April Empties 9/24

⭐️⭐️⭐️

This is the Bubble Cosmic Silk Hydrating Milky Toner.

I have some beef with Bubble about this. The product itself is really good. It's the perfect milky consistency, and my skin loved it. I used it twice a day, and it didn't break me out or irritate my skin at all. It does have an awful scent, and the packaging sucks. It shoots all over the place if you don't wait 30 seconds to close the top after dispensing it. But while using this, I found these clear, slimly, almost plastic pieces coming out with the formula. I took a video and posted it to TikTok to see if anyone else was having this problem, and to bring it to Bubble's attention. They told me to email them and I did. But they were only willing to help me if I provided them with an order number and receipt. This was gifted to me by an influencer, and I did not have that information. I explained that I won it in a giveaway and their response was “well can't you contact that person and get that information from them?” And obviously I can't do that. So they refused to help me, and I explained that I was not looking for a refund, and not even a free product. I wanted them to know about this issue and fix it. I am also a Bubble Ambassador, so you would think they would have more respect for me, or just take me more seriously. They didn't offer any kind of explanation as to what this substance was, and just told me there was nothing they could do and to have a nice day. I continued to use it, but had to look thoroughly at the product I dispensed before applying it to my face, and I ended up not finishing it because more and more would come out when it was almost empty. And I did shake it every single time before using it, it was defienetly not product that hadn't mixed or dissolved. The entire interaction I had with them put such a bad taste in my mouth about the entire brand. They make really great products - this being one of them! But the fact that I came to them with a legitimate complaint about a foreign substance in my product and they completely dismissed me because I didn't pay for it is unacceptable in my opinion. I will not be purchasing any other Bubble Cosmic Silks, and I will honestly be a lot more cautious about what I do purchase from Bubble, if anything at all moving forward.

#bubble #productreview #milkytoner #empties #april

5/4 Edited to

... Read moreUsing skincare products consistently can reveal unexpected issues, and my experience with the Bubble Cosmic Silk Hydrating Milky Toner was a perfect example. While the toner’s milky consistency absorbed nicely and didn't cause irritation or breakouts, I found an unusual, slimy, almost plastic-like substance mixed within the formula. I made sure to shake the bottle thoroughly each time, so it wasn’t a case of undissolved ingredients. The recurring appearance of these particles especially when the bottle was near empty was quite alarming. This raised concerns about product safety and quality control, which are critical when applying products directly to the face daily. Sharing this on social media and contacting the brand seemed like the right thing to do; however, the lack of support from Bubble was disappointing. Asking for purchase proof when the product was gifted in a giveaway felt dismissive and put a sour note on an otherwise good skincare line. Packaging also contributed negatively to the experience. The toner’s dispenser would shoot the product unpredictably if not closed carefully, making the application process frustrating. Additionally, the strong unpleasant scent detracted from the enjoyable texture and hydration it provided, which are key for hydrating toners like this. Despite these drawbacks, I continued to use the toner because it suited my skin well and didn’t provoke any adverse reactions. However, discovering unknown substances mixed in with the product made me wary of using it to completion. When choosing milky toners or hydrating toners, it’s important to watch not only for skin compatibility but also product quality and company responsiveness to customer concerns. Product safety should always come first, and transparent brand communication is essential to building trust. This experience taught me to verify brand reliability and product integrity more thoroughly, even with gifted items. If anyone else has noticed similar 'foreign particles' in their Bubble Cosmic Silk Hydrating Milky Toner, sharing experiences can help bring awareness to the brand and potentially improve quality controls. Trying other milky toners from reputable brands might also be worth considering if you seek effective hydration without such issues. Overall, while the Bubble toner has great moisturizing benefits, the concerns I encountered unfortunately overshadow the positive aspects.

Related posts

April Empties 12/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Memoire Archives Work From Home Body Lotion (this comes in a 4 piece set, I only finished the mini body lotion this month). I was actually using this as a hand lotion! I didn't realize it was a body lotion (even though it's literally right there on the bottle). This
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

0 likes

April Empties 11/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Splash Salve by Hanni. I have never seen or tried a product like this before, and I am hooked! I have already repurchased this, and I don't think I will ever be able to shower without it now. I did buy the fragranced one, and I don't think I could describe this
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

2 likes

April Empties 23/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Smashbox The Original Photo Finish Smooth & Blur Primer. I finished a sample size - a VERY small sample size. I got maybe 3 uses out of it. But this is one of my all time favorite primers! It blurs my skin so well, and it makes my makeup last all day long. It's
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

55 likes

April Empties 19/24
❌ ⭐️ This is the Redken One United Lightweight Leave-In Hair Conditioner. I received a free sample of this from Ulta. It is a very small sample, I got about 3 ½ uses out of it. I did not notice a difference in my hair at all. It's supposed to provide your hair with 25 different benefits, ki
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

1 like

April Empties 8/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Cocokind Electrolyte Water Cream. I finished a deluxe mini. I was actually shocked at how much I liked this! Drugstore moisturizers are hit or miss for me, but this one is so good! I would honestly compare it to the Tatcha Water Cream! That's how luxurious and good
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

0 likes

April Empties 10/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is The Morning Dew Cleanser from SKIN&CO. I finished a mini. I really like this brand! This cleanser was good, honestly not my favorite but I would use it again. It doesn't really lather that well. I just kind of stays in a gel form. It also didn't feel like my skin wa
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

1 like

April Empties 14/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Delícia Drench Body Butter from Sol de Janeiro. I finished a mini, and I NEED to restock this ASAP!!! This is the most amazing smelling body butter I've ever used. I can't even describe the scent, it's just so good. So sweet and warm. This paired with the ma
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

1 like

April Empties 4/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the COSRX Snail 92 All In One Cream. It deserves 10 stars! This is a holy grail product for me. I will always stay stocked up on this! This was gifted to me by COSRX, but I have since purchased it with my own money. This is one of the best moisturizers I've ever used, a
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

2 likes

April Empties 13/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ These are the Lemme Sleep Sleep Tight Gummies. I bought and finished a 1 week supply (14 ct). I LOVED these!!! I have seen these around for a while, and I thought the craze was just because it's a Kardashian brand. But I saw one woman RAVE about these and show how well she slep
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

9 likes

April Empties 18/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Not Your Mother's Clean Freak Dry Shampoo. I finished a mini. Out of all the NYM dry shampoos, this is my least favorite, simply because of the smell. This one is “original” fragranced, but it is a very powerful smell. I don't mind it, but if I have a migraine (wh
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

0 likes

April Empties 17/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ These are the Clean Skin Club Clean Towels in Blemish Control. I bought and finished the 10 count to try for the first time. I cannot believe how well these actually work!!! I thought these were just a gimmick honestly. I thought there was absolutely no way these towels actually wo
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

0 likes

April Empties 16/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the In The Zone Sheet Mask by I DEW CARE. I love this brand - they make AMAZING face masks! I think this was my first time trying this mask though. I don't have dry skin at all, but my skin drank this up!! There was not a drop of serum left in this mask when I took it o
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

1 like

April Empties 15/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ These are The Good Patch Brighten Up Under Eye Patches For Dark Circles. These were gifted to me from The Good Patch, and I truthfully really liked them! This was my first time trying their undereye patches. I loved how hydrated they are - but not so much that they slipped down my fa
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

1 like

April Empties 6/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the VT COSMETICS CICA Reedle Shot 300 Night Exosome. I LOVE this! I think this is the second or third bottle I've gone through, I'll never stop repurchasing this. I use this as directed - on dry skin right after cleansing - and it make my skin SO soft and smooth. Th
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

4 likes

A flat lay of various empty personal care and beauty products on a textured surface, including body washes, hair treatments, skincare items, and a deodorant, with 'My February Empties' text overlay.
A flat lay of empty personal care and beauty products, some marked with a star indicating repurchase intent and others with a burst indicating no repurchase, on a textured surface.
Hair care products, including a large green tub of treatment and three bottles of cleansing and conditioning products, with text praising their hydrating and frizz-controlling benefits.
🌸February empties 🌸
Very late to posting my February empties but I just kept forgetting 😭 #empties #emptieshaul #monthlyempties #beautyproducts
Greenteamochicat

Greenteamochicat

23 likes

April Empties 1/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Prequel Universal Skin Solution Dermal Spray. This is my favorite hypochlorous acid spray! The mister on this is one of the best I've ever seen. This bottle also lasts a long time! I use it twice a day, morning and night, and it lasted me a little over 2 months! It re
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

2 likes

April Empties 2/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ These are the Thayer's Exfoliating 2% AHA Facial Pads With Witch Hazel. Words cannot express how much I love these!! I am a Thayer's Ambassador, and I did receive these for free. But I truly did love these and I will be repurchasing immediately! I used these every single mo
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

1 like

April Empties 5/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the TONYMOLY I'm Rice Makeup Removing Cleansing Oil. I really liked this cleansing oil!! It is on the thin side, and it does a really good job or double cleansing, and getting all my makeup off. This is a great budget cleansing oil. I do have other ones that I like better
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

2 likes

April Empties 20/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Verb Ghost Conditioner for Fine to Medium Hair. I finished a 12 oz bottle (not sure if this is their regular size or mini). I finished the shampoo last month. I liked using them together! This is a super thick, and hard to get out of the bottle conditioner. It almost has a
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

0 likes

April Empties 3/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Cocokind Calming Magnesium Mist. I think this is the second one I've finished up. I LOVE this and it has become a staple in my routine. The bottle lasts a LONG time! I use this morning and night, and it calms my skin down so nicely. My skin is less red, less irritat
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

1 like

April Empties 7/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Medicube PDRN Pink Peptide Serum. I love this serum so much - I've already repurchased it! PDRN is seriously taking over my skincare routine and I am not mad about that! This is a thicker serum (and naturally pink, so who doesn't love a pink serum?!) and works s
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

2 likes

April Empties 21/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the HUDA BEAUTY Easy Bake Blurring Setting Spray with 16-Hour Wear. I finished a mini, but truthfully I finished the mini a while ago, I just keep refilling it with the full sizes I bought that arrived broken. I bought two full sizes, 2 days in a row, and they both arrived
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

0 likes

April Empties 22/24
✅ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This is the Luminous Silk Natural Glow Blurring Foundation by Armani Beauty. I finished a mini. I don't think I've ever gone through a foundation as fast as I went through this one!! This was not the best shade match, but I love that they have a very wide range of shades -
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

2 likes

April Empties 24/24
❌ ⭐️ This is the Then I Met You Living Cleansing Balm. I did NOT finish this! I used it one time, and my entire face broke out in a horrible rash! I got a mini in a Sephora Favorites Gift Set, so there was no box of instructions or ingredient list. It smells very citrus-y, and I can't handl
Tori Ray

Tori Ray

1 like

part 2 april empties ‘26
i was surprised i finished that touchland body mist but i’m excited to have it done and to start a new fragrance. i have a few tiny bottles of perfume i want to put in my rotation for the weeks to come. only one more medicube mask left unfortunately but i do have two more face masks (i believe)
miaatheweirdo

miaatheweirdo

0 likes

April Product Empties
Here’s everything I finished this month! Lotion, Wax Melts, and body spray! I also included the prices, where you can buy them (minus one), and what I liked or disliked about them! #aprilempties #productempties #emptiesreview #bodycareproducts #springfavorites
maddy

maddy

5 likes

Empties of April
Overall this is my first post about my empties. Some of these were from maybe a week before April, but I wanted a decent amount to share and show for my project pan. Even though this might not look like a lot to you, but it is a lot to me especially with my overconsumption #empties #emptieso
Sam sham

Sam sham

11 likes

April Empties & would I buy them again? ✨🌸
This are all my April empties and I’m gonna let you know if I would buy them again or not. (Picture 1)Starting with the lemme gummies - Lemme Kylie Cosmetics (No) didn’t see any changes at all - Lemme Play (Yes) They balance my period so yes - Lemme Purr (Yes) love them they just work for m
Jovana ✨🩵

Jovana ✨🩵

14 likes

April empties 🤍
I’ve loved doing project pan but I’m definitely going through this slower than I thought lol. I still have so much to get through hopefully summer I’ll be using a little more #projectpan #emptieshaul #empties #productempties
Ciara

Ciara

16 likes

April empties 21 products 🗑️
These are my April empties, I’ve finished 21 products. I’ve completed a lot of small products this month. 7 of them are from my spring project pan(check that post out + update coming) I would repurchase all of these tbh. I finished a total of 73 products so far in 2026🎉🎉 #empties #Haul #beaut
Jessica.Shawnte

Jessica.Shawnte

28 likes

project pan empties
#projection #projectpan2025 #aprilempties #projectpanupdate
carlie🪩

carlie🪩

48 likes

A flat lay of various empty beauty products, including lotions, cleansers, sunscreens, and creams, from brands like EOS, Native, Aveeno, Byoma, Tree Hut, and The Ordinary, indicating April empties.
Two makeup empties are shown: a Glossier biscotti balm dotcom and a Facile lip jelly tint, with text indicating positive feedback for the balm and mixed feelings for the tint.
A Phlur Soft Spot eau de parfum bottle is displayed as a perfume empty, with text explaining it was used as an office perfume to finish it up.
April empties!
A peak into my trash
Joy Benavides

Joy Benavides

288 likes

empties of april 🧡
so far this is all i have. i have a few more products that are on their last leg, so there might be a part two for april😙 #empties #april
miaatheweirdo

miaatheweirdo

3 likes

Empties
Have you tried any of these products?💕 | | #emptieshaul #emptiesproducts #empties #products #emptiesbeautyedition
manda

manda

11 likes

April + march empties
#empties #emptiesreview #emptiesskincare
Tonnymeow🎃🍂

Tonnymeow🎃🍂

2 likes

march empties pt 2 😛
part two !!! looking forward to what i finish in April 🥰🥰 #empties #march25 #aprilalready
miaatheweirdo

miaatheweirdo

3 likes

🌸April empties: would I repurchase??? 🛍️
💧 Laneige Water Bank Freebie from a creator event. Hydrating, didn’t break me out, but no major skin improvements. ⭐️ 7/10 🌙 Estée Lauder Advanced Night Repair Most likely to repurchase. Using a sample now, if others don’t compare, I’ll buy again. Pricey, but sales at Ulta Beauty help. ⭐️ 9/
Feli J

Feli J

9 likes

April Empties🌸🌸
How has April come and gone? It was a sloooooow month, but I got 2 products done! I loved my Innisfree moisturizer (I tried a new one!), but I’m gonna go back to the green tea one. My skin needs alllll the hydration! The Black Cherry Merlot lotion is one of my favorite lotions EVER!! Its scent wa
Madeleine Myers

Madeleine Myers

1 like

april empties - makeup
I finished three products in April! For makeup, I finished my second bottle of the Glossier Perfecting Skin Tint and as much as I wanted to purchase a new one, unfortunately, I am a recently graduated college student with a lot of student loans that need to be paid off. I also ran out of was my NYX
julie lui

julie lui

5 likes

February 2026 Empties
Went through a lot this month - posting this in April bc I was too lazy to take the pic lol #empties #emptiesskincare #projectpan #emptiesofthemonth #emptieshaul
A🕊️🦢

A🕊️🦢

6 likes

Rating April Empties
Always trying to new products but with so many constantly on the market it’s hard to keep up. These brands never let me down and I tend to reach for their products the most 😊 #products i always reach for #estheticianapproved #empties #emptiesskincare #productsiuse #productempties #Le
Heidiac

Heidiac

5 likes

A hand holds two empty body lotion bottles, one light blue and one light purple, both designed for 24-hour moisture and dry skin.
A hand holds a white foaming wash for sensitive skin and a yellow jar of body scrub with bamboo extract and shea butter.
A hand holds two small jars of face cream, one purple labeled 'The Dewy Skin Cream' and one light green labeled 'The Water Cream'.
April emptiesss
Natalie

Natalie

269 likes

April Empties
April Empties 🫶🏾 @Dove Beauty & Personal Care @Old Spice @CeraVe @Prada @Armani beauty @Pariscornerperfumes @BORNTOSTANDOUT My samples came from @Scent Split #empties #Fragrance #bodycare
Shay

Shay

13 likes

Empties!!
#projectpan #empties #emptieshaul #Lemon8Diary #beautyfinds
Lucy Ferguson

Lucy Ferguson

41 likes

April Empties
My April empties helped me decluttered. I’m prioritizing some of my candles and my perfume samples. I have so many so I’m trying to use them up! I’m also focusing on my Ulta samples to use them up and see if I find anything I like. Project pan is making me realize how large the samples actually
sweetoxox

sweetoxox

1 like

April Project Pan Empties
Lots of empties this month! #empties #emptiesskincare #emptiesofthemonth #productempties #aprilempties
hailey madison

hailey madison

6 likes

APRIL BEAUTY EMPTIES ✨🌸🤍
Some of my fav beauty products I finished in April! Will def be repurchasing these all ✨🤍🌸 #favoritebeautyproducts #bestbeautyproducts #aprilempties
Alexa 🤍

Alexa 🤍

14 likes

March Empties🌷
•This was a kind of slow month for product use, but I got through some and made some progress on some others!!! •I love my gourmand scents, but some of these were a bit too sweet for my taste. I’m slowly figuring out my scent likes and dislikes which is great!! Stay tuned for some April produc
Madeleine Myers

Madeleine Myers

20 likes

April 2026 Empties
My beauty trash! #emptiesskincare #empties #beauty #skincare
Seb140476

Seb140476

3 likes

A clear plastic bin holds various empty beauty and personal care products, including a cut-up EOS body lotion, a deodorant, and shampoo bottles, representing the user's "March Empties."
A hand holds a light blue, cut-up EOS 24H Moisture Body Lotion bottle, featuring a winter-themed design and the "Whipped Vanilla" scent.
A hand holds a SheaMoisture Manuka Honey & Yogurt Hydrate + Repair Shampoo bottle, formulated with Mafura & Baobab Oils for extremely dry, brittle hair.
March Empties
happy april! these are my empties from last month. as you can see from the cut up eos bottle, i do not let anything go to waste. i don’t know if its just me but finishing a product makes me feel super accomplished. i always look forward to seeing what products i cleared each month. how many
alexis 🌻

alexis 🌻

11 likes

January empties ❄️
Here’s the list of empties I have for January! -Keranique Deep Hydration Follicle Strengthening Conditioner @ Ulta for $24.00 -Garnier Whole Blends Taming Leave In Miracle Frizz Tamer Coconut Oil & Cocoa Butter For Very Frizzy Hair @ CVS for $9.99 - Mixed Chicks Deep Conditioner @ Ul
Alexis

Alexis

8 likes

Huge Empties Rating 🧴⭐️🫶🏼
Pt 2? 👀 Skin Type: combo (dry in winter) Skin problems: blackhead, pores, uneven tone #ratemyemties #products #empties #Lemon8Diary #lemon8boxchallenge @Lemon8 Beauty
May Clanton

May Clanton

749 likes

First week of April empties and replacements!
#empties #emptiesandreplacements #projectpan #emptiesss #emptiesproducts
Lucy Ferguson

Lucy Ferguson

11 likes

April Empties!
Products I’ve been absolutely LOVING recently! 1) Tree Hut… everyone’s favorite affordable body care brand. I’ve completely used up both the Tangerine Sugar Scrub (I already have the peppermint one from the holiday season in my shower) and the Coco Colada Shave Oil. The scrub smelled so good and
Taylor🎀

Taylor🎀

4 likes

MONTHLY EMPTIES - APRIL
My empties from the month of April! All linked on my ShopMy in my bio! Frenshe Vanilla Skin Hair & Body Mist - smells so good and the scent actually lasts a long time! Great body mist for the price Whipped Beef Tallow Moisturizer - very thick & creamy. Works very well for dry ski
Kailee

Kailee

4 likes

my April empties
my empties for April!!! #projectpan #empties #emptieshaul
Cloey 💖🐾

Cloey 💖🐾

2 likes

See more