Rating + Ranking My Eyeliners 🖤

After trying out these different eyeliner products and sharing my top picks, I realized there's so much more to learn about getting that perfect eye look! Since I've only recently gotten into wearing eyeliner more regularly in 2024, I wanted to share some extra tips and insights I've picked up along the way, especially for anyone else who's just starting or looking to perfect their technique. First off, understanding the different types of eyeliner can make a huge difference. My ranking included both eyeliner pencils and liquid eyeliner pens. Pencil liners, like the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide On, are fantastic if you're going for a softer, smudgier look or if you want to tightline your upper lash line. They're often easier for beginners to control for a subtle definition. However, when it comes to creating a truly sharp and dramatic winged eyeliner, a liquid eyeliner pen is usually your best friend. They offer intense color payoff and allow for much more precision. Speaking of winged eyeliner, this was probably the hardest part for me to master! My biggest tip is to start with a steady hand. I find it easiest to rest my elbow on a table. For the wing itself, many people swear by drawing a small dot where you want the tip of your wing to end, then drawing a line from your lower lash line up to that dot. After that, you connect the tip back to the middle of your upper lash line. Practice really does make perfect, and don't be afraid to clean up any wobbles with a cotton swab dipped in micellar water. When you're shopping for a new eyeliner, consider what you want it to do. Do you need something super pigmented and dark for a bold statement, or a more subtle shade for everyday wear? Longevity is also key – nobody wants their eyeliner smudging halfway through the day! Look for terms like 'waterproof' or 'long-wearing' if that's a priority. And as my ranking shows, you don't always have to splurge on high-end options; there are some amazing drugstore eyeliner products that perform just as well, if not better, for a fraction of the cost. My journey with eyeliner has taught me that experimenting is half the fun. Don't get discouraged if a certain type or brand doesn't work for you right away. What works for my eye shape and preferences might not be perfect for yours, but hopefully, my reviews and these extra tips give you a great starting point for finding your own holy grail eyeliner!