buy or bye: ELF edition

2025/7/31 Edited to

... Read moreELF Cosmetics is well-known for offering budget-friendly makeup products that often rival high-end brands in quality. In this edition of Buy or Bye, several ELF products have been reviewed to provide consumers with an informed perspective on what’s worth purchasing. Among the highly recommended items is the ELF Lash-Ingrol Curling Mascara, praised for its ability to add volume without clumping, a key concern for mascara users seeking fuller lashes without heavy residue. This product has received positive feedback for delivering the desired volume effect while maintaining a smooth finish. Another standout is the ELF So Good & Affordable Lip product in Neutral Brown, which offers an instant natural look at a wallet-friendly price. This lip color fits well within everyday makeup routines for those seeking affordable yet effective lip options. However, not all ELF products performed well for all skin types. The ELF Power Grip Primer has been labeled a 'bye' due to patchiness, particularly for individuals with normal to dry skin, suggesting it might be better suited for other skin types or avoided if you suffer from dryness. Similarly, the Halo Glow Liquid Filter caused breakouts for some users, indicating that it may contain ingredients that do not agree with sensitive or acne-prone skin. For setting makeup, the ELF Stay All Night Setting Mist has been highly praised for its long-lasting hold, reportedly keeping makeup in place for up to 16 hours. This product is ideal for those who require durable makeup wear throughout the day or night. Finally, the ELF Camo CC Cream with Vitamin B5, Tremella Mushroom, and Hyaluronic Acid offers hydration but has mixed reviews regarding its finish, with some describing it as patchy and others appreciating its moisturizing properties. This highlights the importance of considering personal skin needs when selecting cosmetic products. Overall, ELF remains a leading affordable brand, blending quality with budget-conscious options. This review helps consumers navigate ELF’s offerings by highlighting both the hits and misses, so buyers can make choices tailored to their skin type and makeup preferences.

107 comments

Adriana Rivera's images
Adriana Rivera

Let's be mindful that she stated that she is NORMAL TO DRY SKIN! I am normal to oily and sensitive skin. What didnt work for her, worked wonders on my type of skin and all of the products listed as well. I guess normal to oily skin has perks, but also patch test it!

See more(3)
Indiacoers's images
Indiacoers

I love @elfcosmetics they have the greatest products! And at a nice price!

See more comments

Related posts

Buy ✅ or BYE❌ Elf makeup edition
You know I love me some elf so that means I have a lot of elf products some that I’ve restocked and obviously some that I haven’t but the ones I currently have on hand. I will definitely give y’all what I recommend Everyone knows that elf is either still in the middle of their branding or they’r
Nyxslyfe🪷

Nyxslyfe🪷

12.7K likes

BUY or BYE - E.L.F Edition
I love Elf but some products didn’t really work for me! Daily Song: ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5: Today’s song is “The 30th” by Billie Eilish. This song is about a car accident that someone close to Billie got into. It hits hard. Did you know that Billie Eilish is releasing her new album “Hit Me Har
n

n

1259 likes

Buy ✅ or bye❌ elf makeup edition
I have always used @elfcosmetics products. Most of them are staples in my collection and they are extremely affordable!!! To be honest with you, elf does it better than most luxury brands. They are a perfect company for you to learn with because it is so easy to use! Some products are not my
Abbie Stricklen

Abbie Stricklen

2305 likes

Buy or Bye!
Products I would or would not repurchase! ❤️ And I made this post with my fav ever @Kennedy Kaemmer !! #embracevulnerability #Lemon8Diary #buythisnotthat #buyorbye #unfiltered #beautyfinds #lemon8creator #fyp #healthylifestyle2024 #LoveYourself
Ella

Ella

12.3K likes

Buy or ByeElf edition!
Buy or Bye! Elf edition! Elf lip oil- Buy! I love this product and it’s really cute! Elf mascara- Bye! It’s sooo clumpy and the packaging gets messy way too easily! Elf liquid eyeshadow- Bye!! Too flaky and it gets into my eyes. It’s only really good for your inner corners Elf setting spray-
Kileyslays

Kileyslays

322 likes

Buy ✅ or Bye ❌e.l.f. edition
Hi everyone!!! Today I'm reviewing everything i have from e.l.f. cosmetics!!! Here's a little review of all the products and their prices! 💌 Brand: e.l.f. elf setting powder: I have this in the pink shade and love it! works super well and does not look chalky 💵 Price: $8.00 ⭐️Overall r
Cordelia

Cordelia

1504 likes

Buy or bye E.L.F edition
@elfcosmetics 💌 Brand:ELF⭐️Overall rating: /9: 4/9 #elf👄stain #elf cosmetic #both from elf 😘 #elfbrand
lucylemon8

lucylemon8

73 likes

Buy ✅ or Bye 👋-makeup edition
-First is the pink elf power grip primer, definitely a Buy ✅ gives you a tacky feel so your makeup can last all day ! -Second is the Maybelline master prime primer, which is a Bye 👋, it left my skin feeling too dry and caused my makeup to be patchy 👎 - Third was the L’Oréal infallible founda
Jadah <3

Jadah <3

1666 likes

Buy or bye: Elf skincare ✨
Want to achieve flawless skin without breaking the bank? Look no further! This affordable e.l.f skincare routine is perfect for all skin types and will leave your skin looking and feeling amazing. * Pro tip: shop these products during the Amazon prime day sales to save BIG Have you tried a
Queen Misfitx3

Queen Misfitx3

1083 likes

#BUYORBYE CRÈME SHOP EDITION💗
💌 Brand: The Crème Shop Purchased from: Marshalls, ULTA, CVS, Thecrèmeshop.com • • • I love the crème shop so muchhhh😍🫶🏻 • • • if you’re interested in a shade lmk please!! i didn’t want to put them all in the pictures because it would look messy🥲 • • • #cremeshop #thecremeshop #S
♡

7562 likes

Buy or BYE ??? Body wash edition 🫧🧼
Hey girlies 💖 here are some of the body washes I’d BUY OR BYE! I’ve personally used all the products show & left my review. I am a feen for body washes and would love to know your favorites! Comment below if you’ve used anything I’ve listed 🫶🏼🩷 #musthavebodyproducts #buyorbye #lemon8
Madison ✨

Madison ✨

7345 likes

Buy or Bye! Elf edition 💋💄
I love Elf products not only because they are affordable, but because they are great quality. If you can’t afford something I bet Elf has made a dupe of it, no questions asked. Thank you Elf for holding it down! These are the products I have bought from them and have used. Some are a hit or miss an
Mariam

Mariam

772 likes

Buy Or Bye Elf Edition
What are your fav products from elf?! And what products are you saying bye to from elf? Overall I think they’re a great brand especially for the price! #buyorbye #elf products #elfmagic #elfhallglow #beauty #beautyfinds #elffavorites #makeup #skincare #summer
ramona <3

ramona <3

13 likes

✨️BUY OR BYE: ELF COSMETICS✨️
✅️ buy: elf skin holy hydration eye cream ⭐️ star rating: 5/5 stars 🤩 💸 price: $10 ✨️ pros: very hydrating & light weight! works amazingly for only being $10! it has hyaluronic acid + peptides. dries down nicely. ✅️ buy: elf skin holy hydration face cream with spf 30 ⭐️ star rating: 4/5
yariibabyy

yariibabyy

1148 likes

ELF buy or bye
My elf buys or byes ! #elf #makeuptips #elf power grip primer #elfmakeup #elf✨
MJVC

MJVC

926 likes

BUY or BYE
Buy or Bye elf edition
Alexis

Alexis

833 likes

Buy or bye - e.l.f edition
I honestly love elf makeup. Most of what I use on a daily basis is from them, and it never fails me. The price is so good for what you get and is my holy grail makeup brand! #buyorbye #elffavorites #elf #makeup #Lemon8Diary #elfmakeup #buy staple pieces #makeuprecommendations #m
gabriella 🦋💌

gabriella 🦋💌

16 likes

BUY OR BYE!✨
I love the liquid blushes!😍 My favorite beauty products of the year 🔥Purchased from:Ulta Beauty #makeup #tips #makeupproducts #review #beautyproductreview
MERII🤍

MERII🤍

4815 likes

buy or bye in ELF
all my faves and least faves and my opinion #elf #HelloLemon8 #Lemon8Diary #buyorbye #fypシ
reta

reta

146 likes

BUY OY BYE?! MAKEUP EDITION 💗
Buy or bye coming from an oily skin girly who has sensitive and textured skin. Top 10 must haves - Dior foundation - Milani conceal + perfect - Smashbox photo finish control - Elf liquid blush - Charlotte Tilbury pressed powder - Rare beauty bronzer stick - Huda beauty setting powde
noemerzzz

noemerzzz

1065 likes

Buy or bye elf edition!!!
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge 👍Pros : most of these are such great products elf is cruelty free and is very cheap 🤔Cons: I don’t like elf’s power grip primer and the lip stains makes your lips very dry Overall these products are so worth getting and you will be satisfied when you buy them and t
Molly Dudzinski

Molly Dudzinski

38 likes

Buy or bye - e.l.f edition 👍👋
Part one of my Buy or Bye elf makeup edition *all my opinion* 🩷First is the liquid camo blush which is definitely a BUY👍it’s very pigmented, and a little goes a long way. Blends easily and stays pretty. 🩷Second the elf camo hydrating cc cream. BYE 👋👎 I personally did not like this it seep
Cynthia

Cynthia

146 likes

Buy or bye?? Elf edition
Elf jelly pop glow stick: 8/10 👍gives a realy good looking cute glow on Camera and in person 👎leaves a really sticky finish Elf putty blush:2/10 👎To thick for my tast elf lip oil:10/10 👍amazing quality for a very low price Elf setting powder:8/10 👍never had any issues with this formula
Caroline Boulay

Caroline Boulay

12 likes

Buy or bye
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge #oilyskin #oilyskincare #larocheposay #CeraVe #elfholyhydration #spalife #spalife pearl serum #naturium ALL MY PRICES ARE FROM TARGET SOME ARE MINIS‼️ 🛍Brand: CeraVe Item: hydrating foaming oil cleanser 💰Price:$12.39 👍Pros:oily skin approved
Jessica.Shawnte

Jessica.Shawnte

376 likes

🎀Buy or Bye!❤️
#lemon8diarychallenge #makeup #buyorbye
olivaaa💕

olivaaa💕

110 likes

Buy or Bye Elf Edition
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge #lemon8contest #fypシ #elf #trend #viral #letschat I recently went to Ulta and decided to try some products from Elf! Elf Halo Glow: BUY -beautiful glow -dupe for Charlotte Tilbury -nice applicator -does leak a lot :( Elf Camo Liquid Blush: BUY (t
Olivia

Olivia

11 likes

Buy or Bye Elf Edition
I have tried many elf products but to be honest some of them are just not worth the hype. Elf Squeeze me lip balm: i like it and use it everyday. I have recommended and i will continue to. I notice some of them aren’t full but when you are in the store you can just shine your flash and make sur
Sophiab

Sophiab

7 likes

BUY OR BYE DRUGSTORE MAKEUP EDITION
These are just my opinions. I have tried so many different drug store products and the buy ones are my daily users. I also rely on them for an accurate product review! For reference I am a very oily girl in the T zone and dry everywhere else. I cannot stand when my makeup separates so these are my
Abbie Stricklen

Abbie Stricklen

1874 likes

BUYorBYEelf edition
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge my first post :) this is just my opinion!! there are mostly 'byes' because some of my favorite products got discontinued. 😭 also disclaimer it was only the first couple of times that I used the blue elf primer that I got an allergic reaction to it. I kep
Brinley Rich

Brinley Rich

4 likes

BUY OR BYE ✨💵
Should you spend your money on these products? Let’s break it down product by product Item: e.l.f. JELLYPOP DEW PRIMER I don’t know how I did my makeup without this. Makes my makeup go on so smoothly, the only bad thing about this product is that it’s limited edition. It has a light watermelon
Darrah🎀✨

Darrah🎀✨

2043 likes

Bye or buy skincare edition!
#summer👙 🪸🌅 #riley
Lemon8er

Lemon8er

536 likes

buy or bye elf edition
BrattyBray7

BrattyBray7

9 likes

buy or bye elf edition
#makeuprecommendations #buyorbye
Abbie grace

Abbie grace

13 likes

Buy or bye
⭐️Summer Fridays Overall rating: 7/10 ⭐️Laneige Overall rating: 5/10 ⭐️Fenty gloss Overall rating: 100/10😍😍 ⭐️Nyx oil Overall rating: 7/10 ⭐️ Elf Overall rating: 9/10😍😍😍 ⭐️Tarte Overall rating: 8/10 😍😍😍 #lipgloss👄💄🦻🏼 #need to have lip options #summerbod #elf lip #healthylifestyle20
Ari 𖣂︎🦇

Ari 𖣂︎🦇

2389 likes

Bye or Buy (elf edition) 💄
These are the things shown in the post: -cream & powder face brush $8.00 -halo glow contour wand (light/medium) $9.00 -halo glow liquid filter (shade 1) $14.00 -poreless putty face primer $10.00 -halo glow highlight wand (champagne campaign) $9.00 -camo liquid blush (coral crush) $7.00
Jazlyn 🎀

Jazlyn 🎀

214 likes

BUY OR BYE?! makeup edition🥰👋🏼
this is all based on my personal opinion, and every product works differently for everyone!!🩷🩷 #buyorbye #makeup #beautyfinds #ViralBeauty #viralmakeup #Lemon8
myra

myra

1096 likes

Buy or bye Elf edition!
This is from my personal experience, some of you guys may have a different experience with these so don’t get mad! Feel free to share your opinions in the comments! 🫶 #buyorbye #buy #bye #elf #makeup #fyp #foryou #fypage
Ameliaaa

Ameliaaa

5 likes

BUY or BYE
buy or bye 🍋 honest review of drugstore makeup products ❤️ #drugtoremakeup #ratebeauty #beautyfinds #byeorbuy #Lemon8 #lemon8challenge #BuyOrBye #ByeOrBuy makeup challenge Maybelinne Fit Me Powder : buy very affordable and turns oily to matte Maybelline Superstay Viynl Lip
olivia

olivia

853 likes

buy or bye: elf edition
#lemon8diarychallenge here are my buy or byes! i LOVE elf, so i decided to do an elf version! ✅ elf liquid blush: this is a total buy! the pigment is amazing and its super easy to blend out with a blush! if you like a strong tint, this is DEF a good choice. ❌ elf lip stain: this one is
mars

mars

80 likes

Buy or bye - e.l.f edition
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge #honestbeautyreview #elf #elf power grip primer #makeup elf MAKEUP Product review 😍💄 ✨These are products I have used before and recently repurchased. I wanted to share with you guys my honest review. 💄list: elf power grip primer. elf por
Classy

Classy

10 likes

Ulta beauty buy or bye!
What’s actually worth your money.. - The DRUNK ELEPHANT drops $38…BYEEE - Key largo TARTE drops $35 still cheaper and work amazing.. BUYYY -ELF bronzing drops $12 can’t beat that price and they work great! 🙌 BUYY -LAURA MERCIER tinted moisturizer $54.. not worth the money and it clogs your p
Grace

Grace

4080 likes

✨Buy or Bye elf edition ✨🍋
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge #fyp #elf #bueaty #elf halo glow💋 Please help me get likes for the challange just comment and I'll like your Buy or Bye post ❤️❤️ Buy: elf halo glow 💵 Price: $ 15 ⭐️Overall rating:9 /10 👍Pros : Super glowy love the packaging 🤔Cons: It sometimes m
Alexiss0205🌺🥥

Alexiss0205🌺🥥

30 likes

BUY or BYE Beauty Edition
✅ BUY: O/S setting spray 🌟:Rating: 10/10 💸:Price: $27. ✨pros: flawless makeup all day ! Definitely recommend for this cali heat ! Sweat and waterproof . ❌ BYE : Elf setting spray 🌟Rating: 7/10 💸Price: $ 10 👀 Cons: oily look after a couples hours on , makeup doesn’t last as good as the O
Marianaaa ♡

Marianaaa ♡

652 likes

Buy or bye - e.l.f edition
I love e.l.f. so if you want to try e.l.f. Here is what I recommend. #elfbest
aubrey2442

aubrey2442

1 like

DETAILED BYE or BUY
I love all my elf products and ive bought a lot so i have to be completely honest here. #elf #Lippies #buyorbye #makeup #lemon8beauty
tbhkelsey

tbhkelsey

209 likes

Buy or bye - e.l.f edition
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge #elf #unfiltered 16 hr camo concealer shade: light ivory rating: 10/10 my favorite concealer it blends in really well and it’s such a good concealer for 7 dollars camo liquid blush shade: coral crush rating: 3/10 it’s hard to blend out and very pig
zera wolfe

zera wolfe

3 likes

Buy or bye elf edition like for pt 2🫶🏻
Pls like and follow #elf products #elfglow #Lemon8 #lemon8challenge #lemon8beauty #lemon8creator #Lemon8Box #buyorbye #buyorbyemakeup #buyorbyelf
Addy_kate22

Addy_kate22

38 likes

#BUYORBYE ELF EDITION!!!💗💗
💌 Brand: ELF Purchased from: ULTA, ELF app • • • trust me on those lip balms!!!😍 if you want to know a shade lmk pls!!!😅💗 • • • #elfsqueezelipbalm #elflipbalm #elf cosmetics lip balm #Lemon8Diary #beautyfinds #ulta #makeup #elf #elfblush #buyorbye
♡

32 likes

Bye or buy (elf edition)🌸🍋🫶
🩷first is the elf squeeze lip balm. I think it is definitely a buy for me because it is very hydrating and looks super good on the lips. 🩷second is the elf contour wand.it is pretty good so I would say it’s a buy because it has a really good price and verity of colors 🩷third is the elf blush wan
Ainsley🌴🐚🐢🦥

Ainsley🌴🐚🐢🦥

6 likes

HONEST Mascara Buy or Bye 💌
Products 🥥🌵 Cover Girl Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara 🥥 ↣ gives length, stays curled ☆ BUY ∘ $ 13 E.L.F. Big Mood Waterproof Mascara 🌵 ↣ so affordable, doesn’t run for the most part in water! ☆ BUY ∘ $ 8 Babe Lash Volumizing Mascara 🥥 ↣ doesn’t do anything for my lashes, no volume
Nat🎀

Nat🎀

3746 likes

Buy or bye - e.l.f edition pt.2 👍👋
Part two of my Buy or Bye elf makeup edition *all my opinion* 🩷First is the elf instant lift waterproof eyebrow pencil which is definitely a BUY👍it’s very pigmented, and has a spoolie on one side, plus it’s waterproof! 🩷Second the elf power grip primer BUY👍 I personally did like how it hol
Cynthia

Cynthia

50 likes

Buy👍 or Bye👎 (makeup edition)
⭐️ Elf Matte Camp Concealer / Overall rating: 0/10 I personally do not like this concealer because it dries too fast, it is patchy and it creases. I got beef with this concealer, it is a no for me! Price: $7.00 ⭐️Born This Way Concealer / Overall rating: 100/10 I love this concealer! It is t
Vale Mejia 🎀

Vale Mejia 🎀

531 likes

Buy or Bye! Elf makeup edition
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge #beauty #elf products 💌 Brand: Elf Cosmetics I would definitely recommend to buy the lip oils they’re so good and with a good price. 🌸The elf primers are good but I would just recommend the Power grip primer I think that a really good one. My least favorite
Anny🌸

Anny🌸

13 likes

Buy or Bye Elf Makeup Edition!! 🌸🌸
Elf Powder Blush- soooo pigmented, easily blend-able! Elf Camo Blush- pigmented AF, dries really quickly, hard to blend Elf Halo glow setting powder- my ride or die setting powder, blurs instantly Elf powder puff- really I just prefer something softer Elf camo hydrating concealer- patchy, rea
joseydenae05

joseydenae05

30 likes

buy 🛍️ or bye 👋 | rating lippies 💋
Honestly rating & reviewing trending lip products💋 I will always be honest when I’m sharing my opinion especially when it comes to the “trendy” stuff. I never want someone to spend money on something that isn’t worth it!! I hate reading reviews & realizing the product is nothing like ppl
skylar

skylar

216 likes

Buy or bye. ELF edition
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge ✅power grip primer 👍Pros: holds onto makeup well Stands up against the southern heat 🤔Cons: Noneeee ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5 ✅hydrating camo concealer 👍Pros: Really high coverage Nice shade range Nice big applicator 🤔Cons: Clings onto dry skin at time
Phoenix

Phoenix

217 likes

Buy or bye - e.l.f edition 💋
What are YOUR go-to elf products? Do any of these BYE products work for you? Comment ⬇️ #elf #elffavorites #makeup bag #makeupforbeginner #makeuptutorial #naturalmakeup #buyorbye #Lemon8 #Lemon8Diary #lemon8creator
Alexis Sparks

Alexis Sparks

34 likes

See more