Makeup Duel: Milk Hydro Grip vs. e.l.f. Power Grip

2024/9/19 Edited to

... Read moreChoosing the right primer can truly make or break your makeup look, especially when you're aiming for that flawless, long-lasting finish. We've all seen the buzz around “grip” primers, promising to lock everything in place. While the original article touched on the direct comparison between Milk Hydro Grip and e.l.f. Power Grip, let's dive deeper into what makes these two prominent cosmetic primers stand out and help you decide which one might be your perfect match, especially considering specific skin needs and preferences. The e.l.f. Power Grip Hydrating Primer has garnered immense popularity, and for good reason. Its hero ingredient, hyaluronic acid, is a game-changer for hydration, making it feel less like a traditional primer and more like a skincare step. When I first tried it, I was amazed by its almost gel-like, slightly tacky texture. This tackiness is key to its “power grip” effect – it truly creates a surface your foundation can cling to, extending wear time significantly. For those with normal to dry skin, this primer not only provides an excellent base but also an extra boost of moisture, leaving a beautiful, natural finish that isn't overly dewy. The packaging, a simple yet effective squeeze tube, makes it easy to dispense just the right amount. On the other hand, the Milk Hydro Grip Primer pioneered this innovative grip technology. Its formula, also boasting hydrating ingredients like hyaluronic acid and niacinamide, feels incredibly refreshing upon application. What sets Milk apart, beyond its sleek pump bottle, is often perceived as a slightly more refined feel and perhaps a touch more 'oomph' in its gripping power. Many users rave about the radiant finish it imparts, giving makeup a healthy, glowing base that lasts all day. For a long time, it was the gold standard for long-lasting makeup, particularly for evening events or demanding days. Now, let's talk about the “dupe” factor. The reason so many consider the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer to be a fantastic Milk Hydro Grip dupe lies in their similar textures and, more importantly, their similar performance. Both primers create that essential tacky layer that genuinely holds makeup in place. They both enhance the longevity of foundation and provide a smooth canvas. While Milk might offer a slightly more luxurious experience and a touch more radiance, e.l.f. comes incredibly close in its core function of providing a robust grip and hydration, making it an undeniable winner in terms of affordability and accessibility as a best affordable vegan primer. Yes, e.l.f. is entirely vegan and cruelty-free, which is a huge plus for many. Milk Hydro Grip is also vegan, making both excellent ethical choices. One of the most frequent questions I encounter is about Milk Hydro Grip Primer for oily skin. While both are hydrating, those with oily skin might find that the intense hydration of these primers can sometimes lead to an overly dewy look or even break down faster in certain areas. My tip for oily skin types is to use a very thin layer, focusing on areas where makeup tends to slide, and perhaps pair it with a mattifying powder in your T-zone. Personally, I've found that even with oily skin, these grip primers can work wonders; it's all about strategic application and what you layer on top. For extremely oily skin, you might prefer a truly mattifying primer, but for those with combination or slightly oily skin looking for a grip, a light hand with either of these can still deliver fantastic long-lasting results. Finally, regarding types of power grip or primers in general, it's worth noting that “grip” primers are a specific category designed to literally create adhesion for makeup. They differ from pore-filling primers (which smooth texture) or color-correcting primers. Understanding these distinctions helps you choose the right product for your specific makeup goals. These hydrating grip primers excel at making makeup last longer and look smoother, bridging the gap between skincare and makeup application. Ultimately, whether you opt for the e.l.f. Power Grip or the Milk Hydro Grip, you're investing in a product designed to elevate your makeup game and ensure your look stays put from morning until night.

21 comments

XpensiveGirl🐩🫧's images
XpensiveGirl🐩🫧

I mean Elf is the dupe.

See more comments

Related posts

Flawless makeup tutorial ♡
Sound on 🔊 Another flawless makeup tutorial ♡ Milk makeup - hydro grip primer Drunk elephant - lip balm Charlotte tilbury - flawless airbrush foundation 15w Toofaced - born this way concealer in butterscotch Rare beauty - soft pink blush in happy Black opal beauty - foundation stick
Katrina Janáe

Katrina Janáe

6877 likes

A store aisle displays various cosmetic products, with text overlays suggesting cost-effective alternatives. The shelves are stocked with makeup, brushes, and beauty tools, highlighting a wide selection of items.
Two brow styling products are shown side-by-side for comparison. One is in a black package, and the other is in a round container with a rose gold lid, illustrating different options for brow care.
Two primer products are presented for comparison. One is in a teal-colored box, while the other is a green liquid in a clear bottle, showcasing different formulations for makeup preparation.
They’re literally the same 🫢
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Freeze vs Elf’s Brow Lift -$26 vs $6 -Elf is arguably better Milk Hydrogrip primer vs Elf Power Grip Primer vs -$38 vs $10 -Elf holds better Charlotte Tilbury Hollywood Contour Wand vs Elf Halo Glow Contour Beauty Wand -$42 vs $9 -Basically the same -elf
Hannah Robinson

Hannah Robinson

2675 likes

Photogenic Makeup 📸🎀
How to achieve photogenic makeup with tips I learned 📸✨ @CTilburyMakeup Sun kissed bronzer Setting spray @esteelauder Double wear foundation @kvdbeauty Foundation @milkmakeup Hydro grip primer Contour sticks @patricktabeauty Duo blush oh she's vibrant @nudestix Cream conce
Uniquely TyAna

Uniquely TyAna

27K likes

A store display showcases various ELF makeup products, including foundations, primers, and concealers. A pink text overlay reads "ELF DUPES FROM WALMART," indicating affordable alternatives for beauty products.
A hand holds an ELF Power Grip Primer in its packaging. Text highlights its gel-like texture, long-lasting wear, and tacky base for makeup, presented as a dupe for a popular grip primer.
A hand holds an ELF Halo Glow Beauty Wand in its packaging. Text describes its creamy, blendable formula and cushion applicator, presented as a dupe for a well-known contour wand.
ELF dupes✨💋 from Walmart
High quality products at affordable prices 🌟 here are my favorite finds: e.l.f. Power Grip Primer —> Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Primer e.l.f. Halo Glow Contour Beauty Wand —> Charlotte Tilbury Hollywood Contour Wand e.l.f. Dewy Coconut Setting Mist —> MAC Prep + Prime Fix+ Setting Sp
Nikki

Nikki

768 likes

oily vs dry skin makeup tips + tricks 💖
I wanted to share some tips & tricks for your makeup routine - 𝙤𝙞𝙡𝙮 𝙫𝙨 𝙙𝙧𝙮 𝙨𝙠𝙞𝙣 edition! 🩷 Choosing the right products for your skin type is key to making your makeup not only look good - but to also last all day/ night. ✨️ If you have oily skin, go for products that will help mattify &am
yariibabyy

yariibabyy

1207 likes

A flat lay of various pink-toned makeup products, including lip glosses, compacts, and lipsticks, on a white surface. The text "ACNE SAFE MAKEUP" is overlaid at the top.
A grid displaying acne-safe setting sprays, bronzers, and sunscreens. Products from brands like Rare Beauty, ELF, ELTA MD, ILIA, and Skinbetter Science are shown.
A grid illustrating acne-safe primers, foundations, and concealers. Products from Milk Makeup, Charlotte Tilbury, Kosas, Benefit Cosmetics, Maybelline, and Rare Beauty are featured.
ACNE SAFE MAKEUP
- part 2 of acne safe - #acnesafemakeup #acnesafe #beautyfinds #unfiltered #embracevulnerability #makeup #unaesthetic #shareyourthoughts
mimi🫶🏼

mimi🫶🏼

13.9K likes

Let me know if you found this helpful‼️ @Blume Skin moisturizer @Paula’s Choice spf @loréal paris usa mattifying primer @Glow Recipe dew drops @Haus Labs foundation @elfcosmetics bronzer @r.e.m. beauty blush @Tower 28 Beauty concealer @Huda Beauty loose powder @NYX Professional Makeup
slaybyjess

slaybyjess

73 likes

A white bag filled with various cosmetic products, featuring a text overlay that reads "Best makeup DUPES" with sparkling accents.
Two different primers are displayed, one in a green spray bottle and the other in a green squeeze tube, presented side-by-side for comparison.
Two pore-filling primers are shown, one in a white tube within a black box and the other in a beige and teal squeeze tube.
Best Makeup Dupes✨
Affordable Dupes You Need! 💸💕✨ 1. $38 Milk Hydro Grip Primer vs. $10 ELF Power Grip Primer ⭐️Milk is super hydrating, but ELF is stickier and holds your makeup all day. Both are great, just depends on what you're looking for! 2. $35 Benefit Porefessional vs. $15 NYX Pore Filler Blurring
Tyra💫

Tyra💫

1142 likes

sultry toasty makeup tutorial
sultry toasty makeup tutorial products mentioned: @milkmakeup hydro grip primer @milanicosmetics conceal + perfect liquid bronzing drops – medium @maybelline lumi matte foundation – 250 + 312 @maccosmetics wear concealer – nc20 @personacosmetics multi stick bronzer – sahara @mcobeauty_us st
Chicwithkels

Chicwithkels

432 likes

A store aisle displaying various makeup products, with text overlay highlighting 'HIGH END MAKE UP DUPES Ulta Beauty'.
Two hands hold up a Milani Make It Last Original setting spray and an Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray, comparing them.
Two hands hold up a L'Oreal True Match Lumi Glotion and a Drunk Elephant D-Bronzi Anti-Pollution Sunshine Drops, comparing them.
Ulta Beauty Makeup Dupes 💋
So glad that there are dupes for high end make ups and these are the makeups I super love: 1️⃣ Milani vs. Charlotte Tilburry Setting Spray - Both the Milani and Charlotte Tilbury setting sprays are designed to lock in makeup and extend its wear. They both aim to keep your makeup looking fresh
Fin Hogar | UGC

Fin Hogar | UGC

1916 likes

My Holy grail everyday makeup products 🫶🏾
When it comes to my everyday makeup routine. Just know these products posted above are TEA! Each product listed has a special place in my heart 🥰🤍 • @narsissist natural radiant longwear foundation • @milkmakeup hydro grip primer • @toofaced born this way concealer in both butterscotch and coco
Shon’Tasia

Shon’Tasia

1159 likes

The exterior of a beauty store with text indicating a comparison of makeup products, highlighting more affordable alternatives.
Two different primers are shown, one in a clear bottle and another in a green tube, illustrating a more affordable option.
Two setting sprays are displayed, one in a box and another in a clear bottle, comparing a higher-priced item with a budget-friendly alternative.
MAKEUP DUPE ALERT 🚨
Hello beautiful ladies ❤️ Here are some high-end makeup dupes from Ulta beauty that I wanted to share with you guys! DISCLAIMER: 🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨The dupes listed above are solely based on my opinion! They are exactly what I’m advertising, which is a DUPE! So it may not be exactly like the product, b
Asyhia

Asyhia

368 likes

Milk bronzing primer review✨✨
#milk bronze and primer #milkmakeup #milk hydro grip primer #makeupreview #honestmakeupreview #milk hydro primer
LILYLADUE 🐆🐆

LILYLADUE 🐆🐆

719 likes

obsessed with this trend by @Toni Bravo !!!! products mentioned: @Kosas Cloud Set Setting Spray @milkmakeup Hydro Grip Gel Skin Tint @rhode skin Pocket Blush in Sleepy Girl @REFY Blur + Hydrate Primer @LAWLESS Beauty Forget The Filler in Strawberry Shortcake #fivefingerfavorites #cl
hannah sophia

hannah sophia

944 likes

For all the cuties who asked for the details on this swampy glam look 😮‍💨 #makeup #makeuplook #makeuptutorial #eyeshadow #eyeshadowlook @maccosmetics @M.A.C Cosmetics Store strobe cream “Bronzelite” @CeraVe under eye treatment @milkmakeup hydrogrip primer @PLOUISE @Plouise
𝓦𝓱𝓲𝓹𝔁𝓛𝓪𝓼𝓱𝓮𝓼

𝓦𝓱𝓲𝓹𝔁𝓛𝓪𝓼𝓱𝓮𝓼

106 likes

Is it the hair that makes this dress ✨✨✨
Sure! Here's a template with all the sections filled in—just let me know if you want it customized further for a specific occasion or personal features: MAKEUP LOOK ✨ Overall style: Soft glam with a glowing finish Skin Tone: Medium with warm undertones Skin Type: Combination (oily T-zon
DressSoul

DressSoul

279 likes

A comparison image shows a green primer bottle and a blue primer tube on a dark, silky background, with text indicating a product comparison.
A green primer bottle is displayed with text describing its characteristics as sticky, lightweight, long-wearing, and noting its cost, along with an 8/10 rating.
A blue primer tube is shown with text highlighting its stickiness, similar ingredients to another product, affordability, and a 9.5/10 rating.
ELF Power grip VS Milk Hydro grip primer
Have you tried either of these primers? i’m curious how everyone else feels about this debate 🫣 disclaimer: I am a makeup content creator and wear both of these regularly so i’ve had time to evaluate how they work🖤 #elfcosmetics #milkmakeup #lemon8beauty #lemon8challenge #letschat
hannah ཐི⋆ཋྀ

hannah ཐི⋆ཋྀ

67 likes

Minimal makeup products
My fav minimal makeup products ⭐️ - In summer time a minimal makeup look is a must have and these are some of my favorite light weight glowy products ⭐️ Starting off with the elf power grip primer this is a great dupe for the hydro grip milk primer and is half the price ! I pay this into my fa
Leasjahjenae

Leasjahjenae

18.7K likes

An open, fluffy makeup bag is filled with various cosmetic products in tubes, bottles, and compacts. The image highlights makeup comparisons, focusing on affordable alternatives.
Two liquid blush products are displayed side-by-side, one with a gold-toned cap and the other with a white cap, illustrating a comparison between similar cosmetic items.
Two foundation products are shown, one in a rose gold bottle and the other in a brown bottle, with their respective applicators, indicating a comparison of similar makeup items.
Dupes 🎀
Hey loves💖 Ok but can someone explain how e.l.f. has so many great dupes for EXPENSIVE makeuppp like please guys keep up with this plz🙏🏼 Anyhow so here are some dupes for some products😁😁 I’m working on a pt2 so wait for it cause more is coming your way!! • e.l.f. liquid blush ($7) is a dup
Clarii 💗

Clarii 💗

5580 likes

acne safe makeup!
i have experience with a lot of these brands and none of them have ever made me breakout! they’re all very thoroughly researched to work well with different skin types and textures. everybody’s skin is different so obviously what works for some won’t always work for others but these are some good b
selfcaresunday

selfcaresunday

323 likes

Testing out the ✨essence✨ Jelly Grip eye primer🪼💚
#eyeprimer #makeuptest #makeuptutorial #essencemakeup
Bunny

Bunny

20 likes

A flat lay of various makeup products for a full face routine, including brow products, face makeup, lashes, lip products, and setting spray, arranged on a brick surface.
An assortment of eyebrow products, including brow pomade, powder, brushes, concealer, and a brow pencil, with text providing instructions for achieving defined and even brows.
A clear bottle of primer and a bottle of matte foundation, with text emphasizing the use of a grippy primer and matte foundation for a long-lasting makeup look.
latina makeup routine! 💋 ultimate baddie vibes ✨
If there is a makeup routine that I absolutely 𝑳𝑶𝑽𝑬, it's the latina makeup routine! 💋 This is my go-to makeup routine. Sometimes, I'll try to do light makeup & I end up just doing this full routine lol. I will say I don't really do lashes, I just curl & apply mascara. But fo
yariibabyy

yariibabyy

637 likes

The image displays various makeup products held by hands, illustrating the concept of affordable alternatives for popular beauty items. It features different primers and glow-enhancing liquids.
A hand holds a green bottle of a hydrating makeup primer. This product is known for its sticky formula, designed to help grip makeup for extended wear.
A hand holds a clear tube of a makeup primer, with a swatch on the skin. This primer is described as sticky, hydrating, and suitable for long-lasting makeup application.
makeup dupes: better + cheaper ✨
i love when you can find a product that is basically the same as the more expensive product instead of milk makeup’s hydro grip primer, try elf cosmetic’s power grip primer 💦 in my opinion, the formula is basically the same. if you want to keep it as similar as possible with the niacinamide, elf
— jennilee ʚ♡ɞ

— jennilee ʚ♡ɞ

655 likes

I’m really a TV show and makeup kinda girl😂
Grwm while I watch one of my favorite shows! I’m gonna have all product details listed but if you need shades just leave a comment and if you need an in depth tutorial, let me know and I’ll do one! #makeup #grwmbeauty #grwm #makeuproutine #CapCut D’alba first serum spray Milk hydrogr
itsmuhnett

itsmuhnett

7 likes

This image displays various makeup products on a wooden surface, illustrating five tricks for achieving long-lasting makeup on a wedding day.
A hand with red nails holds two bottles of sticky primer, emphasizing the first trick for ensuring makeup stays in place all day.
A hand with red nails holds a bottle of long-lasting foundation, highlighting the second trick for achieving medium, buildable, and transfer-resistant coverage.
5 tricks for long-lasting makeup for bride! 💄💍
I wanted to share 5 tricks to keep makeup set all day on your wedding day 💄💒💍 These tips + tricks will help you achieve your best wedding makeup that not only looks good, but will have you feeling confident that your makeup will stay in place all day on your big day. Let's get into the 5
yariibabyy

yariibabyy

121 likes

Blurry vs Dewy Which side are you? 👀✨I split my face to show the difference in finish… which one is for you? Matte (Blurry) Side: @NYX Professional Makeup Makeup Matte Finish Setting Spray @Dominique Cosmetics Cooling Blur Matte Primer @Anastasia Beverly Hills Matte Foundation @NARS Cosmetic
Christen Dominique

Christen Dominique

277 likes

A flat lay of various makeup products arranged on a gray surface, with a white floral arrangement in the background. The image has a text overlay that reads 'my go-to makeup products by category'.
A collection of primer and luminizer products, including a gray tube, a glass bottle with a rose gold cap, and two frosted glass bottles, displayed on a gray surface with white flowers in the background.
A display of foundation, skin tint, concealer, and eye brightener products, including a black-capped bottle, a dropper bottle, a wand applicator, and a small pot, set against a white floral background.
my go-to makeup products by category
I LOVE makeup and I LOVE trying new products, but these are all of my absolute go-to’s by category: PRIMER and LUMINIZER: Refy Glow & Sculpt Face Primer Charlotte Tilbury Hollywood Flawless Filter Saie Glowy Super Gel in Starglow & Sunglow FOUNDATION and SKIN: Giorgio Armani Lumin
Sophia Giuffré

Sophia Giuffré

834 likes

A flat lay of five different hydrating primers for dry to combo skin, labeled 'FAVORITE primers.' Products include a green bottle, a yellow pump bottle, a clear bottle with gold cap, a bronze tube, and a pink tube.
Two bottles of a popular hydrating grip primer, one in green and one in gold, with text explaining that both grip makeup, but the gold one adds a dewy finish for radiance.
A pink tube of a hydrating jelly primer, described as an affordable option that smooths and hydrates dry/combo skin while gripping makeup.
Favorite Hydrating Primers for Dry Skin 💧✨
Here are my favorite primers for dry to combo skin types! These are great for keeping your makeup looking flawless while keeping your skin hydrated and glowing ✨ 1. Milk Hydro Grip Primer ⭐️ One of my go to primers ! Ideal for dry to combo skin, this primer keeps makeup locked in all day wi
Tyra💫

Tyra💫

145 likes

Something about red with silver glitter makes me feel soooo lush ❤️🩶✨ #makeup #makeuptutorial #eyeshadow #eyeshadowtutorial #eyeshadowlook #makeuplook #summermakeup @Anastasia Beverly Hills Perfect brow pencil @Morphe Cosmetics solo artist priming cream eyeshadow “airplay”, cheek
𝓦𝓱𝓲𝓹𝔁𝓛𝓪𝓼𝓱𝓮𝓼

𝓦𝓱𝓲𝓹𝔁𝓛𝓪𝓼𝓱𝓮𝓼

303 likes

Silent review of all setting sprays I’ve tried! Can u guess my fav 😏 What should I review next? #silentreview #settingsprays Product list: 1. e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist 2. @Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray 3. @milkmakeup Hydro Grip Set + Refresh Spray
izzy

izzy

196 likes

Beginner Friendly Makeup Tutorial 💗 Products used: @DanessaMyricksBeauty Yummy Skin Skin Tint - 13 | Yummy Skin Flushed - Golden Hour @elfcosmetics Hydrating Camo Concealer - Deep Chestnut & Medium Beige| Halo Glow Pressed Powder - Rich Warm | Lip Plumping Gloss - Pink Paloma @Rare Beau
Sapphireallia

Sapphireallia

173 likes

An interior view of a Sephora store featuring various makeup displays, with the text "Sephora Minis" prominently overlaid, highlighting mini-sized beauty products.
A hand holds a pink box for a cooling water jelly tint, with a smaller pink box indicating the shade. A price tag shows $24.00 for the product.
A hand holds a white box for a hydro grip primer, with a smaller white box showing product details. A price tag indicates $20.00 for the item.
Makeup Minis🤍
🤍Sephora Minis🤍 🖤Product One: MILK - Cooling Water Jelly Tint 💰Price: $24.00 ~ SHEER LIP & CHEEK STAIN - Cooling Water Jelly Tint is a long-lasting lip and cheek stain with a hydrating, bouncy jelly texture that glides on for a sheer, buildable burst of color. 🖤Product Two: MILK - Hydr
Kenz

Kenz

330 likes

See more