Then She Was Gone: Book Review 📕📖

“Then She Was Gone” by Lisa Jewell presents an intriguing premise but ultimately fails to deliver a satisfying narrative. The pacing is uneven, with sections dragging on without much development, leaving the reader disengaged. While some characters are well-developed, others feel superficial and lack depth, making it hard to connect with their stories. Overall, the book has moments of promise, but the execution leaves much to be desired, resulting in a disappointing experience

⭐️⭐️

@Lemon8 Book Club #lemon8challenge #lemon #lemon8bookclub #BookReviews #thrillerbookrecs

2025/2/15 Edited to

... Read moreIn 'Then She Was Gone,' Lisa Jewell weaves a compelling tale centered on family dynamics, secrets, and emotional turmoil. This novel, hailed as a New York Times bestseller, navigates the complexities of grief and betrayal, presenting readers with unexpected twists that heighten suspense. Critics note the book's blend of personal discovery and mystery, emphasizing its exploration of deep emotional scars and redemption. Fans of thrillers might find it a gripping read despite its critiques regarding character depth and pacing. Engaging with the themes of love and loss, the story challenges perceptions of familial bonds. For those seeking book recommendations in the thriller genre, Jewell's work may provide a blend of chilling suspense and heartfelt storytelling, making it a worthwhile addition to your reading list. Overall, while it offers a haunting emotional experience with an intense narrative, it also serves as a reminder that not all stories resonate equally with their audience. Whether you love a good thriller or are looking for a narrative that prompts reflection on familial relationships, 'Then She Was Gone' stands as a thought-provoking choice.

Related posts

A book cover for Lisa Jewell's 'Then She Was Gone' is centered against a blurred bookshelf background. Overlay text reads 'BOOK REVIEW AND BOOK AESTHETICS' with an arrow, and the Lemon8 logo with username '@shotgunmel8' is in the corner.
Then She Was Gone Book Review
Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell Genre: Thriller, Mystery, Psychological thriller, Suspense My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 My Thoughts: Wow. Ok, so...I had a lot of mixed feelings about this book. It started off super slow, and the majority of the writing seemed unimportant, kinda just like rambl
Mel

Mel

19 likes

A hand holds the book 'Then She Was Gone' by Lisa Jewell, featuring bare branches and pink leaves on the cover. Overlaid text reads 'BOOK REVIEW'. A ticket graphic shows the book title, author, a 4-star rating, and a note recommending the book. The Lemon8 logo and username are visible.
Then She Was Gone Book Review
⭐️Overall rating: 4/5 ⭐️ It took me a while to get into the book because of the format and style of it. It felt like it was for teens in high school. Also the story was just dragging a bit. I wanted to dislike it at first, maybe I’m just impatient I know they have to build up the backstory and e
Jade❤️

Jade❤️

25 likes

A person holds the book cover for Lisa Jewell's "Then She Was Gone," a #1 New York Times Bestseller. The cover features bare tree branches with falling pink leaves. Overlay text reads "Then She Was Gone" and "Let's talk about it," with "Lemon8 @t0xicbrooke" at the bottom.
Then She Was Gone-let’s talk about it
Honestly I have no words for how insane this book was. Definitely not what I was expecting but I also cannot stop talking about it. It’s a mix between romance and true crime when a 15 year old girl goes missing and 10 years later her family starts getting answers but none of the answers they receiv
Brooke Drew

Brooke Drew

474 likes

The image displays the book cover for 'Then She Was Gone' by Lisa Jewell, a thriller novel. The cover features bare tree branches with pink petals and the title in red. Overlays include 'Book Review' and 'MY RATING: 3.75/5', alongside a color palette on the left.
Then She Was Gone | Book Review 🤨
📚 Book Review 📖 Book name: Then She Was Gone ✍🏻 Author: Lisa Jewel 🤨 Genre: Thriller 🌟 My rating: 3.75 🌟 💭 My review: I give this book a 3.75 🌟 because the first half is very slow and kinda boring. In hindsight, there was a reason for it but could have been a bit better. The last half was bett
Laken

Laken

7 likes

The image displays the book cover for 'Then She Was Gone' by Lisa Jewell, featuring bare tree branches against a light background. Overlaid in pink are the words 'BOOK REVIEW', and a purple box shows a '3/5 ⭐' rating. The author is identified as a New York Times Bestselling Author.
BOOK REVIEW: THEN SHE WAS GONE
Earlier this week, I finished reading Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell. This one came as a recommendation I've had from friends & I see tons of hype about it online. Honestly y'all for me it wasn't the best 😬 I found that it had a slow start & the writing style wasn't my fav
Sarah

Sarah

6 likes

A hand holds the book 'Then She Was Gone' by Lisa Jewell, featuring a cover with bare branches and red leaves. Overlays highlight themes like 'GRIEVING MOTHER,' 'MISSING GIRL,' 'SINISTER VIBES,' 'MULTIPLE POV,' and 'UNANSWERED QUESTIONS,' with a 'REVIEW' and three stars.
Then She Was Gone 🍉🤍👒
book review | Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell 🌸 my rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️ Setting: London 🇬🇧 No one ever just disappears. Laurel Mack’s daughter, Ellie Mack, suddenly disappeared one day. She was only fifteen. Never to be heard from or seen again. Eventually the case goes cold. Now, 10 years
chelsea

chelsea

56 likes

Then she was gone
This book was the best book I’ve read this year! It had me in all my feelings! I never cried while reading, I bawled my eyes out for Ellie Mack! I will recommend this book to anyone and everyone! My heart hurts for the girls that this happens too. The saddest truest book I’ve read in a long time!
Kelsea Meeks

Kelsea Meeks

33 likes

Requested book review 🫶🏼✨
#books 🫶🏼 #reading📖 #bookrecommendations #fy #reading📚
Sammi Gibson

Sammi Gibson

1 like

Book Review 📚🌟
Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell If you love suspenseful mystery novels, this one is definitely for you! I did figure out the plot twist before it was revealed, so it was a little predictable for me, but that's just my personal opinion. Even so, I had such a fun time reading it and couldn'
Mya 📚🕷️

Mya 📚🕷️

11 likes

✨Book Review✨
This has been a great great read. I could hardly put this thriller mystery down trying so hard to figure out the ending. This is a page turner and a mind blower. ⭐️Overall rating: 10/10 #thenshewasgone #lisajewell #bookreview #bookreviewsoflemon8 #such a good book Virginia
JessAnn

JessAnn

7 likes

Book Review
This book was amazing!! Finished in 2 days and my mind is blown! #lisajewell #bookreview #thrillerbook #bookish #tbrlist
A_hauck28

A_hauck28

4 likes

A hand holding the book 'Invisible Girl' by Lisa Jewell, with 'Book Review' text overlaid. The book cover features an icy texture with a red rose. The background shows a chain-link fence and green benches in an outdoor setting. The Lemon8 logo and username @lexitmiller are visible.
Invisible Girl - BOOK REVIEW
I just finished Invisible Girl By Lisa Jewell literally 10 minutes ago! I posted what I thought about it yesterday and my anticipated rating but I am ready with a full review now! 🍋 A B O U T 🍋 The book follows a disappearance of a teenage girl named Saffyre and the multiple people potentially
lexi :) :(

lexi :) :(

5 likes

A person holds the book 'The Girls Are Never Gone' by Sarah Glenn Marsh, featuring a hand reaching from dark water on the cover. An overlay indicates 'Book Review' and a 4.5-star rating, aligning with the positive review of the paranormal mystery.
Book Review
The girls are never gone by Sarah Glenn Marsh This book was so good! It’s about a girl with a paranormal podcast going to stay at a supposedly haunted estate for a whole month, a girl drowned at the lake many decades ago and it was ruled out as an accident but is that really the truth? It’s u
Kirsten Gibbs

Kirsten Gibbs

118 likes

Book review
I just had to get this one off my chest because i’m not over it. Never will be until book two comes out. Still a 5 star rwas hands 🙌 down! #forcedproximitybookrecs #indieromanceauthor #booktokfyp #tragiclovestory #lovetriangle
Nadia Braeckel Books

Nadia Braeckel Books

2 likes

Book review
Murder Game~it was a pretty okay book not really much, it is good for people who don’t like those nail biting things more of a cozy murder thriller book. Five total strangers~ it started slow picked up in the middle then ended slowly. It is a good book just isn’t fast paced the entire book The pe
Aubrie📖🩷

Aubrie📖🩷

202 likes

gone tonight book review
Finished this one on the plane! ✈️ I was in Nashville on a work trip for 3 days and naturally brought 3 books plus my Kindle with 😂 my worst nightmare is having downtime without a book!! I knew I had to read this after I loved House of Glass by this same author and I'm so glad I did! This
Lauren 🪴📚😻

Lauren 🪴📚😻

19 likes

A book titled "Powerless" by Lauren Roberts is displayed on a white quilted surface. Text overlays read "BOOK REVIEW!", "4.8/5", and "*page spoilers*". Decorative hearts and flowers are scattered around the book.
An open book shows the title page "POWERLESS" with colored tabs on the left page. The tabs are labeled with categories like "romance, love," "world building," "Kai," and "Paedyn." The text overlay says "My tab categories."
An open book displays pages 396 and 397 of "Powerless." Page 397 has a purple highlighted section and handwritten heart doodles in the margin, indicating a favorite passage.
Powerless Book Review! ✨🤍💚💜🏹🗡️🗝️
Author: Lauren Roberts Genre: romantasy My rating: 4.8/5 My review: Recently, I’ve only been reading romance, but I've been wanting to get into the fantasy world! My friend told me about how much she loved this book, because it was a mix of both genres, so I decided to give it a try. I am s
Abby

Abby

81 likes

An iPad screen displays a digital notebook cover with a beige background and black and white polka dots, featuring the text "Book Reviews" and "2026" in pink.
The front cover of the book "If Cats Disappeared From The World" by Genki Kawamura, featuring a black kitten, is held by a hand with a ring on a dark patterned surface.
The back cover of the book "If Cats Disappeared From The World" is shown, displaying a synopsis, author information, and ISBN details, held by a hand.
Book Review: If Cats Disappeared From The World
Okay, so I know I said the next book would be Dracula BUT I wanted to do a review of a book I am reading for a book club I joined. As you can see from the title, we are currently reading “If Cats Disappeared from the World”. As you can also see from the cover, I plan to use this as a new cover for
🌷flowerbbv🌷

🌷flowerbbv🌷

0 likes

🤯 BOOK REVIEW
So I had to take a break from my normal book readings lol, and pick me up a good thriller that I really enjoyed… I been eyeing this one all over KU but kept passing it by until today and it did not disappoint.. pretty much wish i read this sooner 🥴… A must read if you like suspense/ psychologica
💕✨TATIANA✨💕

💕✨TATIANA✨💕

155 likes

An open book with text visible, featuring an overlay that reads "WLW Book Review ✨💕" and glowing butterfly and flower graphics. A Lemon8 watermark is at the bottom.
The front cover of the book "Forget Me Not" by Alyson Derrick, featuring red floral line art and a woman's profile. An overlay reads "Forget Me Not Alyson Derrick".
The back cover of the book "Forget Me Not" with red floral designs, a book blurb, ISBN, and price information. A Lemon8 watermark is at the bottom.
WLW Book Review ✨💕
I absolutely loved this book, This is definitely worth the read. This book definitely has plenty of cliffhangers. This was so so written. I wish I could re-read it again like it was the first time! #booktok #booktok #books #wlw #wlwbooks #queerbooks
⭐️Lainey ⭐️

⭐️Lainey ⭐️

87 likes

Honest Book Review 🔮🌿✨
⭐️Overall rating: 4/5 I really enjoyed this book! It had a beautiful storyline, the characters were well thought out, the writing was poetic and immersive. I honestly don’t know why this book doesn’t get more hype because I thought it was really good! I wanted to give this book a 5 star rati
linds

linds

7 likes

A person stands in front of a bookshelf, reaching for a book. Overlay text reads "My Honest BOOK REVIEW Rating 4/5 Plus books I want to read!" indicating a book review post.
A book cover for "Then She Was Gone" by Lisa Jewell, featuring bare tree branches and falling petals. An overlay note states, "I haven't had the chance to read this one yet but I've heard such great reviews."
A book cover for "Verity" by Colleen Hoover, showing a dark background with a golden, intricate design. An overlay note reads, "5/5 THIS BOOK WAS AMAZING," reflecting a positive review.
Book Review 📖
Book Review Book name: Then she was gone My rating: Haven’t read yet My review: ^^^ Book Review Book name: Verity My rating: 5/5 My review: Now I know this is a Colleen Hoover book but trust me on this. This is one of the best books I’ve read that actually got me back into reading. It’s j
Noelle ☀️🌺🌊🐙

Noelle ☀️🌺🌊🐙

6 likes

A dark-themed bookshelf features 'Shadows of a Tortured Heart' by Loane Raleigh, a white skull, and other books like 'Foxglove' by Adalyn Grace. Decorative elements include crystals, floral vines, and celestial-patterned boxes, creating a gothic aesthetic.
Book review✨🖤
Okay but why did this book absolutely wreck me in the most beautiful way 😭🖤 I don’t even know where to start. As someone who has personally struggled with anxiety and depression, I felt so seen. Not in a surface level, romanticized way. In a real, raw, almost uncomfortable way. It felt like hold
Mak_taylor1

Mak_taylor1

9 likes

The book cover for "The Obsession" by Natasha Preston, featuring a dark house with glowing windows at night. The cover notes "The #1 New York Times Bestselling Author of The Haunting" and a "Walmart Exclusive Content" sticker.
✨Book Review✨
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Very Entertaining.. Revenge Secrets Fake Friendships Connie- A Teenager who’s mom is forcing her to make videos about every aspect of their life, is tired of oversharing her life , she only wants I be a normal person with privacy. Girls start dying and she needs to find out
Mrs.Book-zilla📖🥀

Mrs.Book-zilla📖🥀

80 likes

The book cover for "Then She Was Gone" by Lisa Jewell, featuring bare tree branches and scattered pink petals against a light background, with the title in bold red letters.
Then she was gone book review📖
Secret hobby of mine is I love to read! 📖 I might have taken me a while to get into this book but once I hit part 4 I was hooked! And finished the rest of the book in one day! Definitely a must read! Had me hooked an saying WTF 😳 #BookReview #book #readreadread ⭐️Overall rating: 7/10
CountryBar_B❤️

CountryBar_B❤️

3 likes

She started it ✨| Book review
𝗦𝗵𝗲 𝘀𝘁𝗮𝗿𝘁𝗲𝗱 𝗶𝘁 𝗦𝗶𝗮𝗺 𝗚𝗶𝗹𝗯𝗲𝗿𝘁 𝟰/𝟱 “ A twisty summer debut thriller about a Caribbean bachelorette party that takes a sinister turn. It’s Lord of the Flies meets and Then There Were None but with Instagram and too much prosecco.The party of a lifetime is nothing like what they expected...” 👿
Iliana Valencia

Iliana Valencia

6 likes

Book Review
This was a quick & easy read! #honestbookreview #newbookreview #readratedandreviewed #readreview
SaritaBeyah

SaritaBeyah

5 likes

Book review 🌸
Book name: Allegiant Author: Veronica Roth Genre: Science fiction, dystopia, romance and young adult fiction Intro: The faction-based society that Tris Prior once believed in is shattered—fractured by violence and power struggles and scarred by loss and betrayal. My rating: 5/5 My review: This
Paula Guzman

Paula Guzman

9 likes

The book cover for 'Wickford Hollow Duet' by M Violet, featuring a skull surrounded by dark flowers and a haunted mansion. The title 'Wickford Hollow' is prominent, with 'Hollow' in pink, set against a dark background. It is surrounded by dark red and black roses, reflecting the book's gothic and spicy themes.
📖 Book Review📖
Duet Rating: 5/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Duet Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Title: Wickford Hollow Duet Author: M Violet 🖤Why Choose 🖤 Reverse Harem 🖤 Strong Language 🖤 Light BDSM 🖤 Bondage 🖤 Ownership 🖤 Food Play 🍑 🖤 Multiple Partners Good Girl (book 1): Meet Bailey, a young woman who got dared on H
Sam Ketchum

Sam Ketchum

9 likes

The Reading List book review
#thereadinglist #book #booktok #BookReview
WitchofNovember

WitchofNovember

2 likes

A physical copy of the romance novel "Back in the Saddle" by Maggie Eckersley, featuring a cowboy and woman illustration, alongside a matching bookmark that reads "CAN WE GET A YEEHAW."
The cover of the romance novel "Back in the Saddle" by Maggie Eckersley, depicting a cowboy and a woman, with an overlaid quote: "I want you to remember how it felt when we were together."
A Kindle e-reader displaying a passage from a book about a recently divorced character named Caroline in a bar, with text overlays indicating "COWBOY X DOCTOR," "HE FALLS FIRST," "SPICY," and "MENTAL HEALTH REP."
new book review: cowboy edition
this book just came out and i just finished it so i thought i’d share my honest review: yall know i loveee a cowboy romance and this one was pretty good! i definitely don’t think i’d ever reread it but it’s hard to disappoint me when it comes to cowboys and spice. Caroline (fmc) is recently divorce
mads

mads

27 likes

Book Review ✨️
I read these 3 over the past few days & I LOVED them! 5/5⭐️⭐️ The possessing her series was gooood, i finished them within a few days 🫣 the spice in it was there for sure 🤪 Ask For Andrea was a thriller i couldn't put down, every chance I had I was reading it, it most definitely gave Te
myrka✨️

myrka✨️

4 likes

See more