4 Books That Didn’t Live Up To My Expectations 😅

2025/12/23 Edited to

... Read moreIt’s often said that managing expectations is key to enjoying any experience, including reading. When highly anticipated books from well-known authors like Colleen Hoover or Sarah J. Maas don’t live up to the hype, it can be quite disheartening. For example, some readers have found that certain thrillers or mysteries, despite intriguing plots and being written by bestselling authors, lack the suspense or execution they hoped for — as noted in my experience with a book that wasn’t "scary enough" despite a captivating concept inspired by classics like "I Am Legend." Translation issues can also play a big role in how a book is received internationally; sometimes a captivating story in its original language loses nuance and excitement when translated. This might explain why some novels that intrigue audiences worldwide still feel flat in certain editions. Expectations built by marketing, reviews, and social media buzz can create a lens through which we evaluate books, sometimes unfairly. It's worth remembering that reading is a deeply personal experience — what doesn’t resonate with one reader might be treasured by another. Engaging with communities relevant to your interests, such as #holidaybookrecs or #bookaesthetic, can be a great way to find better matches tailored to your preferences and to share experiences openly. Have you ever felt let down by a much-anticipated book? It’s a common sentiment among readers, but sharing these moments often leads to discovering new favorites through honest recommendations and discussions around what expectations we bring to our reading journey.

Related posts

Books that left my jaw on the floor
Fair warning, friends: these books are NOT for the faint of heart. They're raw, intense, and full of messy emotions. They delve into darkness, pain, and the messy realities of life. But they also offer glimpses of hope, resilience, and the incredible strength of the human spirit. I've fe
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

9736 likes

For those who didn’t know 👀 There are books
So I’ve been seeing a lot of Practical Magic posts. Idk if it’s the algorithm or I’ve found my people. Practical Magic is my favorite movie. I have two copies on DVD for emergencies. It wasn’t until last year I thought I should check and see if there’s a book. Turns out there are FOUR. I know I was
T

T

867 likes

Spicy books with discreet covers
The Dixon Rule is definitely the spiciest book out of these recs 🤭 #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookrecs #bookboyfriend
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

6968 likes

A person views a framed painting in a museum, with the overlay text "4 BOOKS TO BE A HIGH VALUE WOMEN" in bold red and white, introducing a list of empowering reads.
The book "UNTAMED" by Glennon Doyle is displayed, highlighted for promoting inner knowing, self-trust, courage, and authenticity, described as an awakening for breaking free from expectations.
The book "THE GIFTS OF IMPERFECTION" by Brené Brown is shown, emphasizing self-compassion, vulnerability, worthiness, and wholeheartedness, offering permission to embrace imperfection.
4 books to be a high value women
Hey ladies! 💘 Want to know a secret weapon in my self-discovery journey? Books 📚 Not just any books, but ones that challenge my thoughts, push me out of my comfort zone, ad make me see the world - and myself - in a new light. These pages have become my mentors, my confidants, my cheerleaders.
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

1193 likes

4 Books Every Mother Needs to Read 📚
1️⃣Fair Play by Eve Rodsky This book is a revolutionary guide for couples looking to rebalance the domestic workload. Rodsky presents a system that helps partners divide household tasks and responsibilities more equitably, aiming to reduce stress and foster fairness in relationships. The book in
irianna

irianna

2268 likes

A stack of books with numerous colorful sticky tabs protruding from their pages, indicating many marked sections. The text overlay reads "Books that EXCEEDED My expectations" with "Lemon8" and "@saragjackson" at the bottom.
The book cover for "Heartless" by Marissa Meyer, featuring a white background with dark thorny vines and red rosebuds, and a red crown. Text overlays indicate "Origin story of the Queen of Hearts" and "Forbidden Love."
Two books, "Divine Rivals" by Rebecca Ross and "Hawk" by James Patterson, are displayed on a wooden surface. Text overlays describe themes like "Found Family," "Dystopian," "Enemies to Lovers," and "Academic Rivals."
Books that Exceeded my Expectations
#read #unfiltered #embracevulnerability #travelwithme2024 #Lemon8Diary #beautyfinds #shareyourthoughts #healthylifestyle2024 #helpmechoose #livephoto
Sara Jackson

Sara Jackson

780 likes

Books/Media I Recommend to Become a COOL GIRL✨🌸💫
(You’re probably already cool but these are just things I consume that make me feel smarter and hotter, ENJOY 😊) BOOKS: Pride And Prejudice- Jane Austen The Celestine Prophecy-James Redfield The Power of Now- Eckhart Tolle Wuthering Heights- Emily Brontë Jane Eyre- Charlotte Brontë Moo
alaudano

alaudano

1874 likes

books that met, exceeded, & did not meet my expectations 🌟🪻🧚🏻
✧˖°ʚ kaitlyn ɞ♡

✧˖°ʚ kaitlyn ɞ♡

116 likes

Barnes & Noble Banned Books Edition 🚫📚
If it’s banned, it’s probably worth reading, right? Twice a week, my daughter and I visit Barnes & Noble. This week, we binge-read the banned book section. Have you ever read any of these books? Here’s a summary of each one and the reasons they’ve been banned. 1. Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bra
𝐊𝐄𝐘𝐎𝐍𝐍𝐀❦

𝐊𝐄𝐘𝐎𝐍𝐍𝐀❦

7361 likes

romance books based off fairytales
here are some of my favorite books based off of fairytales book recs 😮‍💨 #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookrecs
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

5259 likes

BOOKS TO READ ON YOUR MENTAL HEALTH JOURNEY📚🧠
When I feel like I am in a rut or just need a little bit of motivation or inspiration, I love turning to self-help books. These are some books that have helped me immensely in the process of working on my mental health, and some that have been highly recommended and are now on my list. There are br
brianna

brianna

3404 likes

Bookish expectations
Here are a few books that met my expectations, exceeded my expectations, didn’t meet my expectations, and a few books that I have high expectations for #books #booksoflemon8 #bookgirly #bookishthoughts #books 🫶🏼
Elle’s 📚 Shelf

Elle’s 📚 Shelf

12 likes

BOOKS I THOUGHT WOULD BE 5⭐️
I still really liked all of the books in here they just didn’t all give me that 5 star feeling. Iron flame just fell short for me and was WAY too long. books like Good Girls Guide and No Exit, I had seen reviews that so many people loved them that I feel like i went in with my expectations too high
Tovah Lewis

Tovah Lewis

890 likes

A person's face is partially visible, with the text overlay "BOOKS THAT HELPED ME UNDERSTAND MYSELF BETTER" and pink flower doodles. The Lemon8 logo and username are in the bottom left corner.
The front cover of the book "How to Be Yourself: Quiet Your Inner Critic and Rise Above Social Anxiety" by Ellen Hendriksen, Ph.D., featuring a person holding white balloons. The Lemon8 logo and username are in the bottom left corner.
The back cover of the book "How to Be Yourself," detailing its content on conquering social anxiety and quieting the inner critic, with praise from various authors. The Lemon8 logo and username are in the bottom left corner.
BOOKS THAT HELPED ME UNDERSTAND MYSELF
Understanding the root of your problems can help you find better solutions to combat the issue. Although, you might have a gist of what’s wrong, having a deeper knowledge of how it affects you and self awareness of why you act the way you do can change your whole perception and attitude towards thi
bunni 🌟

bunni 🌟

636 likes

A hand holds a stack of books with white spines on a textured white background. The text overlay reads "SUMMARIZING MY FAVORITE WLW BOOKS" in pink and orange, with sparkling graphic elements. The Lemon8 logo and user handle "@lifewithiri" are in the bottom left.
The book cover for "I Kissed Shara Wheeler" by Casey McQuiston, featuring a blonde woman and a pink envelope. Text highlights it as YA, Contemporary, Mystery, Dramatic, Enigmatic, and Romantic, with a summary about Chloe Green unraveling clues after a kiss.
The book cover for "Iris Kelly Doesn't Date" by Ashley Herring Blake, depicting two women in front of a house. It's described as Romance, Contemporary, Humorous, Charming, and Relatable, with a summary about Iris breaking her dating rules for a new girl.
9 Must-Read WLW Romance Books 🏳️‍🌈
🌈 Get ready to fall in love with these captivating WLW novels! These are some of my personal favorites, featuring glamorous Hollywood tales, heartfelt historical romances, and contemporary love stories with a twist. Each book is packed with emotion, drama, and unforgettable characters.
irianna

irianna

653 likes

Book expectations vs reality 💫📚
Sometimes the hype around books (esp Booktok books) can lead me to being let down 🥲 even some of the books that let me down were still good but my head created wayyyy too much hype over them based on what everyone was saying 🥵 if you’ve read any of these do you agree or disagree?👀 #unpopular
Alexzandra📚✨🐉

Alexzandra📚✨🐉

108 likes

books i’m SCARED to read and WHY
i feel like i’m going to be attacked by sjm fans but idk why lol #books #reader #shatterme #sarahjmaas #bookgirly
hannah ☕️🪐

hannah ☕️🪐

792 likes

Books that exceeded my expectations.
Have you read any of these books?? #books #booktok #Lemon8 #lemon8community #readingaesthetic
𝔾𝕒𝕪𝕒𝕟𝕖'𝕤 𝕎𝕠𝕣𝕝𝕕♡

𝔾𝕒𝕪𝕒𝕟𝕖'𝕤 𝕎𝕠𝕣𝕝𝕕♡

38 likes

A person reads in bed, surrounded by book covers like 'Funny Story' and 'Hamnet', illustrating books that met expectations. The titles include 'Novel Love Story' by Ashley Poston, 'Wild Reverence' by Rebecca Ross, and 'The Nightingale' by Kristin Hannah.
A person laughs in a bookstore, surrounded by book covers like 'Shark Heart' and 'A Man Called Ove', representing books that exceeded expectations. Other titles include 'Beg, Borrow, or Steal' by Sarah Adams and 'The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue'.
A person views art in a gallery, with book covers like 'Happy Place' and 'Piranesi' displayed, showing books that didn't meet expectations. Titles include 'A Curse for True Love' by Stephanie Garber and 'Wild Dark Shore' by Charlotte McConaghy.
Book expectations
book expectations vs. reality📖 IB: @léa #booktok #bookrecs #bookish #booklover
MacK’s Books

MacK’s Books

12 likes

An open book with pink tulips on its pages, featuring the text "Fantasy books with toe curling spice" and chili, fire, and flushed face emojis. The Lemon8 logo and username are at the bottom left.
The book cover for "Chained" by Lacey Lehotzky, depicting a dagger and chains on a dark background. Text bubbles highlight its "unrelenting spice," "feral MMC energy," and "captor-captive" theme, with a 5/5 spice level.
The book cover for "What Lies Beyond the Veil" by Harper L. Woods, featuring a dark design with snakes and red/gold lettering. Text bubbles describe it as having "Fae + spice," "possessive & deadly MMC," and "painful angst," with a 4.5/5 spice level.
Fantasy books with toe curling spice
You ever read a book so spicy that you physically *have* to put it down for a second? Like, “let me collect myself before I combust” level spice? These books?? They DELIVER. They understood the assignment. Here's your “forbidden magic, powerful (and possessive) beings, dark fantasy worlds, a
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

605 likes

An overhead shot of several books and a tablet, with an open book in the foreground. The text overlay reads "books that look innocent but aren't," introducing a collection of romance novels with unexpected themes.
The book cover for "My Killer Vacation" by Tessa Bailey, featuring an embracing couple. Overlaid text describes it as a "quick n spicy m*rder mystery" with "grumpy x sunshine" and a bounty hunter character.
The book cover for "Night Shift" by Annie Crown, showing a man and woman in a library, the man holding a basketball. Overlaid text highlights it as a "quick read" with a "swoon worthy college basketball mmc" and a "book worm."
books that look innocent but aren’t
things we left behind is my roman empire 😩😭😮‍💨 #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookrecs
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

3906 likes

A hand holds a stack of three books, with the overlay text "SHORT BOOKS for literary girls w/short attention spans," introducing a selection of concise novels.
A hand holds the book "Small Things Like These" by Claire Keegan, rated 4.5 stars. Overlays highlight it as Irish literature that explores religion and gendered social expectations, described as thought-provoking and enlightening.
A hand holds the book "Sula" by Toni Morrison, rated 5 stars. Overlays describe it as a contemporary classic by a Nobel Prize winner, exploring class, race, gender, and female societal expectations.
SHORT BOOKS (for girls w/short attention spans)
Perfecting the art of the short novel is no easy task. Constructing a compelling plot, characters, and setting in less than 200 pages requires a certain level of technical skill that many authors struggle with. However, these three books do all of these things almost flawlessly. They not only manag
bookrvws

bookrvws

5551 likes

5 Most Disturbing Books 😨
2024 brought a new favorite genre to me: literary fiction with a sub genre of horror and thriller (more often than not - body horror!!!) Here are my top five books of 2024 that disturbed me in there own unique ways 😳😂 (please check trigger warnings) 5. Bunny by Mona Awad: an MFA writing p
Mandy 🕯️

Mandy 🕯️

592 likes

4 short but shockingly deep books
You know those books that are short enough to finish in a day but leave you thinking about them for *weeks*? Yeah, these are exactly that. 🌀 They might look small, but don’t let their size fool you—they’re packed with big emotions, heavy ideas, and twists that’ll leave you sitting there like, “What
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

825 likes

Romance books I’m scared to read 📚😅
I LOVE reading romance books but here are five that I’m too intimidated to read! I’ve had each of these books for so long and I do plan to read them eventually, but I keep pushing them back on my TBR! There’s something about starting a new long series that is always intimidating for me, and I j
Bethany Taylor

Bethany Taylor

510 likes

Short books (that will leave an impact) 📚
If you're looking for some quick but powerful reads, here you go! These books are short but will leave a mark long after you finish them. Whether you're in the mood for a love story, some deep reflections on life, or something a little magical, here’s what I’m loving lately: 📚 How Not to
Lee | Booktok

Lee | Booktok

454 likes

✨ Focus on your tasks, not others’ expectations
Most people spend their lives trying to be liked. This book argues that true freedom begins when you stop needing approval. The Courage to Be Disliked completely changed how I think about happiness, trauma, and relationships. Sometimes growth means accepting that not everyone will understand
Bintou’s Books

Bintou’s Books

233 likes

Some of my favorite books 📚
Looking for some new book recommendations , these are some of my favorite books for healing, inner work, and getting closer to God. #bookrecommendations #bookgirles #selfhelpbooks #favoritereads
Elisa Gallegos

Elisa Gallegos

112 likes

A stack of popular books including 'Hidden Pictures', 'A Study in Drowning', and 'Powerless' is shown with overlay text that reads 'POPULAR BOOKS THAT I DO NOT RECOMMEND'.
A hand holds the book 'Powerless' by Lauren Roberts, rated with three stars. The accompanying text criticizes the book's 'dislike to lovers' trope, cringe banter, and derivative plot, expressing disappointment.
A hand holds 'The Silent Patient' by Alex Michaelides, rated with three stars. The text criticizes the book's plot twist, stating it ruined the story and overshadowed the main character, leading to a disappointing read.
save ur time & money on these books 😬
OMG these books were my absolute favorites!!! [EXTREMELY LOUD INCORRECT BUZZER NOISE] Seriously though, I really disliked all of these. I won’t say I hated them (except maybe Hidden Pictures) but I do have strong negative feelings about them, mostly because a lot of them were extremely hyped up
molly

molly

351 likes

A hand holds a stack of five fantasy books on a white textured background. Text overlay reads "Fantasy Books I Have High Expectations For."
The book cover for "The Deer and the Dragon" by Piper CJ, featuring a dark figure with antlers and a mask, on a white textured background.
The book cover for "Daughter of No Worlds" by Carissa Broadbent, showing a woman in a red dress with a sword amidst red petals, on a white textured background.
Fantasy Books I Have High Expectations For
#bookrecommendations #fivestarbooks #fantasybooks #fantasy #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge
Keeks 📖🏹

Keeks 📖🏹

386 likes

Books to read
Linh

Linh

289 likes

A woman smiles while holding a cup, sitting on a yellow couch in a cozy room with bookshelves. Text overlay reads "BOOKS TO BE HIS DREAM GIRL Or you just gotta be a better version of yourself, a high value women EVERYDA."
The book cover for "UNTAMED GLENNON DOYLE" is prominently displayed in a room with bookshelves. Text highlights it as "Raw," "Soul-stirring," "Liberating," and a "Must-read" for breaking free from expectations.
The book cover for "YEAR OF YES SHONDA RHIMES" is on a table with drinks. Text describes it as a "hilarious and inspiring reminder to say YES to opportunities," highlighting it as "Adventurous," "Motivating," and "Eye-opening."
Books to be a high value woman
Ladies, ever felt like you were chasing a mirage of “perfection”? 🙋🏻‍♀️ I sure did. I hustled, I strived, I tried to cram myself into a mold that wasn't even *mine*. It was a recipe for burnout, not brilliance. Then, a few books told a different story. They weren't about being flawless o
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

152 likes

📚books i found at half priced books📚
this was my first time EVER at half price books and i was in love! okay i was pretty mad the i only got $4.16 for 6 books, but i think i went in with too high of expectations. but def let me know if you have also been scammed by half price books. so my local half priced books had so many amazin
jarissa 🫶

jarissa 🫶

99 likes

A person holds an open book titled 'The Seven Year Slip' by Ashley Poston. The image has text overlay 'BOOKS VS my expectations' and features the Lemon8 logo with user handles.
A person holds an open book, with five book covers overlaid, representing 'books that met my expectations'. Titles include 'The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo' and 'Alchemy of Secrets'.
A person holds an open book, with five book covers overlaid, representing 'books on my TBR that I have high hopes for'. Titles include 'For the Record' and 'An Introvert's Guide to Life and Love'.
♡ books that... ♡
i've been seeing this cute little trend everywhere & i'm OBSESSED 🤩 it was way too much fun, something about putting books into these categories scratches a very specific itch in my brain 😂 💕 books that met my expectations 💕 i knew i’d love these ones & they delivered exactly wh
megs💝

megs💝

7 likes

Dark romance books that simply met my expectations ✨
📚 Title and Author: Game on (by Navessa Allen) 📚 Title and Author: Does it hurt (by H.D Carlton) 📚 Title and Author: Older (by Penelope Douglas) 📚 Title and Author: Little stranger (by Leigh Rivers) 📚 Title and Author: God of malice (by Rina Kent) 📚 Title and Author: Pretty monster
Onna!’🩷

Onna!’🩷

14 likes

BOOKS🥰
#lemon8diarychallenge "When You're Ready, This Is How You Heal" by Brianna Wiest is a transformative book that offers guidance and insights on the healing journey. Drawing on personal experiences and research, Wiest provides practical advice and tools for individuals seeking to h
Grace

Grace

446 likes

even more spicy books I need to read ASAP!!🌶️🖤
I am absolutely obsessed with a good, spicy, smutty, dark romance book and I keep buying more and more! The spicier, the better!!! 🌶️❤️‍🔥 My TBR is growing by the day and I seriously cannot get enough!! With that, here are a few more of the spiciest books on my physical to-be-read shelves and m
anika janelle🌿

anika janelle🌿

2013 likes

I didn’t expect to love these books so much!
these are my dark horse books aka I picked them up without having any real expectation and ended up being blown away. This to me is the best part about being a reader - that you can still find books that surprise you even after reading hundreds! What books did you read that totally surprised you or
bookrvws

bookrvws

82 likes

more unlikeable books 😬
Part 2 of my most overrated books of the year is here 👀📚 If part 1 raised eyebrows, this one might really do it. These are the books that had so much hype, glowing reviews everywhere, and massive expectations… but just didn’t fully deliver for me. Not bad books — just ones that didn’t live up to th
Lauren 🪴📚😻

Lauren 🪴📚😻

10 likes

Booktok expectations
turns out…i’m fine with my own pace 🤷‍♀️ #booktok #bookish #readinglife #readerlife #readerstruggles
Hannahbanana0131

Hannahbanana0131

27 likes

Books to Read As a Psych Major!! 🧠
As a Psych major, here are some books I have read, especially when I am tanning, to broaden my knowledge on the subject itself! 1) ATOMIC HABITS Author: James Clear Genre: Self-Help My rating: 10/10 My review: As a young adult who has faced many challenges during my teenage years, this b
Juliana :)

Juliana :)

351 likes

Popular books I did NOT vibe with
This is not a dig at anyone who likes these books. They just weren’t for me. What popular books didn’t live up to your expectations? #lemon8bookclubchallenge #lemon8bookworms #popularbooks
Brittany

Brittany

38 likes

Books That Exceeded My Expectations📚💕
Two of these are in my top reads for the year (read 38 books so far) and one is a top read from last year! AND they are on KindleUnlimited!! #kindleunlimitedbooks #fantasybooks #romancebookrecommendations #bookrecs #darkfantasyromance
Sage|INHC

Sage|INHC

1 like

A classroom bookshelf with red bins full of books, overlaid with text "BOOKS FOR YOUR Classroom & Lessons AS AN ELEMENTARY TEACHER," introducing the topic of books for elementary education.
A hand holding "The Leaf Thief" book, featuring a squirrel with autumn leaves, with text indicating it's a seasonal book for interactive read-alouds to celebrate seasons.
A hand holding "David Gets in Trouble" book, depicting a boy on a stool, with text explaining its use for teaching classroom behavior expectations.
Books & lessons I use as an elementary teacher!
Hey guys!! As I gather more books for my future classroom, I love to tie in lessons with books & you can come up with so many for any different theme! Below, I suggested books with lessons you can tie into your classroom! 📚 For the first book, I have a seasonal book. My students love the c
Riley Mulder

Riley Mulder

35 likes

8 Books at B&N I almost bought but didn't
While I did buy a lot of books from Barnes and Noble there were so many that caught my eye that I put back. These got added to my list to buy later. 🦴Nettle and Bone *AUTHOR: T. Kingfisher *GENRE: Twisted Fairytale I bought another book by this author on the same day and another title was my
✨️Morgan📚

✨️Morgan📚

1144 likes

See more