Let’s review Katabasis…or dnf it.

Sadly… this book was a no for me.

A journey into Hell? Magick? Dark academia? Hell yes. I was so stinkin excited to get into this book, because it was my first REAL experience of the “academia” genre. I had high expectations since Kuang’s “Poppy War” has such raging reviews!

What the actual FUCK did I read?!?!

First off, lets start with the few GOOD things! I absolutely love the way Kuang is able to delve so deeply into descriptive writing! It is very inspiring to me personally, as I struggle to make the most boring sentences into something beautiful. She can do this!

Second, she knows her shit. Believe me, when I first started reading the “unending” descriptions of Hell and philosophy, along with all the different kinds of theories into what Hell is actually like, I was blown away! I was so excited to see where it all peaked.

Until it didnt. A “trip to hell” can’t just be so… unimportant. So…boring, if Im being honest… and now heres where I got up and left the classroom…

Do you know how many PARAGRAPHS of philosophical descriptions I just ended up SKIPPING OVER because they were just… so… in your face, im so smart, look at me????? I mean, COME ON!

Kuang, you’re giving Hermoine Granger 😭 and trust me, I love Hermoine as much as the next HP fan, but come on! It truly makes me feel dumb cuz I have NO CLUE what you are talking about! Who tf is “Immanuel Kant”? “Jeremy Bentham”? “Russell”???? Am I fr expected to know who these people are?!? Im not a philosopher, im just a reader!!!

While yes, this book is VERY academic in nature, it reads like a boring paper, which was written by a college student who thinks their topic is EVERYTHING. I could do without. What I really wanted was for Alice and Peter to really come together. Also, this book is supposed to be “emotionally wrecking” I fail to see this coming to pass. The book felt like I was sitting in the audience during a debate. Boring.

This was basically a textbook. No grand scheme, no punchline, no real point to the entire thing. If it had one, I’d say it’s this: 𝑦𝑜𝑢 𝑎𝑖𝑛𝑡 𝑠𝑚𝑎𝑟𝑡. Logic and reasoning is great and all, but…if thats the only reason behind your existence, then it’s really nothing at all. Researching your book content is great! Kudos! But this felt like I was in a lecture that never ended.

Thanks, but no. DNF at 30%.

2025/9/8 Edited to

... Read moreEven though 'Katabasis' didn't quite hit the mark for me personally, I totally get why people are drawn to its aesthetic, especially when searching for 'Katabasis R.F. Kuang art.' The book's premise alone, a journey into Hell steeped in dark academia, conjures up such vivid imagery. When I first saw the cover, and imagined what the art of this world would be like, I pictured something straight out of a gothic novel – think crumbling ancient ruins, shadowy libraries filled with old, dusty books, and statues of classical figures looming in the mist. It's the kind of vibe that makes you want to cozy up with a dark, mysterious read, even if the content itself didn't always grab me. The promise of a visually rich, intellectually stimulating world is a huge part of dark academia's appeal, and the 'Katabasis' concept definitely delivers on that front, even if the execution didn't quite land for my reading style. The OCR results of images associated with the book actually perfectly capture this aesthetic: the 'Katabasis' book cover itself, combined with gothic architecture and diagrams of Dante's Inferno, really sets the scene. It’s this visual storytelling that often draws us into dark academia in the first place, isn't it? The idea of delving into forbidden knowledge in atmospheric settings, surrounded by ancient texts and imposing historical backdrops. For those looking for 'Katabasis art,' I’d absolutely recommend exploring fan art communities online – platforms like Tumblr, Pinterest, or even dedicated bookstagram accounts often feature incredible interpretations that truly bring a story's mood to life. You might find artists who’ve envisioned the 'journey to the underworld' or the philosophical discussions in a way that’s visually stunning. Looking at different editions' covers or even just mood boards inspired by the themes of Hell and philosophy can be a great way to appreciate the visual side of the story, distinct from the reading experience itself. It’s fascinating how a book's concept can inspire so much creative visual output, regardless of individual reader experiences. And for those of you searching for 'Katabasis PDF,' I totally understand the desire to dive right into a new book without delay! While I can't recommend specific unauthorized sources, I always suggest checking your local library first. Many libraries now offer e-books through fantastic apps like Libby or OverDrive, which is a brilliant free way to access popular titles like this one. Not only is it convenient, but it also helps support libraries which are such vital community resources. Plus, there's nothing quite like holding a physical copy, feeling the pages, or for those who prefer to 'read' on the go, an audiobook can be a wonderful, immersive experience. Supporting authors by legally purchasing their work, whether it's an e-book or a physical copy from your favorite indie bookstore, is super important too! It ensures they can keep writing the stories we love (or sometimes, as in my case, DNF!). If you're hesitant after reading reviews like mine, borrowing from a library or trying a sample chapter is a great way to see if it's for you without committing financially. Happy reading, however you choose to explore your next literary adventure!

4 comments

Ashley Kordas - Phillips's images
Ashley Kordas - Phillips

Yessss! Totally agree, I felt like my head was going to explode if I kept pushing my way thru reading this one. Way too much!

📖📚 TheLetterboxLibrary 📚📖's images
📖📚 TheLetterboxLibrary 📚📖

Ooo which cover is that! Mines just a black and white cover.

See more(2)

Related posts

DNF🤦🏾‍♀️
I’m sorry I just could not get through this book, I tried to like it, matter of fact I wanted to like it. I heard so many good reviews on TikTok but it disappointed me so bad. I just didn’t like how Winter was so grown at an early age🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️. What are your thoughts? #lemon8bookclub #blac
Neshab

Neshab

197 likes

Booktok Books I’m Too Scared To Buy
There are too many good books out there, and I’m not afraid to DNF… I’m afraid of wasting my money!!! Have you read these? Should I attempt to read these??? (Maybe I’ll have to finally get a library card…) #book shopping 🛒 #booktok #lemon8bookclub #bookstoreadinfall
✨📚CulliferBooks📚✨

✨📚CulliferBooks📚✨

1130 likes

A desk with an open book, 'Katabasis' by R.F. Kuang, featuring a woman's image and text from Chapter 39. A record player, plush toys, and art supplies are also visible, highlighting the user's current activities.
A gaming setup displays Genshin Impact gameplay and character details. A bookshelf filled with books like 'The Poppy War' and 'Divine Rivals' stands beside it, with new aespa posters on the wall.
A desk organized with journals, stationary, pencils, a pumpkin candle, an aespa album, and a Kindle. An open book is labeled 'current read,' surrounded by various desk accessories.
what’s on my desk this week 🌙
listening: taylor swift, aespa, nmixx (finally we got a full album from them 😭), ive also been loving atm by jihyo on twice’s ten years anniversary album playing: genshin impact!! this game has me in its clutches again watching: silent hill f gameplay bc im too broke to buy it rn 🙂‍↕️ rea
moa 𝜗𝜚˚🕯️⋆🪞‧₊˚

moa 𝜗𝜚˚🕯️⋆🪞‧₊˚

83 likes

“ DNF ” & HERE’S WHY…
Book: The Princess & The PI Author: Nikki Payne Genre: Romance, Romantic Suspense 🌶️ level: Not sure because i didn’t finish. 🌸: Hey Bookish Babes, *Sighs* I decided to DNF The Princess and the Pi around the 40-page mark. While I went in excited by the premise, the story ultimately di
🌸: Your Fav Bookish Babe

🌸: Your Fav Bookish Babe

27 likes

A hand holds the FairyLoot exclusive edition of R.F. Kuang's Katabasis, featuring a beige and gold illustrated cover with stairs and the title. Overlaid text reads 'FairyLoot August'.
A hand holds the spine of the Katabasis book, which displays a continuous illustration of a winding staircase with figures in arched alcoves.
A hand holds the back cover of the Katabasis book, which is light pink with a gold border and the quote 'Alice Law, you naughty girl. You're trying to go to Hell.'
Katabasis
Absolutely love FairyLoot’s edition of Katabasis and I can’t wait to read it 😍 #books #booksoflemon8 #fantasybooks #specialeditionbooks #darkacademiabooks
Elle’s 📚 Shelf

Elle’s 📚 Shelf

61 likes

MY TRIP TO BARNES AND NOBLES 🫧🌷✨🛍
Adding these to my TBR asap!!! So many new books I’ve been seeing at B&N recently. I bought Katabasis by R.F. Kuang this trip and I’m so excited to crack it open! What’s your most recent B&N purchase? #lemon8challenge #lemon8bookclub #BookReview #barnes and noble #shopping
thea 💐🌟💝

thea 💐🌟💝

11 likes

May Reads
All the books I read this May and my rating out of 5 stars. Let’s talk “Katabasis”… am I the only one who hated it? I really wanted to love it but it just came off so pretentious that my eyes glazed over. It’s my first book I almost DNF of the year. “Swordheart” was a pleasant surprise as I
Ashley Kordas - Phillips

Ashley Kordas - Phillips

8 likes

Let me finally start using this app
to tell you guys that I picked up Katabasis yesterday! So excited to read this. I read some last night and im already so intrigued to follow this journey R.F. Kuang has created. I loved Babel and it was devastating. Hopefully, this book won't hurt me like Babel did lol. #currentlyreading #kat
Moonlightkxss

Moonlightkxss

9 likes

KATABASIS
I can't wait to read this… #booktok #readersoflemon8 #booksoflemon8 #bookcousins #katabasis
MangosNhotsauze📚

MangosNhotsauze📚

14 likes

Katabasis Fairyloot Unboxing
NO SPOILERS PLZ! Only time I’ve ever had FOMO over a sub box. Luckily got it for a pretty good price on Mercari. #rfkuang #katabasis #fairyloot #books
kaylee ‧͙⁺˚*・༓☾

kaylee ‧͙⁺˚*・༓☾

9 likes

A book cover for 'The Fury' by Alex Michaelides, with an overlay stating 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW' and a circular graphic indicating 'Rating: DNF'. A Lemon8 watermark is at the bottom.
Rating: DNF
This is my March TBR!!! It wasn’t good 🤪 The Fury was a bust for me and only got 50% through before putting it down. The invisible hour was fantastic I enjoyed quite a bit but! I unfortunately wasn’t in the mood for the shining so I didn’t get to it this month. My April TBR will be out soo
Liz

Liz

4 likes

A person holds 'IMMORTAL DARK' by Gest Girma, a book with a dark cover showing a hand holding a gothic building and a Chloe Gong quote. Overlaid text asks 'Should I DNF??', surrounded by emojis including a sleeping scarecrow, witch hat, cauldron, and a pumpkin-bodied teddy bear with a knife.
Should I DNF?? Is it worth the finish??
Okay, readers—help me out! I’m getting bored with this one. Should I finish it or just DNF and save my sanity? 📚💀 #dnfbook #booktok #BookReview Update: I decided to DNF it and I will try again another time.
Anna Rogers

Anna Rogers

19 likes

A book cover-style image for 'The Butterfly Garden' by Dot Hutchison, featuring a white butterfly on a dark, soil-like background. Overlaid text reads 'DNF Did Not Finish!' with a yellow 'X', and 'Emmmm...'. The image visually represents a book that was not completed.
DNF Did NotFinish!
I read over 100 pages but ultimately had to discontinue. The book failed to capture my interest and felt flat. I had anticipated more due to the positive reviews. Not everyone are going to like the same books 🤷‍♀️ #dnf #books #bookish #booktok #BookReview
CruzMaria Velazquez

CruzMaria Velazquez

4 likes

The cover of Stephen King's novel 'Billy Summers' features a dark background with red and gold text, and a torn paper effect revealing some internal text. The title and author are prominently displayed.
3rd DNF of 2026
DNF'd. I am a huge Stephen King fan but this one is just not for me.
Christina

Christina

8 likes

The book cover for J.T. Ellison's 'A Very Bad Thing' features a pink-hued hallway with a silhouette, highlighting its 'Twisty' plot, 'Family secrets,' and 'Guessing game' elements. It includes a quote from Meg Gardiner.
book review 👇🏼
This was so good! It is almost 500 pages😅 I did manage to read this in a total of three days tho🙌🏼 but anyways enough about me, this was so twisty and just a roller coaster of emotions. It was rather slow in the beginning and I almost did dnf it but I’m so glad I pulled thur because it was worth it
Aubrie📖🩷

Aubrie📖🩷

3 likes

Newest DNF:
#dnf #audiobooks #bookwormsoflemon8 #scifibooks #books
Em’s library📚🌈🐉🦇

Em’s library📚🌈🐉🦇

1 like

A book titled 'Boy Parts' by Eliza Clark is featured in an honest book review, displayed on a wooden surface. The cover shows a grayscale image of a person's upper body with the title in pink and white text. The review gives the book a 3.5 out of 5-star rating, with a quote from Jessica Andrews on the cover.
Boy Parts - An Honest Review
im not a heavy reader, i mean i have a goal of reading FIVE books this year. it takes alot for me to actually pick up a book nevermind finish it. it took me 2 months to finish this, a LONG 2 months. its a decent book, its worth a read if you like reading about an unreliable narrator having a com
mj

mj

10 likes

DNFs from this week
DNF in the book world refers to “did/do not finish” these are books you started but ultimately decided we’re not worth your time in the end. I had a high DNF week. I read 4 books and I DNFed 4 books. Two of those books I did not start though because I read book 1 of the trilogy and decided not
wickedreads ❄️

wickedreads ❄️

34 likes

A hand with black and gold flake nail polish holds the book 'Luckiest Girl Alive' by Jessica Knoll. The cover features a woman's face, mentions it's a 'New York Times Bestseller' and 'A Netflix Film'. Overlay text reads 'My first DNF ever!'.
My first DNF ever!
Listen I DONT DNF books…. I just don’t. But this…. This book I’m 20 pages in and I’m reading the FMC and it’s like she’s monotoned….. it’s awful! No personality…. I’m nodding off reading it. So I said F@CK IT!!! I have too many books on my shelf screaming my name to read them. I’ll come back to he
shannell fisher

shannell fisher

7 likes

A book cover for 'The Surgeon' by Leslie Wolfe lies on a white textured surface, with text overlays highlighting themes like 'Cheating husband,' 'Jealousy,' and 'Successful surgeon loses her first patient.' A hand with heart-designed nails holds the book.
Almost DNF… but somehow I did🤷‍♀️
⭐️Overall rating: 2/5:⭐️⭐️ I hate to not like a book but I couldn’t wait for this one to be over. I picked this book up because I saw a review that said it was good but honestly the only good part was the last chapter. The entire book you are waiting for something to go crazy but you just continue
Maddy.walls

Maddy.walls

110 likes

✨Book Review ✨
⭐⭐ About the first 50% of this book was a complete page turner was insanely creepy and then towards the end I feel like it fell off was about to DNF but I stuck through it my thoughts now is so I still want to know what was in the walls 😒
Nina Marie 📚

Nina Marie 📚

77 likes

A book titled 'THE FURY' by Alex Michaelides, featuring a large blue evil eye design over a sandy landscape on its cover. The text overlay reads 'I am trying to get in to this', indicating the user is struggling to read the book.
Dnf but determined to finished
🌟Have you ever just had a book that you were just not into? I have heard so many good things about this book , I just can’t get into it? 🌟This might be #dnf for now! But I am no quitter! I still want to finish, I just don’t know if I’ll be satisfied at the end of all of this! ⭐️Let me kn
Shunte Biblio

Shunte Biblio

7 likes

Katabasis!!!!
So happy to have my hands on this new release by one of my favorite fantasy authors!! #booktok #newreleasebooks2025 #rfkuang #booksoflemon8
Krys Janay

Krys Janay

1 like

DNF?!?
Yall! I don’t understand the hype. Call me crazy, but I DNF this one at about 65%. Sorry not sorry 🤷🏼‍♀️ #booktok #credencebookreview
Ashley carroll

Ashley carroll

0 likes

A Kindle e-reader displaying the cover of 'The Long Way Home' by Jessa Hastings is shown on a car seat next to a black bag. The text 'BOOK REVIEW' is overlaid, along with 'Reading enriches the mind.' and 'lemon8 @idkkkkkkkklkkkk'. A star-shaped accessory is also visible.
REVIEW:🌸 Magnolia parks series
I made it through 4 out of 5 books. As much as I wanted to enjoy this series I just didn’t really. Magnolia parks just wasn’t a character I liked. I did like daisy and Christian and that’s why I kept going but ultimately it wasn’t enough. I tried really hard to get through it and DNF’d Into the dar
Nic

Nic

2 likes

Katabasis Deluxe Unboxing! 📜
My 7-months-late birthday present is here! 🥳 #lemon8bookclub #newbooks #booktok #bookrecommendations #Unboxing
toadstool._.reads🍄

toadstool._.reads🍄

0 likes

HAD TO DNF
I had to tell even my family about the part that made me pause in this book. 😂 I'm laughing because I'm hoping it gets better in the story. However, I won't be finding out anytime soon.😂 It was the 2nd chapter, but I had to put it down. The story, so far, seems to be character drive
✨️WrittenInMelanin✨️

✨️WrittenInMelanin✨️

2 likes

Finished.Loved it.So.Much.
This book absolutely resonated with me. The character development from RF Kuang is always fantastic but this one was closer to home than the Poppy Wars. Although my doctorate isn't from an Ivy League or Oxbridge college 😉 The level of research and detail she steeped the story in was mind bog
ScienceintheFiction📚🔬✍️

ScienceintheFiction📚🔬✍️

4 likes

DNF
I really tried to give this book a chance.. What Lies Beyond the Veil by Harper L. Woods. The beginning was interesting, but then it went downhill. it felt like I was starting to read a Wattpad story instead of an actual book. The writing was a bit..off. A lot of "I said, he said, I expl
Kay

Kay

2 likes

An open book with green foliage and a candle, featuring the title 'BOOKS I'VE DNF AND WHY!' and text 'SWIPE' indicating personal opinions on books the author did not finish.
The cover of 'Verity' by Colleen Hoover, surrounded by reasons for not finishing it, including 'not a fan of colleen hoover,' 'the writing was not the best,' and 'very problematic author.'
The cover of 'Fourth Wing' by Rebecca Yarros, with reasons for not finishing it such as 'the pacing was terrible,' 'no character development,' and 'I HATED the MC.'
Books I’ve DNF’ed & Why!
These are my own opinions reasons why I could not finish the books. Do you agree with me? . . . . . . . . . #read read read #lemon8bookclub #reading #BookReview #blackgirlcreator #fyp #dnfbook #reader #blackgirllemon8 #booksbooksbooks
sage🌳

sage🌳

57 likes

Katabasis by R. F. Kuang 🔥📚
I received my Signed First Edition of Katabasis today for Barnes and Noble! I am beyond excited 😁 You can watch my unboxing video on my TikTok! #fyp #booktok #katabasis #rfkuang #unboxing
miguel

miguel

5 likes

A person holds "The Cinnamon Bun Book Store" book, with text "My booktok hot takes" and the book's title displayed, setting the theme for reading opinions.
Two books, one red and one titled "KATABASIS" by R.F. Kuang, are shown with text advocating for Booktok to read more diverse books beyond popular, repetitive plots.
An open book with visible text, a red can, and sticky notes are shown, with text stating "Nesta is the best and most relatable character in acotar."
My Booktok Hot Takes
I will die on the hill of any of these hot takes but specifically the last one. You better not count that book as read if you can’t tell me what it was about better than the synopsis of the book that is literally on the cover. #Booktok #HotTakes #BooktokHotTakes #IWillDieOnThatHill #Re
Valencia

Valencia

3 likes

A bookshelf filled with various fantasy and young adult books, including 'Lightlark', 'Blood & Ash', and 'The Priory of the Orange Tree'. A white text overlay reads 'Book Review'. A small figurine stands on the top shelf, with Lemon8 watermarks visible.
LightLark Review!
Light lark: Non-Spoiler Review: 1/5 stars Honestly wish I would have dnf’ed this book. It was boring, damn near put me into a reading slump. Just to find out 3 books in and the love triangle thing is still going… yeah no thanks. #lightlark #books #booktok #reading #lightlarkbyalexast
Miranda A📚

Miranda A📚

6 likes

DNF
I got to about 30% but just couldn't get into it 😭😅 #unpopularopinion #bookreview #projecthailmary #booktok #book
alliekingm

alliekingm

1 like

Book review
The Caretaker just did not work for me at all. I wanted to love this book because the premise sounded so promising, but it ended up being a huge disappointment. The story felt messy and unfocused with too many distractions, side moments, and constant back-and-forth that made it hard to stay investe
Michele Farrugg

Michele Farrugg

8 likes

DNF at chapter 7 😣 was it just me?
I really tried to push through, but I could NOT get past chapter 7 😣 This one ended up being a DNF for me. The biggest issue was the writing style. It felt super repetitive… short sentences, the “not this but that” structure over and over. I honestly felt like I was reading the same thing eve
Courtney ❤️‍🔥

Courtney ❤️‍🔥

3 likes

First DNF of the Year
#dnf #books #reading #readersoflemon8 #horrorbooks
taylor_made_books

taylor_made_books

4 likes

BOOK REVIEW📚✨
Book: Dear Debbie Author: Freida McFadden Genre: Psychological Thriller 🌶️: None Rate: 4.5/5 ⭐️ 🌸: Hey Bookish Babes , Chile…… This was my second book I’ve read by Freida & her pen doesn’t disappoint!! I thought this book at first was going to be a sweet, unhinged, diary-style emoti
🌸: Your Fav Bookish Babe

🌸: Your Fav Bookish Babe

50 likes

A black and white image of a grand, ornate building, possibly a mansion or castle, viewed from a stone staircase. The text overlay asks, "What books have you DNF'ed?" The Lemon8 logo and username @raemwrites are in the bottom left corner.
What books have you dnf?
I’ve never been one to put myself through a book I didn’t like. I’ve done it all my life where I would just let it sit. Before the Colleen Hoover hate train started or that I noticed, I was reading Layla and it was the most mind numbing experience in my life. The second book in the Knockmou
rae mill ☀️ writes

rae mill ☀️ writes

7 likes

A book cover for 'The Love of My Life' by Rosie Walsh, featuring a raindrop effect and a pink 'BOOK REVIEW' overlay. It's a New York Times Bestseller and a Good Morning America Book Club pick, with a quote from Laura Dave. A pink bookmark is visible at the top right.
DNF ‼️‼️
This is one book I could not Get through its to much going on to many characters is the wife telling even lieing like come on .., If you have read this how did you like it ??? #dnfbook #booktok #BookReview #books #book recommendations #bookshelf #bookish
Tymara

Tymara

3 likes

A hand holds a Kindle displaying the cover of 'One Dark Window' by Rachel Gillig, featuring a gothic illustration. Overlay text asks, 'Do you trust Book reviewers?' The background is a blurred outdoor setting, and a Lemon8 watermark is visible.
Let’s talk about book reviewers
Recently, I’ve been watching a lot of book review videos on YouTube. As an avid hobby collector, one of my favorite bujo content creator also does book reviews. I enjoy hearing somebody’s genuine thoughts on a book and I enjoy an authentic review, one not tainted by monetary value. Recently I saw h
Alicia C

Alicia C

9 likes

Books I DNF📚
Hopefully I’ll eventually get around to finishing these😭 if you’ve read any of these books lmk your thoughts in the comments!🥰 #lemon8bookclub #lemon8BookChallenge #books #BookReview #booksididntlike #dnf #letsbefriends #letschat #letsgrowtogether #newtolemon8
𝐄𝐯✿

𝐄𝐯✿

21 likes

Whomp whomp ah book review
Hey book lovers! So, I recently finished The Neighbor Favor by Kristina Forest, and… whew. Let’s just say, this was not the cozy, feel-good slow-burn I was hoping for. 😬 I went into this book so ready to fall in love. A romance with email pen pals, awkward charm, and a promise of that sweet slow
Tuesday Meshell

Tuesday Meshell

86 likes

First DNF of the year 😔
Yeeaaahhh I just...couldn't. The writing style is great, and you can tell the author did her research about the ancient myths and how the gods & magic were thought of back then, but... The MC is so frustrating to me, she's so stupid. And I find it difficult to sympathize with stup
Tylan Stroud

Tylan Stroud

11 likes

See more