Book Review: The Scammer
The Scammer is an interesting novel posing as a psychological thriller. This book is potentially inspired by the father who moved into Sarah Lawerance College with his daughter and her roommates. He was later charged with racketeering, sex trafficking, forced labor, and so much more. There are also faint hints of influence from the Natureboy cult and other “black power” based cults that swept through Black YouTube not too long ago. Combining the two concepts is such an intriguing idea. Unfortunately for me, the execution didn’t quite capture its potential.
First, let’s talk about the pacing. This kind of story is posed to speak to the delicate manipulation that can lead to full on exploitation that college students experience and that people experience in cults. I believe Tiffany aims to explore the exploitation of race and naivety within black college culture. With that being said, the pacing is too fast, the manipulation not subtle. Also, the narration sometimes felt like too much tell and not enough show. We were told that Devonte was charismatic, but it never truly came across in his behavior. The speed at which the people assimilated was so quick, it felt unrealistic. This pacing also impacted the characterization.
We didn’t get enough time to truly invest in our characters. They didn’t have enough depth to drag any true emotion or concern out of me. Especially Jordan, who had the perfect potential backstory with what happened with her brother, and why she wanted to come to Frazier. The rest of the girls didn’t have much substance either. I know this is a thriller, and everyone is supposed to be mysterious, but for me to be afraid for them, I had to like them. I had to feel they were human, and there was nothing there to give me that feeling. Plus, the decisions everyone made went way beyond suspension of disbelief. I found myself annoyed with every decision they made. It was hard for me to believe that they could adapt a random man into their life so easily, even if he was their new roommate’s brother.
Speaking of Devonte, his foundation was so rocky that it was surprising any of the girls bought his act. Only a few of them were sheltered and they all came to a great school for various reasons. They all should have had a healthy dose of skepticism that could have been ebbed away over time. Also, Devonte’s long speeches often felt like info dumps for the reader.
Finally, let’s talk about Nick. He is a very interesting character to plop in the middle of this story. While I can appreciate his and Jordan’s connection, it feels misplaced here. You’re telling me that out of all the people that met Devonte, the ONLY WHITE MAN on campus was the one who “saved” Jordan. He was the only one who saw through Devonte’s BS? Then the way he ran the frat house was very suspect. Not to mention his backstory 🙄. Tiffany D Jackson had a brilliant concept. I applaud her way of thinking. I believe a l more intentional commentary on black on black exploitation and more careful suspense building could have added life to this story. Lastly, the plot twist at the end was interesting, but I believe that if the hidden plot twist negatively impacts the characterization in a story, then it isn’t a beneficial plot twist. Some of Jordan’s choices were because of the plot twist we didn’t know about, but her choices in line with the story didn’t make the plot twist worthwhile. The white savior with the deep black background, slut shaming self hating parents, and polarizing plot twist left me disenchanted by The Scammer.
#blackbookreviewer #thrillerbookrecommendations #blackgirlslemon8 #booktok
After diving deep into Coco J's thoughts on Tiffany D. Jackson's 'The Scammer,' I couldn't help but reflect on what makes a psychological thriller truly captivating. This genre thrives on suspense, manipulation, and often a slow burn that gradually unravels a twisted reality. 'The Scammer' promises this, drawing inspiration from chilling real-life events like the infamous Sarah Lawrence cult case, where a father moved in with his daughter's college roommates, leading to exploitation and criminal charges. The premise of exploiting vulnerability within a college setting, as suggested by the book, is incredibly unsettling and ripe for a gripping read. For those curious about the plot, 'The Scammer' introduces us to a group of college girls whose lives are upended when a charismatic, older man, Devonte, infiltrates their close-knit circle. He quickly begins to exert control, manipulating them through various means, much like the hand manipulating puppets on the book's cover. The story aims to explore themes of power dynamics, exploitation, and the subtle ways trust can be eroded. It's a tale designed to make you question human nature and the ease with which people can fall prey to charismatic figures. Tiffany D. Jackson is known for her compelling YA thrillers, often tackling tough, relevant social issues. Her ability to craft tense narratives is usually a standout, which makes the critiques in Coco J's review all the more interesting. Many readers come to her work expecting a certain level of psychological depth and suspense, and 'The Scammer' certainly has elements that speak to her signature style. If you're considering picking up 'The Scammer,' it's widely available. You can find the physical book at major retailers like Amazon, Barnes & Noble, or support your local independent bookstore. For those who prefer listening, 'The Scammer' audiobook is also an option, perfect for commutes or while doing chores. Listening to thrillers can add another layer of immersion, especially with a good narrator who brings the characters' voices and the escalating tension to life. Speaking of the book, have you seen the stunning cover for 'The Scammer'? It's so striking – that hand manipulating figures like puppets against a purple and pink backdrop really sets the tone for a darker story. The visual perfectly captures the theme of control and deception central to the narrative. While the review highlights some areas where the execution might have faltered, the core concept remains powerful, especially when you consider its unsettling real-world parallels. It certainly sparks a conversation about exploitation and vulnerability, particularly within young adult communities.
