Who’s better vampire? Bella Swan vs. Elena Gilbert

Los Angeles
2025/10/18 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, fellow supernatural fans, let's get into what I consider one of the greatest vampire debates of all time: Bella Swan versus Elena Gilbert! Both iconic, both turned into creatures of the night, but who truly became the 'better' vampire? I've spent countless hours re-watching their journeys, and here's my take. First, let's talk about their powers and transformation. Bella Swan's transformation in Twilight was intense but, once complete, she emerged as one of the most powerful newborns. Her self-control was legendary, especially for someone so new to vampirism. I mean, resisting Edward's blood? That's commitment! Her unique mental shield ability is also a game-changer, protecting not just herself but those around her from psychic attacks. She becomes this incredibly strong, fast, and resilient being, almost effortlessly powerful. She truly embraced her new life, finding joy and purpose in her enhanced existence. Elena Gilbert's journey in The Vampire Diaries was far more tumultuous. Her transformation was a constant struggle, riddled with emotional turmoil, especially when her humanity switch was off. We saw her battle with bloodlust, making some questionable choices along the way. While she gained standard vampire abilities like super strength, speed, and compulsion, her unique challenges often revolved around her moral compass and regaining her sense of self. I think her compulsion ability was super useful, but it also showed how much she wrestled with who she was becoming. It felt like she was always fighting against being a vampire, whereas Bella eventually found peace with it. Beyond their fangs and supernatural abilities, their personal styles are another huge point of discussion! Elena Gilbert's outfits were always so effortlessly cool and practical for Mystic Falls. Think classic denim, simple yet chic tops, and those signature leather jackets. Her look was the epitome of the 'girl next door' who could also kick vampire butt. I always admired how she balanced comfort with a touch of sophistication, whether she was at the Grill or facing down an ancient evil. Her everyday style is still so inspiring for casual, put-together looks. Then we have Bella Swan's outfits. Her style evolved from a slightly awkward, earthy Pacific Northwest vibe to a more refined, elegant look after her transformation, but always remained true to her practical roots. Before, it was all about those cozy flannels, hoodies, and sneakers – perfect for Forks' rainy weather. Her signature dark brown hair color framed her face beautifully, giving her that understated, natural beauty that everyone loved. Even as a vampire, she maintained a simple elegance, often opting for darker, richer tones that highlighted her new, ethereal beauty. I loved how her style reflected her journey from human to vampire, always practical yet subtly chic. So, who's the better vampire? It truly depends on what you value. If you're looking for raw power, quick adaptation, and unique defensive abilities, Bella Swan might be your pick. But if you appreciate a character who battles morally, displays deep emotional struggles, and eventually earns their strength through adversity, then Elena Gilbert shines. They both leave an undeniable mark on the vampire genre, and honestly, both sagas – Twilight and The Vampire Diaries – gave us such rich lore and complex characters. What do you think? Who wins this ultimate vampire showdown for you?

174 comments

😒🤏ERICA🥀🫩's images
😒🤏ERICA🥀🫩

ELENA ALL THE WAY😭

See more(7)
Rosalie's images
Rosalie

Bella, and for the people saying Bella is annoying, I agree that in the movies she is but in the books I kind of took her as more of a “idgaf” person instead a ball of awkwardness. 🤷‍♀️ just my take lol

See more comments

Related posts

A newspaper-style graphic titled "LOLLY'S NEWS" with the headline "HOW TO: ACHIEVE ELENA GILBERT'S WARDROBE." It features a smiling image of Elena Gilbert (Nina Dobrev) with long brown hair, set against a blurred outdoor background.
A collage titled "HENLEY SHIRTS" featuring six images. It displays various long-sleeved Henley shirts in blue, grey, burgundy, black, and purple, often with white lace trim. Elena Gilbert is shown wearing some of these shirts.
A collage titled "SPAGHETTI STRAP TANK TOP" featuring six images. It displays various spaghetti strap tank tops in white, olive green, burgundy, purple, and plaid patterns, some with lace trim. Elena Gilbert is shown wearing some of these tank tops.
Elena Gilbert 🌸
#elenagilbert #thevampirediaries #wardrobestylist #inspooutfits
𝓚𝓪𝓽𝔂 💋

𝓚𝓪𝓽𝔂 💋

133 likes

This is so Vampire Diaries
#2000sfashion #y2kfashion #elenagilbert #falloutfitinspo #outfitideas
HyperBees

HyperBees

4688 likes

Calling all vampire diaries fans 🌲🩸
This is your sign to visit mystic falls irl #vampirediaries #tvduniverse #elenagilbert #elenagilbertoutfit #covington
Sarahlfarma

Sarahlfarma

2480 likes

The vampire diaries part 2
Lyla Fox

Lyla Fox

502 likes

Elena Gilbert Dopplegangers
Confusing people that don’t watch TVD
Klementia💕

Klementia💕

194 likes

A young man with dark curly hair, identified as Gilbert Blythe, is shown lying down with his eyes closed, wearing a dark suit jacket over a white shirt and tie. He rests his head on a white patterned pillow.
A young man with dark curly hair, identified as Gilbert Blythe, looks slightly to the right with a thoughtful expression. He is wearing a light-colored, long-sleeved shirt with suspenders in an indoor setting.
A young man with dark curly hair, identified as Gilbert Blythe, smiles gently while looking towards the viewer. He is partially visible from behind a light-colored wall or doorframe, wearing a dark jacket over a light shirt.
Gilbert Blythe pics for yall
#gilber t Blythe
Taytay

Taytay

32 likes

Vampire Diaries Now and then!! TVDU
The vampire Diaries and The Originals before and after super cool to see them right next to each other …look at this! Matt looks a little funny because he is and Lexi is not my favorite out of these awesome creations but enjoy. #thevampirediaries #theoriginals #tvd #nowandthen #fyp New
Kitty McTaco

Kitty McTaco

40 likes

This F100 sittn like it owns the lot…12 West Gilbert AZ.
@aztruckco @truck #f100 #trucksoflemon8 #fyp
aztruckco

aztruckco

48 likes

Vampire Diaries Themed Car Accessories ❤️❤️❤️
#caraccessories #vampirediaries #bloodred #theme #salvatore
VonaX

VonaX

616 likes

The Vampire’s Diaries
Damon & Elena forever ❤️ #elenagilbert #damonsalvatore #vampire #thevampirediaries
Katherine LM

Katherine LM

145 likes

Nina Dobrev is shown side-by-side in two distinct outfits, one elegant in black and heels, the other casual in a leather jacket, jeans, and sneakers, under the title "Twin telepathy challenge."
A social media reel screenshot shows Nina Dobrev in two outfits for a "Twin telepathy challenge," with text "Put your hands on your head. Spin around." and "Doppelgänger edition," indicating a popular trend.
A close-up portrait of Nina Dobrev with long, dark wavy hair, wearing a dark top and a pendant necklace, portraying a serious or intense character.
Elena or Katherine? Nina Still Has It!
I screamed when I saw Nina Dobrev’s latest reel, it’s a doppelgänger showdown and my Vampire Diaries heart wasn’t ready. She recreated Elena and Katherine so flawlessly it’s like 2010 never ended. The reel is quick, fun, and nostalgic in the best way, and she captioned it “doppelgänger edition” whi
tasiaa

tasiaa

182 likes

🖤ᵉˡᵉⁿᵃ ᵍⁱˡᵇᵉʳᵗ/ⁿⁱⁿᵃ ᵈᵒᵇʳᵉᵛ ᵖⁱᶜˢ ᶠᵒʳ ʸᵒᵘ🖤
🅲🅷🅰🅽🅳🅻🅴🆁🖤🧛🏻🥀🆃🆅🅳

🅲🅷🅰🅽🅳🅻🅴🆁🖤🧛🏻🥀🆃🆅🅳

4 likes

A close-up of a woman with dark hair and a shocked expression, her mouth slightly open, in a dimly lit setting.
A woman with long dark hair and a serious, slightly sad expression looks off to the side.
A woman with dark, curly hair styled in an updo wears an elaborate green off-the-shoulder historical dress with lace details.
My Elena and Katherine moment 🥰
#katherinepierce #elenagilbertedit #vampirediaries
Debbie-A

Debbie-A

14 likes

A woman, Elena Gilbert, in a maroon top and dark jeans, with text overlay 'How to dress like Elena Gilbert' and a Lemon8 watermark.
A person wears a black V-neck top with white lace layered underneath, illustrating open necklines and lace details as part of Elena Gilbert's style.
A person wears mid-washed, low-rise flared jeans and Converse sneakers, showcasing these elements as part of Elena Gilbert's fashion.
How to dress like Elena Gilbert♥️🌹🗝
I would describe Elena’s style as y2k romantic with a gothic twist🕷❣️🕊 Who should I do next? #vampireaesthetic #vampirediaries #vampy #outfits #fashion #elenagilbert #romantic #style
Abby’s Archieve

Abby’s Archieve

5930 likes

Vampire Diaries ✨
The are perfect together 🥹❤️ #vampirediaries #elenagilbert #damonsalvatore #tvshows #thevampirediaries
Katherine LM

Katherine LM

186 likes

Gilbert Blythe dump because idk
#lemon8diarychallenge
DailyObsessions

DailyObsessions

89 likes

Elena Gilbert’s Bedroom
Home Suite Salvatore is an airbnb in Covington Ga • • #tvd #thevampirediariesedit #mysticfalls #airbnblife #airbnbcontentcreator
Malloree

Malloree

1551 likes

Elena Gilbert outfit inspo- The Vampire Diaries 😘😘
#thevampirediaries #inspo #outfit #fyp #viral
bailey boo

bailey boo

272 likes

Jeremy Gilbert🥰
Klementia💕

Klementia💕

158 likes

Elena Gilbert Makeup Tut💄
Elena Gilbert inspired makeup tutorial <3 Products used: ♡Too Faced Natural Eyes Eyeshadow Palette ♡Rare Beauty mascara ♡ Rare Beauty bronzer stick ♡Rare Beauty eyebrow pencil ♡NARS blush in shade “Behave” ♡Fresh Sugar Lip Treatment in shade “Rose” #fyp #fypシ゚viral #elenagilbert
✨Kayrina✨

✨Kayrina✨

72 likes

I love Jonhnnie Gilbert 🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤
#CapCut
𝓰𝓲𝓪♱✞ʚ☠︎︎ɞ

𝓰𝓲𝓪♱✞ʚ☠︎︎ɞ

24 likes

Johnny Gilbert
Ghost Face 😈

Ghost Face 😈

1819 likes

Elena Gilbert from The Vampire Diaries is shown on a laptop screen, holding a lit match, set against a blurred outdoor background.
A laptop displays a promotional image of the main cast of The Vampire Diaries, including Elena, Damon, and Stefan, under a full moon, with a green outdoor background.
The iconic love triangle from The Vampire Diaries is depicted on a laptop screen, with Elena Gilbert between Damon and Stefan Salvatore, against a blurred outdoor setting.
Elena Gilbert: Love, Loss and Vampires✨
Okay, so Elena Gilbert. She’s like the “girl next door” meets “eternally caught in supernatural chaos.” She starts off as this sweet, somewhat moody high school girl from Mystic Falls. You know, dealing with totally normal things like the tragic death of her parents and trying to hold her life toge
Lea Elizabeth✨

Lea Elizabeth✨

130 likes

Elena Gilbert Outfit🎀
This outfit and Elena’s pilot episode outfit will always be my favs💕 #fypシ #thevampirediaries #elenagilbert #outfitideas #outfitrecreation
✨Kayrina✨

✨Kayrina✨

1071 likes

Vampire Diaries Unhinged Story Time. Let’s Burn it
TVD Fans! Let’s go!! All the unhinged things…we all have them …let’s burn it. Not the typical stuff like yes Sybill sucked, Cade ridiculous. Don’t even get me started on Professor shit for brains and the whole cure puzzle line. We know Caroline & Klaus were endgame, Alaric had some great momen
Kitty McTaco

Kitty McTaco

44 likes

Right after Elena gets her Humanity back. #vampirediaries #cry #emotions #elenagilbert #humanity
✨𝔹𝕣𝕚𝕥𝕥𝕒𝕟𝕪 𝔻𝕒𝕨𝕟✨

✨𝔹𝕣𝕚𝕥𝕥𝕒𝕟𝕪 𝔻𝕒𝕨𝕟✨

73 likes

A close-up of Elena Gilbert with her hair in a ponytail, looking to the side. The image serves as a cover for 'rating elena gilbert outfits'.
Elena Gilbert is seen from behind, wearing a blue zip-up hoodie and dark jeans. This outfit is rated 9/10 as 'literally so cute'.
Elena Gilbert stands outdoors, talking on a phone, dressed in a dark blue short-sleeved top and dark jeans. This outfit is rated 8.9/10 as 'soooooo cute'.
rating elena gilbert outfits
#tvd #elenagilbert #elenagilbertoutfit #thevampirediaries #outfitideas
brooklyn23

brooklyn23

74 likes

Elena Gilbert Core
#elenagilbert #vampirediaries #y2kfashion #2000sfashion #outfitideas
HyperBees

HyperBees

41.8K likes

A portrait of Nina Dobrev as Elena Gilbert, with the text "HOW TO DRESS LIKE -ELANA GILBERT-" overlaid, suggesting a style guide.
A flat lay showing a dark blue long-sleeve top, white lace trim, black Converse sneakers, jeans, headphones, and "The Bell Jar" book, illustrating neutral and natural hues.
A flat lay featuring a red ribbed short-sleeve top with a tie front, white lace trim, jeans, black Converse, a book, and small accessories, showcasing Elena Gilbert's style.
How to look like Elena Gilbert
#thevampirediaries #elenagilbert #vampireseries #reposts @Noelle ☆
𝓚𝓪𝓽𝔂 💋

𝓚𝓪𝓽𝔂 💋

47 likes

Photo dump of Johnnie Gilbert
Gabberssss

Gabberssss

26 likes

Vampire Diaries
#vampirediaries #vampirediariestvd #tvd #elena ✨Outfit Details: #elenagilbertoutfit
Staaci

Staaci

54 likes

The vampire diaries 🩸
In my TVD era ✨ 💌 Brand: @Jaxon’s Tie Dye Workshop #thevampirediaries #katherinepierce #elenagilbert #damonsalvatore
Sam Morse

Sam Morse

21 likes

i’m free peoples biggest fan #freepeople #loveshackfancy #coquette #preciousmoments #coquetteaesthetic #lanadelrey #antique #dollette #elenagilbert #coquettestyle #dolletteaesthetic #coquetteroom #vintage #coquettecore #pinterestroom #bellaswan
— ˗ˋ ୨୧ ˊ˗ —

— ˗ˋ ୨୧ ˊ˗ —

11 likes

A hand holds 'The Vampire Diaries: The Awakening' by L.J. Smith, featuring the TV series cast on the cover. Other Vampire Diaries books are visible on a Books-A-Million shelf in the background, with a text overlay 'BOOKS A MILLION Vampire Diaries Book Series'.
The Vampire Diaries Book Series 🩸🧛🏻
You can find the Vampire Diaries Book Series at Books•A•Million! ❤️ The Vampire Diaries is a young adult vampire romance novel series by L.J. Smith, which began in 1991 with The Awakening and follows high school student Elena Gilbert's love triangle with vampire brothers Stefan and Damon Salvat
Justine Marie Carter | Inspo ✨

Justine Marie Carter | Inspo ✨

9 likes

i’m free peoples biggest fan #freepeople #loveshackfancy #coquette #preciousmoments #coquetteaesthetic #lanadelrey #antique #dollette #elenagilbert #coquettestyle #dolletteaesthetic #coquetteroom #vintage #coquettecore #pinterestroom #bellaswan
— ˗ˋ ୨୧ ˊ˗ —

— ˗ˋ ୨୧ ˊ˗ —

8 likes

Elena Gilbert inspired outfit
Another outfit inspired by Elena Gilbert ౨ৎ - - - - - Top: ShopCider Jeans: True Religion Vervain necklace: Amazon - - - _____________________________________________ Elena Gilbert Inspired Outfit, Recreating outfits, Elena Gilbert, Elena Gilbert outfits, Elena Gilbert clothes, Lace tri
✨Kayrina✨

✨Kayrina✨

1707 likes

Bella swan outfitIdeas
#bellaswan #elena gilbert #twilight
McKenzii

McKenzii

46 likes

Elena Gilbert
#elenagilbert #thevampirediaries
☂️

☂️

47 likes

Rating Vampire Diaries characters
Pumpkin pie is my favorite 🎃😍 #vampirediaries #elenagilbert #damonsalvatore #stefansalvatore #thevampirediaries
Lisa Diana

Lisa Diana

105 likes

Gilbert Bylthe
#Gilbert #gilberybylthe #pookie Guys, I'm so sorry for not posting as much, I'll get back to it 😔😚😅
DailyObsessions

DailyObsessions

43 likes

Vampire Diaries
#vampirediaries #iansomerhalder #elenagilbert #fypシ #fypシ゚viral
Theofficial_snowghost

Theofficial_snowghost

7 likes

A black long-sleeve top with white lace trim, black sneakers with white laces, and a silver necklace with a locket and hoop earrings, laid out on a dark, web-patterned surface.
A pink short-sleeve top with white lace trim, black sneakers with white laces, a silver necklace with a locket, and hoop earrings, labeled as "Ross $7.99" and "Amazon Converse dupe."
A grey ribbed tank top with lace trim, a silver necklace with a locket, and hoop earrings, with a black sneaker partially visible, labeled as "Shein."
How to dress like Elena ✨
Whenever fall gets here I love to bring out my Elena Gilbert outfits. These are my new ones 🖤 I almost didn’t get the olive one glad I did! #elenagilbert #outfitinspo #CONVERSE #2000sfashion #tvd
Riah🍂🎃🕸️🤎🧸

Riah🍂🎃🕸️🤎🧸

419 likes

Elena Gilbert core closet
My closet tour with Elena Gilbert inspired clothes♡ #elenagilbert #thevampirediaries #tvd #closettour #outfitinspo
✨Kayrina✨

✨Kayrina✨

52 likes

A moodboard for The Vampire Diaries featuring the main trio (Elena, Damon, Stefan), Katherine Pierce, and other characters. It includes the show's logo, a hand touching lavender, a dark bridge, and a group of vampires, all set against a dark, mysterious aesthetic.
An aesthetic moodboard for Elena Gilbert, showing her with a phone, vervain locket, Converse shoes, a note, and a map of Mystic Falls. It also features her parents' gravestone with a crow and text about doppelgängers.
An aesthetic moodboard for Stefan Salvatore, including his ring, him holding flowers, a photo with Klaus, and text about being a 'ripper'. It also shows books, a football, and medical supplies from Mystic Falls Hospital.
The Vampire Diaries Aesthetics
I haven’t posted on here in soooooo long! 😭 So for my “I’m back!” post I decided to do something I love - make a moodboard. With my obsession with The Vampire Diaries still here I decided the show characters would be my first victims 😂 So here is the aesthetics of 3 main characters from The Vamp
𝐀 🫶🏼

𝐀 🫶🏼

486 likes

See more