Happy St. Patrick’s Day - Reuben Sandwich

2024/3/17 Edited to

... Read moreHey everyone! While my initial post zoomed through how to make a super quick Reuben, I wanted to dive a bit deeper into why this sandwich is such a St. Patrick's Day favorite, and share some extra tips and variations I've picked up along the way. First off, the big question: Is a Reuben sandwich actually Irish? Fun fact – it's generally accepted as an American creation, likely with Jewish-Lithuanian roots! However, because of its star ingredient, corned beef, it’s become a beloved staple for St. Patrick's Day celebrations here in the States. Corned beef might not be a traditional Irish dish either (cabbage and bacon is more authentic!), but it became popular among Irish immigrants in America. So, even if it's not strictly Irish, it's definitely part of our St. Paddy's Day food tradition! Now, about those ingredients. To truly make the best Reuben, especially if you're aiming for that 15-minute mark, quality matters. Corned Beef: You can use deli-sliced corned beef for speed, which is what I often do. But if you have leftover slow-cooked corned beef brisket from a St. Patrick's Day feast, thinly slice it against the grain for an even more tender bite. Swiss Cheese: Don't skimp on this! A good quality Swiss (Emmentaler or Gruyere also work beautifully) melts like a dream and adds that creamy, nutty counterpoint to the sauerkraut. Sauerkraut: This is crucial for that tangy kick. I usually give mine a light rinse and a good squeeze to remove excess brine – it mellows the flavor just enough without losing its essential zest. Rye Bread: Marble rye is my personal favorite, but any good, sturdy rye bread will do. The key is to butter or spread mayo on the outside before grilling for that perfect golden, crispy crust. Russian or Thousand Island Dressing: While store-bought is perfectly fine for speed, sometimes I whip up a quick homemade version: mayo, ketchup, a dash of Worcestershire, a little relish, and a pinch of paprika. It takes only a minute and elevates the sandwich! To really nail that 'easy and quick' promise, here are my go-to tips: Prep Ahead: Have all your ingredients sliced and ready to go. Hot Pan is Key: Get your skillet or griddle nice and hot before you even think about laying down your sandwich. This ensures a quick, even toast. Layer Smart: Start with cheese on the bottom slice of bread, then corned beef, sauerkraut, dressing, and then another slice of cheese before the top bread. The cheese on both sides acts like glue and helps everything melt beautifully. Looking for other St. Patrick's Day sandwich ideas or ways to use similar flavors? Corned Beef Grilled Cheese: If you want something even simpler, just skip the sauerkraut and dressing and make a grilled cheese with corned beef and Swiss. It's cheesy, savory, and super comforting! Reuben Casserole: For a crowd or a more substantial meal, a Reuben casserole is fantastic. Layer sliced rye bread, corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and then pour a mixture of Thousand Island dressing and cream of mushroom soup over the top. Bake it until bubbly and golden. It’s hearty, delicious, and a great way to feed a family. Whether you stick to the classic quick Reuben or try one of its delicious variations, these flavors are perfect for celebrating St. Patrick's Day or just enjoying a hearty, satisfying meal any time. Happy cooking!

13 comments

angelbaby's images
angelbaby

TIM YOUR CLASSIC REUBAN SANDWICH 🥪 LOOKS SO DELICIOUS. MY FAVORITE SANDWICH 🥪 IS ROAST BEEF WITH ONIONS BABY SPINACH TOMATOES PROVOLONE CHEESE WITH MAYO. HAPPY ST. PATRICKS DAY

Liz's images
Liz

Wait - why did I think you always had to boil corn beef? I have to try this!

See more comments

Related posts

Now THIS is how you do a Reuben 🥪✨ #reuben #sandwichtiktok #foodietiktok #portland #foryoupage
PDX Foodie Files

PDX Foodie Files

2 likes

Classic Reuben Sandwich
#lemon8challenge #dinnerideas #lemon8foodcoupon #lemon8food @Lemon8 Food
Tim Clowers

Tim Clowers

161 likes

Now THIS is how you do a Reuben 🥪✨ #reuben #sandwichtiktok #foodietiktok #portland #foryoupage @Portland Trailblazers
PDX Foodie Files

PDX Foodie Files

1 like

Wannabe Rachel Sandwich Recipe 🥪
Wannabe Rachel Sandwich Recipe Would you rather have a Rachel or a Reuben Sandwich?! All recipes are found at www.ameliaisnotachef.com INGREDIENTS Sandwich * 8 slices sourdough bread * Butter, for spreading on the bread * 8 slices Swiss cheese (2 per sandwich) * 1+ large heirloom toma
ameliaisnotachef

ameliaisnotachef

1674 likes

Massive Reuben Sandwich!
finally trying the Reuben! #nycfood #Sandwiches #reuben @Lemon8 Food #lemon8food
jeremyj

jeremyj

55 likes

Happy St Patrick’s Day from The Grillium
🍀 Celebrate St. Patrick’s at The Grillium! A fun hangout in Forest Lake for families and friends—great food, ice cream for the kids, and crafted drinks for the adults. Enjoy Irish décor, Reuben or Rachel sandwiches, quesadillas, flatbreads, Patty Melts, root beer floats, Grasshopper drinks an
The Grillium

The Grillium

1 like

Meal Prep Reuben Bowls
Its giving egg roll in a bowl but so so so much better! This one pan low carb Reuben skillet is the same ingredients as the meal prep version I shared on Wednesday, but this version is made as a one pan skillet dinner! Same protein packed low calorie meal but in this version made in one pan for
Kelli Shallal - Hungry Hobby

Kelli Shallal - Hungry Hobby

945 likes

MILANO REUBENS 🍀>>
See step by step how Milano Market makes there FAMOUS Reuben’s LOVE a cheese pull!? The Reuben has it. LOVE a saucy, messy bite? The Reuben has it. LOVE a meaty stack? The Reuben has it. #lemon8partner #nycfoodreview #nycfood #nycfoodie
NYWillEatYou - NYC FOOD

NYWillEatYou - NYC FOOD

20 likes

5 More Dinner Ideas
-Buffalo Chicken Enchiladas - Mississippi Pork Roast & Mashed Potatoes -Mongolian Beef & Rice -One Pan BBQ Chicken Potato Bake -Reuben Sandwich Bake #lemon8partner #cookingideas #dinnerideas #dinner #dinners
A Date Night In

A Date Night In

721 likes

A smiling woman with yellow hair enthusiastically holds up a large, generously filled pastrami sandwich. A plate with fries and coleslaw is visible on the table in front of her.
A young child in a high chair looks at a plate featuring a pastrami sandwich, fries, and coleslaw, holding a single fry. The setting appears to be a deli.
A woman and a child are seated at a table with a large pastrami sandwich. The woman holds a piece of the sandwich, while the child holds an onion ring, looking at the food.
Pastrami Reuben Sandwich
Do you love Pastrami???? Delicious 😋
Seun.scott

Seun.scott

6 likes

Reuben sandwich 👌🏽🔥
Once I learned how to make these it was over 🤤👌🏽 #sandwiches #fypシ゚viral #foodie #cook
shannz

shannz

5 likes

Ziggys
Ziggys Cafe in Springfield MO #whitetrashadventures #foodies #burgers #porkfritter #blt
White Trash Adventures

White Trash Adventures

29 likes

Reuben Sandwich
This #reuben sandwich just hit right especially with fresh marble rye bread from #calisebakery The #currentbackyard griddle never disappoints especially in this cold #newengland weather. #griddlecooking #recipes
ChefShawnN

ChefShawnN

7 likes

Let's Make a Corned Beef Sandwich 🥪 aka Reuben
Recipe 4oz Cooked corned beef 2ea Seeded rye bread 2ea Tablespoons russian dressing 1/4 Cup sauerkraut Russian dressing recipe 1/2 Cup Mayo 1/4 Cup Chili sauce 1ea Teaspoon worcesteshire sauce 1ea Teaspoon Hot sauce 1/2 Teaspoon prepared horseradish 1ea Pinch of ground black pep
SteviesFoodWorld

SteviesFoodWorld

15 likes

MUST-TRY SANDWICHES IN CHARLOTTE, NC!
🔥 MUST-TRY SANDWICHES!! 🔥 Where are all my sandwich lovers, because I’m coming in hot with some of Charlotte’s best sandwiches that keep this lady DROOLING! 😍 5 MUST-TRY SANDWICHES: 🤤 Italian: Capicola, pepperoni, salami and cheese, lettuce, tomato, salt, pepper, oregano, oil, and vinegar 📍 Sa
Sarah | Charlotte Food Scene

Sarah | Charlotte Food Scene

1056 likes

A glimse into our day❤️💚🎄
Hailey Michael

Hailey Michael

4 likes

🥪🍴 Classic Reuben Sandwich with Russian Dressing
🥪🍴 **Craving Comfort Food? Try This Classic Reuben Sandwich with Russian Dressing!** 🍴🥪 Savor the ultimate comfort with our Classic Reuben Sandwich recipe! Featuring tender corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, gooey Swiss cheese, and homemade Russian dressing—all grilled to perfection between slices o
LavandaMichelle

LavandaMichelle

48 likes

reuben pretzel bites #reubenpretzelbites #reubensandwich #kingshawaiianpretzelbites
Tina Belts

Tina Belts

15 likes

Corn beef Reuben
Sometimes all you need is a good Reuben and a quiet lunch break. • • #ChefJess #fyp #Lemon8 #recipe #cooking
Jessica Rhone

Jessica Rhone

70 likes

Scooby doo sandwiches 🥪 #fyp #reubensandwich
LaylaJade🌈

LaylaJade🌈

0 likes

Reuben Sandwich
#food #foodie #foodies #dinner #dinnerideas
ChristyMum78

ChristyMum78

1 like

Loaded Reuben potatoes soup.
This St.Paddy’s day I made this recipe. So excited for the leftovers. It was definitely a process but definitely delicious. #soupseason #reubensoup #stpatricksday #cookwithme
De4202020

De4202020

3 likes

A Reuben sandwich, cut in half, is presented on a white plate alongside a generous serving of crispy potato chips and a green pickle spear. The toasted marbled bread reveals layers of meat, melted cheese, and sauerkraut, suggesting a classic and appetizing meal.
the best sandwich (IMHO) the Reuben. nom nom
#lemon8diarychallenge
Married Angel

Married Angel

0 likes

Foodie Chap’s Reuben sandwich and ribs
Carolyn aka CurlCurl 431

Carolyn aka CurlCurl 431

3 likes

See more