Every mascara I have tried

2024/6/27 Edited to

... Read moreFinding the right mascara can be a game changer for your makeup routine. With so many options available, it's essential to understand the different formulas and their intended effects. In this guide, I dive deep into various mascaras, comparing popular brands like L'Oreal and CoverGirl, as well as unique formulations such as waterproof and volumizing options. I discuss the essential factors to consider when choosing a mascara, including brush design, ingredients, and waterproof capabilities, to help you make informed decisions. Additionally, I share tips on application techniques to achieve the desired look, whether you're aiming for a natural enhancement or dramatic lashes. For those with sensitive eyes, I include recommendations for hypoallergenic formulas that deliver results without irritation. The mascara journey is personal — it's about finding the perfect balance between length, volume, and comfort. Join me as I uncover the highlights and lowlights of my mascara experiences, ensuring you can step out confidently with lashes that wow.

Related posts

Maybelline Firework Mascara Review 💖
GUYSSS!! I’ve found a new mascara I am obsessed with!! I have used this mascara everyday since I first tried it!! I’ve gotten so many compliments after using this mascaras. It seriously is a blend of the features you hope for in a mascara, but all in one! Have you tried this mascara yet? Wha
Mia DeLuca

Mia DeLuca

3209 likes

A store aisle displays various mascara products on shelves, with overlay text indicating a review of favorite mascaras and a star emoji.
A hand holds a pink packaged mascara, rated 8/10. The description notes that three coats are needed for great lashes.
A hand holds a purple packaged mascara, rated 7/10. The reviewer suggests it for casual outings.
Mascara Rating and Why? 👀
I love makeup and that’s why I created this page. I wanted to give you guys my favorite mascaras right now and why I love them. I have tried a lot of different mascaras and I know what I look for in my mascara. Let me know if you have tried these mascaras and is my rating fair? #letschat
Ty 😍✨✌🏽

Ty 😍✨✌🏽

1009 likes

A pink textured background with white text that reads "Why I will NEVER use another mascara," featuring two 'X' symbols.
A close-up view of a hazel eye with natural eyelashes, looking upwards, with the word "Before" at the top.
A close-up view of a hazel eye with mascara applied to the eyelashes, looking upwards, with the text "After 1 coat!" at the top.
Why I will NEVER use another mascara
I LOVE this mascara! I have tried my fair share of mascaras and this one is by far my favorite. I use the L’Oréal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Mascara in the shade Deep Burgundy. I have hazel eyes so the burgundy helps bring out the green! In one coat I get such a lift and the color is subtle b
Tia_425

Tia_425

2241 likes

Lengthening Mascara!! 👀
Ok.. are we seeing this? I’m obsessed with my L’Oréal Paris mascaras, but this one is just chefs kiss 😚 This is the Telescopic in carbon black (exact one is in my LTK in bio) I always use the original Telescopic in the gold tube, which is also amazing, but then tried the carbon black and was like W
Mia DeLuca

Mia DeLuca

5306 likes

A young woman with long brown hair and blue eyes smiles at the camera, wearing a bright green vest. Overlay text reads "Rating Mascaras i've tried."
A gold mascara tube and wand are displayed, with a close-up of the brush. Text indicates a perfect rating and highlights its ability to hold curl and ease of removal.
A pink mascara tube and wand are shown. Text gives a high rating but notes that the product dries out quickly.
Rating Mascaras i’ve tried
I’m a big mascara girly and these are my most recent Mascaras i’ve tried and out of all of them Grande Lash Mascara takes the cake every time
Grace💖🌟🪩🎀

Grace💖🌟🪩🎀

1890 likes

A flat lay shows three mascara tubes and a black eyelash curler on a white surface. The text indicates a mascara tutorial for long lashes and a 3-step routine.
A black eyelash curler is centered on a white surface. The text identifies it as an eyelash curler, described as effective for curling lashes.
A rose gold mascara tube is shown on a white surface. The text identifies it as a mascara for adding volume and making lashes look fuller.
Mascara Recommendations✨
These are some of my must have products for making my lashes look longer and more full!🫶🏼 I tend to alternate between the L’Oréal lash paradise mascara and the Ilia limitless mascara for adding volume, but I always use the telescopic for separating my lashes at the end since the wand is very precis
Melanie

Melanie

3344 likes

A hand with black glitter nail polish holds two mascara tubes, one black and one rose gold, featuring raised text. The image has an overlay text "Mascara I will repurchase Every.Single.Time."
Mascara I will repurchase Every.Single.Time
#beautyfavorites #lemon8challenge #mascara #MAYBELLINE #lashsensational #drugstoremakeup Maybelline Sky High Lash Sensational - love it. This is my go-to. I have it in both waterproof and regular formulas and both are so good. The wand✨separates my lashes really well and doesn’t a
RebeccaAnderson

RebeccaAnderson

12 likes

Mascara Wand Hack
MASCARA WAND HACK: Have you tried re-using your dried up mascara wands for these hacks before? I have been doing this hack for years at this point and I don’t think I’ll ever stop doing it! No need to buy spoolies anymore👏🏼 I personally love it to tame my flyaways and comb through my ey
MADDY MCCLAIN

MADDY MCCLAIN

307 likes

Have you tried the new extensions mascara????
Real talk… I love this stuff. It immediately separated and added length. I can’t say one bad thing about it. It never flakes…left it on over night and it was still immaculate 🤌🏼. #lorealmascara #mascararecommendations #makeup #baddieonabudget @
Larissa

Larissa

160 likes

A close-up image shows a black tube of 3D fiber mascara on a gray textured surface, with a title 'Honest EMPTIES & RESTOCKS Review'. Five gold stars indicate a positive rating, and a text box provides a review praising the mascara's lengthening ability.
fiber mascara!✨
#ratemyempties #lemon8challenge
alli🍒

alli🍒

5 likes

Mascara Rec!
Okay I am obsessed with this mascara I have been for sooo long now. This is the YSL Beauty Lash Clash. It looks so stunning with only a few layers like I did in this video but honestly I also love it with multiple layers too. Have you tried this yet?! #mascara #mascarareview #mascararecomme
Mia DeLuca

Mia DeLuca

859 likes

Bad Girl BOUNCE Mascara😳💕
What's your thoughts on the new mascara?? I'm a huge fan of their bad girl bang mascara but this...idk it's not competing. Have you tried it? #mascara #mascararecommendations #mascararoutine #mascaras #mascarareview
𝐎(𝐋𝐈𝐕)𝐈𝐀

𝐎(𝐋𝐈𝐕)𝐈𝐀

39 likes

Too Faced Viral Mascara Try On🍫💗
Okay I LOVE the brown shade! I used the black shade ALL the time a few years ago and these do not disappoint 😍 Let me know if you’ve tried it! #mascara #mascarareview #mascararecommendations #mascarahack #viralmascarareview #mascarabeforeandafter
Brianna Adams

Brianna Adams

954 likes

Mascara Makeup Hack 🖤
I’ve been using this mascara hack for years now it’s so simple but very effective to get longer lashes 👀 — All you need is a compact or handheld mirror! 🪞 Using a mirror to see your lashes from an underneath angle makes it so much easier to lift your lashes without using a lash curler Apply
Nikoletta K 🎀

Nikoletta K 🎀

26 likes

Have you changed your mascara?
Let me share my latest discovery: the first time I tried this incredible mascara, I was instantly smitten! As someone who adores voluminous lashes, I was thrilled to find that it completely delivered. The unique two-in-one brush wand is a game changer! The first wand does a fantastic job of separat
Emy | Beauty | Lifestyle

Emy | Beauty | Lifestyle

3 likes

fiber mascara✨
#ratemyempties #lemon8challenge
alli🍒

alli🍒

5 likes

best mascara duo ever?? 🤎🖤👀
Black mascara on top, brown on the bottom — my new favorite lash combo!! ✨ Black defines and lifts the top lashes ✨ Brown keeps the bottom lashes soft and natural The contrast makes your eyes pop without looking too heavy!! It’s perfect for everyday, soft glam, or clean girl looks 😇 Have
taylor nicole🎀

taylor nicole🎀

57 likes

LIFE CHANGING ✨mascara remover✨
I literally used to NEVER wear mascara simply because I hated taking it off so much. This product has changed my life and I wear mascara almost every time I go out now! I highly recommend this product if you hate taking off mascara like me! #makeup #makeuptips #makeupforbeginner #makeupt
kwinn

kwinn

332 likes

A flat lay displays two mascara tubes, one pink and one dark gray, arranged with various seashells. The image features a text overlay that reads "This or That As a Glossier Employee," suggesting a product comparison.
This image compares two mascaras, highlighting their wands. The pink mascara features a straight, skinny wand, while the dark gray mascara has a curved, full wand. Text describes the characteristics of each, including coverage and shedding.
Two mascara tubes, one pink and one dark gray, are shown against a light pink background with a brand name. The pink mascara is labeled with a higher price, and the dark gray mascara is labeled with a lower price. Seashells are also visible.
🌹This or That🌷- Comparing Mascara (as a current employee at Glossier)
Hey girl! 👙 Working with guests at Glossier means educating them on our brand and products, guide them in navigating application, color matching, and helping them find the best product for them. I get questions at work like “be honest… is this worth it?” And “what’s your experience using this pr
Ellie

Ellie

4 likes

A gold-colored L'Oréal Telescopic mascara tube is diagonally placed on a white background. Text overlays read 'Tried and True' and 'Mascara'. The bottom left corner shows 'lemon8 L'Oréal Telescopic @kimwjohnson'.
Tried and True Mascara
I have tried so many mascaras over the years, but I always come back to the one that never fails me. L’Oréal Telescopic lengthens and separates my lashes and never clumps or smudges. My eyes are very sensitive to eye makeup, and this one never gives me issues. I will choose this one every time over
Kimberly Johnson💛

Kimberly Johnson💛

14 likes

A Too Faced Ribbon Wrapped Lash mascara tube and its pink box are displayed. The box highlights 'Extreme Length & Lift,' 'No Smudging, Clumping, or Flaking,' and '24-Hour Wear,' with before-and-after eye illustrations. The mascara wand is visible.
✨ Mascara Addict ✨
A tubing mascara from Too Faced? Okayyyy, but is it good? 🫣 *Complimentary in exchange for my review I love me a good tubing mascara, so I was really excited about this. Unfortunately, it did not work out for me. The formula is very wet, so immediately, my lashes were all stuck together. Lik
CeeCee

CeeCee

12 likes

A hand holds three tubes of Prosa mascara: two purple and one gray. The labels show 'Maxi-Volumen' and 'Profesional' mascara with a silicone brush and waterproof formula, consistent with the product described.
A woman smiles at the camera, showcasing her curled and volumized eyelashes, consistent with mascara application. She wears a black top and an earring.
A woman takes a selfie, making a pouting expression. Her eyelashes are visibly curled and enhanced with mascara, wearing a beige jacket over a black hoodie.
The only mascara I’ll ever use
#lemon8review #lemon8contest This is the only mascara I will ever use First 3 pics are with mascara, last pic is lashes not curled and no mascara (sorry I don’t have a better picture of myself mascara free ) Prosa mascara is the only one that will keep my lashes curled. It’s also super af
Crista Renteria

Crista Renteria

51 likes

Worth Every Bit of $75✨💐🧴💄💋
So my job had a tester sale for us last week and omggggg $75 well spent 🥰 I feel like I manifested this because I told myself the woman I’m becoming wears luxury on her body from head to toe. From my clothing, to purses, to beauty & skincare🧴I started a “grown woman era” wishlist on my Nordstro
✧ Vonnie, xoxo ✧

✧ Vonnie, xoxo ✧

11 likes

A hand holds a silver mascara tube with a distinctive black logo. A speech bubble overlay states, 'The mascara I trust on long days!'
A close-up of the mascara tube's bottom reveals text including 'LASH LATEX', '1 MASCARA', and 'MADE IN FRANCE', along with volume details.
A hand holds the sleek silver mascara tube horizontally, showcasing its design and the black logo in the center.
The mascara I trust on long days!
This mascara stays PUT! Probably why it’s a bit on the pricier end. It not only lengthens and completely sculpts your eyelashes, but it will last all day long! This mascara is wonderful and I cannot stress it enough! It is sworn to be up to 24 hour wear and sweat resistant. I get it in the shade 1.
Victoria Reyes

Victoria Reyes

1 like

Have you tried this mascara?
Product: Clio Kill lash mascara #makeup #makeupreview #kbeauty #mascara #clio kill lash
mekaela ☺︎︎

mekaela ☺︎︎

14 likes

The image displays two green mascara tubes, one in its box, on a white textured background. The packaging highlights '230% more volume' and features 'before' and 'after' eye images. Text on the box mentions '96% significant impact' and '94% lashes stay lifted all day'.
Clinique high impact mascara
High Impact Mascara ♡ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ #clinique #highimpactmascara #cliniquemakeup #makeup #review
leahmariashops

leahmariashops

3 likes

A blurred hand holds a light purple mascara tube. Overlay text reads 'THIS IS THE BEST MASCARA SWIPE'. The image also includes 'lemon8 @risatrishann'.
the best mascara??
The Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara💜💜💜 I understand it’s a little on the pricey side, but it truly is the best mascara I have ever tried. It brings length and volume which is something I really look for in a mascara. If you’re curious, try the mini first! #makeup #makeuproutine #makeuptip
♡RISA♡

♡RISA♡

20 likes

A new mascara product in its packaging, featuring a model's eye with enhanced lashes, is displayed on a surface with other blurred makeup items. Text on the image indicates it's a 'Top 5 Mascara' and highlights its 'very black' shade, suggesting volume and lift.
✨ New Mascara Alert + My Top 5 ✨
I just tried this new mascara and the volume immediately caught my attention 😍 My lashes look fuller, darker, and lifted without feeling heavy or clumpy. It builds really nicely and gives that bold lash look I love right away. Since lashes are kind of my thing, here are the top 5 mascaras that a
Tiana 🇵🇷

Tiana 🇵🇷

36 likes

No Mascara Trend Using Aquaphor!
Have you tried this?! I hate taking off mascara so I love this! #makeup #makeuphacks #makeupforbeginner #ViralBeauty #viralmakeuphack #makeuptrend #makeuproutine #makeuptips #makeupforbeginners #cleangirlaesthetic
Mackenzie B

Mackenzie B

50 likes

I love mascara.
#mascara #theyre real mascara #Lemon8Diary #makeup
makenzie addison

makenzie addison

23 likes

Mascara vs…
Fake lashes pros: - I only have to apply 5-7 days - I’m a PERFECTIONIST when it came to mascara and it was never perfect - I don’t have to take off mascara every night anymore - they’re waterproof Do you think you’d ever try fake lashes? #beautyroutine #lemon8challenge
Jenni

Jenni

1 like

Tubing Mascara ✨
I’m officially back to using this tubing mascara every day. Waking up not looking like a complete zombie has been the BEST! I forgot how voluminous it makes my lashes too. I mean look at them 😍 Not to mention how easy it is to remove it during my morning routine where my time is so limited. I lo
The Kristen G

The Kristen G

5 likes

This mascara is THAT GIRL!
Tarte sent me their Tarlette Tubing Mascara and besties… I’m impressed. I tried both the brown and the black and the first thing I noticed was how smooth the formula is. No harsh smell, no clumping, and it gave my lashes such a beautiful lift and separation. The brown is perfect for a sof
Sye Self Care + Fashion + Life

Sye Self Care + Fashion + Life

3 likes

A person holds a light blue and white tube, identified as a mascara remover and product review. The person has light green nail polish.
A person applies a product to their eyelashes with a wand. Text overlay indicates it's a mascara remover and enhancer, with one side for removal and the other for growth serum.
A person holds a white tissue with dark smudges, demonstrating the removal of mascara. Text overlay instructs to apply on lashes and wipe off.
Mascara remover review?!🤍
Hey guys! Behind every great mascara is an even greater mascara remover! 💫✨ Today, I'm putting this little gem to the test and sharing my thoughts with you all! 🌟 Say goodbye to panda eyes and hello to squeaky-clean lashes! 🐼 This remover promises to whisk away every last trace of mascara w
leah baha

leah baha

339 likes

Maybelline Sky Tubes Tubing Mascara
As a pro artist, Maybelline Sky High Tubes is a tubing mascara marvel. The flexible wand coats every lash evenly, delivering insane length and clean separation without clumps. It builds beautifully from natural to dramatic. True smudge-proof, flake-proof wear that genuinely lasts all day, yet slide
KAREN💄POSTS BEAUTY

KAREN💄POSTS BEAUTY

69 likes

See more