Here’s my honest review 👀

#kbeautyfinds #lemon8challenge

🚫 I wouldn’t buy it again

This green tomato mask has been ALL over TikTok lately and I finally tried it because I was super curious about the blackhead claims

And okay… I need to be honest about this product because I feel like the viral videos are VERY misleading.

I genuinely thought those little black dots you see when massaging the product were actual blackheads coming out of the skin… but they’re not. The black particles are already inside the formula from the beginning

The more you massage it, the more visible they become, so honestly a big part of the “wow effect” feels like marketing.

Now for the actual product itself:

I personally would NOT recommend this for dry skin or even most combination skin types.

After I rinsed it off my skin felt SUPER tight, especially around my cheeks.

So in my opinion this mask is mostly for:

very oily skin

people with lots of sebaceous filaments/blackheads

people who like deep cleansing clay masks

If you already struggle with dryness or sensitivity… I honestly think this could feel too stripping.

Not the worst product ever, but definitely one of those “viral products” that looks more dramatic online than it actually is in real life

5/25 Edited to

... Read moreIt’s so easy to get swept up in the whirlwind of viral skincare products, isn't it? I’ve definitely been there, scrolling through TikTok, seeing amazing transformations, and thinking, 'I NEED that!' But after trying countless trends, including masks like the highly-talked-about green tomato one, I’ve learned a few crucial lessons about navigating the hype. One of the biggest takeaways for me is to approach 'instant pore cleanse' claims with a healthy dose of skepticism. We all want clearer skin, but true pore refinement and blackhead reduction take time and consistent care. Often, those satisfying 'black dots' or 'gunk' you see coming out of a mask are either part of the product's formula, like I experienced with the green tomato mask, or simply sebaceous filaments – natural oil plugs that are part of our skin's healthy function, not necessarily something to harshly extract. Real blackheads are oxidized sebum, and while masks can help, they rarely offer an instant, dramatic pull. When it comes to clay masks, which this green tomato mask essentially is, they can be fantastic for oily and blemish-prone skin. Ingredients like kaolin or bentonite clay are brilliant at absorbing excess oil and drawing out impurities. However, as the original review mentioned, they can be incredibly stripping, especially if you have dry, sensitive, or even combination skin. My cheeks, for instance, often feel so tight and uncomfortable after a harsh clay mask, which can actually compromise the skin barrier and lead to more issues. So, what does work? For persistent blackheads and congested pores, I’ve found that consistency with gentle chemical exfoliants like Salicylic Acid (BHA) can be a game-changer. These ingredients penetrate oil to clear out pores from within, rather than just pulling from the surface. Hydrating masks, often enriched with ceramides or hyaluronic acid, are also vital for keeping the skin balanced, which surprisingly helps reduce oil production over time for some people. If you're still keen on trying a mask with unique ingredients, research is key. While 'green tomato water' might sound intriguing, look for scientific backing on its purported benefits. Is it truly deeply cleansing, or simply a novel addition? Don't let clever marketing overshadow actual efficacy. For an 'instant pore cleanse' feeling that's actually beneficial, I prefer gentle exfoliating masks with fruit enzymes or very mild acids that clean without stripping. Ultimately, my journey with viral skincare has taught me that what truly works is understanding my own skin type, listening to its needs, and choosing products with proven ingredients over fleeting trends. It's about building a consistent routine that nurtures your skin, not just chasing the next big thing on TikTok. Finding products that genuinely make my skin feel healthy and balanced, without the 'wow effect' marketing, has been far more rewarding in the long run.

1 comment

DestinyK's images
DestinyK

Thanks for sharing your honest opinion! So helpful 🙂

Related posts

A green bottle of 'method. mindful matcha body wash' sits on a shower shelf. The bottle label highlights 'matcha yuzu jasmine' scents and claims it 'leaves skin feeling soft + fresh'. Text overlays read 'Matcha Body Wash' and 'Worth The Rave?'.
Here’s My Honest Review
This Matcha body wash is HEAVENLY! It shook me when I used it because I thought I wouldn’t like it. It have a subtle yet bold fragrance it’s very cooling and it’s nothing like any other product Ive used from them 10/10 #hardlaunch #lemon8challenge #letschat
TheeMotherTrucker

TheeMotherTrucker

557 likes

An overview of various beauty and personal care products from a budget store, including lip care, room sprays, toilet sprays, hand wipes, facial scrub, and body washes, presented for review.
Six sets of lip masks and lip oils in different colors and scents like rose, lavender, lemon, apple, peach, and mint, rated 9/10 for hydration and plumping.
Three concentrated room mists with scents such as peach & mango, lychee & pine, and vanilla & cashmere, rated 10/10 for use as clothes sprays.
Honest Review on Viral Dollar Tree items‼️
❤️Hello My Boujie Budget Baddies 🤑 I hope you’re all having an amazing day! If you’re new here WELCOME! I hope you consider following me for content like this & MORE😁 🍋Here’s some of my honest reviews on some of my favorite DT products. I usually will test each product for about a week to be
HeyItsAshleyK1

HeyItsAshleyK1

1520 likes

Three pink skincare products from the b.pure Glow Up line are displayed on a shelf, including a toner, serum, and night moisturizer, all featuring watermelon extract. The image is overlaid with text reading "HONEST REVIEW Worth it?" and "Glowy Skin".
Honest review⬇️
I have very dry skin. I’m not sensitive to products so I tried this and here’s my honest opinion Toner: I do this before adding anything to my face. Ig cleans up any dirt (?) and impurities on my face and leaves my face looking clean and clear. 10/10 serum: I apply this after I use the toner
🎀Krystal🎀

🎀Krystal🎀

2095 likes

An honest review of four body care products: a whipped oil butter, body oil, shave oil serum, and body lotion, all from a vanilla cashmere collection. The image features a five-star rating and text indicating a collection review.
A close-up of a whipped oil butter product in a light purple jar, rated 5/5. Text describes its nice and thick consistency, like a butter, and expresses appreciation for its inclusion.
A close-up of a body oil product in a light purple bottle, rated 3/5. Text notes it smells great but the bottle is small, the oil is watery, and moisturizing could be better for its value.
Honest Review: eos Vanilla Cashmere Collection
❤️Hello Everyone! I hope you’re having an amazing day! If you’re new here WELCOME to my page. I hope you’ll consider following me for more content 😁 ❤️Honest Review: I love the smell of vanilla cashmere and so far EVERYTHING has the same exact smell which is good. Overall I like everything. I
HeyItsAshleyK1

HeyItsAshleyK1

923 likes

A hand holds a bottle of suncare oil spray with SPF 20, labeled for protection and tan. The image has a text overlay indicating it's an honest review of the product, specifically the SPF kind. The background shows a blurred indoor setting with a couch.
My HONEST review of Carroten
I have seen all over Tiktok that Carroten is the new brand to get you golden brown, and since i’m leaving for Ft. Lauderdale in less than a month, I had to try it. So here’s what I thought⬇️: - at first spray, it comes out as orange?? (if you’re like me and don’t immediately put together th
jennaca 🫧

jennaca 🫧

171 likes

TikTok made me read it & here’s my honest review 👀
Lots of people were posting about this book and raving about it before I succumbed to and actually read it. 👀 In my Let Them era 💅 Here are my honest, and raw thoughts: The let them theory is a popular self help concept. This book encourages us to release the desperate need to control oth
Reneè Nicole 💫🧿

Reneè Nicole 💫🧿

13 likes

A hand holds a bottle of black castor premium hair oil, reviewed as great for hair growth retention, with a 4-star rating.
A hand holds a bottle of rosemary and mint shampoo infused with biotin, reviewed as a past obsession but a little drying, with a 3-star rating.
A hand holds a bottle of curl shampoo for curly hair, which is reviewed as lacking moisture but smelling heavenly, with a 2-star rating.
Honest Natural Hair Review 🪮
Just tried some natural hair products from TJ Maxx and here’s my honest review: Some of them really surprised me in the best way! 💁🏽‍♀️ A few were total game-changers for my curls—moisturizing, defining, and smelling amazing. But, not every product was a win. Some left my hair feeling a little heav
HaulsbyKT

HaulsbyKT

173 likes

Honest review
My HONEST gisou review🍯🌸🐝 I am obsessed with gisou, here are my thoughts on the products I have tried!!🤍 gisou lip oil(watermelon sugar) | $28 9/10 •such a shimmery glossy lip oil. The most perfect shade of pink. I get asked about this lip oil often. The only down side to this lip oil… I fin
Kansas Grace

Kansas Grace

2456 likes

Exterior view of Lee Ren Hair Salon in NYC, featuring a prominent purple sign with the salon's name in English and Chinese characters on a brown building facade with an arched window.
Interior view of a busy hair salon with a checkered floor, multiple styling chairs, and large mirrors reflecting the space, illuminated by purple-pink lighting.
Street view of Lee Ren Hair Salon's exterior in NYC, showing its dark facade, multiple signs with the salon's name, and a dark-colored car parked in front.
$25 Blowout in NYC – Here’s My Honest Review!
📍LEE REN HAIR SALON I got a $25 blowout in NYC, and it was such a steal! I didn’t make an appointment—I just walked in after seeing some buzz about LEE REN HAIR SALON online. It was pretty busy, and most of the chairs were full, but despite that, I only waited a couple of minutes before they sea
Emma Taylor

Emma Taylor

1 like

A smiling young woman stands outside a beauty store, with text about being asked for skincare help.
A young woman lies in bed, looking tired with visible skin imperfections, labeled 'Before...'.
A young woman in a car, smiling with clear, glowing skin and makeup, labeled 'After...'.
Rating Sephora skincare, here’s my honest review.
#skincaretips #sephora #glowup #skincarereview #usa
Emily

Emily

0 likes

A person walks outdoors, wearing white jeans adorned with a colorful food pattern, a black crop top, and carrying a black shoulder bag. The jeans feature various illustrations of food items like bread, vegetables, and seafood, with a relaxed fit around the waist.
My honest review of the Lisa Says Gah! jeans
After seeing these “it-girl” jeans all over my socials I caved and bought them. Here are my thoughts. 1. Material is 100% cotton and so comfortable! I was worried they would be too tight or stiff but ugh they’re a dream 2. I wish I sized down :( they still fit nice but they do have some give t
ryleigh ✿

ryleigh ✿

330 likes

Three Ôrebella perfume bottles in green, yellow, and pink with gold caps are displayed on a reflective surface, introducing an honest review of the fragrances.
A woman holds the green Ôrebella perfume bottle, representing the Salted Muse scent, which is described as an earthy fragrance with an 8/10 rating.
The yellow Ôrebella perfume bottle, representing the Blooming Fire scent, rests on sand with driftwood, described as having a unique, warm, and cozy fragrance with a 10/10 rating.
‘Ôrebella Honest Review ⭐️
Here are descriptions of three different scents: 1. Salted Muse: A scent that combines sea salt and pink pepper with earthy amber notes. Initially, it smells earthy when applied, but it gradually warms up and develops a woody and warm character. 🌿 2. Blooming Fire: A blend of patchouli and be
myfavpins

myfavpins

76 likes

✨🛁Dr Teal’s Sugar Scrubs: A Male’s Honest Review🧽✨
✨ Exfoliation day just got interesting because my fiancé had some thoughts on these Dr Teal’s Shea Sugar Scrubs! If you’re not familiar, these scrubs are designed to gently exfoliate, remove dead skin, and leave you feeling soft, smooth, and moisturized. Just massage onto damp skin in circular moti
Margarita

Margarita

45 likes

A hand holds a clear bottle of "LOVE & CARE REFRESHING INTIMATE WASH FOR WOMEN" with a pump. Text indicates it's a beneficial product for intimate care.
A hand holds the "LOVE & CARE" intimate wash bottle upside down, showing a small amount of liquid. Text highlights it as a women's intimate care secret that lasts three months.
A close-up shows pink liquid and bubbles from the "LOVE & CARE" intimate wash bottle. Text describes it as non-itchy, refreshing, and good-smelling.
Here's My Honest Review After 3 Months of Use 🎀
So, I’ve talked about intimate care before, but today, I just have to share my experience with Secrethem LOVE CARE Intimate Wash Liquid after using it for 3 months! 🫣 When I first started, I was struggling with the discomfort and sticky feeling down there, especially in the hot weather and durin
IronManFan

IronManFan

2 likes

HONEST PUMPKIN SPICE PERFUME REVIEW 🎃🍂✨
I just bought Pumpkin Epicee by Le Monde Gourmand hair and body mist and here's the rundown: PRICE: $28 NOTES: Pumpkin Spice, Nutmeg & Frothed Milk, Musk & Sandalwood MY REVIEW 👇👇 SMELL: 10000/10, it smells delicious! I was so excited when I smelled it! LASTING POWER: 7/10,
Lushie Club 💖

Lushie Club 💖

258 likes

A hand holds an open box containing four small perfume bottles, labeled 'KAY ALI Freedom Musk Bouquet', 'Freedom Musk Santal', 'Freedom Musk Matcha', and 'Freedom Musk Latte'. The image is titled 'Freedom Musk Obsession Collection My HONEST Review' with decorative elements like flowers and drinks.
A hand with dark red nails holds a light pink perfume bottle labeled 'KAY ALI Freedom Musk Bouquet | 27'. Text describes it as soft, clean, powdery floral, and fresh, rated 7.5/10, and not full-bottle worthy.
A hand with dark red nails holds a light brown perfume bottle labeled 'KAY ALI Freedom Musk Santal | 34'. Text describes it as soft, warm musk with creamy santal, beautiful, smooth, and the star, rated 100/10.
Honest Kayali Freedom Review ✨(Don’t Fight Me) 😂
So my Kayali Freedom Obsessions review is finally here and y’all…please don’t drag me 😭💗 Yall KNOW I love Kayali DOWN, always have, always will but one thing I always have to do is be honest in my reviews. Out of the whole set, the only one I would buy a full bottle of today is Musk Santal…she
Jecenia Monique

Jecenia Monique

458 likes

A kotatsu table with a light-colored top, a patterned blanket, and pillows for seating, set up on a gray rug. A black cat is visible in the background, illustrating the home setup.
A split image showing the kotatsu's heating element glowing underneath the table, and a hand demonstrating the 'Off' and 'On' positions of the inline power switch on the cord.
A kotatsu table with a patterned blanket, a red cushion on a wooden stool, and a patterned pillow, arranged on a gray rug, ready for use.
Owning a Kotatsu a honest review
No hate but!!! First off….its not a fire hazard!!! (As long as you as a person know to turn it off ) it doesn’t for mine stay on it has a cool down mode. I’m only saying this as the most often complaint or criticism is “fire hazard” Sorry for the rough tone but here we go! It a space heater!
Skootie

Skootie

285 likes

A hand holds a green bottle of strengthening shampoo with a black pump top, featuring rosemary and mint. The label indicates it's infused with biotin for longer, healthier hair. The background is a white tiled wall, with text overlays about a one-week review.
MY HONEST REVIEW🌿
🌿For the past week I’ve been using this shampoo religiously, I work a laborious job and when I get home from work my main goal is relaxation. 🌿SLEEP! This has definitely helped me fall asleep faster AND stay asleep, I’ve only woken up a couple of times this entire week which is rare for me. 🌿
Alexandra Mackenzie

Alexandra Mackenzie

232 likes

Four light blue skincare containers are displayed on a white surface, with a green plant in the background. The containers include a foaming oil cleanser, a lipid-peptide cream, an eye treatment, and a barrier restoring gel cream. Text overlays read "With actual Reasons", "Skincare", and "BUY".
An honest review
I’m back with another honest review from someone who’s not trying to sell you some thing 🩵 Today’s focus is #skincare specifically …SKINFIX. Now right off the bat this is a very expensive brand …. caught myself looking at it for a couple months trying to talk myself away from it because to be
With Love, Kirsten

With Love, Kirsten

66 likes

A hand holds a dark bottle of liquid chlorophyll drops with a dropper. The label identifies it as a vegan, peppermint-flavored dietary supplement. Overlay text asks, "My Honest Chlorophyll Review Glow? Energy? Detox?". A social media watermark is in the corner.
My Honest Review: Chlorophyll & Soft-Life Wellness
Everybody on the internet is putting chlorophyll drops in their water… but nobody is really saying what it actually does. So I tried it consistently, and here’s the real tea 🌿✨ I’ve been using MaryRuth’s Vegan Chlorophyll Liquid Drops (Peppermint) in my water, and I wanted to share my honest
ElevatedByShell

ElevatedByShell

16 likes

A black SlumberPod blackout tent is shown fully assembled over a pack and play, with the title 'My Honest SlumberPod Review' overlaid.
A black travel bag for the SlumberPod is displayed on a textured rug, with the text 'Travel bag' indicating its purpose.
The components of the SlumberPod, including the rolled-up black fabric cover and several silver poles, are shown on a rug.
My Honest SlumberPod Review
I was gifted a Slumber Pod by the company directly. I thought I’d do a full review on it here on Lemon8 and give my honest opinion. If you don’t know, the Slumber Pod is a black out tent that goes over a pack and play. It’s meant to be another solution for black out curtains when you’re travelin
Samantha Gail

Samantha Gail

43 likes

My honest review…
Here is my honest review of the second Airbnb I stayed in while being in Dallas Link for Airbnb: https://www.airbnb.com/slink/Mljxs9mT #airbnbfinds #airbnbreview #airbnbexperience #airbnbrecommendations #dallastexas #lemon8diarychallenge #bdayindallas #reviews #dow
AlexciaRaquel 💕

AlexciaRaquel 💕

3 likes

An overhead flat lay of various beauty empties and restocks on a knitted blanket, including a moisturizer, hand cream, foundation, concealer, and highlighter, with text indicating an honest review and suitable for dry skin.
An open compact of a shimmery highlighter, rated 10/10, resting on a knitted blanket. A pink phone is reflected in the compact's mirror.
An empty, squeezed tube of hand cream, rated 10/10, on a knitted blanket. Text describes it as long-lasting and effective.
✨Rate My Empties✨ | Honest Review 👀
Here are my honest thoughts regarding my empties, some are worth getting again and some are not 🤷🏻‍♀️ #ratemyempties #beautyfinds #shareyourthoughts #rarebeauty #Loccitane #skincare #lemon8challenge #lemon8partner #fashionfinds #whatsinmybag
Jennifer A 🎀

Jennifer A 🎀

24 likes

A flat lay of various makeup and skincare products in pink and gold tones, with text overlay indicating a makeup review focusing on a specific brand.
A pink and black mascara tube with a wand. The accompanying text describes it as a volume and length-giving mascara that prevents smudging and is affordable.
A pink mascara tube with a black wand. The text praises its ability to provide curl and enhance natural lash length, often used in combination with another product.
Honest Makeup Review!!✨💕💅
i love elf with all my heart and it is my favorite brand of makeup! heres my honest opinion on it❤️ #elf #makeup #WhattoWatch #lemon8challenge #thebest #inspo
Hayley💕

Hayley💕

11 likes

Four different body wash bottles are displayed on a store shelf, each with a distinct color and formulation. The bottles are labeled with their specific functions, such as multi-oil, salicylic acid, glycolic acid, and vitamin C. The text "Honest Review" is overlaid on the image.
Honest review: Naturium. Is it worth the $$?
The Glow Getter Voted-The softest skin! This one is top tier, the hype is real BUT I personally would not use this alone. It just doesn’t make me feel clean enough BUT when I combine it with either The Smoother Salicylic Acid or The Smoother Glycolic Acid Exfoliating wash it works wonders and does
Auri

Auri

607 likes

A hand holds two Sand + Fog perfume oil bottles, 'Vanilla Cake' and 'Marshmallow Skies,' against a green background. Text overlays announce 'SAND + FOG Perfume Oils' and 'HONEST REVIEW,' inviting users to swipe for more.
A hand holds the Sand + Fog 'Vanilla Cake' perfume oil bottle. Text describes its decadent gourmand scent with notes of creamy vanilla, orange zest, sugar, musk, and butter, highlighting it as a sophisticated vanilla fragrance.
A hand holds the Sand + Fog 'Marshmallow Skies' perfume oil bottle. Text describes its creamy marshmallow scent, with notes of strawberry, raspberry, vanilla, cream, sugar, and musk, noting the fruitiness is subtle.
Sand + Fog Honest Review
Honest Review: Sand & Fog Perfume Oils (Marshmallow Skies & Vanilla Cake) I recently tried out the new Sand & Fog perfume oils, and I have to say these two stood out to me the most: Marshmallow Skies and Vanilla Cake. Both are absolutely delicious if you’re into gourmand scents. L
HeyItsAshleyK1

HeyItsAshleyK1

328 likes

A flat lay of various viral makeup products, including powders, blushes, and gels, on a white textured surface, with the text "VIRAL MAKEUP Honest Review" overlaid.
A pink compact with an "O/S" logo and an open container of loose powder, described as a powder used under the eyes, with a note about the packaging.
An open compact featuring a reddish-pink blush pan and a mirror, identified as a luminous blush that the reviewer did not like.
VIRAL MAKEUP honest review
Here is my honest review of some viral makeup products The one size beauty powder is great, but I’m not a huge fan of the packaging. I also feel like there’s better powders out there for the same price. When rare beauty came out with a luminizing blush I was so excited. Honestly, this was su
Adi 🐝

Adi 🐝

112 likes

The image shows the book cover for "Psyche and Eros" by Luna McNamara, featuring a blue background with decorative feathers, an arrow, a butterfly, and flowers. A search bar overlay reads "an honest review," and a quote from Jennifer Saint is visible at the top. A Lemon8 watermark is in the bottom left.
Psyche and Eros: an honest review
⭐️Overall rating: 4/5 This was such a cute book filled with adventure, grief, and love. However, it's a retelling, and Psyche has been warped into what is essentially a brand new character altogether. She's not a girly girl like in the original tale. She's a tomboy here and doesn'
Mercedes

Mercedes

3 likes

A hand holds two EOS body lotions, 'Whipped Shea & Sugar' (blue) and 'Sparkling Amber' (pink), from the Winter Collection. The image features the title 'EOS WINTER COLLECTION MY HONEST REVIEW'.
EOS Lotion Winter Collection: My Honest Review ❄️
I just had to get my hands on both of these. I finally found Sparkling Amber after yall help (THANK YOU LEMON SQUEEZIES 🍋❤️)! Here’s my honest reviews: Whipped Shea & Sugar 🍡 Notes: brown sugar | blush peony | caramelized crème brûlée • Def my favorite out of the two • Think of a
Lovee Tee 🫶🏾

Lovee Tee 🫶🏾

31 likes

A display of light blue denim mini skirts on hangers in a store, with a price tag visible. The image features text about a viral PacSun denim mini skirt review and outfit ideas.
A flat lay of a PacSun light blue stretch mid-rise denim mini skirt, priced at $42.95. The image includes a 9.5/10 rating and details about its soft, stretchy fabric, slight waist gap, belt loops, sizing down, and perfect length.
A person models Outfit #1, featuring a light blue denim mini skirt paired with a white ribbed tank top, a black belt, white socks, and grey sneakers, standing in front of a mirror.
Honest review of the trending PacSun mini skirt!!
Have you been seeing this skirt all over social media too??! I was definitely influenced so I ran to PacSun to check it out lol I am so so glad I did though. This skirt really does live up to all the hype 💯 Here is my honest review: I am 5’2” and the length of this skirt is perffffect for me. M
denny

denny

1138 likes

A flat lay shows a variety of SHEGLAM makeup products, including foundations, blushes, and other items, arranged on a textured surface. The image asks, 'is it worth the hype?'
A hand holds an open jar of SHEGLAM Smoothing Primer, a light pink cream product. Text indicates a 5/10 rating, noting it was 'too greasy' but makeup 'lasted all day.'
A hand holds a bottle of SHEGLAM Matte Foundation. Text indicates a 9/10 rating, highlighting its 'full coverage' and that it 'blends well with liquid products.'
SHEGLAM💄 HONEST REVIEW
I’ve seen Sheglam all over TikTok and was skeptical about the brand/ quality🤨 The brand reached out to me and sent me some products to try and I absolutely LOVE some of them while others….trash🚮 Here are my thoughts⬇️ 💄 The smoothing primer is wayyy too greasy for my liking. I have oily skin so I
Erica Giles

Erica Giles

61 likes

See more