Lemon8Lifestyle community
itsemily🦇
itsemily🦇

229 followers

Follow
Follow
Follow
A red poster-like image features a black silhouette of a person in a doorway, casting a long shadow, above the "Stranger Things" logo. The text overlay reads, "the first shadow & S4 doesn't make sense to me."
A smiling family of four, including two adults and two children, stands outdoors. The text states, "in S4 henry was 12 years old when he did what he did to his family that was March 1959."
A young boy in a white gown sits distressed in a chair while an adult man leans over him. The text explains, "and that's when he went to the lab with dr. brenner unti 1979 when 11 banished him into the upside down."
A person stands with their back to the viewer, looking up at a large, tentacled monster in a dark, otherworldly landscape. The text states, "he then created the mind flayer in the upside down. shown here in S4."
A group of young people, including a woman standing center, are on a stage set with lockers, resembling a high school play. The text describes the live-action play's setting in 1959 with Henry at 14 in high school.
A young man with a blindfold holds hands with a young woman in a dimly lit room with candles. The text states, "it shows then that he was flayed in HS and did what he did to patty newby."
A young boy in a grey tank top holds a resistance band, looking directly at the camera. The text asks, "and then he was sent to the lab with dr. brenner??"
Hands hold an old playbill for "Oklahoma!" dated November 6th, 1955, listing cast members like Henry Creel. The text overlay mentions a Season 5 play dated November 6th, 1959, with Henry, Joyce, and Hopper.
A young boy in a white gown sits distressed in a chair while an adult man leans over him. The text questions, "but in season 4 he went to the lab march 1958. so how is he in the play in HS when he would've been 12 in the show and at the lab?"
1/10

You may also like

No content
See more on the app
See more on the app
See more on the app
14 saved
76
2

this sh!t makes my head hurt

2025/11/28 Edited to

... Read moreThe timeline surrounding Henry Creel, also known as One in Stranger Things, especially as presented in Seasons 4 and 5, has caused a lot of head-scratching among fans. According to the show's lore, Henry was 12 years old in March 1959 when he committed a traumatic act against his family and was subsequently sent to Dr. Brenner's lab. This event is pivotal as it leads to his banishment into the Upside Down, where he eventually creates the Mind Flayer. However, the timelines in the show seem to contradict other depictions, such as the live action play referenced by fans. The play apparently takes place in 1959 as well, but shows Henry as a 14-year-old high school senior involved with Joyce and Hopper, which conflicts with the lab timeline since he couldn’t physically be in both places at once. Moreover, the play includes events like Henry's flaying in high school and his interactions with characters like Patty Newby before being sent to the lab — a timeline shift that fans find confusing. These narrative conflicts might be attributed to the show's non-linear storytelling and creative liberties taken with flashbacks and alternate realities. It's also possible the creators intend to reveal more information that will reconcile these discrepancies in future episodes. In any case, understanding Henry's arc requires careful attention to the exact dates and the show's blending of timelines. For fans trying to piece together the events, creating a detailed timeline charting key moments—such as Henry’s age, dates of the lab experiments, the play’s setting, and the creation of the Mind Flayer—can help clarify. Engaging in community discussions, watching episodes closely, and following official Stranger Things content updates or interviews might provide new insights. Overall, Stranger Things continues to deepen its complex narrative web, challenging viewers to connect dots across seasons. This engrossing mix of sci-fi, supernatural, and surreal drama keeps fans theorizing and invested in trying to unlock the show's full mysteries.

2 comments

Ava's images
Ava

O my freaking god I just realized this

4/8
Reply