Dior Lip Oil vs. ELF Lip Oil

I honestly like both.

✨Dior✨

The Dior one is a cherry oil based lippie. The applicators is pillow soft. Glossy but yet pigment. (Depending what color you pick.) It doesn’t matter what kind of skin tone you have all of the Dior cherry oil gloss looks good on everyone! The formula in my opinion is just a little bit sticky but not entirely super, super sticky. Also a little goes a long way. She is $40. Packaging is lovely. It’s giving ✨luxury✨ but left in heat or sun the oil will come up from the tube & melt on to whatever. It will stain/ruin your clothes/purse bc it’s oil based.

🎀ELF🎀

The Elf lippie is suppose to be a dupe to the Dior. She is Apricot oil based. It has the same type of applicator, pillow soft but not as soft. The formula is just a bit thinner so she glides. They have a lot of colors but the colors are not pigment at all. It’s a slight hint of color. She is $8 vs $40. The package is well made. The product doesn’t come up from the tube but I don’t like the design of the packaging.

I think both products have their pros & cons but I still enjoy both.

2024/8/26 Edited to

... Read moreAfter diving deep into the Dior vs. ELF lip oil debate, I wanted to share a bit more about my experience and help you decide if the budget-friendly ELF really stands up to its luxury counterpart. I know so many of us are on the hunt for effective high-end dupes, especially when it comes to cult favorites like the Dior Lip Oil. And let me tell you, ELF has made a strong case for itself! When it comes to evaluating ELF's lip oil, I've found it truly shines as an everyday staple. While the original article touched on the apricot oil base, it's worth noting how that contributes to its surprisingly nourishing feel. My lips feel genuinely hydrated without being overly greasy. For those asking which ELF lip products are most similar to high-end brands, this lip oil is definitely at the top of my list. The way it glides on, almost effortlessly, thanks to its slightly thinner formula, gives a comfortable, non-tacky finish that's often hard to find outside of pricier options. Let's talk about the 'dupe' factor a bit more. While the Dior offers that distinct cherry oil luxury and a slightly more cushiony feel from its applicator – that vibrant pink one you see in photos – the ELF's 'pillow-soft' applicator, even if a touch less plush, still delivers a smooth, even layer. I've found that for eight dollars, the experience of applying the ELF lip oil is remarkably similar to a high-end product. It gives that gorgeous, glossy sheen that elevates any look, much like its pricier rival. One thing I've explored further is how the ELF lip oil wears throughout the day. While the pigment is subtle, which is perfect for a 'my lips but better' look, the glossiness holds up well. I usually reapply after a few hours or after eating, but I don't feel like it completely disappears. For those who want a bit more color, I've had great success layering ELF's lip oil over a lip liner or a matte lipstick to add shine and hydration without disturbing the base color. It’s a fantastic way to stretch its versatility! Regarding the packaging, as mentioned, the ELF tubes – those neat rectangular ones, perhaps the orange or red shades I've seen – are well-made. Even if the design isn't my absolute favorite, the crucial part is that the product stays put. Unlike some luxury oils that can have leakage issues in warm conditions, my ELF lip oils have consistently held up, which is a major win for tossing it into a purse without worry. This reliability is a huge plus when you're evaluating a product for daily use. Ultimately, if you're looking for an excellent product that gives you that high-end lip oil look and feel without the hefty price tag, ELF's lip oil is absolutely worth considering. It might not be an exact 1:1 dupe in every single microscopic detail, but it delivers on the core promises: hydration, shine, and comfort, making it a stellar high-end alternative.

51 comments

Lemon8er's images
Lemon8er

I have both both of them are really good. I don’t really have a favorite

See more comments