Books I’m too scared to pick up thanks to booktok

I haven’t read any of these books yet, but I’ve seen so many negative reviews and comments. I don’t think that will stop me from reading them in the future, but they’re definitely not on my TBR right now. #lemon8bookclub

Arizona
2024/12/28 Edited to

... Read moreBookTok has revolutionized the book community, but not all recommendations come without a warning. Many readers have found themselves hesitant to pick up certain popular titles after seeing a flood of negative reviews on social media platforms. Among the most mentioned are Colleen Hoover’s works, where criticism often highlights perceived issues with writing quality and thematic depth. For instance, "It Ends With Us" has received mixed reactions, with some praising its emotional storytelling while others are put off by its content. Likewise, books like "Icebreaker" by Hannah Grace have caused disappointment due to unmet expectations that were inflated by viral trends. Readers are left wondering whether these books deserve a spot on their TBR lists or if they should heed the advice of fellow readers online. In addition to these, titles like "A Court of Silver Flames" by Sarah J. Maas are often scrutinized for pacing and character development, prompting discussions about whether high-profile books are sometimes overhyped. Ultimately, while BookTok can guide us, it can also create apprehension, leaving readers torn between curiosity and caution. Are there hidden gems among the negative feedback? Will the negative attention push us to miss out on potentially great reads? This article aims to encourage readers to think critically and make informed decisions about their reading choices.

383 comments

lena 🍒🫧🐻's images
lena 🍒🫧🐻

The sons balls thing is from Ugly Love, it ends with us, was on of my favs actually although she’s a controversial author

See more(20)
nicole's images
nicole

Tender is the Flesh is AMAZING for any horror/ thriller/ psychological lover. It’s pretty graphic so definitely read trigger warnings and get a sense of what the book is about before reading!! Definitely one of my favorites

See more(8)

See more comments

Related posts

books i am too scared to pick up
please convince me to read these 🥲 #books #bookwormsoflemon8 #reading
hannah

hannah

425 likes

Booktok Books I’m Too Scared To Buy
There are too many good books out there, and I’m not afraid to DNF… I’m afraid of wasting my money!!! Have you read these? Should I attempt to read these??? (Maybe I’ll have to finally get a library card…) #book shopping 🛒 #booktok #lemon8bookclub #bookstoreadinfall
✨📚CulliferBooks📚✨

✨📚CulliferBooks📚✨

964 likes

Books that scared the authors who wrote them
😱 These scary books didn’t just scare readers—they haunted the people who wrote them. From Stephen King to Thomas Harris, these authors were actually scared by their own thriller and horror novels. 📌 Save this list for your next jittery midnight read. #booktok #booksoflemon8 #darkbooks #
Thriller Book Recs 2025

Thriller Book Recs 2025

6505 likes

Fantasy books I’m too scared to read
I’ll eventually get to these….. eventually. Have you read any of these?? #fantasybooks #tbr #highfantasy
grace’s reads ❤️‍🔥✨

grace’s reads ❤️‍🔥✨

35 likes

sAD booKs i nEEd uR OPiNiON oN! 😭🙏🏽
Context: Every Last Word: I’m am currently reading Every Last Word and i have no opinion yet, unfortunately I’m not far in. Maybe like 10 pages and im too scared to read it because i heard it’s so so sad, and I don’t really want a book that’s going to make me cry. A Thousand Broken Pieces: I h
BookishBae🤍✨🧸

BookishBae🤍✨🧸

3093 likes

Books I’m scared To buy and read
#books 🫶🏼 #reading 📖 #readreadread #booktoker #booktok #booksimscaredtobuy
Marylyn✨🤍

Marylyn✨🤍

1042 likes

Must have books to learn manipulation
I’ll be real—before reading these books, I thought manipulation was just something villains did in movies. Turns out, we’re ALL being manipulated daily, whether it’s by ads, politicians, or even our own friends (yikes) 😬 After reading these, I felt lowkey enlightened and slightly paranoid 🤯 But
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

2879 likes

Books I’m scared to read.✨🤧
I love books and I have a very wide spread of genre but these books are something different 💌 😳🎀 #bookwormsoflemon8 #read📚 #lots of books #📚books #lemon8challenge
(☆Boo𝙺diaries(☆

(☆Boo𝙺diaries(☆

691 likes

📚 Books I’m Scared to Read 🫣
Less that I’m scared to read them, more that I’m intimidated to start them 😅🫣 Whether it’s because they’re really long books/series, or because they’re insanely hyped up, these are my daunting physical TBR books… - #lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge #Lemon8Diary #letschat #tbr
carmen 📚

carmen 📚

647 likes

books that intimidate me
books i’m too afraid/can’t bring myself to read — have you read any of these? if so convince me 😭 — save for later 🫶 #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge
mads

mads

13.8K likes

Books that even scared Stephen King
These scary books even terrified Stephen King and other famous authors. With that kind of endorsement, why wouldn’t you add them to your TBR? Some great horror books and dark thriller reads in this must-read list of book recs! #horrorbookrecommendations #scarybooks #booksoflemon8 #booktok
Scary Book Recs

Scary Book Recs

1811 likes

6 books that legit scared me
These six scary books actually terrified me—and I loved it! A nice mix of book recommendations that include horror lit, serial killer thriller books, and dark reads. Perfect for a TBR list #that’s a little too short on scary book recs. Enjoy! #disturbingbooks #serialkillerbooks #bookrecomme
Great Thriller Books

Great Thriller Books

829 likes

books I’m too scared to read
Has anyone read the Madison Kate series by Tate James and if so, is it worth the read and spoil some of it down below 🧍‍♀️ #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #spiciestbooks #booktok #bookrecs
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

1221 likes

books that intimidate me
part two <3 lmk if you’ve read any of these !! ——— #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8challenge
mads

mads

8525 likes

Books on my TBR that I’m too scared to read 🥲
Have you read any of these?! Okay so I have had these books for 1-2 years, just sittin on my TBR. Staring me straight in the eye. 👀But yall. I’ve gotta admit…. 😬Im literally too scared to read these lol 🙋🏽‍♀️Hear me out… I’m a sucker for grabbing books that are highly recommended by
Amber

Amber

798 likes

books i’m SCARED to read and WHY
i feel like i’m going to be attacked by sjm fans but idk why lol #books #reader #shatterme #sarahjmaas #bookgirly
hannah ☕️🪐

hannah ☕️🪐

792 likes

Book series I’m intimidated to read 🫣📖
Listen, I love a good book series, but there are some that have been on my TBR for YEARS because I’m too intimidated to start them. Here are four that have been on my TBR for so long, and why I haven’t read them yet 📚 *PLEASE let me know which ones you think I absolutely have to read! ✨Throne
Bethany Taylor

Bethany Taylor

451 likes

Books I’m scared to read and why
I own a lot of these and at this point they’re collecting dust until I have either the time or nerve to read them 😭😭 #book #booksimscaredtoread #bookish #bookworm #booktok
Natty 📚✨

Natty 📚✨

443 likes

TBR Books I’m Scared to Start 📚
❗️UPDATE ❗️ I read If He Had Been With Me, REALLY did not like it. 2/5 stars (don’t come for me) 😭. It didn’t make me emotional at all, (which I’m a very emotional person), I’m surprised I even finished it. I started Twisted Love, dnf’d wasn’t my cup of tea 0/5 stars. I finished The Naturals serie
Trinity ✨

Trinity ✨

529 likes

Popular books I’m scared to read !
#findyourbook #bookwormsoflemon8 #books 📚 #acotar #booksforlife📖
stormy.brownn

stormy.brownn

191 likes

how I annotate my books
Here are some places you can get your annotate supplies: -amazon -michaels -hobby lobby #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm #book #booktok #bookaesthetic #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #bookrecs
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

10.6K likes

Horror Books I’m Kind of Scared to Read 😬
As it is getting closer to Halloween and all things spooky 👻, I figured it is time to pull out some of the horror books on my TBR that I have been putting off reading (mainly because I am a scaredy cat still when it comes to horror) 😓 👻Midnight Rooms by Donyae Coles - Set in a foreboding Gothic
Lauren 📚📖

Lauren 📚📖

95 likes

Romance books I’m scared to read 📚😅
I LOVE reading romance books but here are five that I’m too intimidated to read! I’ve had each of these books for so long and I do plan to read them eventually, but I keep pushing them back on my TBR! There’s something about starting a new long series that is always intimidating for me, and I j
Bethany Taylor

Bethany Taylor

510 likes

🌷Books I’m scared to start🌷
I might need some convincing that’s all🤭👀 #books 🫶🏼 #reading 📖 #booktok #bookstagram #bookrecs
Jacey Coleman🤎

Jacey Coleman🤎

238 likes

THIS BOOK MADE ME SOB 😭
When I picked up this book, I honestly expected to be bored and not really enjoy it too much. I did not expect to be bawling my eyes out for hours after finishing it 🥲 BOOK TITLE: Bright Side by Kim Holden I didn’t read the synopsis before going into this book & I’m lowkey glad I didn’t. I
KENNEDY ♡

KENNEDY ♡

723 likes

I HAVE TO DNF THIS BOOK! TOO MUCH 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
📚👀 The book in question : Court Of The Vampire Queen Honestly, I love the book, great story. Good smut it’s just toooo much. 🥵Every chapter is SMUT. Every few pages is SMUT and the conversation is leading to more smut!!🌶️🌶️🔥🔥🔥 I just want more story plot, it’s actually interesting and once i
Valentina📚🌸💕

Valentina📚🌸💕

1784 likes

Books I am SCARED to Read!
We all have those books that while they sound amazing… they are daunting and therefore we put them off. Here is my list of books that I need a little push before I read! 1. If We Were Villains – M.L. Rio I must admit, the main reason I am scared to read this is twofold: it is character driven a
emma privitera

emma privitera

1631 likes

Bluford series (23 Book Series )
Do you all remember these books? I started reading them in high school, and my teacher used to make us read them out loud. I started reading them in high school. However, I didn't get to read all of them because I didn't know the series was still happening. Her last book came out in 2020, a
Lia32pride2.0🌟🍋

Lia32pride2.0🌟🍋

1120 likes

Pick a Color, Get a Book!
Choose one of the colors then scroll to get your book! Comment which book you got ☺️ (I’ve seen several people do this so credit to whoever came up with it!) * * * * #lemon8bookclub #books #bookaesthetic #bookwormsoflemon8 #lemon8bookchallenge #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendati
Hannah 🧡

Hannah 🧡

5480 likes

SPICY BOOKS! 📚
these books are SPICY!! twisted love twisted games twisted lies things i meant to say american queen american king american prince promises and pomegranates a million kisses in your lifetime fourth wing ACOTAR series the ritual haunting adeline hunting adeline icebreaker preist
blimmi 🍂🤎📚

blimmi 🍂🤎📚

3814 likes

Books scared Stephen King…
These aren’t just scary stories—they’re nightmare fuel that left even Stephen King, Gillian Flynn, and George R.R. Martin seriously shaken. If you're hunting for horror books that are actually terrifying, add these spine-chilling reads to your TBR. Perfect for fans of psychological horror, book
Great Thriller Reads

Great Thriller Reads

210 likes

Books I love that you won’t find on booktok
If you want to get out of the Colleen Hoover rabbit hole here are some great books to venture out of mainstream authors. I love reading from booktok too, but if you are looking for something different here’s some recs 🫶🏾 #books #recommendations #booktok #shareyourthoughts #reading #he
LOVIE ROBINSON

LOVIE ROBINSON

1598 likes

convince me to read these books 🫶
i want to read these series so bad and i truly can’t wait, but at the same time i am so scared and have been putting them off for awhile! please help convince me to finally read them 🥹 #books 🫶🏼 #bookseries #bookrecs #tbrlist #lemon8bookclub
brittany 📚☁️✨

brittany 📚☁️✨

97 likes

books i’m scared to read
more books i can’t bring myself to read.. lmk your thoughts or if you’ve read any of these 👀 ——— #bookrecommendations #booksoflemon8 #bookwormsoflemon8 #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge
mads

mads

278 likes

Books I'm scared to read: Part one:
- If He Had Been With Me series by Laura Nowlin: I heard mix reviews on this one. Some people said it was really good but sad while others said it was terrible. So I really have high expectations for this one. - Lock Every Door/Survive The Night by Riley Sager: I've been meaning to read his
Paisley Hanson💙❤️🖤

Paisley Hanson💙❤️🖤

184 likes

Am I high, or did the author… (fever dream books)
Hold up, did this book just mess with my head? Hey there, fellow bookworms! Ever finished a book and just stared at the wall, blinking in confusion, wondering if you hallucinated the whole thing? Yeah, me too. Those are the glorious (or maybe terrifying?) fever dream books. You know the ones -
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

1988 likes

Spooky Books Recs Not Trending on BookTok
It’s still spooky season, so more spooky book recs! I went a little haywire with this one with some non traditional spooky books. I get so tired of seeing the same books recommended over and over again. So here’s some weird but still scary books for you to check out! If you can’t read t
quinnireadssome

quinnireadssome

279 likes

Dark romance books📚
Books with pretty pages is an automatic buy! #sprayededges #darkromancebooks #booklover #darkromancebookscenes #lemon8bookclub
Destiny|Books📚

Destiny|Books📚

199 likes

Books that scared their authors
These chilling books even scares the authors who wrote them. #scarybooks #thrillerbooks #darkbookclub #darkbooks #booktok
ThrillerBookSnob

ThrillerBookSnob

78 likes

BOOKS I’M SCARED OF.
Ok I’m terrified of these books lowkey!! Kind of embarrassed to admit it 😄🫣✌️ Tender is the flesh was the scariest book I read last year. But I loved the writing and the characters were really interesting. I just saw another book by this author, should I read it or will I be terrified lol
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

143 likes

pick one to get a book
what book did you get/have you read it? #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #readingnook #readingaesthetic #bookstagram #bookrecs #bookclub #bookish #readwithlemon8 #booksoflemon8 @Lemon8 BookClub
mads

mads

724 likes

Books that scared me good
These three scary books gave me goosebumps—in a wonderful way! If you like dark thriller books, serial killer murder mysteries, and outright creepy horror stories, add these to your TBR list of must-reads! #scarybooks #thrillerbookrecommendations #lemon8bookcommunity #booksoflemon8 #boo
Kara Reads Thrillers

Kara Reads Thrillers

112 likes

Books I am scared to read
These are some popular books I have been hesitant to start! Do you have any? #lemon8diarychallenge #books 🫶🏼 #reading📖 #books #Lemon8 #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge
Tara🖤

Tara🖤

90 likes

BOOKS TO MAKE YOU SEEM INTELLIGENT IN PUBLIC PT. 2
You guys loveddddd my first version of this - so here’s another one! 🥂🤩 THE DEFINING DECADE BY MEG JAY, PhD • This was a very insightful read and left me feeling super inspired to make the most of my 20s. My only critique was at some points, it felt the author was pushing some narratives a bit
KENNEDY ♡

KENNEDY ♡

774 likes

See more