Olipop or Poppi? What do you like better?

There’s a whole controversy going on right now with Poppi sending vending machines to influencers.

Do you like Olipop or Poppi? I am personally an Olipop fan! I haven’t tried Poppi but I love the Olipop flavors and I think their packaging is so much cuter! 🥤😋

#letschat #lemon8contest #lemon8creator #olipop #poppi

2025/2/10 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so we all love diving into the Olipop vs. Poppi debate, right? But beyond the taste and cute packaging, there's a super practical question that often comes up, especially when you're stocking your pantry: Is Poppi shelf stable? I totally get why this is a common search query, because who wants to buy a case of their favorite bubbly only to find out they need an extra fridge just for drinks? Let’s clear this up once and for all! Generally speaking, Poppi is indeed shelf-stable before it’s opened. This means you can keep those unopened cans of Root Beer, Classic Cola, or Strawberry Lemon in your pantry, cupboard, or a cool, dry place without needing refrigeration. This is fantastic news for anyone who likes to buy in bulk or doesn't have a ton of fridge space. It gives you more options for storage, just like the image asks, 'What do you like better?' when it comes to convenience! However, and this is the crucial part, once you pop open a can of Poppi, it absolutely needs to be refrigerated. Think of it like a regular soda or juice – once exposed to air, its freshness starts to diminish, and you want to preserve those beneficial prebiotics. Typically, it’s recommended to consume an opened can within 3-5 days for the best taste and to maximize its probiotic benefits. This ensures you're getting all the good stuff Poppi promises! Always remember to check the 'Best By' date printed on the bottom of your Poppi cans. This date is your best indicator for peak quality and efficacy. Storing them correctly will help maintain their fizzy goodness and the effectiveness of the apple cider vinegar and prebiotics. Avoid leaving unopened cans in direct sunlight or extremely hot environments, as this could potentially affect the flavor and even the integrity of the can over time. A nice, consistent room temperature is ideal. Compared to Olipop, the storage recommendations are quite similar. Olipop also advises storing unopened cans in a cool, dry place and refrigerating them after opening, consuming within a few days. So, whether you're team Olipop or team Poppi, the storage rules largely align, making it easy to manage your healthy soda stash. Knowing this information definitely helps me decide which 'options' to stock up on during sales, ensuring I always have my favorite flavors on hand, perfectly preserved. It's all about enjoying your drinks at their best, from the first sip to the last!

124 comments

Belle's images
Belle

Olipop - but lately I’ve been an Alani girl. Not the same but still.

Kylie's images
Kylie

I'll pop

See more comments

Related posts

Two soda cans, Poppi Raspberry Rose and Olipop Strawberry Vanilla, are displayed on a kitchen counter. The image asks "Poppi vs Olipop What's better?" and highlights features like 4g sugar for Poppi and digestive health benefits for Olipop.
Poppi vs. Olipop
Personally, I like both (and these are my 2 favorite flavors), but I’m curious to know what you guys think! Do you prefer Poppi over Olipop, or vice versa? Is one better than the other? #olipoplover #poppilover #olipopsoda #olipopvspoppi #soda #poppisoda
Abby

Abby

285 likes

Poppi- Punch Pop 🍍 💗🏝️✨🍊
This limited edition “Love Island” Punch Pop is soo delicious! I wish it was a permanent flavor 😆 I love the prebiotics and low sugar in these drinks. I definitely had to make a nice mocktail with this! 😋✨ Fill cup with ice 3 oz orange juice 2 oz pineapple juice Top with Pop Punch Gar
Stirred by Moe

Stirred by Moe

150 likes

A store shelf displays various Poppi and Olipop prebiotic sodas. Poppi flavors include Raspberry Rose and Cherry Limeade. Olipop offers Classic Root Beer, Classic Grape, and Cherry Cola. The image asks which brand is better, showcasing different packaging and options for these healthy beverages.
Poppi or olipop
I want to try some healthy drinks but I’ve heard mixed reviews on both so I’m asking my lovely friends on here which one is better olipop or poppi #poppi #olipopflavors #olipopreview #healthylifestyle2024
Lexi

Lexi

8 likes

A hand holds a pink can of Poppi Prebiotic Soda Strawberry. Overlay text reads "I TRIED POPPI" and "here's what i think..." with a confused emoji, suggesting an initial reaction to trying the drink.
i tried poppi… here’s what i think…
i’m starting to hop on the good bevvy trend and a while back, i tried olipop. i’m a soda lover (dr pepper girl for life) and i wanted to find a good substitute for soda as it’s obviously not great for you. olipop was okay… you could REALLY taste the stevia and i feel like the flavors just aren’
m a l e n a

m a l e n a

29 likes

Poppi OR Olipop
So I just recently started drinking these probiotic sodas, and honestly I’m having a hard time picking what ones I like and wanna stick to😫 What are your favorites? The only Olipop I tried was the Barbie one yesterday and I honestly rate it a 7/10 ! I’ve seen so many people say Olipop is good but
M.L.E.

M.L.E.

628 likes

A hand holds an orange can with a stylized orange slice design. The can features the brand name and text indicating '4g Sugar' and 'It's Time to Love Soda Again'. Overlay text asks 'Do Yall Drink Poppi?' with decorative orange flower emojis. Lemon8 branding is visible at the bottom.
Poppi or Olipop?
I’ve always been an olipop girlie but recently I started drinking poppi instead and I’m in love ! I’ve been trying to get away from soda and juice and find that this is a great alternative to that and the prebiotic benefits don’t hurt either #prebioticsoda #poppi #olipop
Asia|Lifestyle ⭐️

Asia|Lifestyle ⭐️

11 likes

🍋 🌸Ranking Every Poppi Flavor So You Don’t Have To
POV: You buy the viral Poppi flavors and immediately become a soda critic 😭🍋 Which flavor are y’all defending? And which one is your favorite?👇 #poppi #drinkreview #foodtok #lemon8 #fyp We love poppi and tried almost every flavor so yall don’t have too 😩
NK TV

NK TV

225 likes

✨🍒 Cherry & Berry Nerds Lemonade x Poppi | Your NEXT Sweet Treat 🍋✨
✨ I might’ve accidentally created one of the BEST sweet treat combos ever 😭 I took the Nerds Gummy Clusters in the Cherry Lemonade Blitz flavor and added them into a Strawberry Lemon Poppi and OMGGG 🤤 The gummy clusters soaked up some of the drink while still keeping that crunchy Nerds coating, and
Margarita

Margarita

59 likes

poppi🍊
What better way to drink poppi than putting it in a starbies cup and tricking your mind that you are drinking a starbies drink because it is that good !? I absolutely love poppi. I prefer it over Olipop. To me, Olipop flavors don’t sound good and they are very…. unique. Whereas Poppi has flavors th
🎀Krystal🎀

🎀Krystal🎀

22 likes

POPPI Blind Box?👀
Need help on flavor recommendations? You can call the Poppi hotline and leave a voicemail describing a little about yourself to get a personalized flavor recommendation! #poppi #drinkpoppi #asklemon8 #lemon8challenge
Kamalei🌺

Kamalei🌺

1337 likes

A Walmart aisle displays shelves stocked with various flavors of mini Poppi beverage cans. A circular overlay highlights a price of one dollar, indicating a special offer for these small cans.
Mini Cans of Poppi $1🥤| Walmart Finds✨🌸
Mini Cans of Poppi at Walmart for $1! 7.5 oz. Cans for $1 is a steal!!!! #poppilove #budgeting #walmart #miyad #probiotic
Miya D🤍💋

Miya D🤍💋

264 likes

Two cans of prebiotic soda, Olipop Cherry Vanilla and Poppi Cherry Limeade, are displayed side-by-side on a counter. Both cans show "5g Sugar" and are labeled as "A New Kind of Soda" or "It's Time to Love Soda Again."
A hand holds a pink can of Olipop Cherry Vanilla prebiotic soda. The can features cherry and flower graphics, with text indicating it supports digestive health, contains prebiotics, and has 5g of sugar.
A hand holds a red can of Poppi Cherry Limeade prebiotic soda. The can features a prominent green logo, states "5g Sugar," and includes the phrase "It's Time to Love Soda Again."
Are you team Olipop, Poppi, or BOTH?
I’m am always looking for different ways to add another health element to my regimen. And while sodas are good, they aren’t good for the body! So last summer, I embarked on a journey to find the perfect drink alternative and found Poppi! Poppi Prebiotic Sodas have 5g or less of sugar, infused w
TheCrystallinaP

TheCrystallinaP

7 likes

A hand holds a yellow can of "evolution REAL FRUIT SODA" in Tropical Mango flavor, featuring a mango graphic. The can highlights "PRE & PROBIOTICS" and "USDA ORGANIC" for digestive and immune health. Overlay text on the image reads "Poppi & Olipop WHO" and "EVOLUTION Gut Health Soda".
THIS got Poppi & Olipop BEAT 🤭
They Have Different Flavors & So Far Mango Is My Favorite. Publix Find 😋 #olipop #poppi #guthealth #guthealthswaps
Wellness✨

Wellness✨

280 likes

A retail shelf displays various soda brands. The top shelves feature Culture Pop cans in multiple flavors. The middle shelves show Poppi prebiotic sodas in individual cans and multi-pack boxes, including Doc Pop, Lemon Lime, Strawberry Lemon, Raspberry Rose, and Minecraft Movie editions. The bottom shelf has Olipop cans.
Poppi and Olipop
#lemon8review #lemon8contest both brands flavors are so good 10/10 LIKE , COMMENT,SAVE AND SHARE YOU ALREADY KNOW TO HIT THE FOLLOW BUTTON
Thriceakapt

Thriceakapt

9 likes

A hand holds a pink prebiotic soda can labeled "Doc Pop" and "poppi", indicating "5g Sugar". A straw is inserted. Text overlays read "This one is 9/10" and "POPPI OR OLIPOP?". The background includes a red blanket.
Poppi Or Olipop?
I’ve been trying to cut back on dr. pepper and soda in general and people rave about these drinks. I have tried multiple different olipop flavors and wasn’t really impressed but I got this poppi today along with a couple more poppi flavors to try and so far this one has blown my mind. As an avid dr
Madds✨⚡️

Madds✨⚡️

3 likes

A hand holds an orange prebiotic soda can featuring a stylized orange slice design. The can displays text including "Orange Prebiotic Soda," "4g Sugar," and "It's Time to Love Soda Again." A laptop and keyboard are visible in the blurred background.
Poppi or Olipop? 🥤
Which brand of prebiotic soda do you like more and what are your favorite flavors? #poppisoda #poppi #olipop #prebioticsoda #poppiprebioticsoda
Megs 🖤🗡️📚

Megs 🖤🗡️📚

3 likes

Olipop or poppi 🧃
I’m so torn between the two! Poppi in my opinion has a tad bit more flavor Olipop has a wide range of flavors to choose from I love the refreshing taste of either though Some benefits: • low calorie • gut friendly • low sugar •fiber supporting digestion 🥤 Which one are you choosing
glowingrace

glowingrace

1 like

A comparison image showing stacks of colorful Poppi cans at the top and Olipop cans at the bottom, separated by a pink banner stating 'OLIPOP VS POPPY'. The cans display various soda flavors against a window blind background.
OLIPOP or POPPI 🥂
WHICH IS BETTER?🧊 Although I haven’t tried all of the flavors from each brand, I personally prefer Olipop. Both are prebiotic drinks that are healthier versions of sodas. Although they are both similar, here’s why I prefer Olipop: (1) Taste: I’ve tried the Root Beer, Coca Cola, and Ginger/Le
Hadley

Hadley

74 likes

Olipop and Poppi, found at OLLIES!
#poppi #olipop #Connecticut
Noellie

Noellie

0 likes

A grocery store aisle displays various pre-cut fruits in plastic containers, including pineapple, strawberries, and mixed fruit. The question 'Olipop or Poppi??' is overlaid on the image.
A hand holds a pink soda can with red berry-like patterns, labeled 'Raspberry Rose Prebiotic'. Shelves of orange and pink cans of the same type are visible in the background of a store.
A refrigerated shelf is stocked with numerous soda cans in various flavors like Watermelon Lime, Vintage Cola, Orange Squeeze, and Cream Soda, featuring a distinct logo.
OLIPOP OR POPPI?? 🍹
I’ve never tried any of these drinks so which one is better?? #lemon8diarychallenge #olipopvspoppi #poppivsolipop #poppisoda #ollipop
harini

harini

8 likes

Two boxes of Poppi prebiotic soda are stacked. The top pink box is Raspberry Rose, and the bottom red box is Strawberry Lemon. Both boxes indicate they are for a healthy gut and contain 4 x 12 FL OZ. (355ml).
I LOVE POPPI! 🥰
✨Are you a Poppi or Olipop girlie? I personally prefer Poppi. Don’t get me wrong Olipop has some good flavors but I gravitate more to Poppi and my son is the same. ✨What’s your favorite Poppi flavor? ❓And if you’re a Olipop girlie, what do you think is the best flavor? I’ll try it because I
Tae Starr

Tae Starr

5 likes

Two holiday-themed beverage cans, labeled "Cranberry Fizz" and "4g Sugar," are decorated with cranberries, snowflakes, and gift boxes, announcing a new holiday flavor.
New Poppi Holiday Flavor!!!
First things first—what is Poppi? If you’re not already familiar, this brand is looking to take soda from sugary treat to better-for-you sipper—while still tasting delicious. Poppi uses apple cider vinegar and prebiotics to support a healthy gut. Each can has fewer than five grams of sugar and is 2
Mariette Diaz

Mariette Diaz

10 likes

A pink can of Poppi Raspberry soda with 5g sugar is in the foreground, covered in condensation. Behind it is an orange can of Olipop Orange Squeeze soda, also with condensation. Both cans are on a wooden surface.
Poppi or Olipop?
I usually get the Olipop because it’s always on sale 😂. Poppi has more added sugar than Olipop, but it has lesser calorie count though. Also, Olipop has crazy percentage for fiber which is something that I need! Ao over all I might be team Olipop, how about you?? #Healthydrink #olipop #p
whodidthat

whodidthat

2 likes

A hand holds an orange Olipop Cherry Cola can, featuring cherry illustrations. The can states it supports digestive health with prebiotics, botanicals, and plant fiber, and is a 12 fl oz 'New Kind of Soda' with 5g of sugar. The background is a soft grey fabric.
Olipop or Poppi?
This is my first olipop. Im usually a poppi girlie. Which do yall prefer? #olipop #lemon8diarychallenge #poppi #foryou
Sage

Sage

10 likes

A shelf displays various colorful Poppi prebiotic soda cans, including orange, green, pink, and red flavors. An overlay reads "Rating Poppi Flavors I've Tried," indicating a review of different drink varieties.
A pink Poppi Raspberry Rose prebiotic soda can is shown with a "10/10" rating. The can features red berry-like patterns and states "4g Sugar" on its label.
A red Poppi Strawberry Lemon prebiotic soda can is pictured outdoors with a "7/10" rating. The can has a large yellow lemon design and mentions "For a Healthy Gut" and "4g Sugar."
Rating Poppi 🍓💗✨
(Just my opinion please don’t come for me!) These are just the flavors I’ve tried! I’m not a fan of cola/pepper flavored drinks so that’s why I’ve stayed clear from them. Poppi’s such a hit or miss for me. Sometimes they’re amazing and other flavors just simply don’t taste that great. What ar
Meg

Meg

111 likes

See more