Why are we stuck in unhealthy relationships?

Why do we stay in social circles that drain us, even when we know they’re harmful?

From classic psychology theories to fMRI research, multiple reasons might keep us with people who may not have our best interests at heart.

This article breaks down the patterns behind staying in unhealthy groups. While it’s not a how-to guide, it explores strategies supported by current literature that help navigate these social traps. (Image: Steve Johnson/Unsplash)

——

If you enjoy research-backed stories on psychology, wellness, and culture, follow for more daily quick facts, two weekly stories, and monthly deep dives.

#magazine #storytelling #analysis #psychologyfacts #unhealthyrelationship

2025/12/20 Edited to

... Read moreMany people find themselves trapped in dysfunctional social circles that drain their energy and well-being, even when they recognize these relationships as unhealthy. This paradox can be explained by a mix of psychological conditioning, brain function, and social dynamics. From an early age, experiences with caregivers and close relationships shape our understanding of love and connection. If early relationships taught us that love is conditional or unreliable, or that emotional closeness requires constant vigilance, we may internalize these as normal. Our brains are wired to seek familiarity because it equates to safety, even if that familiarity is harmful. This neurological preference means that unhealthy social groups can feel safer than unknown, healthier environments. Another factor is the rigid social roles that dysfunctional groups enforce. People often adopt identities such as "the mediator," "the voice of reason," or "the funny one" to maintain their place in the group. These roles create dependency and make leaving feel like a betrayal of one’s identity and relationships. The social pressure to conform and the fear of isolation also reinforce staying in toxic circles. Research using fMRI supports these ideas by showing how social pain activates similar brain regions as physical pain, explaining the strong emotional resistance to leaving social groups. Moreover, behavioral studies highlight that people are more willing to tolerate harm when their social identity and self-esteem are intertwined with the group. Strategies to navigate these traps involve increasing self-awareness of these patterns, seeking supportive and positive social connections, and gradually redefining one’s identity outside the unhealthy group. Psychological approaches like cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and mindfulness can help individuals recognize and reframe dysfunctional beliefs. Building new social networks that validate healthier behaviors contributes to breaking free from these cycles. Understanding the psychological and neurological roots behind our attachment to unhealthy relationships offers a compassionate perspective. It encourages patience and persistence in seeking better social environments, emphasizing that change is challenging but achievable with informed support and personal growth.

Related posts

Signs of an unhealthy gut… and how to fix it
Your gut is trying to tell you something. Listen to it. #guthealth #digestivehealth #healthygut #probiotics #wellness
Welldiet

Welldiet

1628 likes

Foods that are actually unhealthy! Part 1
Juices made out of squeezable fruits (like oranges and grapes) are actually bad for you! Since these fruits have sugar in them, when you turn them into juice, the sugar rushes in instantly and your body consumes sugar way faster than when you eat them. This can cause bloating and if
Arisa_glowup

Arisa_glowup

1454 likes

A flat lay image featuring a cup of coffee, black sunglasses, and decorative items on a patterned surface. Overlay text reads "HOW TO Detach From Toxic Relationship" with a "swipe" arrow, serving as the article's title slide.
The text "Identify the reason" is displayed over a background of sheer white curtains with light filtering through. A white box below contains text advising to ask why one is stepping back from a relationship.
The text "Free your emotions" is displayed over a background of sheer white curtains. A white box below contains text suggesting ways to release emotions like talking to a friend or journaling.
How to Detached From Toxic Relationships ‼️
The ability to detach from certain outcomes and people is incredibly powerful. Not only does it relieve pressure and stress, but it also has a way of making you more magnetic. I can't explain the science behind it, but when I stop desperately pursuing something and instead focus on what I can c
Milaidy🫧🌺🍕

Milaidy🫧🌺🍕

730 likes

🚨10 WEIRD signs you’re body is UNHEALTHY😬
Here are 10 weird but REAL signs your body might be unhealthy 1. Your burps smell extra funky Not normal “I had onions” funky—more like rotten or sulfur-y. Could mean gut bacteria imbalance, slow digestion, or food sitting too long. 2. You rarely sweat Your cool system doesn’t kick i
thewealthyauntie

thewealthyauntie

1078 likes

How To Manage Unhealthy Cravings ✨
I am truly the QUEEN of craving everything unhealthy. I genuinely feel I have the biggest sweet tooth known to man. This discovery has me very excited! I’m hoping this will help me from caving into my cravings. 🍫 ➡️ 🍌 🍟 ➡️ 🥜 🍪 ➡️ 🥦 🍔 ➡️ 🥩 🍭 ➡️ 🍉 🍕 ➡️ 🍣 🥖 ➡️ 🥬 #food #foo
Courtney

Courtney

127 likes

Unhealthy things I am unlearning as a mom 🌸
Being a good mom is my top priority. 1. Punishing emotions. I will not get my daughter in trouble for yelling at me, crying, or anything else. If you were crying and somebody told you you have no reason to be, or that they’ll give you a reason to cry, how would you feel? Worse? 2. Shaming.
Shay

Shay

3961 likes

A woman with long blonde hair, seen from behind, looks out over a body of water with buildings in the background. The text asks, 'WHY DO TOXIC RELATIONSHIPS FEEL SO HARD to walk Away from?'
A pink wide-brimmed hat, an open book, and a sliced fig are arranged on a surface. The overlaid text states, 'Emotional highs and lows create strong attachment.'
A picnic scene features a pink cake, watermelon, drinks, and flowers on a checkered blanket. The text reads, 'You remember the good moments more than the painful ones.'
Why Toxic Relationships Are So Hard to Leave
Toxic relationships can feel incredibly hard to walk away from—and it’s not just about love. Emotional highs and lows create strong attachment, making the connection feel intense and difficult to leave. You may find yourself focusing on the good moments while hoping things will change, even when
QuietClarity

QuietClarity

42 likes

signs of an unhealthy gut & what to do about it
This was such a popular topic so let’s chat gut health (part 2)! If you have digestive issues, you’re not alone. Many factors affect your gut health, like family and genetic history and how your body is built. But there are also factors you can control, like stress and diet. the gut is the body’s s
gabrielleassaf

gabrielleassaf

6614 likes

5 Signs of a Unhealthy Metabolism
When working properly, your metabolism effectively converts the foods you eat into nutrients and energy for your body. When it isn’t working properly, the foods you eat can be stored as fat and not properly converted to energy. This can happen for many reasons, including hormone imbalances, med
staci york 💛🍋

staci york 💛🍋

3263 likes

Two people lie on a rock overlooking a valley with trees and cliffs. Text overlay reads: "HOW 'UNHEALTHY HABITS' MAY EQUAL Trauma responses."
A sunset over a landscape featuring vineyards and distant houses. Text overlay reads: "You stay up too late because it's the only time you feel at peace."
Blue ocean water under a partly cloudy blue sky. Text overlay reads: "You're a perfectionist because it's the only way you feel in control."
“unhealthy habits”may actually be trauma responses
#mentalhealthawareness #mentalhealing #mentalhealth2025 #traumaresponse #unhealthyhabits
Maja🤎

Maja🤎

15 likes

A person with an obscured face and a hand touching their shirt, overlaid with the title "Healthy Boundaries We set in our relationship" and a kiss mark, introducing the topic of relationship boundaries.
A man practices golf at a driving range with a golf bag beside him, illustrating the boundary "No hanging out ALONE with people of the opposite sex."
A woman takes a mirror selfie in a gym with a neon peach sign, representing the boundary "No lying (about anything)" in relationships.
HEALTHY BOUNDARIES FOR LONG-TERM RELATIONSHIPS
1. No hanging out with friends of the opposite sex ALONE. In our opinion, when you’re in a monogamous relationship, there is no reason why you should be hanging out with a person of the opposite sex alone. In a group setting it is fine, but we both find it a little suss if all of a sudden we sta
Gracie

Gracie

46 likes

3 Questions For Healthy Relationships
Healthy relationships are not defined by the good days. They are defined by how you handle the hard ones. Ask yourself these three questions. This is for educational purposes only and not to be misconstrued as psychotherapy #healthyrelationship #relationshipadvice #couplestherapy #a
EmbracingJoyTherapy

EmbracingJoyTherapy

40 likes

Your relationships will continue to fail.
Here’s why your future relationships will never work out if you don’t do neuropsychology: Unhealed trauma and old emotional patterns will keep sabotaging your connections, no matter how hard you try. Without reprogramming your mind, you’re bound to repeat the same destructive cycles. Neuropsycholog
Achilles king

Achilles king

1241 likes

A person's midsection wearing a sports bra and shorts, with text overlay "5 SIGNS OF AN UNHEALTHY GUT + 6 THINGS YOU CAN DO ABOUT IT" and a swipe arrow.
A person's midsection with text listing "5 SIGNS OF AN UNHEALTHY GUT": constant fatigue, upset stomach, unintentional weight changes, food intolerances, and skin irritation.
A bed with pillows, featuring text tips to improve gut health: lower stress levels, get enough sleep, and stay hydrated.
Signs of an unhealthy gut ✨
Did you know that your digestive system is home to thousands of different types of bacteria and microbes? They all play different roles in keeping you mentally, emotionally, and physically healthy. That's why it's super important to keep your gut happy and healthy! ✨Here are a few signs
Michelle G.

Michelle G.

2835 likes

A list titled 'stop doing this' on a white background with a faded image of a woman, enumerates unhealthy habits such as arguing, pretending happiness, people-pleasing, normalizing trauma, and procrastinating, aligning with self-improvement.
Unhealthy Habits
Improve your mindset and quality of life with these tips. Change starts with how you respond to others. Not everyone will understand your journey and that’s okay. Be comfortable with change and letting things go. 🤎 #badhabits #mindset #mentalhealth #selfimprovement #selfcareroutine
Valid Creations

Valid Creations

28 likes

Habits that Destroy Relationships
Just like with living a healthy lifestyle, having a healthy relationship is hinged upon the day to day habits we incorporate into our lives. Some of these habits will make our relationship happier and some will end in a broken, unhealthy relationship. These are a few of the habits I’ve noticed b
staci york 💛🍋

staci york 💛🍋

542 likes

My Unhealthy Healthcare Internship
I don’t think people talk enough about unhealthy healthcare environments, especially when you’re young and trying to learn. My internship was supposed to be about growth. Instead, it taught me how easily you can lose yourself when you’re trying to prove you belong. I was doing tasks outside
VowArchive

VowArchive

7 likes

Healthy Alternatives to Unhealthy Foods
Only get what you can afford! There’s always off brand versions of certain products you can purchase if you are on a tight budget. But whenever you go to the store just be on the look out for certain alternatives to unhealthy products. There’s a lot more than what I listed! Note: It is okay to
angelina

angelina

129 likes

5 unexpected signs that your relationship is unhealthy ✨🚩❤️‍🔥💔
Sometimes we mistake red flags for connection or sparks for the right fit when in reality we’re repeating toxic patterns from the past 🥴🚩🚩 #couplestiktok #relatable #couples #relationshipadvice #relationships
Nicole | YT & IG: theiconnic

Nicole | YT & IG: theiconnic

0 likes

Why You Keep Getting Into Toxic Relationships 💔😭
We tend to gravitate towards the things we are good at, that we are familiar with, that we know. Whenever you attempt to start a new habit or you find yourself in a new environment you begin to experience resistance and discomfort. This can keep many from persisting to create change because it’s un
iamchrisgoode

iamchrisgoode

6 likes

This is why you choose unhealthy relationships
#relationshipsmatter #healthyloverelationships #relationshiptoself #healing #trauma
Dr Marlene Phillip | Trauma Ed

Dr Marlene Phillip | Trauma Ed

28 likes

SIGNS OF AN UNHEALTHY GUT😖
The state of your gut impacts your overall health from your mental health to energy levels, digestion, weight, inflammation, how you feel in your body and truly so much more! All of these symptoms are not normal but they can mean your gut needs some support. I know this all too well because I
chels

chels

3004 likes

A light green lined paper with a drawing of a woman in black, wearing a pink hat and carrying a pink bag, walking away from a list of nine negative things, including fake friends, heartbreak, and negativity. Two orange butterflies are also depicted.
walk away from something that are unhealthy
cause it's not worth it of your life
Angel Walker

Angel Walker

7 likes

UNHEALTHY FOODS I WOULD NEVER EAT
needless to say, all foods are fuel for your body! everything is perfect for your body in moderation, unless it’s rotten, raw, or you’re allergic of course! No foods are considered “bad foods” and everything works together to make your body work like it’s supposed to! #lemon8fitness #dinne
Morgan 🦈👙🪼

Morgan 🦈👙🪼

1717 likes

Listen if You Feel Stuck in a Toxic Relationship 💔
You might not even realize that you are in a narcissistic relationship. Do you often feel like your partner is love-bombing, gaslighting, and doing controlling tactics? It’s not all in your head... The first step in breaking free is understanding that the love you’ve been seeking from them
iamchrisgoode

iamchrisgoode

7 likes

Breaking unhealthy habits
We all have or have had unhealthy habits that have delayed things from happening in our lives. Whatever yours are God has given you the power to break them. #breakthrough #LifeAdvice #fypage #faith
Jessica Jones

Jessica Jones

14 likes

A person in a grey tank top holds a phone and a white mug, smiling, with text overlay "THOUGHT PATTERNS i thought were normal" and Lemon8 branding.
A person sits on a bed, looking at their wrist while holding a white mug, with text "pessimistic thinking: constant focus on what could go wrong instead of right" and Lemon8 branding.
A bedroom scene with white curtains, a window, a black nightstand, and a lamp, featuring text "all-or-nothing and overgeneralization" and Lemon8 branding.
that actually are but unhealthy..
believing these thoughts has played on my mental health in many more ways than one… and honestly, they still turn up every now and then.. but you know.. thoughts aren’t always facts. if you can think negatively, you also hold the power to think positively. remember, our thoughts aren’t alwa
R Y E S I A

R Y E S I A

131 likes

7 REALITIES GOOD MEN SHOULD NEVER IGNORE IN RELATIONSHIPS ⚠️
✨ A good woman brings peace… a draining one brings confusion and exhaustion ✨ Not every relationship becomes unhealthy loudly. Some relationships slowly exhaust people through: 💬 QUESTION: What do you think good men need most in relationships today? 👇 COMMENT your thoughts below. ❤️
Aisha .T Cleaners & J Advocate

Aisha .T Cleaners & J Advocate

11 likes

The image shows two people holding hands, with text overlayed: "HEALTHY VS. UNHEALTHY EXPECTATIONS SUPPLIES In relationships." The Lemon8 logo and username are at the bottom.
A couple is hugging from behind in a kitchen. Text overlays describe unhealthy expectations of a partner tending to all emotional needs versus healthy expectations of having multiple sources for emotional nourishment.
A gym floor with dumbbells and a water bottle, viewed from above. Text overlays contrast unhealthy expectations of no conflict with healthy expectations of conflict bringing depth and closeness.
HEALTHY VS.UNHEALTHY EXPECTATIONS in a marriage
Expectations can really set us up for failure in a relationship if we’re not careful with what we are expecting. I put together a few toxic expectations that can really cause a wedge between you and your spouse if you don’t nip it in the bud early! 1. Expecting our partner to tend to all of our
Ashlie

Ashlie

18 likes

healthy vs unhealthy relationships
when there is lack of balance your relationship will tip over 👁️
Endo'sPurpose

Endo'sPurpose

6 likes

A person with a tampon string hanging from their nose, reddish stains around their mouth and chin, and giving a thumbs-up. The text overlay reads "Had to pull a sebastian 😭", referencing a scene from the movie "She's the Man" where a character uses a tampon for a nosebleed.
The unhealthy amount of romcoms pay off in time🤷‍♀️
#idk #shestheman
your favorite camryn🎱💋🪩🎸🎬

your favorite camryn🎱💋🪩🎸🎬

15 likes

A woman takes a mirror selfie, making a duck face, with the text overlay: "3 'low maintenance' habits that ruined my relationships." She wears a black top and holds a phone.
A couple, a woman and a man, embrace outdoors. Text overlay reads: "'I don't need gifts or dates' I stopped expecting romance, attention and appreciation...! normalized emotional neglect and called it low maintenance."
A man walks away on a sidewalk next to a white car and bushes. Text overlay states: "'I don't care where we go or what we do' I always deferred to my partners preferences (which was people pleasing and made me lose my voice)."
Are you “low maintenance” in relationships?
I think a lot of us get praised for being low-maintenance, when in reality we’re just suppressing our needs. The tough thing for me to come to terms with was that while being low maintenance made me easy to be with short term, it led to burnout, resentment, and emotional disconnection long term
carley ◡̈

carley ◡̈

124 likes

Signs of an Unhealthy Gut & What to Do About It 🌿
Hey friends! If you've been feeling off lately (even when you’re doing everything right), it might be your gut sending you a not-so-friendly signal. 😕 Our gut health is EVERYTHING – it impacts everything from our mood to energy, skin, and even immune function. So today, let’s chat about some co
Nicole🍒

Nicole🍒

811 likes

Healthy Relationships God’s Way 🤍
Healthy relationships; whether romantic, family, friendships, or even the way we show up for ourselves, reflect God’s heart. In Scripture, love is described as patient, kind, humble, and genuine (1 Corinthians 13:4). A healthy relationship doesn’t demand perfection, but it does require honesty, gra
Lindsey Marie

Lindsey Marie

152 likes

5 SIGNS OF AN UNHEALTHY METABOLISM (i wish i knew)
Storytime: for a short time in high school i randomly decided to become “vegan” even though i had absolutely no idea what that entailed (all i really knew was to not eat dairy or meat)🥩 So with that, I followed a diet of straight salads, pasta and fries😂 And along came a BUNCH of mineral/vitamin de
Cassidy

Cassidy

402 likes

Are you ok with being in an unhealthy relationship
@stephanspeaks Are you ok with being in an unhealthy relationship? #stephanlaborssie
VSGENT

VSGENT

1 like

How to Not Be Harmed in Relationships 🛡️❤️‍🔥
“When there is no enemy within, the enemy outside can do us no harm.” - African Proverb “You are never destroyed by anyone except yourself.” - Friedrich Nietzsche When we accept ourselves, take action from the present, adapt wisely to overcome the obstacles we face, then we experience growth.
iamchrisgoode

iamchrisgoode

8 likes

A graphic comparing healthy and unhealthy relationships. The green side lists positive traits like Compliment, Forgive, and Trust with icons. The red side lists negative traits such as Criticize, Hold grudges, and Distrust with icons. A broken heart icon separates the two columns.
Healthy Relationships Vs Unhealthy Relationships
Healthy Relationships Vs Unhealthy Relationships #healthyrelationships #toxicrelationships #selfworth #lifelessons #Lemon8
It’s The Real Jay Anthony

It’s The Real Jay Anthony

212 likes

Maintaining Relationships
#unhealthyrelationships #selfpreservation #selfgrowthgoals #iamstillblooming
The Bloom Nurse

The Bloom Nurse

23 likes

An infographic titled "The Tree of Successful Relationships" features a brown tree. Its branches list elements like Trust, Respect, Honesty, Laughter, Communication, Intimacy, Shared Values, Forgiveness, and Pathological Envy. The roots are labeled Empathy, Commitment, Security, Friendship, all grounded in soil representing love, safety, and mutual support.
THE TREE OF SUCCESSFUL RELATIONSHIPS
THE TREE OF SUCCESSFUL RELATIONSHIPS Healthy love doesn’t just happen—it’s nurtured, rooted in shared values, and watered with consistent effort. This visual breaks down what makes a romantic relationship not just survive, but thrive. BRANCHES (What Grows Above the Surface) These are the beaut
Kylie SAHM

Kylie SAHM

701 likes

See more