One of the most compelling aspects of Elle Rivers' "It Was" is how it masterfully blends classic romance tropes into a genuine and relatable small-town setting. The dynamic between the grumpy and sunshine personalities creates spark and tension that feels natural rather than forced, making the characters’ evolution particularly satisfying. I’ve always appreciated how forced proximity tropes, such as sharing a house, force characters to confront their feelings and misunderstandings in tight quarters. This novel showcases how living under the same roof can bring out warmth, humor, and vulnerability, especially when combined with the responsibilities and nuances of a single dad figure. From personal experience, the theme of "found family" resonates deeply, as the characters create bonds that transcend blood relations. Moments like shifting their usual dinner routine to eat outside under the sky—despite house rules—highlight the importance of shared moments over rigid structures. It reminds me of times when family dinners had to adapt to circumstances, reinforcing love and togetherness regardless of the setting. If you’re drawn to stories with meaningful connections and heartfelt moments wrapped in an engaging romantic storyline, "It Was" delivers. The inclusion of emotional rules like prioritizing dinner together over location adds layers to the narrative, making it both charming and reflective of real-life complexities in relationships. This book is ideal for readers who seek a cozy yet emotionally resonant romance enriched with small-town charm and authentic character growth.