3 Popular #BookTok Books I Wasn’t A Fan Of

The Silent Patient- Not sure if it is my pattern recognition skills, but knew early on who was culpable and who wasn’t. Loved the pace, but dragged on at certain points. It was very creative I will say!

The Perfect Marriage- Omg, the biggest disappointment! I could instantly tell what was going on. However, it did keep you entertained and would recommend for beginner thriller readers!

Never Lie- This has to be the most popular Frieda book, and I am not exactly sure why. It was fast paced, #but I feel like other Frieda books are far more entertaining than this one.

#booktok #bookrecommendations #bookworm #thrillerbooksaddict

2025/1/12 Edited to

... Read moreThe rise of #BookTok has brought numerous novels into the spotlight, yet not every popular title resonates with every reader. In this article, I discuss three highly recommended thriller novels—'The Silent Patient' by Alex Michaelides, 'The Perfect Marriage' by Jeneva Rose, and 'Never Lie' by Frieda McFadden. Each of these books has achieved bestseller status and generated significant buzz, but my personal experience highlights some common critiques. 'The Silent Patient' is known for its psychological depth and innovative twists, but I found myself predicting key plot points rather early on, which diminished my reading enjoyment. On the other hand, 'The Perfect Marriage,' while offering an engaging narrative, felt formulaic and predictable. I believe it's a suitable pick for those new to thrillers, yet failed to deliver the gripping suspense I sought. Finally, with 'Never Lie,' a title that many hail as Frieda McFadden's best work, I shared a feeling of discontent; while fast-paced, it didn't offer the suspenseful punch I had anticipated. For those who are passionate about reading and are navigating the current trends within the literary community, it’s essential to approach #BookTok recommendations with a discerning eye. Consider your reading preferences and the buzz around these titles critically, as not every trend aligns with all readers' tastes. Happy reading!

Related posts

Banned Books I found at B&N
Some of these don’t make sense!?? Can someone explain who’s putting these books on the banned list? #lemon8bookcommunity #bannedbooks #BookTok #lemon8books #bookstagram
Rachel Gwilliam🫸🏻📖🤏🏻✨

Rachel Gwilliam🫸🏻📖🤏🏻✨

1478 likes

Books I ignored in college & regret now
Remember those dusty books on my college bookshelf? The ones I swore I'd read “someday”? Yeah, well, “someday” is here, and I'm kicking myself for not cracking them open sooner. Turns out, those pages held insights I desperately needed back then - about history, the human spirit, dreams,
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

11.4K likes

A smiling woman holding a mug, sitting on a yellow couch, with text overlays indicating a financial journey from $10 to $10,000 and introducing books she read to achieve this.
The book "I Will Teach You To Be Rich" by Ramit Sethi, surrounded by text bubbles highlighting its practical approach to financial automation, conscious spending, and simple investing for a "rich life."
The book "The Total Money Makeover" by Dave Ramsey, with text describing it as a tough-love guide for financial fitness, emphasizing gazelle intensity, emergency funds, debt freedom, and budgeting basics.
Money books to build wealth
From ramen noodles to rooftop views, the journey from $10 to $10,000 was wild! 🚀 But it wasn't just about hustle and side hustles. Don't get me wrong, those helped A LOT. But the real game-changer? Books 📚 These weren't your typical beach reads. These pages were packed with mindset s
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

1025 likes

Two people are seated at a pink outdoor table, one eating and the other reading a book. The image is overlaid with yellow text stating, 'THESE BOOK WILL DESTROY OVERTHINKING,' illustrating the article's theme of using books to combat overthinking.
The book 'The Power of Now' by Eckhart Tolle is displayed, with text highlighting its benefits for inner peace, spiritual awakening, and living in the present moment. It's described as mind-blowing and helpful for understanding overthinking.
The book 'Feeling Good: The New Mood Therapy' by David D. Burns is shown, with overlaid text emphasizing its cognitive power, positive shifts, helpful techniques, and mood-boosting effects, likening it to a personal therapist.
These books will destroy OVERTHINKING
My brain used to be a non-stop drama queen, overthinking EVERYTHING 😩 But girl, I was DONE 🙅‍♀️ Done with the anxiety, the sleepless nights, and the constant feeling of being on edge. I knew I deserved better – we all do! ✨ So, I embarked on a self-care journey, and that's when I stumbled upon
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

1652 likes

Books to become a people magnet
🧲 The people magnet secret I used to be that person who blended into the background, always wondering why some people just naturally drew others to them. It felt like a secret club I couldn't track. But over time, I realized it wasn't about being the loudest or the most outgoing. It was
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

1807 likes

5 books for 5 skills
I've always been a bit of a bookworm, but it wasn't until recently that I realized the power a few pages could hold. We're not just talking about stories here, but about tools for rewiring your brain, understanding the world (and yourself) better, and even transforming your life. Hon
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

1482 likes

For those who didn’t know 👀 There are books
So I’ve been seeing a lot of Practical Magic posts. Idk if it’s the algorithm or I’ve found my people. Practical Magic is my favorite movie. I have two copies on DVD for emergencies. It wasn’t until last year I thought I should check and see if there’s a book. Turns out there are FOUR. I know I was
T

T

866 likes

3 books to earn f**k you money 🤑
Earning money is hard, but knowing how to control it is way harder. I found some amazing resources that totally changed the game! First, I realized I needed a clear plan and some tough love (sometimes we all need a kick in the pants, right?). Then, I learned how much our mindset actually affects
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

1235 likes

An image displaying six distinct color schemes, each composed of multiple paint swatches, labeled #1 through #6. The title reads: 'CHOOSE A COLOR SCHEME GET A BOOK REC (AGAIN!)'.
A book titled 'Intermezzo' by Sally Rooney, corresponding to color scheme #1. It is described as contemporary literary fiction with a stream of consciousness style, featuring brothers Peter and Ivan Koubek.
A book titled 'Graveyard Shift' by M.L. Rio, corresponding to color scheme #2. It is a horror mystery thriller novella about five people discovering a grave in a college cemetery.
choose ur own adventure: book rec edition
Was this just another opportunity for me to play with my paint samples? …maybe. mind ur business 🫵🏻 But book recs!! Book recs of all genres!! Choose your favorite color scheme (or multiple 👀) and find what book awaits you! There’s something here for everyone, from literary fiction to horror to s
molly

molly

1895 likes

A light green Amazon Kindle device rests on a white fabric with red heart patterns. Text overlay reads "MY 5 STAR THRILLER BOOKS" and "SWIPE," indicating a list of recommended books.
Thriller books I rate 5 stars
Book 1: Tell Me What Really Happened by Chelsea Sedoti -> 5 friends go camping and in the middle of the night one goes missing. Book 2: That's Not What Happened by Kody Keplinger -> She saw her best friend die in the school bathroom during a shooting. Everyone thinks she died a cert
Alice

Alice

1250 likes

An overhead view of a Target store's book aisle, with shelves of books on both sides and a central display. The text overlay reads: 'Books I'd get at Target if I wasn't BROKE' and 'SWIPE FOR MORE'.
A hand holds 'The Spellshop' by Sarah Beth Durst, featuring a magical cottage illustration on the cover. The text overlay states: 'I've seen this all over TikTok'.
A hand holds 'Caraval' by Stephanie Garber, which has a dark cover with a sparkling blue star design. The text overlay reads: 'I've heard some good things'.
Books I’d get at Target if I wasn’t BROKE
Are these any good? #targetbooks #bookish #foryoupage #tbr
Kenzie|📚🎀

Kenzie|📚🎀

1116 likes

A stack of books with a wine glass on top, featuring titles like 'The Silent Patient' and 'Red, White & Royal Blue', representing desired Amazon reads.
A pink boxed set of 'Dork Diaries' books 1-3 by Rachel Renée Russell, described as a classic elementary school read with high ratings.
Helen Hoang's 'The Kiss Quotient' series 2-book collection, including 'The Kiss Quotient' and 'The Bride Test', noted as a popular romance novel set.
Amazon reads I want to try if I wasn’t so broke✨😭
#lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge
Amirah Curry

Amirah Curry

49 likes

TBR Books I’m Scared to Start 📚
❗️UPDATE ❗️ I read If He Had Been With Me, REALLY did not like it. 2/5 stars (don’t come for me) 😭. It didn’t make me emotional at all, (which I’m a very emotional person), I’m surprised I even finished it. I started Twisted Love, dnf’d wasn’t my cup of tea 0/5 stars. I finished The Naturals serie
Trinity ✨

Trinity ✨

531 likes

i read popular booktok books!
and this is how i felt about each of the ones i read! 📚💗 | #booktok #BookReview #Lemon8 #shareyourthoughts #books #booksoflemon8
hailee💐

hailee💐

21 likes

The image displays open books with text, overlaid with the bold white and red text "BOOKS I'M TOO SCARED TO READ," indicating a list of intimidating books.
Four book spines from the 'Reformed Player' series by Becka Mack are shown, with arrows pointing to tropes like 'reformed player,' 'brothers bestfriend,' 'single mom,' and 'roommates.'
Four book spines from the 'Ruby Creek' series by Elsie Silver are displayed, with arrows indicating tropes such as 'enemies to lovers,' 'brothers bestfriend,' 'second chance,' and 'fake dating.'
Books I’m scared to read.✨🤧
I love books and I have a very wide spread of genre but these books are something different 💌 😳🎀 #bookwormsoflemon8 #read📚 #lots of books #📚books #lemon8challenge
(☆Boo𝙺diaries(☆

(☆Boo𝙺diaries(☆

705 likes

Booktok lied…
Booktok failed me this time… I’m usually a pretty easy to please reader - I like most books! However, this popular read was just not for me. Love on the Brain by Ali Hazelwood was a 1 star read for me - I could barely make it through this one. Should I try a different Ali Hazelwood book?
Khloemyers

Khloemyers

675 likes

Two books, 'If Only I Had Told Her' (red with rose, 2.5 stars, broken hearts) and 'If He Had Been With Me' (dark with lollipops, 4.5 stars, broken heart), are displayed on a white blanket with the title 'BOOKS I'VE READ AND HOW I FEEL ABOUT THEM'.
The book 'Better Than The Movies' by Lynn Painter, featuring a yellow cover with cartoon characters, is shown on a white blanket with 4.5 stars and two pink heart emojis.
Two books by Alice Kellen, 'All That We Never Were' and 'All That We Are Together', with vibrant rainbow floral covers, are displayed on a white blanket, each with 4.5 stars, a relieved face emoji, and a bandaged heart emoji.
✨Rating Books I’ve Recently Read✨
Here are my opinions on some books I’ve read so far this year <3 Have you read any of these?! What are your hot takes? I’m personally very confused as to how It Ends With Us was so popular on BookTok bc I just wasn’t a fan. Am I the only one? 🫣🫣 #booktok #lemon8bookclub #bookaesthetic
Val 🩷

Val 🩷

8 likes

A hand holds a stack of books, with pink text overlay "BOOKS I WILL ACCEPT ZERO CRITICISM ON" and "Lemon8 @mollz.y" in the corner.
The book cover for "Young Mungo" by Douglas Stuart is displayed with five white stars. Overlays provide a Goodreads summary and details like "416 pages," "literary fiction," "LGBTQ+," and "heartbreaking," along with a trigger warning.
The book cover for "The Spear Cuts Through Water" by Simon Jimenez is shown with five white stars and "six star read!!". Overlays include a Goodreads summary and details such as "576 pages," "epic fantasy," "LGBTQ+," and "quest plot."
molly’s must read books!! 📚
5 standalone novels and 2 trilogies you HAVE TO READ!! I’ve read almost 50 books this year and these are some of my favorites so far. You’ll notice that not all of them are 5 stars and yet I still classify them as a must read. That’s because I don’t just rate books out of 5 stars, I rank them ba
molly

molly

551 likes

A stack of five cozy mystery books with fall themes, topped by a white mug featuring the 'Luke's Stars Hollow Coffee Shop' logo, suggesting books for Gilmore Girls fans.
The book cover for 'The Pumpkin Spice Cafe' by Laurie Gilmore, depicting a charming cafe, accompanied by a plot summary about a fresh start in a small town.
The book cover for 'Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice' by Katie Cicatelli-Kuc, showing a couple on a bench amidst autumn leaves, with a plot summary about a New England village coffee shop.
GILMORE GIRL FANS: These books are for you! 🫶🍁📚☕️
I am an ADVIDE Gilmore girls fan. I have watched since I was in middle school. An OG fan when it wasn’t on Netflix (I don’t even think Netflix was a thing?!) but the show came out with NEW episodes weekly in the WB. Yeah.. those were the days. Nowadays I of course own all the DVDs lol but I wil
Ashlie

Ashlie

874 likes

Books for Pride 🏳️‍🌈
Happy Pride Month!! 🥰 Here’s a few books I’ve either read or want to read that have queer relationships. Check out Goodreads for some more lists or if you’d like me to make a part 2 let me know!! Tried to add different genres and some not so popular ones! If you have any suggestions for me pls
Alex🍒

Alex🍒

529 likes

Books i’d get at B&N if i wasn’t broke
#barnesandnoblefinds #books #bookshopping
arwenstfu💋

arwenstfu💋

11 likes

short, weird books to have a short, weird time
All of these books are less than 300 pages and two of them are under 200 👀 These books may not be easy reads, but they do go by fast! I love having short books on hand after finishing a longer series or even just for a break between bigger, heavier-themed books. That’s not to say that small book
molly

molly

421 likes

books i read in january: part 1
i finished 15 books in january!!! all of these are really good reads. i’m definitely on a thriller kick & these books did not disappoint. the only book that wasn’t quite a thriller was “the girls in the stilt house”, but still a really good read. it has notes of mystery, but not really thrillin
aude jones

aude jones

826 likes

The cover of the book "THE KNIGHT AND THE MOTH" by Rachel Gillig, featuring a woman in armor, is displayed on a white surface with dried flowers. Overlaid text reads "So... I didn't like it."
A person holds a dark book with a silver emblem, labeled as "DARK ROMANTASY" and "POPULAR ON BOOKTOK," in front of a white bookshelf filled with various books.
An open book shows "CHAPTER SEVENTEEN THE ARDENT OARSMAN," with overlaid text "HOW FAR I MADE IT BEFORE I COULDN'T TAKE IT ANYMORE" pointing to the chapter. A bookshelf is blurred in the background.
I DNFed this popular booktok book. Here’s why📚
So… i know how could I? I should state that before I started this I knew I wouldn’t like it. ✨I have owned One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig and actually unhauled it after reading one page. ✨Heres why I DNFed after 17 WHOLE CHAPTERS I started this book and was enjoying the story of it all &
her.bookescape

her.bookescape

6 likes

Horror Books featuring Haunted Houses!
Love a chilling haunted house story? 🏚️👻 Here are some spine-tingling horror books all featuring creepy haunted houses! 🖤📚 1. HOW TO SELL A HAUNTED HOUSE: I loved this book and I ate it up in just a day! Although it wasn’t completely terrifying and had some pretty heartfelt moments, there were t
TheGeekGoddess

TheGeekGoddess

383 likes

A bookshelf filled with various books, overlaid with text "BOOKS TO BREAK ANY BAD HABITS IN JUST 1 WEEKS" and crossed-out bad habits like staying up late, procrastinating, eating junk food, and scrolling for hours.
The book cover for "The Power of Habit" by Charles Duhigg, featuring a rat in a hamster wheel. Overlays explain that most actions are automatic and the book helps understand and change daily patterns.
The book cover for "The Craving Mind" by Judson Brewer. Overlays discuss why people are addicted to bad habits and how the book explains cravings and brain wiring to outsmart them.
Books to break bad habits
You ever catch yourself doing the same bad habits over and over, even when you KNOW they’re bad? 🤦‍♀️ Scrolling for hours, procrastinating, eating junk food, staying up late—been there, done that. And every time, I’d tell myself, *“I’ll stop tomorrow.”* Spoiler: I didn’t 😅 Then I picked up these
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

482 likes

A shelf of books with text overlay "Popular Booktok Books And why I DNF'd them SWIPE" and a thinking emoji. The image introduces a discussion about not finishing popular books.
The book cover for "Kingdom of the Wicked" by Kerri Maniscalco, featuring a skull and snake, is shown on a grey blanket. A review explains the book was DNF'd at 62% due to a flat plot and disliked trope.
The book cover for "Ninth House" by Leigh Bardugo, featuring a snake, is displayed on a grey blanket. A review states the book was DNF'd at 25% because the plot was confusing and drawn out.
Cancelled For DNFing Popular Booktok Books? 😔😩
Well, maybe not cancelled… but it definitely is a weird feeling when everyone is raving about how much they loved the book you just couldn’t finish reading for whatever reason! 😓 I feel like many readers struggle with DNFing (stands for Did Not Finish) books especially the ones that Insta and Bookt
Lauren 📚📖

Lauren 📚📖

64 likes

Three romance novels are stacked, with the top book titled 'The Spanish Love Deception' by Elena Armas. Overlay text reads '3 spicy books you NEED to read'.
A book titled 'Her Soul to Take' by Harley Laroux, featuring a dark cover with a skull and succulents. Overlay text expresses enjoyment of the book's 'spice'.
Two books by Sierra Simone, 'American Prince' and 'Salt Kiss', are displayed. Overlay text praises Sierra Simone's writing and the 'spice scenes' in these books.
3 spicy books you NEED to read
I was a little weirded out my the cover of her soul to take but I really liked the romance part of the book, I wish there was a discreet version available #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendati
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

235 likes

The book cover for 'Dead Inside' by Chandler Morrison features a skeleton in a police uniform holding red flowers, surrounded by insects. A review snippet rates it 8/10, stating it's 'not for the faint of heart'.
The book cover for 'Cows' by Matthew Stokoe shows a close-up of a cow's face in a blueish tone. A handwritten note on the image rates it 4/10, saying 'was good until it wasn't'.
The book cover for 'Crank' by Ellen Hopkins features the title in large, stylized letters with the tagline 'Is the high worth the crash?'. A handwritten note rates it 9/10, expressing surprise it took so long to read.
Books I’ve read this year plus my next read
Just recently got into splatterpunk I know crank isn’t in the genre but I’m a big horror fan so I’m all about them🖤🩸 #gorebooks #horrorbookcommunity #horrorbooks #splatterpunk #spookybookhaul
Avalon Wauer

Avalon Wauer

524 likes

The image displays open books with the text overlay '25 SPICY ROMANCE BOOKS TO ADD TO YOUR TBR LIST'. A 'lemons @readers.archive' watermark is at the bottom.
Four book covers are shown: 'King of Wrath' by Ana Huang, 'For The Fans' by Nyla K., 'Haunting Adeline' by H.D. Carlton, and 'Brutal Prince' by Sophie Lark, against a background of open books.
Four book covers are displayed: 'God of Malice' by Rina Kent, 'The Ritual' by Shantel Tessier, 'Hooked' by Emily McIntire, and 'Praise' by Sara Cate, on a background of open books.
25 spicy romance books to add to your tbr list
here’s my monthly post unfortunately I was running out of time today so I had to do 25 instead of 50 #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookrecs #bookboyfriend
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

1304 likes

A flat lay image showcasing a collection of books read in August, with titles like 'Shark Heart' and 'The Reformatory'. The books are arranged on a white radiator cover and a wooden book stand, with a mirror reflecting a window in the background. Text overlays announce 'books I read in August with comments + ratings'.
A hand holds the book 'When the Reckoning Comes' by LaTanya McQueen, rated 3.5 stars. The genre is described as 'atmospheric, southern gothic', with a comment noting good execution in the first half but a flat second half.
A hand holds the book 'Spitting Gold' by Carmella Lowkis, rated 3 stars. The genre is 'French historical fiction, spiritualism', with a comment suggesting the premise was loved but editing was needed.
the seven books I read in August
I finally had a productive reading month this past August! This last year has been hard being back in school and juggling reading for pleasure. Especially with a subject like history that is so reading heavy, I found this past year that aside from the burnout, I felt incredibly guilty for picking u
bookrvws

bookrvws

167 likes

A wide shot of a book aisle in a store, with shelves full of various books. A white text overlay reads 'Books I would buy from Walmart if I wasn't ✨broke✨'.
A book titled 'LOCAL WOMAN MISSING' by Mary Kubica, with a dark forest cover and pink text. The right image shows the book's sprayed edge featuring a pink tree-like design.
A book titled 'UNDER THE SAME STARS' by Libba Bray, featuring a light blue cover with a burning matchstick. The right image displays the book's sprayed edge with a red and white wood grain pattern.
Books I would buy from Walmart if I wasn’t ✨broke✨
I love a good sprayed edge #walmartbooks #bookhaul #newbooks #bookbuying #lemon8bookclub
Jamie Bolton

Jamie Bolton

784 likes

A person in bed reading a book, with text overlays "Free Books", "You need a Kindle! From a girl who loves Hard copy", and "Kindle edition", introducing the topic of free Kindle books.
A table piled high with numerous physical books, accompanied by text describing the Libby App (Overdrive) for borrowing digital ebooks and audiobooks for free with a library card.
A hand holding a white Kindle device displaying text, with text overlays "Amazon first reads" and "Free for prime members", illustrating a method for obtaining free Kindle books.
How to get Free Books- Kindle edition
Hi all this is an updated post on how to get free books (this is kindle edition) so first off, if you don’t have a kindle let me make my pitch. up until a couple months ago, I was purely a hard copy book girlie. I bought an Amazon kindle fire a few years ago and HATED reading on it. The brigh
Kayla

Kayla

1516 likes

A stack of popular books including 'Hidden Pictures', 'A Study in Drowning', and 'Powerless' is shown with overlay text that reads 'POPULAR BOOKS THAT I DO NOT RECOMMEND'.
A hand holds the book 'Powerless' by Lauren Roberts, rated with three stars. The accompanying text criticizes the book's 'dislike to lovers' trope, cringe banter, and derivative plot, expressing disappointment.
A hand holds 'The Silent Patient' by Alex Michaelides, rated with three stars. The text criticizes the book's plot twist, stating it ruined the story and overshadowed the main character, leading to a disappointing read.
save ur time & money on these books 😬
OMG these books were my absolute favorites!!! [EXTREMELY LOUD INCORRECT BUZZER NOISE] Seriously though, I really disliked all of these. I won’t say I hated them (except maybe Hidden Pictures) but I do have strong negative feelings about them, mostly because a lot of them were extremely hyped up
molly

molly

356 likes

Need some Halloween and autumn books?
- Halloween Party by Agatha Christie Full transparency, I haven’t finished this book 🙈 I’ve read multiple AC books and this one wasn’t in my opinion one of her best. However it has some very heavy Halloween and fall vibes so if you’re wanting something to get you into the season this one is great
Ruthie Sewell

Ruthie Sewell

28 likes

See more