introduced at once, I couldn’t keep up with who was who 2.) mythical creatures that I couldn’t picture/ description w
shannell fisher

shannell fisher

673 likes

DNF | What it really means…
Started it. Didn't like it. Closed it. 📖 BookTok 101: What DNF really means? #BookTok #viral #fyp #dnf #lemon8bookclub #tiktokpartner #books #read #Bookish #bookrec #howtostartabooktokaccount
jolieeggs_Books

jolieeggs_Books

116 likes

📚 Day 14: A Popular Book you DNF’d
ReadWithShell💜

ReadWithShell💜

9 likes

The front cover of "Disney Stitch! The Manga Collection!" featuring Stitch winking and a smiling girl, surrounded by pineapples and flowers. The title and a note about bonus chapters are visible.
The spine and top edge of the "Disney Stitch!" manga book, showing an orange spine with white patterns of pineapples, flowers, and Stitch.
An open page from the "Disney Stitch!" manga, displaying black and white artwork with a character saying "BUTTERFLY!" and the page number 113.
DNF 😭
Unfortunately this one was not it. It is cute in it's own right but it is just not for me. The mini stories did not make sense and it was hard for me to distance myself from the original movies in order to read this. I am sure that some people love this collection and the art is amazing ☺️ I a
Kylee Schnorf

Kylee Schnorf

4 likes

“ DNF ” & HERE’S WHY…
Book: The Princess & The PI Author: Nikki Payne Genre: Romance, Romantic Suspense 🌶️ level: Not sure because i didn’t finish. 🌸: Hey Bookish Babes, *Sighs* I decided to DNF The Princess and the Pi around the 40-page mark. While I went in excited by the premise, the story ultimately di
🌸: Your Fav Bookish Babe

🌸: Your Fav Bookish Babe

27 likes

A bookshelf displays numerous books, some standing upright and others stacked. A white text overlay reads "Books that I have DNF'ed," indicating these are titles the author did not finish reading.
The book "The Frugal Wizard's Handbook for Surviving Medieval England" by Brandon Sanderson rests on a patterned pillow and teal blanket. An overlay explains it was DNF'd because it was a simulation, not a time machine story.
The book "Things We Never Got Over" by Lucy Score, featuring daisies on its cover, lies on a patterned pillow and teal blanket. An overlay states the author lost interest despite its popularity.
Books I didn’t expect I would DNF 🥺
I was super bummed about DNF’ing all of these books 😭 most of them are super popular and everywhere in my feed!!! I have such a specific style of reading that I prefer. I’ve noticed that I tend to have a hard time reading books that are written by English/Irish/Scottish writers since they tend
Amber

Amber

512 likes

10th DNF of 2026
The writing felt choppy and I was bored by the 4th chapter.
Christina

Christina

3 likes

A hand holds the book 'A Love Letter to Whiskey' by Kandi Steiner, 5th Anniversary Edition, with a Goodreads rating of 4.37. A cup and blanket are in the background, along with text overlays like 'Reading' and 'Lemon8 @marthaaaaaxr'.
✨Currently reading : A love Letter to Whiskey📖✨
I've switched up the order of my Tbr about a million and one times. But for GOOD reasons ! "A love letter to whiskey" popped up for my friend and I and we were automatically intrigued by the book and story line and decided to give it a try. The book revolves around the main character
Martha

Martha

13 likes

The image shows the book cover for "The Vacancy in Room 10 Motel" by Seraphina Nova Glass, identified as a "Current Read." The book rests on a black and white fuzzy blanket, with a red heart bookmark on top. The cover features a motel scene at sunset.
DNF’d
I wanted to read and finish but I DNF’d in the beginning only because the chapters felt long to me. My plan is to try all the books I have DNF’d throughout the year again in Dec, so we shall see if I can make it through in a couple of months. Do you DNF or push through? -Val
Holly Molly

Holly Molly

37 likes

A physical copy of "The Only Purple House in Town" by Ann Aguirre lies next to a Kobo e-reader displaying the same book cover, both resting on a pink fluffy blanket.
A Kobo e-reader displays a page from "The Only Purple House in Town," with highlighted text, resting on a pink fluffy blanket. The screen shows chapter two of the book.
A close-up shot of the physical book "The Only Purple House in Town" by Ann Aguirre, featuring a purple house illustration and various floral and celestial elements on its cover.
giving a book i dnf a second chance
my ADHD has been the cause of many dropped books lol. but now that I'm on medication I figure I could go through my dnf books and see if I actually like them after all. most of the time I drop a book it's bc I find something else that grabs my attention 🤭 so far I'm enjoying myself!
Mercedes

Mercedes

27 likes

Let’s talk DNFs
what makes you put a book down for good? Slow start? Annoying characters? We want to know! 🖊️👇 #booksoflemon8 #lemon8bookclub #books #dnf #read
jolieeggs_Books

jolieeggs_Books

101 likes

A hand holds a digital e-reader displaying "DNF" in white text, with an overlay "Books I did not expect to". The background is a black and white floral pattern with decorative stars and hearts.
A hand holds a digital e-reader showing the cover of "Filthy Rich Vampires: For Eternity" by Geneva Lee, featuring ornate dark and gold floral designs. The background is a black and white floral pattern.
A hand holds a digital e-reader displaying the cover of "The Exception to the Rule" by Christina Lauren, with a yellow background, blue speech bubbles, and white and blue text. The background is a black and white floral pattern.
Books I DID NOT expect to DNF
📚 Books I Didn’t Expect to DNF 😭💔 I went in ready to love them. The hype was loud, the covers were cute, the vibes were vibing and then somewhere along the way, I tapped out 👀 ⭐️ Pucking Around – I wanted a hockey romance and spice, but it just kept going and got very messy. ⭐️ The Spanish
reagan westerly

reagan westerly

636 likes

books i DNF-ed 🚫📚
if you’re not sure what DNF means, it means Did Not Finish! i really try to make it a habit of always finishing whatever i’m reading, but these two just have never made me want to pick them back up again! 🌐 Crossings by Alex Landragin: On the brink of the Nazi occupation of Paris, a German-Jewi
ayersellie

ayersellie

231 likes

Books I had to DNF 😬
#books 🫶🏼 #dnf #reading #lemon8bookclub #book
Sofi’s grwm 🌀

Sofi’s grwm 🌀

114 likes

A white mug with the text 'wake up. BE AWESOME. repeat.' filled with a dark beverage, sits next to the book 'You Can Heal Your Life' by Louise Hay. The book cover features a red heart design and states it's an international bestseller.
Do You Push Through a Book… or DNF It?
Do you give books a fair try just to see what you can learn from them, or do you automatically move them to your DNF stack? I’m currently working my way through this one, and it’s not hitting like her first book — and maybe it’s not supposed to. Sometimes a book meets you where you are, not wh
Becoming Through Books

Becoming Through Books

11 likes

My first DNF book
I’m usually one to finish a book even if it gets slow but this book I can not and will not finish!!!! It started off great but then I got confused and it turned into something strange. It went from the girl doing palm readings trying to help an old guy friend find his missing child to the boy turni
Khatcher4

Khatcher4

2 likes

First DNF of the Year
#dnf #books #reading #readersoflemon8 #horrorbooks
taylor_made_books

taylor_made_books

4 likes

Book Review: A Love Letter to Whiskey 📚
If you like emotional romance with poetic writing, this one will pull you in — but it may also frustrate you. What I loved: • The writing style is beautifully poetic • The “whiskey” metaphor as addiction is a powerful theme • The audiobook includes Jamie’s POV at th
Katlynn Nelson

Katlynn Nelson

9 likes

1st dnf of the year
#readinginmymeadow #booktok #dnfbook #bookish
🐮🌻📚Moo Meadows📚🌻🐮

🐮🌻📚Moo Meadows📚🌻🐮

2 likes

A Love Letter To Whiskey by Kandi Steiner
The only way to really describe this is two toxic people taking turns being toxic…and I loved it 🤣 I do think it could have been shorter OR not so much filler OR added more to the in-between times but that’s just me. I had a great time reading this. It was frustrating and exhausting and I was smitt
Miranda Baker

Miranda Baker

9 likes

Another book added to my DNF list
Ughhh this book was so cringe to me. Maybe this is for a younger reader, but I was only able to listen to 10% of it before I quit. #dnf #dnfbook #dnfseries
Christine

Christine

0 likes

A love letter to whiskey ❤️🥹
Started 2026 wrapped up in this book and let me tell you 10/10 recommend. The roller coaster of emotions, but I couldn't get enough. As if her version wasn't enough, his was even better Have you read it? What were your thoughts? What do I need to read next? #kandisteiner #BookTok #alo
Mama Cole ✨

Mama Cole ✨

6 likes

First DNF of the year 😔
Yeeaaahhh I just...couldn't. The writing style is great, and you can tell the author did her research about the ancient myths and how the gods & magic were thought of back then, but... The MC is so frustrating to me, she's so stupid. And I find it difficult to sympathize with stup
Tylan Stroud

Tylan Stroud

11 likes

An audiobook cover for "A Reaper's Heart: The Forbidden Attraction" by Kendra Necole, featuring a muscular person with dreadlocks and tattoos from behind. The audiobook is performed by Lauryn Nichols and Midnite Michael, is part of the "Pharaoh's Army" series, has a 4.2-star rating, and shows a "Borrow" button.
A Dark Revenge Story I Wanted to Love, But DNF
I recently started this book and ended up DNF’ing it 🫣. Quick mini recap: This is a dark revenge story centered on Reaper, a man shaped by trauma and fueled by vengeance. His path collides with Lotus, a forbidden and dangerous love who forces him to confront emotions he buried long ago. As de
Courtney ❤️‍🔥

Courtney ❤️‍🔥

11 likes

A hand with painted nails holds the white and gold cover of the book "Love Letter to Whiskey" by Kandi Steiner, a 5th Anniversary Edition, with "Currently Reading" overlaid.
A love to whiskey 🥃
#bookrecommendations #romancebooks #booksoflemon8 #book
Mari_books

Mari_books

46 likes

DNFing books is NOT a crime 🙌🏼
Your time and energy are valuable and if you just aren’t vibing with your current read then put it down and pick up a different one! Life is too short and there are too many good books to give up time and energy on reads that just aren’t resonating with you! Happy reading my loves 💖 #lemon
✨Shannon✨

✨Shannon✨

9 likes

DNF
I won’t hold you, I tried it in audiobook form as well & I couldn’t get into it. Idk what it was but I know I instantly lost interest in this book. Maybe I’ll try again later but as for now ? 0/10 for me.. #dnfbook #eeeyuck #reading #books #dnf
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

42 likes

8th DNF of 2026
DNF. The characters felt like bad actors.
Christina

Christina

6 likes

I had to DNF my first book of the year 😭
I have never DNF’d a book but I can’t keep putting myself through this like an unhealthy relationship 🤣 I even got myself through 50 Shades and I despised that book 💀 I’m not sure what it is…the slow plot or what but I couldn’t bring myself to finish this book and it put me in a slump of not wantin
K 🦋

K 🦋

8 likes

My first (soft) DNF of 2026
I’m so sad to say that I made the decision to soft DNF Game On. While I ate up Lights Out & Caught Up; Game On is just not hitting the spot the same way. I am so disappointed! The story is good but Tyler is just not what I was hoping for I guess? Have any of you read it? What were your thou
K Reads📚

K Reads📚

3 likes

A hand holds the book 'A Love Letter to Whiskey' by Kandi Steiner, 5th Anniversary Edition, with a quote from Penelope Ward. The book is against a dark fuzzy background, with 'My Next Read!' overlay and sparkle graphics.
Love Letter to Whiskey 🤎🥃
I’ve been waiting so long to read this one & i’ve heard great reviews. Have you read this book? #lemon8bookclub #newreads #bookaesthetic #readingcommunity #booksbooksbooks
BookishWitLani ✨

BookishWitLani ✨

67 likes

The image shows four main actresses from "Pretty Little Liars" in black dresses, looking dirty, with one holding a finger to her lips. The show title is at the bottom, and a search bar for "Shows I DNF (Did Not Finish)" is at the top.
The image features the cast of "Gossip Girl," with a woman lying in the foreground. Overlaid text states, "Not a single character was likable. The story lines were repetitive and unbearable." The show's title and broadcast information are at the bottom.
The image displays five actresses from "Pretty Little Liars" in a lineup pose against a height chart. Overlaid text reads, "I think they lost direction. They didn't know who A was gonna be and it became too convoluted!" The show title is at the bottom.
Shows I DNF (Did Not Finish)
I’m not saying these shows are good, but they did get on my nerves 😭 You was dragged out completely! And Nah, Pretty Little Liars was doing anything towards the end! Bc wym Alison still alive, Spencer got a twin sister, A went from being one person to a whole group of people! #fandom #lemon8c
L a n a i s Li 🧚🏽‍♀️

L a n a i s Li 🧚🏽‍♀️

324 likes

Unhinged DNF👀
Let's stir the pot! What unhinged reason did you DNF a book? ☠️ #letsstirthepot #viral #trending #fyp #booktok
The Twilight Bookworm

The Twilight Bookworm

5 likes

My first book on my DNF list
I’d never believed I could put a book on a DNF list. I’m one of those people that could start watching a crappy movie, and I’ll watch it until the end just because I feel like I already invested time in starting it and now I gotta see it through. So naturally I would feel that way about books too.
Christine

Christine

14 likes

My first DNF of 2026 👎
I really wanted to like this book. Given Our History looked right up my alley. Unfortunately I just couldn’t get into because it goes back to the past and then the present. I think it’s just hard to follow the storyline sometimes when it’s written like that. I also had some anxiety and it was hard
Brook

Brook

5 likes

4th DNF of 2026
DNF'd. The plot felt like a rerun. I've read that premise at least 3 times. His writing is good. Maybe a different book?
Christina

Christina

5 likes

A book titled 'THE FURY' by Alex Michaelides, featuring a large blue evil eye design over a sandy landscape on its cover. The text overlay reads 'I am trying to get in to this', indicating the user is struggling to read the book.
Dnf but determined to finished
🌟Have you ever just had a book that you were just not into? I have heard so many good things about this book , I just can’t get into it? 🌟This might be #dnf for now! But I am no quitter! I still want to finish, I just don’t know if I’ll be satisfied at the end of all of this! ⭐️Let me kn
Shunte Biblio

Shunte Biblio

7 likes

4th Dnf of the year
🫠 I wanted to like this book and I actually enjoyed the male character and the female was a badass.but the problem I felt like I read this before cause it's so familiar to red queen with hunger games plot and I was more forcing myself to read it. #dnf #booklemon8 #booklemon #fantasyb
Christina 🫶📚

Christina 🫶📚

4 likes

Sadly DNF
DNF'd at 32% I was intending on actually reading this whole thing, to see if it was any better than the 1st book. Sadly I feel like it just got worse in my opinion. I hate most of the characters (namely: Feyre, Rhysand, and Tamlin), and the ones I don't hate I'm completely indifferen
Amanda Lietz 📚

Amanda Lietz 📚

7 likes

The first book I am starting in 2026!
My first read, I am starting this year is a love letter to whiskey, what is your first book of the year? #booktok #2026 #books
Katlynn Nelson

Katlynn Nelson

1 like

A book cover for 'The Surgeon' by Leslie Wolfe lies on a white textured surface, with text overlays highlighting themes like 'Cheating husband,' 'Jealousy,' and 'Successful surgeon loses her first patient.' A hand with heart-designed nails holds the book.
Almost DNF… but somehow I did🤷‍♀️
⭐️Overall rating: 2/5:⭐️⭐️ I hate to not like a book but I couldn’t wait for this one to be over. I picked this book up because I saw a review that said it was good but honestly the only good part was the last chapter. The entire book you are waiting for something to go crazy but you just continue
Maddy.walls

Maddy.walls

110 likes

See more