💙 Best Jersey Mike’s Order

2025/1/10 Edited to

... Read moreHey everyone! I often get asked about my go-to Jersey Mike's order, and honestly, it's an art form! There are so many amazing choices, from the freshly sliced meats to the crisp veggies and, of course, those incredible dressings and sauces that truly make the sandwich. Let me walk you through some of my favorites and how I build my perfect sub, ensuring it's always packed with flavor. First off, let's talk about the essential dressing options. The 'Jersey Mike's Way' is iconic for a reason – it's their signature blend of red wine vinegar and olive oil, which adds that perfect tang and richness that complements almost any sub. But don't sleep on their other choices! Their creamy ranch dressing is a fantastic alternative, especially if you're going for a turkey or chicken sub. For those who like a bit of a zesty kick, sometimes they have a delightful chipotle mayo or a spicy relish that can truly elevate your sandwich. Always remember to ask what's available; sometimes there are seasonal specials that are worth trying! Moving on to sauce options, beyond the standard oil and vinegar, Jersey Mike's excels in fresh condiments. While they might not have a vast array of 'sauces' like other fast-food places, their quality ingredients make all the difference. Classic yellow mustard and mayonnaise are always on hand for those who prefer traditional flavors. My personal secret to adding a fantastic zing is their hot cherry pepper relish – it's a game-changer! For cheesesteaks, you'll typically find options like white American cheese or provolone, and some locations might even offer a creamy cheese sauce, so be sure to inquire if that's what you're craving. Now for the toppings – this is where you can truly make your sub uniquely yours. Freshness is key at Jersey Mike's, and their lettuce, tomatoes, and onions are always crisp and vibrant. Pickles add a wonderful crunch and brininess that I can't do without. If you're like me and love a little heat, jalapeños are a must-add! And don't forget the spices! A sprinkle of salt, pepper, and oregano is usually offered, and these simple additions really bring out the flavors of all the ingredients. If you're building a classic like the #13 Original Italian, you'll get thinly sliced provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni – all prepared right in front of you. For vegetarian options, you can load up on all the fresh veggies they have to offer. When it comes to the Jersey Mike's menu with prices, you'll find a range depending on the size of your sub – mini, regular, or giant. While specific prices can vary slightly by location, I always find their subs to be a great value for the quality and freshness you receive. You can easily check their website or app for the most up-to-date pricing in your area. My personal recommendation is to keep an eye out for their monthly sub special; it's a fantastic way to try new flavor combinations without breaking the bank! And for the perfect drink pairing with my delicious sub? Lately, I've been absolutely loving the Odyssey Elixir. Specifically, the Odyssey 222 Energy + Focus Sparkling Blue Raspberry flavor is my absolute favorite. It's not just a tasty treat; it also gives you a nice boost with potent ingredients like Lion's Mane (1500mg) and Cordyceps (1250mg), plus a substantial 222mg of natural caffeine. It really helps me stay focused and energized throughout my day. It's a fantastic healthy energy drink option that doesn't compromise on flavor – definitely worth trying with your next sub! So there you have it – my secrets to crafting the best Jersey Mike's order. Don't be afraid to experiment with different combinations of their dressing, sauce, and topping options. Every visit is a chance to discover a new favorite! What's your go-to order? Let me know!

Related posts

A close-up of a generously filled Jersey Mike's #13 sub sandwich, cut in half, showcasing cold cuts, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pickles, and pepperoncini on a toasted roll with herbs and cheese, resting on white paper.
Jersey Mike’s Order!
What’s your order!? This is #13 🤤 #jerseymikes #Coldcuts #subsandwich #foodie
Roundtreeee

Roundtreeee

1143 likes

A Jersey Mike's paper bag stands behind a clear plastic container holding an Italian 'Sub in a Tub' salad. The image highlights a new favorite way to order Jersey Mike's, with the bag featuring the logo and a 'Now Hiring' QR code.
A close-up of an Italian 'Sub in a Tub' salad in a clear plastic container, showing ingredients like ham, provolone, tomatoes, pickles, and onions. Text indicates it's 400 calories and costs $10.80, listing all the ingredients.
A fork lifts a portion of the Italian 'Sub in a Tub' salad, displaying various ingredients like meat, tomatoes, and pickles. The text expresses a preference for the Italian over the club sub due to more meat and filling, but wishes for better topping distribution.
this is the BEST low cal jersey mikes order 🤤
Round two with the Jersey Mike’s “Sub in a Tub” and it’s officially a staple lunch!! I’ve tried the club sub before, but ordering the Italian this time completely changed the game. So much more meat and way more filling! Here is exactly how I ordered it: ✨ Italian Sub in a Tub ✨ Add pickles ✨
Myra 💞

Myra 💞

72 likes

A close-up of a Jersey Mike's ham and provolone sandwich, cut in half, revealing layers of ham, lettuce, and a creamy yellow sauce. The image includes text detailing the order: "HAM & PROVOLONE SANDWICH MIKES WAY ADD PICKLES YELLOW MUSTARD COOKED HAM & COOKED ONIONS PLEASEEE".
Jersey Mikes Order ✨
I have never been satisfied with my cold cut sandwiches from Jersey Mikes until I started getting this order 10/10 😍
Kayle Love 💘

Kayle Love 💘

1241 likes

A person holds a clear container of a Jersey Mike's California Club salad bowl with extra turkey and bacon, against a blurred background of a Jersey Mike's restaurant. Text overlays describe the high-protein meal and a pro tip for dipping chips.
⭐️My new HIGH PROTEIN fave Jersey Mike’s order
YUMMY HIGH PROTEIN MEAL! Special menu: ⭐️California Club as a Bowl⭐️ EXTRA TURKEY EXTRA BACON AND let Mike have his way Pro Tip: get chips to dip in the bowl + ask for a side of ranch if you’re feeling it #jerseymikes #foodideas #foodie #healthyfoodideas #food
TiannaMarieee

TiannaMarieee

1037 likes

A Jersey Mike's healthy option bowl, featuring sliced turkey and provolone cheese topped with banana peppers, jalapeños, tomatoes, onions, lettuce, and oregano. Ordering instructions and ingredients are overlaid, with a bag of Miss Vick's chips in the background, all within a car interior.
Jersey Mikes ⬇️
On the go? Need something healthy? Order this, you will thank me later! This is so delicious without the bread and olive oil!! #healthy #jerseymikes #louisiana #onthego
Ⓣ

1013 likes

My 370 calorie Jersey Mike’s Order 💕✨
I take off the olive oil & cheese (cause I’m lactose intolerant lol) which takes off 370 calories. & I add cherry pepper relish, banana peppers, & honey mustard 💕 I use the spicy dill pickle chips to scoop up bites & it’s SO GOOD. But you could save even more calories if you got the
kiarareneepeavy

kiarareneepeavy

866 likes

A person holds a low-carb Jersey Mike's #13 sub in a tub, featuring lettuce, meat, tomatoes, jalapeños, and a creamy dressing. The image, taken inside a car, highlights a keto-friendly meal option.
Jersey Mikes Order
My love for Mr Mikes runs deeepp 🤧 Ii always order a number 13 in a tub (half portion of the meat) Mikes Way with extra Oil/vinegar and add jalapeños ❤️ I don’t get any dressing I just shake it up with the oil and vinegar 🤌🏾💋 #jersey mikes #ketomeals #weightlosstips #nursingstudent #
Najani, SRN 🩺

Najani, SRN 🩺

702 likes

ADDICTIVE 10 ingredient JERSEY MIKES BOWL? … no w
ADDICTIVE 10 ingredient JERSEY MIKES BOWL? … no way….(IMMA FIND IT 😩) #jerseyMIKES #foodfinders #salad #foodie #foodreview
AuthenticTeecee2.0 ™

AuthenticTeecee2.0 ™

4293 likes

A large salad-style meal in a rectangular container, featuring various deli meats including pepperoni, cheese, and vegetables, drizzled with dressing. A bag of cheese-flavored tortilla chips is in the background.
A close-up view of a hearty salad in a rectangular container, showcasing a mix of sliced meats, pepperoni, cheese, and fresh vegetables, topped with dressing.
A hand holds a forkful of the salad, showing a mix of shredded lettuce, sliced tomatoes, onions, pepperoni, and deli meats, with the container blurred in the background.
Viral Tiktok: Jersey Mike's Sub in a tub
This was sooo good + fresh! I added pepperoni's + French dressing (from home) and let me just say...it was 🔥 10/10! Have you tried it yet? The lost of the ingredients in the comments. #Lemon8 #jerseymikes #food #foodie #lemon8food
QTPie Vibez

QTPie Vibez

1059 likes

Apparently good?? Trying the viral jersey mike's nacho hack
Is this actually the best thing on the "secret menu," or just another internet trend? Today we are finally putting the viral Jersey Mike’s Nacho Hack to the ultimate taste test! 🧀🥖 If you haven’t seen it, this hack involves taking a hot, cheesy Philly cheesesteak and dumping it directly in
Sidney eatz

Sidney eatz

140 likes

A brown Jersey Mike's Subs paper bag with the brand logo and "A SUB ABOVE" slogan. Text overlays read "MY JERSEY MIKES ORDER" and "Worth it!!!!", indicating a food delivery or takeout.
A Jersey Mike's #8 Club Sub sandwich, cut in half, on Rosemary Parmesan bread with turkey, ham, provolone, bacon, mayo, honey mustard, lettuce, salt, and pepper. It is accompanied by a side of relish and Flaming Hot Tostitos chips.
A purple bag of Tostitos Xtra Flamin' Hot chips, featuring a lime graphic. Text on the image asks "Have you tried these before? Taste like takis," emphasizing their spicy flavor.
Jersey Mikes Subs
My Jerseys Mikes Order I love their Club Sub on Rosemary Parmesan Bread My order: Turkey,Oil ,Ham, Provolone,Applewood Smoked Bacon Mayo,Honey Mustard ,Lettuce,Salt and Pepper I like the Hot Chopped Pepper Relish on the side. 10000/10. My favorite sub. I also ate my sandwich with Flamin
ErinCole

ErinCole

456 likes

A Jersey Mike's Turkey and Provolone Bowl with extra turkey, vegetables, and pepper relish, is shown in a white container. A hand holds a bag of Miss Vickie's Spicy Dill Pickle chips above the bowl, all inside a car.
Jersey Mikes Order 510 Cals + 42g protein
This is my jersey mikes order Number 7 Turkey and Provolone Bowl Extra Turkey Meat Lettuce Tomato Onions Cheese Banana pepper Jalpenos Pepper Relish on top A cup of pepper relish on the side No oil No vinegar they carry tons of calories to add more protein you can do protein chip
LifewithNeek💗|Nursing Student

LifewithNeek💗|Nursing Student

994 likes

Jersey Mikes order 🤤
I have 2 orders depending on my mood! #13 on Parmesean rosemary bread, Mikes way, add mayo, red pepper relish and banana peppers! Or #10 which is tuna, on rosemary Parmesean bread, mikes way, add honey mustard, red pepper relish and jalapeños. Salt and vinegar chips and a Diet Pep
LifewithKD

LifewithKD

533 likes

Trying Jersey Mike’s Sub in a tub!!
I tried the sub in a tub from Jersey Mike’s! This is a lighter way of eating your favorite sub! You can get any sub you like hot or cold in a bowl! Whether you want to eat a salad or make them into nachos by adding chips, it’s your choice!🙂 ✨My Review✨ 🥪Club Sub in a Tub $10.75 (7/10) - I wan
Ari’sWorld🌍💕

Ari’sWorld🌍💕

100 likes

A Jersey Mike's paper bag and an open container with a 'Sub in a Tub' featuring lettuce, ham, and onions. The image includes text overlays for a 'Sub In A Tub Review' and 'SINCE 1956 Jersey Mike's SUBS'.
A close-up view of a 'Sub in a Tub' in a white container, showcasing shredded lettuce, sliced ham, and onion rings, seasoned with herbs. An overlay describes it as 'Simple But Loaded 500 Calories, No Bread Fresh, Crunchy, Flavorful'.
A white plastic fork lifts a portion of the 'Sub in a Tub,' showing lettuce, ham, and onions. An overlay states 'First Bite Thoughts Not Gonna Lie... This Hit Light But Filling', emphasizing the meal's satisfying nature.
Low Carb Jersey Mike’s Order 🥗
I’ve been trying to make a few lighter choices, so I decided to try Jersey Mike’s sub in a tub 👀 🥖 My Order: • #2 Jersey Shore’s Favorite Bowl • Ham, capacuolo, provolone • Lettuce, onions • Olive oil blend + red wine vinegar + oregano 🍽 What It Comes With: • Chips (Miss Vickie’s Jalapeñ
Brianna

Brianna

98 likes

A hand holds a cut Jersey Mike's sandwich, revealing layers of ham, provolone, shredded lettuce, and sliced tomatoes on Rosemary Parmesan bread. The other half rests on white deli paper with the brand's logo. Text overlay reads "MY JERSEY MIKES ORDER".
My Jersey Mikes Order
Jersey mikes is one of my favorite places! My go to order is: - Ham and Provolone on Rosemary Parmesan Bread - Mikes way - Miss Vickie's Sea Salt on the side with a Pepsi #jersey mikes #Takeout #myjerseymikesorder #foodie
Laurel

Laurel

34 likes

My Jersey mikes Order🥪
Jersey mikes is one of my favorite places!😋 My go-to order is: - Turkey & provolone - mikes way - add banana peppers, honey mustard, and mayo - Miss Vickie’s spicy dill pickle chips on the side with a Pepsi #jersey mikes #takeout #myjerseymikesorder #foodie
Reeselynn

Reeselynn

120 likes

Deshas Delicious Jersey Mike’s Sub!! 🚨🔥
#summerdiary #lemon8contest This is desha subs these are a must try do it yourself 🔥🔥🔥 #jersey mikes #share #lemon8challenge #Lemon8 #foodie
Jakari Lashika

Jakari Lashika

596 likes

Jersey Mikes Bowl 🤤
Number 7 Turkey and provolone. Add bacon and pepperoni. Salt and vinegar. Oil. Mayo. Banana and jalapeños peppers. Pepper red relish. Ask them to chop it up. Grab pepper packets. Put the lid on and shake it up till it all mixes together. Enjoy ✨ Thank me later ❤️🤤 also order online for pick up. S
Big Carm

Big Carm

440 likes

A close-up overhead shot of a "Jersey Mike's Sub in a Tub" in a white container. It features shredded lettuce, sliced onions, tomatoes, pickles, and deli meat, all coated in a creamy dressing. A black fork is visible on the right.
Jersey Mikes 🥗 🥪
#jersey mikes #jerseymikes #eatwithme #eatwithlemon8
Ana Alondra

Ana Alondra

779 likes

A Jersey Mike's 'Sub in a Tub' salad is shown in a white container, topped with shredded cheese, pickles, and peppers, with text indicating 'Sub in a Tub 400 cals'.
A checklist of Jersey Mike's toppings shows Provolone, Swiss, Jalapeño Peppers, Banana Peppers, Dill Pickles, Oregano, and Green Bell Pepper selected for a sub in a tub.
A checklist of Jersey Mike's toppings shows Jalapeño Peppers, Banana Peppers, Dill Pickles, Oregano, Green Bell Pepper, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, and Hot Chopped Pepper Relish selected.
Jersey Mikes Order
400 cals for the whole tub! Have you guys tried sub in a tub? Today 100% of the proceeds went to charity! 🥪 #caloriegoals #countingcalories #subinatub #jerseymikes #vegetarian
One Pound Baby Mom

One Pound Baby Mom

32 likes

Jersey mikes in a calorie deficit
#jersey mikes #caloriedeficitwins #lowcaloriemeals #quickmeals #lowcarbfoods
Demi Does It

Demi Does It

500 likes

JERSEY MIKES ORDER
Freakin love Jersey Mikes! Their cherry pepper spread is elite #jerseymikes #foodreview #dallas
Blondeswhoeat

Blondeswhoeat

207 likes

A Jersey Mike's sub sandwich, cut in half, is held up, revealing turkey, white cheese, shredded lettuce, and pickles on a light bread roll. The image features a "JERSEY MIKES ORDER" text overlay, emphasizing the sandwich's origin.
Jersey mikes order
Number 7 MINI (also love as a tub) White bread or sometimes rosemary parm 🧀 👌🏻Mikes way ❌ tomatoes 🍅 Pickles 🥒 Deli mustard 😍 Bacon 🥓 I prefer it swimming in vinegar too 🤪 #jersey mikes #jerseymikes #sandwich #restaurantorder #foodie 📍Location: Jersey Mikes OBX Overall r
TORI NORRELL

TORI NORRELL

46 likes

Jersey Mikes Mukbang
Chicken Bacon Ranch with extra chipotle mayo and banana peppers is the only answer #mukbang #mukbangs #jerseymikes
GastroGremlins

GastroGremlins

119 likes

The VIRAL Jersey Mike’s Nachos… but with TUNA?
The VIRAL Jersey Mike's Nachos just got a massive upgrade. Forget the turkey—we’re trying the Tuna Nacho Hack. Here is exactly how to order it and why this might be the best secret menu item yet. #JerseyMikes #FoodHack #ViralFood
Sidney eatz

Sidney eatz

4 likes

Double Meat Jersey Mike’s Cheesesteak 🔥
#jerseymikes #cheesesteak #foodie
Donnie Otero

Donnie Otero

212 likes

Jersey Mikes Sub In Tub
Very delicious 😋 10000/10
HEADFANEEE

HEADFANEEE

42 likes

Handing Out Jersey Mikes to Hungry People!🥹❤️
Joshlilj

Joshlilj

989 likes

My Jersey Mikes Order
One of my many favorites🩵😙 #jersey mikes #foodoflemon8 #foodinspiration
Aniah R.

Aniah R.

104 likes

Jersey Mikes order ✨🥪
I love a number 13 from Jersey Mikes- add pickles, chipotle mayo & cherry pepper relish on Rosemary Parmesan bread 🙌🏾😮‍💨 What’s your order? #jerseymikes #hoagie #subsandwiches #lunch #lunchinspo
Asia ✨

Asia ✨

110 likes

✨Love Jersey Mike’s…
What’s your Jersey Mike order? I want to try new sandwiches and bowls! Comment or message me ☺️🩵 #jersey mikes #26 #BaconRanchChickenCheeseSteak #Food #sandwiches
Jess

Jess

0 likes

First Jersey Mike’s order and I’m impressed 🥗😍
I can’t believe I’m just now discovering Jersey Mike’s. I usually go to Subway, so I didn’t even realize we had a Jersey Mike’s nearby. For my first order, I got the Turkey & Provolone Bowl loaded with toppings and sauces, and honestly, it was so good 🤤. I loved how all the flavors came toge
Cookwithme🥰🥰

Cookwithme🥰🥰

11 likes

My jersey mikes order
I order the regular-sized Jersey Shore favorite on white with extra lettuce, all the veggies, extra jalapeno, salt and pepper. A regular sub will usually last me two meals, which is why I don’t add any liquid. I don’t add any oil, vinegar, mayo, or mustard. If you really want to save a lot
T A Y L O R 🌵☀️

T A Y L O R 🌵☀️

10 likes

Jersey mikes
This is my to go order for jersey mikes 😋 what’s yours? #jerseymikes #sandwhich #dinner
Mei✨

Mei✨

96 likes

Jersey Mikes 😮‍💨
Club sub in tub 😮‍💨😮‍💨 Add banana peppers ❤️❤️ #jerseymikes #salad
It’s.yanapooh

It’s.yanapooh

42 likes

Handing Out Jersey Mike’s to Hungry People!🥹❤️
Joshlilj

Joshlilj

619 likes

Handing Out Jersey Mike’s to Hungry People!🥹❤️
Joshlilj

Joshlilj

230 likes

A close-up shot of a hearty salad bowl filled with shredded lettuce, various deli meats, banana peppers, and other vegetables, all coated in a creamy dressing. A black fork is inserted into the meal, which is presented in a light-colored container on a striped placemat.
Jersey mikes
The bowls at jersey mikes are so good. The Original Italian mikes way. Add pickles and banana peppers. The pepper relish. ( I bought the container of it) so good. And I add my own mayo and mustard.
Crystal kostyk

Crystal kostyk

415 likes

A hand holds a cut sub sandwich, revealing layers of ham, provolone, lettuce, pickles, and pepperoncini's, on branded deli paper. Text overlays read "All Time Favorite" and "JERSEY MIKES ORDER," highlighting a pregnancy craving.
✨Jersey Mikes Order✨
Honestly this was my BIGGEST pregnancy craving!! 🥪ORDER—> ⭐️Mikes way, Ham and Provolone ADD pickles, and pepperoncini’s #jerseymikes #sandwichideas #Lemon8Diary #pregnancycraving
ANGELICA

ANGELICA

22 likes

Bogg Bag Spotted At Jersey Mike’s
Why Jersey Mike’s Love’s The Bogg Life, Too! @Jerseymikes.eu @ #Lemon8 #boggbag #bogglife #arkansas #jerseymikes
KhaliahAli

KhaliahAli

369 likes

Jersey Mikes sub🖤
My order - the original Italian mikes way- add spicy brown mustard, mayo, jalapeños *regular size* #jersey mikes #fyp #subsandwiches
naee ❤️‍🔥

naee ❤️‍🔥

69 likes

A close-up overhead view of a "sub in a bowl" with shrimp, deli meat, lettuce, tomatoes, and pickles, lightly dressed. The word "Lunch" is overlaid on the image.
An overhead view of the same "sub in a bowl" with shrimp, deli meat, and vegetables, now generously covered in a white dressing, with a fork and knife.
Two slices of chocolate cake are visible in a clear plastic container. The text "can't go without desert" is overlaid on the image.
Jersey Mike’s again 🥰
#lunch bowl I’m hooked like a fish with these subs in a bowl .. BUT this time i put my own spin to it and added shrimp into it & OMG 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥.. Sooooo goood!!! Maybe i’ll eat this way from here on out 💯🩷‼️
Lady B ❤️

Lady B ❤️

254 likes

Jersey Mike's
#jerseymikes #subsandwiches #fastfood #fyp #foodie
Grumpy

Grumpy

21 likes

My jersey mikes order
#jersey mikes #jenizmyname #fyp #viral #foodie
Jenizmyname

Jenizmyname

2 likes

A Jersey Mike's 'Sub in a Tub' featuring grilled chicken, melted cheese, grilled onions, peppers, shredded lettuce, and sliced tomatoes in a white container. Text overlays promote it as 'Jersey Mikes High Protein Low Carb -for weight loss-'.
Jersey Mikes Sub In A Tub
Calories: ~500–520 • Protein: ~55–60g • Carbs: ~8–10g (from onions, peppers, tomato) • Fat: ~18–22g • Fiber: ~3–4g ✅ Why This Is a Great Choice: • High protein = helps preserve muscle as you lose weight • Low carb + low-moderate fat = s
𝓒𝓱𝓮𝔂. ♡︎

𝓒𝓱𝓮𝔂. ♡︎

181 likes

A hand holds a Jersey Mike's 'Sub in a Tub' salad with bacon, lettuce, tomato, and pickles. In the background, there's a jar of pickled red onions and a container of tzatziki sauce. Text overlay reads 'Jersey Mike's Sub in a Tub'.
My sub in a tub order from jersey mikes 🥪🥣
Grabbed a low-carb sub in a tub from Jersey Mike’s & took it up a level at home 🤭 Added pickled red onions + tzatziki sauce and it was chef’s kiss 😍 Healthy, filling, and still flavorful! my order was the #7 add bacon lettuce tomato pickles and red wine vinegar omg soo good #jersey mikes
Angelofmine

Angelofmine

12 likes

Jersey Mike's Tuna
The best sandwich ever! Run to Jersey Mike's and order this sandwich! #jerseymikes #viral #sandwich # 10 Tuna Rosemary Parmesan bread Mikes all the way no tomatoes Pickles/ banana peppers/jalapeños chopped pepper relish Honey mustard
✨Kelly ✨

✨Kelly ✨

15 likes

The best jersey mike’s sandwich
#jersey mikes #eatwithme #fy
juuicy_mandaa🎀

juuicy_mandaa🎀

12 likes

Low carb jersey mikes!
#lowcarbs #fastfood #fypシ゚ #caloriecounter #heathymealideas
Demi Does It

Demi Does It

355 likes

See more