A book everyone loved but I didn’t…

"A Court of Thorns and Roses" by Sarah J. Maas has received a lot of buzz, but for me, it didn't meet the lofty expectations it was hyped up to have. The idea of a modern take on Beauty and the Beast is interesting, but the way it was done felt underwhelming. The story dragged at times, with parts that dragged on and made it hard to keep interested. Moreover, the growth of the characters was lacking; I was at times annoyed by Feyre, the main character, and she didn't feel as captivating as I had hoped. Additionally, the way the world was created, though detailed in some places, was often confusing. There were instances where the backstory could have been more thoroughly examined, but instead, it was skimmed over or overshadowed by the romantic aspects. Although I understand the effort to mix fantasy with romance, it seemed like the romance aspect was too dominant, making the story feel somewhat cliché. In the end, the book didn't strike a chord with me as I expected, and I was hoping for a more unified and captivating story.

I give it a ⭐️⭐️

My ex best wouldn’t stop talking about this book. Only reason why I picked it up. #fantasybookreview #book reviews #book reviews #the reappearance of #books @Lemon8 BookClub @

2024/11/26 Edited to

... Read moreIn the realm of fantasy literature, 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' has garnered a wide readership and acclaim, marking it as a staple in contemporary fantasy. The story, inspired by the classic Beauty and the Beast, weaves romance and adventure, yet it has sparked a debate among readers regarding its narrative execution. Many readers find that while Sarah J. Maas excels at crafting immersive worlds, the pacing of the story often hinders the development of key themes and character arcs. The main character, Feyre, has been critiqued for her lack of depth, leaving some readers wishing for a more dynamic portrayal of her growth throughout the series. Many reviews highlight that the romantic elements overshadow the plot, which could lead to a feeling of cliché among avid fantasy fans. Moreover, the novel's rich fantasy backdrop—while appealing—sometimes leads to confusion, particularly when intertwined with a romantic plot that some perceive as overpowering. The demands of world-building alongside romance may detract from the narrative's coherence. Readers looking for a nuanced balance between fantasy and romance might find themselves disappointed. For those seeking a deeper dive into character development or more substantial world-building, exploring other fantasy novels that maintain this balance could be enlightening. Additionally, engaging with community discussions on platforms like book review forums can provide varied perspectives on this divided topic, fostering a broader understanding of the genre and its expectations. Whether you're a steadfast Maas fan or approaching the series with caution, each reading experience contributes to an expanding dialogue about the evolving landscape of fantasy literature.

24 comments

Sassy Wolf's images
Sassy Wolf

I suffered through all of them- never got the hype

See more(2)
Wikki's images
Wikki

About halfway through is when I got into it. But I had to use audible. But they do get better!

See more comments

Related posts

Best book for anyone with ADHD
This book was recommended to me a while back by someone here on Lemon8, they said it was very informative and easy to follow, so of course I immediately purchased it since I have a loved one with ADHD and would love to learn more about it so I know how to best help. The book didn’t disappoint, it h
Byaombe •••

Byaombe •••

996 likes

Dark Academia book recommendations 🕰️🕯️
​Hi guys! Autumn is approaching us and for me that means dark academia season is in full swing. I’ve put together a small list of book recommendations that have everything from rainy libraries, old books, dark romance, and fueled obsessions. Enjoy! 1. The Queens Gambit. This is one of my all ti
romneyellen

romneyellen

950 likes

Sports Romance Book Review🏊🏼‍♀️📖💗
Hey Y’all 😊 This is my honest review of Deep End by Ali Hazelwood. First things first thank you PS Bookclub for this limited edition cover if ykyk!! #booksummary 📚 Title and Author: Deep End by Ali Hazelwood 🌟 Genre: Contemporary/Sports Romance 💬 Short Summary: Scarlett the FMC is a ju
Jayde 💫🍒🪩

Jayde 💫🍒🪩

645 likes

Books I loved that didn’t make my top 10
I loved these books down but they just didn’t make it into my top 10 of the year #popularbooks #blackauthor #lemon8bookclub #bookish #topten
AleekaReads

AleekaReads

67 likes

8 Books at B&N I almost bought but didn't
While I did buy a lot of books from Barnes and Noble there were so many that caught my eye that I put back. These got added to my list to buy later. 🦴Nettle and Bone *AUTHOR: T. Kingfisher *GENRE: Twisted Fairytale I bought another book by this author on the same day and another title was my
✨️Morgan📚

✨️Morgan📚

1171 likes

A person holds a stack of college books, covering their face, with text asking an English Major for an honest review of required reading. The image features a Lemon8 logo.
A dog looks at an open copy of Fyodor Dostoevsky's 'The Brothers Karamazov,' described as a loved novel and a beautiful story of forgiveness. The image includes a Lemon8 logo.
A dog lies next to three Dante books: 'Inferno,' 'Purgatorio,' and 'Paradiso,' which are described as dragging and self-indulgent. The image features a Lemon8 logo.
required reading - what i loved & what i didn't
hi friends! 🌈 i graduated a few years ago and thought this might be fun to make!! 📜 i graduated with a bachelor's degree in English and n e a r l y a minor in theatre / philosophy (my schedule didnt work for either one, so i ended up being a few credits short of a double minor lol) 👩‍🎓
Grace Anne

Grace Anne

251 likes

A hand holds several books with light-colored spines. Overlay text reads "MY FAVORITE BOOK BOYFRIENDS (PART 4)" and "(may contain mild spoilers)". Lemon8 logo and username are at the bottom.
A collage for Cade Eaton (Heartless) featuring a cowboy hat, a guitar, a man with a child in a hot tub, a man on horseback, and a couple. Text highlights his traits like "grumpy cowboy with a big heart."
A collage for Aaron Warner (Shatter Me Series) with images of an eye, a red rose, a dove, a couple kissing, and a man writing. Text describes his "passionate love" and "soft spot for animals."
fav book boyfriends
i could make a hundred parts to this omg (cade eaton, aaron warner, johnny kavanagh, loren hale, aiden crawford, nate hawkins, luke ryder, jacob maddox, alex volkov) who’s your favorite book boyfriend?? #lemon8bookclub #readersoflemon8 #bookboyfriend #bookwormsoflemon8 #bookrecomm
mads

mads

1392 likes

BOOKS I DIDN’T EXPECT TO LOVE
Sometimes you feel like you’re forcing yourself to read something that’s been on your TBR for so long… and it ends up that you actually LOVE it!!! This is kinda what happened with these books: A Million Kisses in Your Lifetime by Monica Murphy Ik this one has mixed reviews bc the plot is a lit
KENNEDY ♡

KENNEDY ♡

43 likes

A reddish-brown book titled 'The Real Glow Up' by Chelsey Armfield, with gold lettering, lies on a white textured surface. Page markers are visible on the right side. Overlaid text reads 'It's just a book...' with a sparkle emoji.
An open book page with highlighted text discussing overcoming the fear of rejection, embracing experimentation, and pursuing creative ideas to embody one's fullest self, without letting others' opinions be a burden.
An open book page with highlighted text emphasizing the importance of rest for mental and physical health, contrasting it with a productivity-focused culture. It describes making time for rest as a radical act of self-care.
It’s just a book…✨
The 📖: The Real Glow Up🤍 The Real Glow up is a gentle guide to self-love, to healing, and to finally coming home in to yourself. It’s a clear map for how to glow from within 🕯️ (B00k 🔗’d in bi0//on amznn🕊️) #selflove #healing #selflovebooks #healingbooks #selfhelp
ChelseyArmfield

ChelseyArmfield

22 likes

A person stands in a grand library with tall bookshelves and a glass ceiling, with text overlay "let's be book FRIENDS" and topics like "book recs," "writing tips," "endless tbr," and "my books."
A person reads an open book on a balcony overlooking a calm ocean with a colorful sunset sky.
A person holds a book titled "Pretty Boys Are Poisonous" by Megan Fox on their lap, featuring a mouth with a snake design on the cover.
let’s be book friends!
hey lemons, i’m hannah! i’ve always loved reading (was in battle of the readers in sixth grade… like battle of the bands but way cooler) but two years ago fell back in love with it! i got back into reading with the after series and then it spiraled from there! a few of my favorite books are:
hannah hamrick

hannah hamrick

243 likes

Sunny Disposition Book Review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️5/5 STARS!! I absolutely loved this book. Not only am I a sucker for a good hockey romance, but forced proximity is also one of my favorite tropes. Some other amazing tropes within this book that I love are Grumpy x Sunshine, hates everyone(ish) but you, and hidden identity. This bo
LKBooks

LKBooks

2086 likes

An open book with yellow flowers on its pages, set in a cozy bedroom, with the text "My most anticipated 2025 Book Releases BY BLACK AUTHORS romance edition" overlayed.
The book cover for "Can't Get Enough" by Kennedy Ryan, featuring a woman with an afro and pink flowers, with the release date May 13th, 2025, and genre forbidden romance.
The book cover for "Audre & Bash Are Just Friends" by Tia Williams, showing illustrated characters and hearts, with the release date May 6th, 2025, and genre friends to lovers.
2025 Book Releases to preorder! 🌸
These are romance books by black authors releasing in 2025 that I will be preordering (if I haven’t already) & why you 🫵🏾 should too! 💕 Can’t Get Enough by Kennedy Ryan Ok, KR is an auto buy author for me so there was no question on whether I was buying this book. Also, I LOVE the Skyland
Jerricka 🎀

Jerricka 🎀

159 likes

A book that got me out of a slump🚔🔪📚🚗🔩
⭐️Overall rating: 4/5: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This book pulled me out of the biggest reading slump. They Are The Hunters was such an addictive, gripping, suspenseful thriller. My eyes were glued to the pages and I couldn't read fast enough. I didn't expect to love it as much as I did, but let me tell yo
Maddy.walls

Maddy.walls

37 likes

A shelf of books with text overlay "Popular Booktok Books And why I DNF'd them SWIPE" and a thinking emoji. The image introduces a discussion about not finishing popular books.
The book cover for "Kingdom of the Wicked" by Kerri Maniscalco, featuring a skull and snake, is shown on a grey blanket. A review explains the book was DNF'd at 62% due to a flat plot and disliked trope.
The book cover for "Ninth House" by Leigh Bardugo, featuring a snake, is displayed on a grey blanket. A review states the book was DNF'd at 25% because the plot was confusing and drawn out.
Cancelled For DNFing Popular Booktok Books? 😔😩
Well, maybe not cancelled… but it definitely is a weird feeling when everyone is raving about how much they loved the book you just couldn’t finish reading for whatever reason! 😓 I feel like many readers struggle with DNFing (stands for Did Not Finish) books especially the ones that Insta and Bookt
Lauren 📚📖

Lauren 📚📖

65 likes

love, love, loved this book 🫶
Overall rating: 5/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ #toalltheboysivelovedbefore #tatbilb #books #favorites #romance #romancebooks #review
Isa 💿

Isa 💿

389 likes

Kindle Unlimited Thrilllers I Loved!
have you read any of these? what were your thoughts? 🤔 i feel like kindle unlimited is so worth it!! #kindleunlimited #kindleaesthetic #thrillerbooks #thrillertbr #thrillerbookrecs #thrillerbookrecommendations #booksummary #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge
Noella 🐞

Noella 🐞

168 likes

A hand holds open the book "Call It What You Want" by Alissa Derogatis, showing pages of text. The image has an overlay that reads "A BOOK FOR THE 20 SOMETHING GIRLIES" and is set against a white door background.
A hand holds the pink spine of the book "Call It What You Want" by Alissa Derogatis. The image has an overlay with the book's title and author, set against a white door background.
A hand holds the pink cover of the book "Call It What You Want" by Alissa Derogatis, featuring a retro phone design. An overlay states "I rated this 4 stars!" and the background is a white door.
A book for the 20 something girlies
I absolutely loved Call it What You Want by Alissa Derogatis. This book follows a couple who is in more of a “situationship” than an actual relationship. I feel like this is a great read for those who are currently out in the modern dating world! This is this authors first novel, and I c
Khloemyers

Khloemyers

372 likes

A hand holds the book "This Is Your Brain on Birth Control: How the Pill Changes Everything," which features a birth control pill pack on its cover. The image also includes text overlays for "Self-help book recommendations" and the Lemon8 username.
A page from the book is shown with highlighted text discussing how birth control may influence women's choice of partners and divorce rates. The word "crazy!!" is handwritten on the page, pointing to the highlighted section.
A book page displays highlighted text explaining that hormones are integral to identity and that hormonal contraceptives change the brain. The phrase "so eye-opening!" is written on the page.
Self Help Book Recommendation for the Girlies
In this amazing book, "This Is Your Brain on Birth Control: How the Pill Changes Everything," author Sarah E. Hill, Ph.D., takes a deep dive into the less-discussed effects of the birth control pill on women's brains. Hill is a leading researcher in evolutionary psychology and addresse
Shelby Evans

Shelby Evans

4686 likes

The image displays the book cover for 'curvy girl summer' by ANIELLE ALLEN, featuring an illustration of a Black woman in a yellow dress and a Black man. A pink 'BOOK REVIEW!!!!' overlay is prominent, with a hand holding the book and some handwritten notes visible.
BOOK REVIEW!!!!
I rate this book 10/10 At times I wanted to beat Aaliyah up but I had to gain some patients with my girl….. I loved how her & friends was so open & nonjudgmental towards one another…. The uncle definitely got on my nerves thru out the book but once she put him in his place I knew that was
Queen-Tye

Queen-Tye

72 likes

🤭Captive but definitely loved
📚Hostile Takeover by Arabella Ames An enemies to lovers novel. #darkromancebooks #enemiestoloversromance #hefallsharder #princesstreatment #romance books #lemon8bookclub #arabellaames
Arabella Ames

Arabella Ames

36 likes

Reading a Book Based On It’s ✨Aesthetic✨
I saw a few videos like this on TikTok, where they try to convince you to read a book based on its aesthetic, so I’d thought I’d give it a try. The first book is “If He Had Been With Me” which I absolutely loved. I know people have mixed opinions on this book, but in my personal opinion, I liked it
Ashley❤︎︎

Ashley❤︎︎

39 likes

A collage of images centered around the book cover for Riley Sager's 'Final Girls.' Surrounding visuals include a woman in a forest, a hand holding a knife, a rustic cabin, a handgun, a police officer, a police car, a mansion, and a couple, all conveying themes of mystery, suspense, and thriller.
✨Book Review✨
Final Thoughts 💭/ Review : I absolutely loved Final Girls by Riley Sager and gave it 4 stars! ⭐️ I was hooked from the very first page—Sager has a way of making me question everyone, and the way every single person could’ve been the killer was honestly mind-blowing. I didn’t see the plot twist com
Deja Price📚

Deja Price📚

7 likes

The book 'Wildfire' by Hannah Grace, the second in the Maple Hills series, is displayed with three highlighters and text indicating a review of the book.
The book 'Wildfire' is shown with a 5/5 rating and descriptive tags like 'Romantic Comedy,' 'Mental Health Rep W/ Family Problems,' 'Forced Proximity,' 'Secret Dating,' and 'SPICY.'
A page from the book 'Wildfire' is shown with highlighted text about a character's humorous dialogue regarding cuddling and sleeping, overlaid with 'WTF?' and a laughing emoji.
Book Review: Wildfire
Book name: Wildfire (2nd book out of 3 in the Maple Hills series). Author: Hannah Grace Genre: Romantic Comedy Intro: It’s about this pair of college kids, Aurora and Russ, they have a one night stand. They then go to camp, thinking that they will never see each other again but they do— a
Rachal Sullivan

Rachal Sullivan

258 likes

A book titled "Powerless" by Lauren Roberts is displayed on a white quilted surface. Text overlays read "BOOK REVIEW!", "4.8/5", and "*page spoilers*". Decorative hearts and flowers are scattered around the book.
An open book shows the title page "POWERLESS" with colored tabs on the left page. The tabs are labeled with categories like "romance, love," "world building," "Kai," and "Paedyn." The text overlay says "My tab categories."
An open book displays pages 396 and 397 of "Powerless." Page 397 has a purple highlighted section and handwritten heart doodles in the margin, indicating a favorite passage.
Powerless Book Review! ✨🤍💚💜🏹🗡️🗝️
Author: Lauren Roberts Genre: romantasy My rating: 4.8/5 My review: Recently, I’ve only been reading romance, but I've been wanting to get into the fantasy world! My friend told me about how much she loved this book, because it was a mix of both genres, so I decided to give it a try. I am s
Abby

Abby

83 likes

book review🌲
book review: ⁣ ⁣ 𝐜𝐫𝐞𝐝𝐞𝐧𝐜𝐞 𝐛𝐲 𝐩𝐞𝐧𝐞𝐥𝐨𝐩𝐞 𝐝𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐥𝐚𝐬 ⁣ ⁣ rating: 4.5 / 5 ⁣ ⁣ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.⭐️⁣ 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ ⁣(swipe for book aesthetic) ⁣ this book— holy hell 🥵 penelope douglas knows how to write them! ⁣”as long as we’re together, we’re home” ⁣ this is very hard to rate because this is definitely not
kaylee ann

kaylee ann

19 likes

Books I Read in School that I Loved 🤍
📒Notes: I read a TON of books as an English major—some of them I liked & some of them were not my vibe. I ended up focusing a lot of my time on British Literature, so that’s why a lot of these books are written by British authors. I also spent a lot of time on medieval & renaissance literat
berryydiaries

berryydiaries

259 likes

lemon8 book tag
switched it up a bit, have you read any of these?? #lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge #Lemon8Diary #bookwormsoflemon8 #booksoflemon8 #booktag #booktok #BookReview #readersoflemon8 #currentlyreading @Lemon8 BookClub
mads

mads

101 likes

A flat lay of the four books from the 'Twisted Series' by Ana Huang: 'Twisted Love', 'Twisted Games', 'Twisted Hate', and 'Twisted Lies', arranged on a gray blanket. The image is titled 'My Reviews on the “Twisted Series” (Each book)'.
The book 'Twisted Love' by Ana Huang, Book One of the 'Twisted Series', with a light blue cover. An overlaid review describes it as 'twisted in many ways' with a 'Spice level: 🌶️🌶️'.
The book 'Twisted Games' by Ana Huang, Book Two of the 'Twisted Series', featuring a cream and gold cover with a crown design. An overlaid review praises it as the favorite, noting a 'Spice level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️'.
My Reviews on the “Twisted Series” (Each book)
These are my opinions on it but y’all need to read it for yourselves to see what y’all think. The spice levels is based off of which had the most 🌶️ scenes. Twisted Games and Twisted Hate had the most. While Twisted Love and Twisted Lies didn’t have many maybe 4-6 max. I might do ratings on the Twi
Lexiii 🎀🎀

Lexiii 🎀🎀

1227 likes

STOP & READ THIS BOOK!!!
| Happy Release Day @amberpalmerauthor !!! 🥃🎱🎀 Josie & Lincoln have become my latest instant obsession! I was careening into a book slump after my last read but the moment I started Between the Pines I found myself smirking and giggling with these two and their insane connection!! As a T
✨Shannon✨

✨Shannon✨

90 likes

You HAVE to pick this book up! 😱⭐️
This book is SO GOOD I NEED EVERYONE TO READ IT! I’ve had this advanced copy sitting in my shelf for awhile… and I really wanted to pick it up but didn’t get a chance until this month and I’m SO GLAD I PICKED IT UP! It is such a good romantasy and I am so upset about the ending I need book two RIGH
SB Allred

SB Allred

12 likes

BOOK REVIEW: THIS COULD BE US 🌸✨
Y’all… I’m not gone hold yall but I loved this book, every since part of it, I’ve seen a lot of people say they didn’t like it but I loved it why? Because it made me feel so much 😭 like ( lil spoiler) it brings up cancer, my mother battled breast cancer when from when I was in 8th grade till I grad
˚ ꕥ Catera ꕥ˚

˚ ꕥ Catera ꕥ˚

51 likes

See more