PROTEIN ICE CREAM!🍓🍰

I’ve been obsessed with trying new recipie with my ninja creami and this is by far my favorite recipe!!

ingredients:

🍓fairlife core power strawberry shake (42g of p)

🍓1 cup fresh strawberries chopped

🍓1 tablespoon granulated sugar

🍓2 tablespoons pudding cheesecake mix (25g)

🍓1 small package of short bread cookies crushed

whisk and freeze for 24 hours!

mix on the “ice cream” setting and re-spin with a splash of heavy cream for a creamy texture!

top with fresh strawberries and short bread cookie crumbs for the BEST protein ice cream 🤩

#hellolemon8 #lemon8recipe #ninjacreami #proteinicecream #ninjacreamirecipe #strawberrycheesecake #homemadeicecream #ninjacreamireview #iowagirl

Iowa
2023/4/29 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so you’ve probably seen my amazing strawberry cheesecake protein ice cream recipe for the Ninja Creami, and trust me, it's a game-changer! But since I've been making so much protein ice cream lately, I wanted to share a few more tips and tricks I've learned along the way to help you get the absolute best results and maybe even inspire some new creations. First off, let’s talk about why protein ice cream, especially with your Ninja Creami ice cream maker, is such a fantastic idea. For me, it’s all about having a delicious treat that also supports my fitness goals. Getting 42g of protein in something that tastes like a decadent dessert? Yes, please! It helps curb those late-night cravings for unhealthy sweets without feeling like I’m depriving myself. Plus, knowing exactly what goes into it makes it so much better than store-bought options. One of the biggest questions I get is about getting that perfect creamy texture. The key is definitely the initial freeze. Make sure your base is completely frozen solid for at least 24 hours, and ideally, freeze it on a level surface. When your Ninja Creami is doing its thing, don't be afraid of that re-spin! Sometimes, after the first spin, it can look a bit crumbly. That’s totally normal. A quick re-spin with a splash of liquid – I often use a little extra Fairlife milk or even a tiny bit of the Fairlife protein shake itself – works wonders. It transforms it into that smooth, scoopable consistency we all dream of. Speaking of Fairlife, it's truly a superstar ingredient for Ninja Creami recipes. The ultra-filtered nature of Fairlife protein shakes makes them incredibly smooth and less prone to crystallization compared to some other protein shakes or regular milk. This means a creamier result right off the bat. So, if you're experimenting with other flavors, I highly recommend sticking with Fairlife as your base for consistency. Their chocolate or vanilla shakes open up a whole world of possibilities beyond the strawberry cheesecake flavor! Want to customize your protein pint even further? Don't stop at just chopped strawberries and cookie crumbs. While those are delicious, think about other mix-ins. A few chocolate chips, a swirl of peanut butter, or even some crushed graham crackers for that extra cheesecake crust vibe can elevate your creation. For a different fruit twist, I’ve tried adding mashed banana or blueberries, and they’ve been equally delightful. You can also play with the pudding mix flavors – sugar-free vanilla or chocolate pudding mix can make for entirely new ice cream experiences. If you're looking to cut down on sugar, consider using a sugar substitute or a natural sweetener like stevia to taste. The beauty of the Ninja Creami is that it makes experimenting so easy and fun! Ultimately, making your own protein ice cream with the Ninja Creami is not just about a healthy treat; it's about enjoying the process and creating something truly delicious that you can feel good about eating. Happy creaming!

14 comments

Emilyoloughlin's images
Emilyoloughlin

Do you add everything and freeze or just the protein shake and cheesecake mix then add the rest of a mix in?

See more(1)
Dana Jean's images
Dana Jean

YUMMMM I love anything strawberry so I need to try this!

See more(1)

Related posts

Protein ice cream sandwiches
Protein Ice Cream Sandwiches – the ultimate guilt-free treat! These creamy, protein-packed sandwiches are the perfect way to satisfy your sweet tooth while staying on track. Ingredients: Cool Whip 1/2 cup PB fit or two scoops protein powder Graham Crackers 1/2 cup chocolate chips #icecre
asipoftexas

asipoftexas

2178 likes

Protein “ice cream” yes please!
Protein Mint Oreo Ice Cream >>> 💚😮‍💨 Save this for later & follow @jfiteats for recipes I don’t know about yall, but I love ice cream and I love oreos. Some things you just can’t give upppp Here’s how to make it ⬇️ Cottage Cheese @oikos Plain Greek Yogurt Vanilla Hon
Jazmyhn Catlin

Jazmyhn Catlin

4380 likes

A Ninja Creami pint filled with cookie butter protein ice cream, topped with whipped cream and cookie crumbles. A spoon scoops out a portion, highlighting the dessert's 250 calories and 21g protein content.
Ingredients for the Ninja Creami base: a Fairlife Core Power vanilla protein shake and Jell-O sugar-free butterscotch pudding mix. A frozen base in a Ninja Creami pint is shown, with instructions to freeze for 12 hours.
Toppings for the Ninja Creami: crumbled Biscoff cookies being added to the ice cream base, alongside a can of Reddi-Wip fat-free whipped cream. The image focuses on preparing the final dessert.
Cookie Butter Ninja Creami protein ice cream
i have been having so much fun experimenting with different Ninja Creami recipes, and this one is my favorite yet. 🤭 Ingredients • 1.5 tbsp of sugar free butterscotch jello pudding mix (this is key! i will be adding a sugar free jello mix into all of my future recipes.) • 3/4 of a fairlife cor
avavescovi

avavescovi

1050 likes

Strawberry Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream! 🍓🍰
I been developing more new ninja Creami recipes and this one hit different! Creamy, sweet, and packed with protein – this one definitely going to my HOF list for when I need a healthy sweet treat. 2 servings of the pudding mix gives it that cheesecake thickness, strawberry extract adds a punch o
jumbeezy

jumbeezy

1519 likes

Protein Banana Cream Pudding!
Such a quick and easy protein dessert idea! Saw others mix in yogurt and protein powder and thought why not just use protein yogurt! Turned out fantastic! I bet if I popped a bowl of it into the freezer it would come out very well! I would have added some cool whip if I had any 😞, but it tastes awe
Pretzel

Pretzel

1629 likes

High Protein Cake Batter Ice Cream
No matter the season, I will be enjoying a protein ice cream 🤣 Especially if I don’t have to feel guilty for eating the whole thing! This cake batter protein ice cream has 41g protein per pint & only 7g fat compared to store bought pints which are usually around 20g fat and 7g protein!
Lyss

Lyss

1440 likes

A bowl of high-protein, low-calorie ice cream topped with chocolate drizzle and square cereal pieces, held by a hand. Text overlays indicate "HIGH PROTEIN LOW CALORIE ICE CREAM" and "35G OF PROTEIN."
A black container of PESCIENCE Select Protein powder in Gourmet Vanilla flavor. Text overlay indicates "1 scoop of protein powder."
A light blue bottle of fairlife fat-free ultra-filtered milk. Text overlay indicates "230 ml of fairlife milk."
HIGH PROTEIN LOW CAL ICE CREAM
do you love ice cream??🍦 i know i do!!! if there is one thing i learned in my fitness journey it’s that there is a healthy alternative to anything out there!! i use to be someone (and still am) who needs a sweet before i go to bed!! as soon as i found out about this ice cream i was amazed!! f
madifore

madifore

584 likes

Low Calorie HIGH PROTEIN Ice Cream 🤎🍫
The easiest way I've found to turn my protein shake into ice cream. Ingredients: • 1 Fairlife Chocolate Protein Shake • 10g chocolate pudding mix • 1 oz heavy whipping cream Mix, freeze for 24 hours, and spin in the Ninja Creami until creamy. Entire pint: 195 calories 31g protein
QuelleChaos🧘🏽‍♀️🔮☮️

QuelleChaos🧘🏽‍♀️🔮☮️

446 likes

Two protein ice cream sandwiches made with only three ingredients are presented on a white plate, ready to satisfy a sweet craving.
The three ingredients for the protein ice cream sandwiches are displayed: a container of zero sugar whipped topping, a box of honey graham crackers, and a scoop of protein powder.
Graham crackers are arranged neatly at the bottom of a clear rectangular glass baking dish, forming the base for the dessert.
Vanilla protein ice cream sandwich
Only 3 ingredients and satisfy your sweet cravings 📍Location:Tempe #ice cream sandwiches Tempe
Clau🌹

Clau🌹

186 likes

Protein ice cream sandwiches
PROTEIN ICE CREAM SANDWICHES 2 cups almond flour 4 tbsp oat flour 1/2 cup sunflower seed butter 4 tbsp maple syrup 4 tbsp almond milk 2 tsp vanilla extract Pinch of salt 1/2 cup mini chocolate chips 1 tub coconut whip 1/2 cup birthday cake protein powder In a bowl, mix together
Victoria Tschopp

Victoria Tschopp

945 likes

High protein healthy chocolate ice cream
INGREDIENTS 1 16 oz container cottage cheese (preferably full fat) ¼ cup honey ¼ cup cacao powder 2 tablespoons almond butter ½ teaspoon vanilla extract flaky sea salt to taste optional INSTRUCTIONS Add cottage cheese, cacao, almond butter, vanilla and honey to a food processor or ble
Avocado_skillet

Avocado_skillet

710 likes

A top-down view of a Ninja Creami pint filled with light yellow ice cream, topped with mini marshmallows and cereal pieces. Text overlays indicate "Ninja Creami Rice Krispie Treat" and "36 G PROTEIN".
A blender cup containing white powder and yellow liquid ingredients, ready to be blended. The recipe ingredients for the protein ice cream base are listed next to the blender.
A Ninja Creami pint filled with a light yellow liquid mixture, with a blue lid placed beside it. The text instructs to transfer the mixture to the pint and freeze for 24 hours.
Rice Krispie Treat Protein Ice Cream
#ricekrispies #ninjacreami #proteinicecreamrecipe #proteindessertrecipe #ninjacreamirecipe
stacyspacetayler

stacyspacetayler

196 likes

Simple Protein Ice cream 🤌🍓
✨Strawberry Cheesecake✨THIS IS SO GOOD This recipe is Greek yogurt based, I will post more with other options such as cottage cheese, protein powder, etc. 🥣This makes 1 serving! If you want more, double or triple recipe🙂 Ingredients 1 1/4 Cup strawberry Greek yogurt (I used chobani zero sugar
TravelWithNoelle ✨✈️

TravelWithNoelle ✨✈️

82 likes

A close-up of pumpkin pie protein ice cream in a clear container, topped with crushed cookie pieces. A whole cookie is visible in the background. The image features the text 'PUMPKIN PIE PROTEIN ICE CREAM' and a small pumpkin graphic.
Pumpkin Pie Protein Ice Cream
Ninja Creami Ice Cream Recipe- Ingredients: 1 cup Fairlife 2% milk (can use any kind of milk but I like fairlife best) 1/2 cup unsweetened almond milk 1 tbsp vanilla instant pudding mix 1 scoop vanilla protein powder 1/4 c cottage cheese (optional but makes creamy and adds more protein)
Alyssa Greene

Alyssa Greene

101 likes

A close-up overhead view of cookie butter protein ice cream in a clear container, topped with cinnamon chips and a spoon. Text overlays read 'Cookie Butter Protein Ice Cream W/ Cinnamon Chips' and 'LOW CALORIE & HIGH PROTEIN!'. The image also shows 'Lemon8 @jumbeezy'.
Cookie Butter Protein Ice CreamW/ Cinnamon Chips
-1 scoop vanilla protein powder -12 oz Fairlife milk -1 packet butterscotch sugar-free pudding mix -1 tbsp cookie butter -dash of cinnamon -1 tbsp of cinnamon chips (topping) Instructions: 1. In a blender (or right in the pint), mix all of the ingredients (except for the cinnamon chips)
jumbeezy

jumbeezy

429 likes

A flat lay of ingredients including a package of Oreo Thins, a tub of Zero Sugar Cool Whip, a box of Honey Graham Crackers, and a packet of Mint Chocolate Protein Powder, laid out on a light-colored surface.
Four rectangular graham crackers are arranged side-by-side on a sheet of parchment paper, ready for the next step in the recipe.
A clear glass bowl contains a generous amount of white, creamy zero sugar cool whip, prepared for mixing with other ingredients.
Protein Oreo ice cream sandwich🍦🍫
128cals & 3.6g protein #proteinideas #highproteinsweets #dessert #highproteinideas
Lainey

Lainey

311 likes

CHOCOLATE PB NINJA CREAMI PROTEIN ICE CREAM ✨✨
260 calories & 30g protein for the chocolate pb ninja creami base!! ✨✨ #proteinicecream #ninjacreamirecipe #ninjacreamiproteinicecream #ninjacreamiproteinrecipe #ninjacreamiicecream
Kayla Berman

Kayla Berman

76 likes

A hand holds a clear cup of yellow cake batter protein ice cream, topped with white cream and colorful rainbow sprinkles. Text overlays indicate '24g of protein' and 'sprinkles', highlighting it as 'cake batter ice cream w/ the ninja creami'.
protein CAKE BATTER ICE CREAM!🧁
the cold stone cake batter ice cream is TOP TIER and I tried my best to copy that but make it protein version! I wish I had bites of vanilla cake to toss in which would have elevated this ice cream so much more!! ingredients: 🧁vanilla fairlife protein shake (24g of protein) 🧁2 tablespoons cake
ganna sumar

ganna sumar

467 likes

High protein peach ice cream
INGREDIENTS 1 16 oz container full fat cottage cheese ¼ cup honey ½ teaspoon vanilla extract 1 peach - chopped with pit removed ⅓ cup graham crackers* INSTRUCTIONS Add cottage cheese, honey, vanilla and peaches to a food processor or blender. Blend until smooth. Add graham. You want th
Avocado_skillet

Avocado_skillet

736 likes

High protein ice cream recipe
One of my favorite ways to enjoy a treat at the end of the day and also get in a bunch of protein is to make me a ninja creami! My favorite flavor would have to be this cookie dough one! Especially because the cookie dough bites (found at target) are sooo yummy! Sometimes I’ll add in a brownie bite
Lyss

Lyss

300 likes

Butter Pecan Protein Ice Cream 🍨
#proteindessert #lowcaloriefood #ninjacreamirecipe #proteinicecream #butterpecan
stacyspacetayler

stacyspacetayler

40 likes

A hand holds a clear container of Cosmic Brownie Protein Ice Cream, topped with colorful sprinkles. Nutritional information for protein, carbs, and fat is displayed on the image.
Ingredients for Cosmic Brownie Protein Ice Cream are laid out, including protein powder, chocolate milk, sugar-free pudding mix, and sprinkles, with blending instructions overlaid.
Three clear containers filled with the ice cream mixture are shown on a kitchen scale, with instructions to freeze overnight and then spin on a lite ice cream mode.
Cosmic Brownie Protein Ice Cream 🔥
#fyp #ninjacreamirecipe #protein
jumbeezy

jumbeezy

217 likes

A hand with pink nail polish holds a clear cup of protein cookie dough ice cream, topped with chocolate chips and cookie dough pieces. Text overlays indicate it contains 42g of protein and was made with a Ninja Creami.
PROTEIN cookie dough ice cream!!🍪🍨
a classic recipe that EVERYONE loves! ingredients: 🍪 fairlife core power vanilla protein shake 🍪 2 tablespoons vanilla pudding mix 🍪 handful of Ben + Jerry’s frozen cookie dough 🍪 mini chocolate chips (for the topping) mix + freeze for 12-24 hours! mix in cookie dough and chocolate chips
ganna sumar

ganna sumar

811 likes

HIGH PROTEIN PISTACHIO CHEESECAKE ICE CREAM: 🍨 

DAY 3 of 30: HIGH PROTEIN PISTACHIO CHEESECAKE ICE CREAM: 🍨 This high protein Pistachio Cheesecake Ice cream has 40 grams of protein and is absolutely delicious! You only need a couple ingredients and it’s so easy to make! This is the perfect treat and is made with cottage cheese! You have to m
DayamifromMiami

DayamifromMiami

506 likes

Pan fried oats + protein ice cream recipe💪
I make healthy easy to make recipes daily! A follow, like, and comment helps me so much! Enjoy some OverallEats:) 345 cal Ninja Creami Ingredients - 2c Fat Free Fairlife milk - 0.5c egg whites - 1 scp protein powder - 1tbsp sugar free jello mix - Splash of vanilla extract - Salt Totals
OverallEats

OverallEats

812 likes

A clear container of creamy, light yellow protein banana pudding ice cream with a golden spoon, held by a hand with blue nails. A black Ninja Creami machine is visible in the background on a tiled counter. The text "PROTEIN BANANA PUDDING ICE CREAM" is overlaid.
Ninja creami PROTEIN banana pudding ice cream 🍌🍨
my go to ninja creami recipe •1/2 cup fair life 2% milk •1/2 cup almond milk •1 scoop vanilla protein •2 tablespoons sugar free banana cream jello mix •2 table spoons of nonfat Greek yogurt -Mix in: half banana and a few vanilla wafers -Top with cool whip #ninjacreami #ninjacreamire
Brittany Loye

Brittany Loye

59 likes

A Ninja Creami machine on a kitchen counter with two containers of protein ice cream. The machine displays various settings like ICE CREAM, SORBET, and GELATO. The image is overlaid with the text "Protein Ice Cream."
A container of protein ice cream, topped with mini Oreos. The ingredients listed are Fairlife Chocolate Protein Shake, Cookies & Cream Jello Pudding mix, and Mini Oreos, for a cookies and cream flavor.
A container of protein ice cream, topped with graham cracker crumbs and cookie dough pieces. The ingredients listed are Milk, Ghost Cinnabon Protein, Cheesecake Jello Mix, Graham Crackers, and Cookie Dough Pieces.
Ninja Creami || Protein Ice Cream 🍦🍨
Here are my #ninjacreami #proteinicecream for the week! Super quick and easy to throw together, and taste really good! I like to use the jello packs for an easy way to flavor different ice creaks I want each time. You can use sugar free versions as well, they are low calorie and you can
✰ Izzybellamar

✰ Izzybellamar

52 likes

Animal Cookies protein ice cream
INGREDIENTS • Vanilla Fairlife Core Power Shake • 1 Tbsp Sugar Free Vanilla Pudding • 1 tsp Almond Extract • 28g of Frosted Animal Cookies Let me know if you give this one a try!!! #ninjacreami #ninjacreamirecipe #proteinicecream #fairlifeproteinshakes #highproteindessert #high
Britni Wukasch

Britni Wukasch

18 likes

See more