BUY OR BYE?! makeup edition🥰👋🏼

2024/7/17 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so we all love a good drugstore beauty haul, right? It's like a treasure hunt finding those hidden gems that perform just as well, if not better, than their high-end counterparts. While I've shared my thoughts on a variety of makeup products, today I really want to dive deep into one of my absolute obsessions: lip gloss and lip balm, especially what you can snag at places like CVS! Seriously, the lip aisle at CVS is a wonderland. I often hear people say they can't find good quality lip gloss without spending a fortune, but let me tell you, that's just not true! I've had some incredible finds that prove you don't need to splurge for a perfect pout. Remember that amazing "lip butter balm" I raved about? The one that's incredibly creamy and blends so effortlessly? That's exactly the kind of quality I'm always on the lookout for, and guess what? Drugstores like CVS are packed with similar, wallet-friendly options. Now, on the flip side, I've also had experiences with some "lipsticks" that, despite their fancy packaging or higher price tag, just didn't deliver. I’m talking about those moments where you spend a bit more, hoping for something revolutionary, and it turns out to be just… okay. For me, if a product (especially a lipstick or gloss) isn't giving me that wow factor, or if it feels too expensive for what it offers, it's a definite 'Bye.' Why invest heavily when there are so many fantastic, affordable solutions available right at your local CVS? When I'm browsing for lip gloss at CVS, I have a few go-to criteria. First, shine is key! I love a high-gloss finish that makes my lips look plump and juicy. But equally important is the texture – nobody wants a sticky mess! I've discovered some amazing non-sticky formulas that give you that glass-like finish without the tackiness. Brands like NYX, Maybelline, and E.l.f. consistently impress me with their gloss formulations. Their plumping glosses often rival more expensive brands, giving that tingle and volume without any discomfort. Hydration is another big factor for me. My lips tend to get dry, so I always look for ingredients like hyaluronic acid, shea butter, or nourishing oils in my lip glosses and balms. There are so many tinted balms at CVS that offer a lovely wash of color along with serious hydration. They're perfect for a quick, natural look or layering under a gloss for extra dimension. It's all about finding that balance between color, shine, and comfort. So, my personal 'Buy or Bye' rule for CVS lip glosses and balms? If it's hydrating, gives a beautiful shine without being sticky, offers a good range of shades, and doesn't break the bank, it's a huge BUY! If it's too sticky, doesn't last, or simply doesn't live up to its claims (especially if it's on the pricier side for a drugstore item), then it's a swift BYE. Happy gloss hunting at CVS, everyone – you might just find your new favorite!

24 comments

Marykate Hull's images
Marykate Hull

I’ve heard you can use the middle part of the ysl lip oil bottle as a ring

Lucy's images
Lucy

I love the elf putty bronzer. I always put a spray of setting spray in the container before J use it and it works so much better

See more comments

Related posts

A clear container filled with various elf cosmetics products, including concealers, lip balms, primers, and powders, with 'Buy or BYEE Elf edition' text overlay.
Four elf Hydrating Camo Concealers with green checkmarks and positive feedback, alongside three elf 16HR Camo Concealers with red X marks and negative feedback, on a fluffy surface.
A four-panel image showing elf Hydrating Core Lip Shine (BYE), elf Glow Reviver Lip Oil (Buy), elf Squeeze Me Lip Balms (Buy), and elf Ride or Die Lip Balm (BYE).
Buy ✅ or BYE❌ Elf makeup edition
You know I love me some elf so that means I have a lot of elf products some that I’ve restocked and obviously some that I haven’t but the ones I currently have on hand. I will definitely give y’all what I recommend Everyone knows that elf is either still in the middle of their branding or they’r
Nyxslyfe🪷

Nyxslyfe🪷

12.8K likes

A hand holds three makeup pencils in a store aisle, with text overlay "Buy or bye Walmart Edition" and decorative flames, butterflies, and rainbow hearts.
A hand holds a white and yellow box for a sunscreen and makeup primer, rated as a 'BUY' for being unnoticeable, working well under makeup, giving a glow, and evening out skin.
A hand holds a light blue box for an eye cream, rated as a 'BYE' because it does nothing and a cheaper alternative is suggested as better.
BUY OR BYE DRUGSTORE MAKEUP EDITION
These are just my opinions. I have tried so many different drug store products and the buy ones are my daily users. I also rely on them for an accurate product review! For reference I am a very oily girl in the T zone and dry everywhere else. I cannot stand when my makeup separates so these are my
Abbie Stricklen

Abbie Stricklen

1877 likes

A flat lay of various cosmetic products, including primers, concealers, blushes, highlighters, and lip products, with the text "BUY OR BYE? MAKE UP EDITION" overlaid, indicating a review.
A vertical display of three cosmetic products from the same brand: a green face primer marked "BYE," a camo concealer marked "BUY," and a halo glow blush wand marked "BUY," with reasons for each rating.
A display of two cosmetic products from the same brand: a baked blush marked "BUY" and a precision brow pencil marked "BUY," accompanied by positive reviews for both.
Buy or Bye? (make up edition)
These are the products that I bought for daily use. But some of them are bye for me. First would be the elf primer neutralizing green, i tried this to reduce my redness before putting make up but i don't really like the texture of the result in my skin everytime i'm using this. While el
Maddie Urban

Maddie Urban

3 likes

The image displays a title overlaying a patch of dandelions and dry grass. The text reads 'Buy or Bye Makeup edition Prices and why', indicating a review of makeup products.
A tube of matte finish concealer is held, labeled as a 'Bye' product. The accompanying text indicates it creases and appears darker than expected.
A dual-ended shaping stick is shown, labeled as a 'Buy' product. The text describes it as affordable, creamy, and easy to blend.
Buy or Bye makeup edition
#BuyorBye #lemon8challenge Bye - e.l.f Camo Concealer: $7.00 Although the elf camo concealer is somewhat an affordable price for me it creases and looks darker than it looks in the bottle. NYX wonder stick: Buy - NYX Wonder Stick: $13.99 The nyx wonder stick is the perfect affordable co
Emily Dean

Emily Dean

4 likes

A collection of various perfume bottles displayed on shelves, with a pink bow graphic and the text overlay "BUY or BYE perfume edition" in pink and yellow bubble letters.
A black high-heel shaped perfume bottle and its box, labeled "Good Girl Parfum." Text highlights its nice design, long-lasting nature, and creamy coffee scents.
A pink, triangular perfume bottle with a black cap, labeled "PRADA Paradoxe," next to its pink box. Text describes it as having a mature, lighter fruity scent, mostly jasmine.
Buy or Bye Perfume Edition
🤩 Buy: Good Girl Parfum 🌟 Rating: 9/10 💸 Price: $60 ✨ Pros: Nice design, Lasts all day, Has more creamy and coffee scents 👀 Bye: PRADA Paradoxe 🌟 Rating: 3/10 💸: Price: $98 🚫 Cons: Mature scent, Lighter fruity scent, Mostly smells like jasmine 🤩 Buy: DOLCE & GABBANA L’Imperatrice
lina

lina

781 likes

Buy or Bye (makeup edition)
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge 💌 Brand: Elf Hydrating Camo concealer ⭐️Overall rating:10/10 - Gives me very good coverage and is very easy to blend. 💌 Brand: Elf Halo Glow Contour ⭐️Overall rating: 10/10 - easy to blend , not patchy , and gives me a very chiseled look. 💌 Brand:
Jas🎀

Jas🎀

2 likes

Buy or Bye Viral Eye Cream Edition 🥑🪩
Products: Pacifica Glow Baby Eye Bright Cream 🎀 ♡ bye ♡ $16 Glow Recipe Avocado Fine Line Eye Cream 🥑 ♡ buy ♡ $42 BYOMA De-Puff and Brightening Eye Gel 🌷 ♡ buy ♡ $13 CeraVe Under Eye Cream Repair for Dark Circles and Puffiness 🐢 ♡ buy ♡ $15 RoC Multi Correxion Revive and G
Nat🎀

Nat🎀

1525 likes

Buy ✅ or bye❌ elf makeup edition
I have always used @elfcosmetics products. Most of them are staples in my collection and they are extremely affordable!!! To be honest with you, elf does it better than most luxury brands. They are a perfect company for you to learn with because it is so easy to use! Some products are not my
Abbie Stricklen

Abbie Stricklen

2320 likes

Buy or Bye Eyebrows Edition ✨
BUY ✨ 🛍Brand: NYX 💰Price: Each item is under $15.00 👍Pros: Affordable, works just as great if not better, and did I mention more affordable 😉 ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5 BUY ✌🏻 🛍Brand: Anastasia Beverly Hills 💰Price: Their main brow products cost well over $20.00 a piece! 🤔Cons: Way too exp
Autumn Turner

Autumn Turner

1770 likes

Buy or Bye? (make up edition)
These are the products that I bought for daily use. But some of them are bye for me. 👇🏼 First would be the elf primer neutralizing green, i tried this to reduce my redness before putting make up but i don't really like the texture of the result in my skin everytime i'm using this. While
Ira Diocson

Ira Diocson

437 likes

A store aisle displaying various beauty products, with the text overlay "ELF buy or bye" in the center, indicating a review of ELF products.
A hand holds an ELF Lash 'N Roll Mascara in its packaging, with text indicating it's a "Buy!!" because it "DOESN'T CLUMP TOGETHER & GIVES THAT VOLUME YOU WANT!".
A hand holds an ELF Instant Lift Brow Pencil in its packaging, with text indicating it's a "Buy!" because it's "SO GOOD & AFFORDABLE".
buy or bye: ELF edition
Here’s my buy or bye ELF edition! One of my favorite affordable brands 💞 #elfmakeup #buyorbye #lemon8beauty #lemon8beautyreviews #lemon8beautycrew @Lemon8 Beauty
dani :)

dani :)

4827 likes

Buy or Bye makeup edition
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge Hers a few of my makeup faves (and not so faves) Bye-Mac Macstack This mascara was amazing at first but I had an allergic reaction and so did a few of my friends that tried it out☹️ It also dried out super fast 3/10 Buy- L’Oreal Panorama This is my new holy g
Spacebunz

Spacebunz

3 likes

BUY OR BYE: Shampoo Edition 🧴
Navigating the shampoo aisle can be a total obstacle, right? 🤯 So many choices, so many ingredients you can't pronounce! 😵‍💫 I've put together a list of shampoos I'd totally recommend and some you might wanna skip. 🤔 I'm breaking down the good, the bad, and the potentially damag
Vanessa |Home & Gardening|

Vanessa |Home & Gardening|

792 likes

BUY OY BYE?! MAKEUP EDITION 💗
Buy or bye coming from an oily skin girly who has sensitive and textured skin. Top 10 must haves - Dior foundation - Milani conceal + perfect - Smashbox photo finish control - Elf liquid blush - Charlotte Tilbury pressed powder - Rare beauty bronzer stick - Huda beauty setting powde
noemerzzz

noemerzzz

1062 likes

BUY or BYE??? (Makeup Edition)
#buy or bye #makeupproducts #makeup
Allison

Allison

3 likes

A collection of various hair care products, including creams, serums, and a scalp massager, arranged on a concrete surface. The text overlay reads 'BUY or BYE Hair edition', indicating a review of these items.
A hand holds a light blue jar of a whipped curl cream. The text 'BUY' is prominently displayed, along with bullet points highlighting its frizz-reducing, moisturizing, and pleasant scent properties, noting its clean ingredients.
A hand holds a light green scalp massager with soft spikes. The text 'BUY' is shown, with bullet points describing its ability to exfoliate the scalp, stimulate hair follicles for growth, and aid product absorption.
BUY or BYE: hair edition✨
Thought I’d hop on this trend but for hair products! I’m still learning what products work well for my hair but so far these are a few of my favorites (and not so favorites). Plus they are all mostly super affordable! ✨Shea Moisture Hydrate & Repair Curl Cream Pros: smells really good, feel
Molly Kellam

Molly Kellam

1249 likes

Two bottles of hair and scalp oils are displayed, one tea tree oil and one black castor oil, with overlay text indicating a 'BUY -OR- BYE' comparison for hair and scalp oils.
A hand holds a biotin oil bottle, highlighting benefits like stimulating hair growth, length retention, reducing thinning, strengthening, and adding shine, marked as a 'BUY'.
A hand holds a chebe oil bottle, detailing benefits such as length retention, moisturizing, preventing breakage, strengthening, and protecting hair, marked as a 'BUY'.
🍋 BUY or BYE (Hair Oil Edition)💁🏽‍♀️
So, I am doing a hair oil comparison and all of these oils I have tried except the chebe and I honestly would choose it over the black castor. I have low porosity and black castor is much too thick and dense and weighs my hair down thinner oils that are more absorbent are better for my hair! I don&
Rani M🦋

Rani M🦋

1032 likes

Bye or buy skincare edition!
#summer👙 🪸🌅 #riley
Lemon8er

Lemon8er

695 likes

A flat lay of various makeup products on a light fabric, including concealers, mascaras, blushes, a lip oil, a highlighter stick, and a pressed powder. The image is titled "Buy or Bye Makeup Edition" and includes a "SWIPE" indicator.
A tube of concealer is shown with a "Bye" rating. Text highlights negative attributes such as not being long-lasting, looking patchy, drying too fast, and creasing. Price information is also displayed.
A bottle of concealer is shown with a "Buy" rating. Text highlights positive attributes such as not creasing, high coverage, long wear, and a creamy texture. Price information is also displayed.
Buy👍 or Bye👎 (makeup edition)
⭐️ Elf Matte Camp Concealer / Overall rating: 0/10 I personally do not like this concealer because it dries too fast, it is patchy and it creases. I got beef with this concealer, it is a no for me! Price: $7.00 ⭐️Born This Way Concealer / Overall rating: 100/10 I love this concealer! It is t
Vale Mejia 🎀

Vale Mejia 🎀

531 likes

BUY or BYE - E.L.F Edition
I love Elf but some products didn’t really work for me! Daily Song: ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5: Today’s song is “The 30th” by Billie Eilish. This song is about a car accident that someone close to Billie got into. It hits hard. Did you know that Billie Eilish is releasing her new album “Hit Me Har
n

n

1257 likes

A flat lay of various cosmetic products on a white surface, with text indicating a review of makeup items.
A collage showing five different cosmetic products, each labeled with a recommendation to either acquire or pass on the item.
A bottle of a liquid glow filter product, recommended for purchase, with text highlighting its skin-enhancing effect.
Buy or Bye! Elf makeup edition
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge #beauty #elf products 💌 Brand: Elf Cosmetics I would definitely recommend to buy the lip oils they’re so good and with a good price. 🌸The elf primers are good but I would just recommend the Power grip primer I think that a really good one. My least favorite
Anny🌸

Anny🌸

13 likes

Buy or Bye: Smell Good Edition
Buy or Bye smell good edition 🎀🤍 I looooove Sol De Janeiro and Treehut Tropic glow! #buyorbye #lemon8challenge #lemon8beauty #lemon8beautycoupon #lemon8beautycrew #beautyfinds #beautyreview @Lemon8 Beauty
dani :)

dani :)

1961 likes

BUY 🤩 OR BYE 😒👋(Affordable Makeup Edition 💄)
Hey! Here are my Buy or Bye affordable makeup items! 💄✨💄✨💄✨💄✨💄✨💄✨💄✨💄 -Ioni perfect brow kit: 10/10 great for beginners BUY👍❣️ -Maybelline Cheek Heat: MEH , BYE ,👎I know it’s suppose to be sheer but it sucks 😂 & disappears within minutes (especially if you have oily skin) -Freckle Pen:
maybeitstyra

maybeitstyra

16 likes

Buy or Bye: Affordable Lip Oil Edition✨
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge TJ Maxx keeps the Gems 💎 and the prices are unmatched 😬🛍️ These Lip oils are fruity goodness!! $3.99 at TJ Maxx .These also can be purchased off their website $6.00 and Urban Outfitters $8.00 Definitely BUY 😬💖💖 #tjmaxxbeauty #beautyfinds #lemon8beauty #lemon8
GirlsGirl🫧🎀

GirlsGirl🫧🎀

2734 likes

Buy or Bye: Makeup Edition 💄💵
Here’s a few of my favorite and least favorite makeup items! I’ve been slowly perfecting my routine and figured I had enough opinions by now to share with you all! Keep in mind that what works for me may not for you, and vice versa! Huda Beauty Setting Powder- since I started using this I’ve se
lizzie matthias

lizzie matthias

23 likes

Buy or Bye! Elf edition 💋💄
I love Elf products not only because they are affordable, but because they are great quality. If you can’t afford something I bet Elf has made a dupe of it, no questions asked. Thank you Elf for holding it down! These are the products I have bought from them and have used. Some are a hit or miss an
Mariam

Mariam

772 likes

Buy or Bye ✌️ ✨makeup edition✨
#buyorbye #makeup #letschat #storytime #lemon8challengediary #lemon8contest #lemon8challenge
I’mJustJen🪩🌱

I’mJustJen🪩🌱

15 likes

Two pink jars of hair styling products are displayed with combs, under the title 'BUY OR BYE Braider edition,' comparing two hair styling products.
A pink jar of a hair styling product is shown with a 'BUY' label. Text describes its pleasant scent but notes its hold may not be strong enough for all hair types, suggesting other versions.
A pink jar of a hair styling product is shown with a 'BYE' label. Text indicates it causes build-up and flakes, suggesting combining it with another product for improved hold.
Buy or Bye: Braider edition ✨
Comparing Shine n Jam vs Edge Booster for that perfect braid down. I prefer the Shine n Jam for its amazing scent, however in my opinion, the hold isn't that great alone for 4c hair. I prefer the red or yellow jar of shine n jam over the rainbow line. The edge booster honestly creates a lot
Queen Misfitx3

Queen Misfitx3

757 likes

A Dollar Tree shopping bag surrounded by various beauty and household items. Products include a pink blush, two orange bottles of hair oil, a white bottle of hair primer, a white tube of facial cleanser, a pink hand sanitizer, and two yellow/purple cleansing sponges. The text 'Buy or Bye Dollar Tree edition' is overlaid.
A green and white pouch labeled 'makeup brush + sponge shampoo' for weekly cleansing. The text 'BUY' and 'I found it' are overlaid, indicating a recommended purchase. It is described as fragrance-free and dermatologist tested.
Two orange bottles of multi-use miracle oil for curls, labeled 'Hair oil'. The text 'BUY' is overlaid, indicating a recommended purchase. The bottles have pump dispensers.
🥰BUY OR BYE (Edition Dollar Tree)
The newest thing from dollar tree is really worth it.Run, don't walk #buyorbye #gamergirl #Deals #travelrecommendations #homedecor #lemon8box #lemon8boxchallenge #lemon8beautycrew #lemon8challenge #storytime
Roxy H

Roxy H

2628 likes

Buy ✅ or bye 👋-makeup edition
I love each of these products!! The only reason I don’t like the glow tape as much is because it’s not as shiny as I’d hope it to be. ~ ~ ~ #makeup #toofaced #tarteglowtape #tarteblushtape #kissingjellylipoilgloss #ultafinds
Hailee🍒

Hailee🍒

5 likes

Buy ✅ or bye 👋-makeup edition
Clothes-beauty🩷

Clothes-beauty🩷

8 likes

🍋BUY OR BYE: Target Edition! 🎯
✨buy or bye, target edition! Tell me if you agree!🍋 #buyorbyebeauty #buyorbyeskincare
💕mia✨

💕mia✨

926 likes

BUY or BYE? Makeup edition 💄
My honest review! These are a few of my favorites. Like and follow for more :) #Lemon8Diary #letschat #makeup #buyorbye #beautyfinds #lifestyle #Lipstick #glowup
Zoey

Zoey

7 likes

BUY OR BYE Affordable vs. Luxury Makeup Edition 🫶🥰
Choosing between some popular makeup choices to help you stay within your budget this summer! What’s worth the cash or not? Check it out during this #buyorbye challenge 🥰💛 #lemon8challenge #buyorbyemakeup #worththesplurge #drugstoremakeup #luxurymakeup
Sydney 🌻

Sydney 🌻

15 likes

SHOWER EDITION 🧼 Bye or Buy
1. Tree Hut Sugar Scrubs (Buy) -💰Price: $12; available at most major retailers and online. These scrubs are praised for their exfoliating and moisturizing properties, making them a great addition to your skincare routine. 2. Flamingo Razors (Buy) - 💰Price: $9 for a starter kit; available at Targ
Allison 🎀

Allison 🎀

380 likes

Buy Or Bye: College Dorm Edition
As An Incoming Junior In College And With Freshman Starting To Buy Things For Their Dorm, Here Is A Few "Buy Or Bye" Items (From Personal Experiences) ✨Drying Mat: Your Shower Caddy And Shower Shows Are Going To Be Wet And Especially If You Have Community Showers, You Don't Want To L
Jasmine Smythe

Jasmine Smythe

1453 likes

A split image featuring two lotion products for a 'Buy or Bye! Lotion Edition!' comparison. On the left is an EOS Vanilla Cashmere Body Lotion in a white pump bottle. On the right is a Bath & Body Works Warm Vanilla Sugar Body Cream in a beige squeeze tube.
buy or bye! lotion edition! eos>>>>
BUY ✅: EOS Vanilla Cashmere Lotion RATING 🌟: 1000000/10 PRICE 💵: $8.98 I literally LOVE this lotion! I use this everyday and every night! I love the smell and the way it makes my skin feel .. I don’t think I’ll ever stop using it lol and the smell stays on the skin for so long! BYE ❌: Bath an
hailey 💞

hailey 💞

870 likes

Buy Or Bye Elf Edition
What are your fav products from elf?! And what products are you saying bye to from elf? Overall I think they’re a great brand especially for the price! #buyorbye #elf products #elfmagic #elfhallglow #beauty #beautyfinds #elffavorites #makeup #skincare #summer
ramona <3

ramona <3

13 likes

buy or bye oily skin makeup edition!
these are my personal opinions as someone who has oily & acne prone skin! elf halo glow - pore clogging ingredients - gave me closed comedones loreal true match foundation - loveee! - a little goes a long way rare beauty highlighter - hard to blend out - patchy huda beauty
haylee

haylee

171 likes

A Ceremonia Hair Wellness Kit in a box, featuring various hair products. The user rates it a 'buy,' praising the guava-scented mask, leave-in conditioner, and hair oil for reducing shedding.
A box for the Shark FlexStyle Air Styling & Drying System. The user rates it a 'bye' due to its loud noise and the difficulty of using the curler wands on long, thick hair.
A hand holding a large bottle of Nature Republic Argan Essential Deep Care Shampoo. The user rates it a 'bye' because it made their scalp itchy.
Buy or Bye Haircare Edition
#buyorbye #haircare #lemon8challenge #lemon8beautycrew #lemon8beauty #byeorbuy #beautyfinds All of these were easy decisions this time. Adored the Ceremonia line, I highly recommend this kit if you’ve never tried the brand before. The scalp scrub left me feeling amazing. Definite
Meaninginmakeup

Meaninginmakeup

12 likes

A collection of various Glow Recipe skincare products, including toners, serums, and creams, displayed on a gold-rimmed mirrored tray. The image has "Buy or Bye" and "GLOW RECIPE EDITION" text overlays, indicating a product review.
A hand holds a jar of Glow Recipe Papaya Sorbet Enzyme Cleansing Balm. The overlay "Buy!!" and text "melts makeup," "super hydrating," and "smells delicious" indicate a positive review.
A hand holds a pink bottle of Glow Recipe Guava Vitamin C Bright-Eye Gel Cream. The overlay "Bye" and text "can't tell a difference" and "no 'wow' factor" indicate a negative review.
Bye or buy glow recipe edition ✨
Bye dull skin, hello Glow 🍋✨ Is Glow Recipe worth the hype? 👀 Let’s talk dewy, hydrated skin and if these fruity favorites are a buy or a bye! 🍑🍉 #Lemon8Diary #SkincareReview #GlowySkin #BuyOrBye #glow recipe
Destiny

Destiny

203 likes

See more