Book review: First lie wins

โ€œFirst Lie Winsโ€ by Ashley Elston offers an engaging mystery that keeps readers guessing. The plot revolves around a tightly-knit group of friends whose secrets unravel, leading to unexpected twists and turns. Elstonโ€™s writing style is accessible, making it easy to dive into the story.

However, some character development felt lacking, leaving a few motivations unclear. While the premise is intriguing, the pacing sometimes falters, leading to moments where the narrative drags. Overall, itโ€™s an entertaining read for fans of young adult mysteries, but it could have benefited from deeper character exploration and a tighter plot. A solid three stars!

โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ#honestbookreview #mysterybooks #books #bookrecommendations #booklover @Lemon8 BookClub

2025/1/28 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, let's talk about the cover of 'First Lie Wins' for a moment because, honestly, it's often the first thing that grabs you, right? When I first saw it, it immediately screamed 'mystery thriller' to me. You know that feeling when a book cover perfectly sets the mood? This one nails it. The design, often featuring a somewhat minimalist yet intriguing graphic or a shadowy figure, really hints at the layers of deception and secrets within Ashley Elston's novel. It's not overly dramatic, but it has this subtle tension that makes you wonder, 'What's the first lie, and who's telling it?' For those who haven't seen it, the typical cover art for 'First Lie Wins' often uses a bold, eye-catching font and sometimes a blurred or ambiguous image that adds to the suspense. It perfectly aligns with what you'd expect from a New York Times Bestseller and a Reese's Book Club pick โ€“ typically covers that are both aesthetically pleasing and indicative of a gripping story. It's not just a pretty picture; itโ€™s a visual promise of the 'unexpected twists in friendships' and the 'intriguing mystery unraveling secrets' that the story delivers. When you pick up a book with a cover like this, you're expecting a ride, and 'First Lie Wins' definitely tries to deliver. The whole concept of 'testing friendships' through 'Lies' is central to the plot, and the cover smartly communicates that sense of unease and hidden truths. It makes you want to dive in and figure out who is who, and what lies they're weaving. For me, a good thriller cover primes you for the psychological suspense to come, and this one does a fantastic job of hinting at the complex web our protagonist, Evie Porter, finds herself in. Beyond the visual appeal, the cover also signals its place in the popular thriller novel genre. It's designed to appeal to readers who love a fast-paced narrative filled with suspense and clever misdirection. The branding as a Reese's Book Club pick further reinforces its standing as a must-read for fans of twisty thrillers. If you're browsing shelves looking for something that will keep you on the edge of your seat, the 'First Lie Wins' cover definitely stands out and communicates exactly that promise. It's a great example of how a cover can be more than just art; it's a vital part of the book's identity and its invitation to readers. That initial visual impact often solidifies the expectation of a captivating mystery, and I think it sets up the reader for the kind of unraveling narrative Ashley Elston presents inside.

Related posts

A hand holds the book 'First Lie Wins' by Ashley Elston, featuring a dark cover with bright green text and a house illustration. Overlaid graphics include a yellow padlock with a key and an hourglass, along with the text 'BOOK REVIEW RATING: 3/5' and 'Lemon8 @brittneyelaine25'.
Book Review: First Lie Wins ๐Ÿ”
Rating: โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ/5 This one had me hooked at first โ€” ๐Ÿ‘€ Secret identities ๐Ÿ•ต๏ธโ€โ™€๏ธ A con artist you canโ€™t fully trust ๐Ÿ’” Twists layered with emotion But somewhere around the middleโ€ฆ it lost me a little. Some plot points felt stretched, and I wanted more depth from the characters โ€” especially when
Brittney

Brittney

12 likes

A graphic featuring the book cover for 'The First Lie Wins' by Ashley Elston, set against a dark blue background. The cover shows a house with the title in bright green. Overlays read 'Currently Reading' in yellow and 'Highly Recommend!' in white. It also includes a quote from Megan Miranda and 'Lemon8 @its.drbooker'.
๐Ÿ“šBook Review: โ€œThe First Lie Winsโ€ by Ashley Elsto
Listen, THIS book had me clutching my pearls, my edges, and my snacks all at the same time! ๐Ÿ˜‚ โ€œThe First Lie Winsโ€ by Ashley Elston is one of the best books Iโ€™ve read in forever. If youโ€™re into suspense, mystery, and a little sprinkle of romance, youโ€™ve gotta get on this one. Emma thought she ha
Kendra Booker

Kendra Booker

30 likes

FIRST LIE WINS
BOOK REVIEW!!!!!! โญ๏ธRating: 5/5โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ Book Description: Evie Porter has everything a nice, Southern girl could want: a perfect, doting boyfriend, a house with a white picket fence and a garden, a fancy group of friends. The only catch: Evie Porter doesn't exist. The identity comes fir
Braybarbie

Braybarbie

30 likes

The book cover for 'First Lie Wins' by Ashley Elston shows large green text over a dark house with a silhouetted figure in a glowing doorway. It features a quote from Megan Miranda, the Reese's Book Club logo, and Lemon8 branding.
First Lie Wins
โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ Read for me! I was engaged the whole time! Only took me a day to finish this one! Try to keep up with all the lies ๐Ÿ˜‰ #BookReview #bookwormsoflemon8 #thrillermystery
Fernadine Mata

Fernadine Mata

7 likes

A graphic titled 'Baddie Book Club Book Reviews' featuring a woman with dark hair and red lipstick. The image includes Lemon8 handles @dejareads0 and @dejareags0, and 'by DFG'.
BBC Book Review: First Lie Wins
4โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ/ 5 Stars Genre: Mystery This was my first mystery Iโ€™ve read in a while and I really enjoyed it !! I think the book was the perfect pace and I enjoyed all of the twists and back stories. I read and also listened to the audiobook while driving. The audiobook is so good I recommend just
Deja

Deja

1 like

Starting a new book today.
Without any spoilers tell me your honest review. #lemon8bookclub #currentlyreading #currentread #reesesbookclub #ashleyelston #firstliewins #bookrecs #lemon8bookchallenge
Ana Webster

Ana Webster

8 likes

The image displays the front cover of the psychological thriller novel "Behind Closed Doors" by B.A. Paris, featuring the title in red and a dark keyhole design. Overlay text indicates "BOOK REVIEW" and a "10/10" rating.
Book Reviewโœจ๐Ÿ–ค Psychological Thriller
Book Review ๐Ÿชป๐ŸŒพโœจ Book name: Behind Closed Doors Author: B.A Paris Genre: Psychological Thriller My rating: honestly.. 10/10, Iโ€™m hoping to find this thrill in another book. My review: I had no idea going into this book exactly what I was getting into. The words and details used made me picture
RM

RM

639 likes

A close-up of the book cover for 'First Lie Wins' by Ashley Elston, featuring a dark house with a silhouetted figure in a glowing window. Overlaid text reads 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW' and 'Rating: 3/5', with a 'Reese's Book Club' sticker visible.
Book Review
Book Review Book name: First Lie Wins Author: Ashley Elston Genre: Psychological Thriller/Mystery My rating: โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ My review: not my favorite. very slow.
Natasha ๐Ÿซถ๐Ÿฝ

Natasha ๐Ÿซถ๐Ÿฝ

3 likes

First Lie Wins Review
My Rating: 4.5โญ๏ธ It took me a few chapters to get invested, but once I did I was completely hooked. Iโ€™m so bored of missing women/domestic conflict thrillers so con-artist thriller this was a breath of fresh air! This story is well plotted and all of the information is purposeful and came back a
Emily

Emily

18 likes

The image features the book cover for 'Anatomy of an Alibi' by Ashley Elston, showing a house at night with pink title text. Below, an overlay reads 'BOOK REVIEW' with a rating of 3.85 from over 71,000 ratings and 9,000 reviews, and a user rating of four out of five stars.
Book Review โœจ
Just finished The Anatomy of an Alibi and Iโ€™m giving it โญโญโญโญโ˜† (4/5). Overall it was a really solid read. The story kept me engaged and I definitely wanted to keep turning the pages to see how everything unfolded. It wasnโ€™t necessarily the best book Iโ€™ve ever read, but it was still a good one. W
Taralynโšก๏ธ

Taralynโšก๏ธ

1 like

A hand with light green nail polish and a pearl bracelet holds an e-reader displaying the cover of the book "First Lie Wins" by Ashley Elston. Green text overlays read "My current Reads," and "Lemon8 @taniaiscopose" is in the bottom left.
Exited for this book!!! โœจโœจ
My current read!! Iโ€™ve been waited for weeks for this book to be available on Libby and finally is my turn!! So excited!! Plot: Evie Porter has everything a nice, Southern girl could want: a perfect, doting boyfriend, a house with a white picket fence and a garden, a fancy group of friends.
Call me Taniaโญ๏ธ

Call me Taniaโญ๏ธ

6 likes

The book cover for 'First Lie Wins' by Ashley Elston, a Reese's Book Club pick, is surrounded by annotations. These describe it as a southern spy thriller with eerie vibes, a twist ending, slight romance, and a 3-star rating, indicating a binge-worthy read.
The perfect southern thriller book doesnโ€™t exiโ€ฆ.
BOOK REVIEW Book name: First Lie Wins Author: Ashley Elston Genre: Psychological thriller โญ๏ธOverall rating: 3/5 My review: This book did live up to the hype. #firstliewins is a southern thriller that I just couldnโ€™t put down. The plot twists were crazy. Our FMC was morally gray which i love
Courtney McCurdy

Courtney McCurdy

2 likes

First Lie Wins
Just started this and whew ๐Ÿ˜ฎโ€๐Ÿ’จ itโ€™s already got me locked in. #currentlyreading #firstliewins #bookrecommendations #thrillers #thrillerbookrecommendations
Hillary

Hillary

11 likes

A hand with light blue nail polish holds the book 'First Lie Wins' by Ashley Elston. The cover features a blue house with bright green text, a silhouette in a doorway, and a 'Reese's Book Club' sticker. The Lemon8 username '@thecozybrooknook' is visible.
First Lie Wins
I really liked this one! Itโ€™s a Reeseโ€™s Book Club Pick. โญ๏ธ4/5 stars So basically Evie is a con artist trying to get info on her unsuspecting boyfriend, Ryan. Little does she know he has some lies of his own that even she didnโ€™t see coming. #readersoflemon8 #books #bookclub #lemon8bookclub
Brook

Brook

16 likes

A stack of romance novels by authors like Lucy Score and Elsie Silver, with arrows pointing to corresponding tropes such as 'small town romance,' 'enemies to lovers,' 'hockey romance,' and 'marriage of convenience.' Nail polish bottles and a floral painting are also visible.
Book review ๐ŸŒธ
#booksummary #lemon8challenge Twisted hate is one of my number ones but lmk if there is a book u want a review on and I will see if I have it
Ameliamarieisme

Ameliamarieisme

3248 likes

A book review graphic for 'First Lie Wins' by Ashley Elston, featuring the book cover with annotations like 'A Mysterious Boss,' 'Cat & Mouse Game,' 'Secret Identities,' 'Fast-Paced,' and a 3-star rating. It prompts to 'slide to description.'
โœจBook Reviewโœจ
โœจBook Reviewโœจ First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston is a gripping psychological thriller with an intriguing premise and a strong storyline. I rated it 3 stars โญ๏ธ because, while I really enjoyed the overall plot and loved the idea behind it, the execution felt a bit messy. At times, the book was hard t
Deja Price๐Ÿ“š

Deja Price๐Ÿ“š

3 likes

A hand holds a Kindle displaying the cover of 'Never Lie' by Freida McFadden. Overlaid text reads 'Book Review' and 'I have a bone to pick with everyone who RAVED about this book to me!!!!!', indicating a critical review.
Book Review | Never Lie ๐Ÿคซ๐Ÿ”ช
I had such high hopes for this book because of how everyone was raving about it but it just didn't do it for me. I personally think Freida's writing is predictable - this is my 3rd book I've read by her, I'm just noticing a pattern. The last part of the book was actually ins
Laura Sprouse

Laura Sprouse

16 likes

A person holds a tablet displaying 'The Hawthorne Legacy' by Jennifer Lynn Barnes, a young adult mystery/romance novel. The screen shows book details and genre tags. Text overlays indicate it's a 'Snow Day Read' and the '3rd Book of 2025'.
3rd Book of 2025 | The Hawthorne Legacy
Whatโ€™s better on a snow day than reading???โ€ฆโ€ฆ Iโ€™ll wait lol I read the first book of this series, The Inheritance Games, last year and was obsessed. Finally got my hands on the second book and so far itโ€™s just as good! Iโ€™m over halfway through and canโ€™t put it down. Will def keep you guys u
sincereleety

sincereleety

8 likes

Current Read: First Lie Wins
Currently reading First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston๐Ÿ–ค This one is giving smart thriller energyโ€”fake identities, secrets stacked on secrets, and that constant feeling that nothing (and no one) is what they seem. Every chapter makes me question everything I just read, which is exactly how I like my t
Lauren

Lauren

12 likes

โœจ Book Review โœจ
If youโ€™re looking for a thriller that grabs you from page one and refuses to let go, First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston is it. Meet Evie Porter โ€” clever, calculated, and living a life that isnโ€™t exactly hers. Every lie she tells is part of the game, but when her carefully constructed world starts t
Jess Treneer

Jess Treneer

2 likes

A black and white image featuring the book "Profit First" by Mike Michalowicz, stacked on other books in a library setting. Red overlay text reads "BOOK REVIEW," and white text at the bottom says "Spend one hour learning after work."
Book Review - Profit First
About two years ago, I turned the final page of โ€œProfit Firstโ€ by Mike Michalowicz, feeling a mix of excitement and anticipation. I couldnโ€™t wait to apply its wisdom to my own business. Today, Iโ€™m here to share that journey with you, not just as a business owner, but as someone whoโ€™s walked the pat
LUMINฤ‚ | Photographers

LUMINฤ‚ | Photographers

10 likes

BOOK REVIEW: NEVER LIE ANOTHER FM NOVEL๐Ÿ“Œโค๏ธโ€๐Ÿฉน
RATING:โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ/5 at this point I need every Frieda McFadden book right now!! ๐Ÿ˜‚, never lie was really good like I didnโ€™t expect it to end how it did but it did and Iโ€™m like OMGGGGG WHATTT ๐Ÿ˜ฑ๐Ÿ˜ฑ๐Ÿ˜ฑ๐Ÿ˜ฑ๐Ÿ˜ฑ it started off a little boring but DEFINITELY picked up and I wasnโ€™t disappointed #thebookishgir
หš ๊•ฅ Catera ๊•ฅหš

หš ๊•ฅ Catera ๊•ฅหš

22 likes

A hand holds the book "Frientimacy" by Shasta Nelson, with the subtitle "How to Deepen Friendships for Lifelong Health and Happiness." The image is overlaid with "1st Book Review of 2024."
An open book displays a section on "How the Frientimacy Triangle Works," featuring a triangle diagram with P, C, V, representing Positivity, Consistency, and Vulnerability. The text explains these three requirements for healthy friendships.
An open book shows a page detailing "The Eight Vital Friend's Roles," listing descriptions for roles like Builders, Champions, Collaborators, Companions, Connectors, Energizers, Mind-Openers, and Navigators. The "Energizers" role is highlighted.
1st Book Review of 2024 โœจ
Frientimacy by Shasta Nelson Genre: self-help Rating: โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ Review: I started reading Frientimacy after seeing the book discussed on TikTok and feeling like it would help me develop greater intimacy with my female friends. Understanding the frientimacy triangle which includes positivi
Alex Davis

Alex Davis

591 likes

A hand holds the book 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on the cover. Overlays include 'Book Review', 'His POV', 'Friends to lovers', and a three-star rating, all on a light-colored bedsheet background.
Book Review: If Only I Had Told Her
You guyssss! I randomly decided to read if he had been with me two weeks ago and zoomed through it in two days without knowing there was a second on the way! Obviously I had to grab it to read Finnys - Iโ€™m half way through and right now Iโ€™m preferring the first over this. Thoughts? ๐Ÿ“–๐Ÿฅ€ #Lemon8Di
MarySylvia Fain

MarySylvia Fain

220 likes

ARC REVIEW
NEW GROWTH ๐Ÿ‘ฉ๐Ÿพโ€๐Ÿฆฑโœ‚๏ธ๐ŸŒธ Author: Taahesi B. Williams Genre: Romance Release Date: June 19, 2025 Rating: โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ Synopsis: Love isnโ€™t safe. Trust isnโ€™t an option. And letting someone in only leads to heartbreak. But grief isnโ€™t something you can outrun. It lingersโ€”waiting, demanding to b
BookishWitLani โœจ

BookishWitLani โœจ

10 likes

A hand holds the thriller novel 'First Lie Wins' by Ashley Elston, featuring a dark house cover and 'Book Review' overlay. The book is a Reese's Book Club pick and a New York Times bestseller. The background shows a decorated shelf with mirrors and a lamp.
Book review ๐Ÿซฃ๐Ÿ“–
First Lie Wins โ€” Ashley Elston ๐ŸŒธ๐ŸŒธ Unpopular opinionโ€ฆ was NOT a fan of this book. Plot and storyline was good, however tricky to follow with the constant back and forth of timelines. Definitely had me interested, but I noticed myself having to re-read a few pages back before picking back up
Jennifer Pace

Jennifer Pace

8 likes

A hand holds the book "Why Women Grow" by Alice Vincent, featuring a dark cover with vibrant floral illustrations. Overlaid text reads "My Honest BOOK REVIEW" and "Rating: 5/5," indicating a positive review of the gardening and empowerment book.
๐ŸŒฑ Book Review: Why Women Grow by Alice Vincent ๐Ÿ“–๐ŸŒธ
Hey Lemon8 fam! ๐ŸŒผ Just wrapped up "Why Women Grow" by Alice Vincent, and OMG, I am obsessed! ๐ŸŒฟโœจ Alice takes us on this wild, wonderful journey through gardens and personal growth, showing how digging in the dirt is more than just a hobbyโ€”it's a whole vibe. ๐ŸŒฑ๐Ÿ’š Her writing is this magi
Candyce

Candyce

222 likes

Recent ARC Review
๐ŸฉตREVIEW๐Ÿฉต โญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธโญ๏ธ Thank you netgalley and viking penguin for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of this book for my Honest oppinion. I LOVED this book! It was so great at keeping my interest! I really did not like first lie wins, so I wanted to give the author another chance so I
Ashley.cwik

Ashley.cwik

4 likes

First Lie Wins
#summerreads2025 #newyorktimesbestsellerslist #ashleyelston #thrillerbooks #summervibes
LaLa

LaLa

6 likes

A book review image featuring the cover of "Never Lie" by Freida McFadden, highlighted with text overlays like "BOOK REVIEW," "Doctor/Patient Recordings," "Murder," "Suspense," and "Page Turner!! 5 โญ." The image includes the Lemon8 logo and username.
BOOK REVIEW: NEVER LIE FREIDA MCFADDEN ๐Ÿ“š
WOW this book really is worth the hype!! If you love a good thriller book with crazy plot twists, murder & suspense, short chapters, multiple POV & timeline jumps- this is the book for you!! Another 5 โญ Freida Mcfadden read & one that I couldn't put down, definitely recommend!! @Le
Sarah

Sarah

12 likes

A book titled "Save Me An Orange" by Hayley Grace, featuring an orange branch illustration on the cover. Overlays include "It's time to Read," "Mental Health," "Family Trauma," and "Positivity & Subdue," with decorative floral and stripe elements.
Book Review! ๐Ÿ“š
I Just Finished Save Me An Orange by Hayley Grace & it was absolutely fantastic. It covers mental health, family trauma & evolving/ overcoming challenges within your life. I highly recommend this read! ๐Ÿ“šName of the Book: Save Me An Orange โœ๐ŸผAuthor: Hayley Grace ๐Ÿ“– Genre: Poetry ๐Ÿ“„ Favor
Gracelyn ๐Ÿคโœจ

Gracelyn ๐Ÿคโœจ

76 likes

First Lie Wins!๐Ÿคซ
๐ŸคซYALL RUN donโ€™t walk and get this book! 5/5โญ๏ธ! i literally stopped reading all my other books just to finish this. I was hooked right from the start! If youโ€™re looking so for fast paced, thriller/mystery to get the year started- this is the book for ya! @Lemon8 BookClub #readersoflemon8 #bo
Tylar Cimone

Tylar Cimone

4 likes

First Lie Wins
This fast-paced narrative is set in the south and features a very likable, yet morally gray, protagonist. Recommended if you like plot twists, cat & mouse games, secrets, obnoxiously large derby hats, and maybe a sprinkling of murder #compellingnarrative #booktok #summerreads #suspensebo
Meow

Meow

5 likes

A stack of books, including 'Powerless' by Lauren Roberts, and a Kindle with stickers, are displayed on a white bedspread. The image features text overlays "ENEMIES TO LOVERS" and "BOOK RECS."
The book cover for "Does It Hurt?" by H.D. Carlton is shown on a white bedspread. The cover features a grayscale image of a woman's face merged with a lighthouse and stormy sea.
The book cover for "Powerless" by Lauren Roberts is displayed on a white bedspread. The cover features a dark forest background with a silver sword adorned with purple flowers.
Enemies to lovers book recs
My favorite trope is an enemies to lovers!! The tension, the groveling, the banter! Here are some great enemies to lovers to get you started with this trope! There is a little bit of all genres! SUMMARIES: Does it Hurt: strangers meet and have a one night stand. The woman is on the run and
Hannah Pilgrim

Hannah Pilgrim

338 likes

A hand holds the book 'The Only One Left' by Riley Sager, featuring a house on a cliff against a red sky. The image includes a 'BOOK REVIEW' title and a search bar overlay for the book's title.
BOOK REVIEW | The Only One Left
Catching up on my book reviews Iโ€™ve forgotten to post โ€” & - holy shit this is one of those books I will always think about and will wish I could read for the very first time again #theonlyone #booktok #bookaesthetic #bookrecommendations #BookReview #booksoflemon8 #bookworm
Laura Sprouse

Laura Sprouse

17 likes

See more