This or That Makeup Edition 🤍

Sharing some of my favorite products. All my honest opinions #makeup #fyp

2025/10/22 Edited to

... Read moreChoosing the right makeup products can often feel overwhelming due to the sheer number of options available today. Based on the insights shared in the original article, let's dive deeper into selecting blushes, foundations, and powders that match your preferences. For blushes, the comparison between NYX's buttermelt blush and Rare Beauty highlights the decision between natural versus glow finishes. NYX is great if you prefer a soft, natural look ideal for everyday wear, while Rare Beauty offers a more radiant effect that suits special occasions or when you want a lively complexion. When it comes to foundation, be cautious about potential undertones like gray casts, which can affect how the product looks on your skin, especially around the chin area as noted with L'Oréal. Lancome and L’Oréal foundations are popular but sometimes have nuances in color matching, so testing before purchase is valuable. Ulta’s sales can be a good opportunity to try pricier foundations without the full investment. Setting powders like those from Maybelline and Essence have their strengths and weaknesses. Maybelline offers solid coverage but could improve with a pink or purple tint to correct dullness or sallowness in skin tone. Essence’s loose setting powder is effective, but some may find it too pink, which can shift your makeup’s undertone undesirably. Colourpop foundations and powders tend to be more transparent and may require layering for pigmentation, making them suitable if you aim for a light or barely-there makeup look. Finally, don’t forget that personal preferences, skin type, and makeup goals should guide your product choices. Reviews like these help set expectations but trying products personally, reading ingredients, and considering your skin’s unique needs lead to the best results.

8 comments

Sasha Whyte's images
Sasha Whyte

You know Maybelline has a pink powder now

Lee Lanae 🇭🇹's images
Lee Lanae 🇭🇹

Do you color correct your chin before putting on makeup? I find that helps. It could still be the foundation but you never know. I live the comparisons.

See more comments

Related posts

A clear container filled with various elf cosmetics products, including concealers, lip balms, primers, and powders, with 'Buy or BYEE Elf edition' text overlay.
Four elf Hydrating Camo Concealers with green checkmarks and positive feedback, alongside three elf 16HR Camo Concealers with red X marks and negative feedback, on a fluffy surface.
A four-panel image showing elf Hydrating Core Lip Shine (BYE), elf Glow Reviver Lip Oil (Buy), elf Squeeze Me Lip Balms (Buy), and elf Ride or Die Lip Balm (BYE).
Buy ✅ or BYE❌ Elf makeup edition
You know I love me some elf so that means I have a lot of elf products some that I’ve restocked and obviously some that I haven’t but the ones I currently have on hand. I will definitely give y’all what I recommend Everyone knows that elf is either still in the middle of their branding or they’r
Nyxslyfe🪷

Nyxslyfe🪷

12.8K likes

Buy ✅ or bye❌ elf makeup edition
I have always used @elfcosmetics products. Most of them are staples in my collection and they are extremely affordable!!! To be honest with you, elf does it better than most luxury brands. They are a perfect company for you to learn with because it is so easy to use! Some products are not my
Abbie Stricklen

Abbie Stricklen

2320 likes

A collage of six hands holding various makeup products, including lip oils, mascaras, primers, foundations, and highlighter sticks. The central text reads 'BUY Or BYE Drugstore Edition,' indicating a review of affordable beauty items.
A hand holds two lip oils. One is a dark red, recommended as a 'Buy' ('Divine wine'). The other is a shimmery light pink, marked as 'Bye' ('candy coded') because the color is not preferred.
A hand holds two mascara products, one white and one rose gold. The white product is identified as a primer, and both are recommended as a 'Buy,' with the primer being essential for the mascara.
Run! don’t walk (drugstore makeup edition)
Love all the “buys” I picked out and most of them I use daily!! I never reach for the purple essence mascara or the candy coded lip oil, they just don’t work me at all and that’s okay! Make sure to save this for later when you’re shopping and follow me for more beauty content!💋 TikTok/insta: s
Sarah 💌

Sarah 💌

672 likes

A collage featuring a woman with fall makeup, showcasing drugstore products like Elf lip oil, Milani blush, Milani lip liner, Essence mascara, and Elf lip balm, highlighting affordable fall makeup options.
A collage focused on lip makeup, displaying various lip looks and drugstore products including Elf lip oils, Elf lip balm in blackberry sorbet, and NYX lip liners in different shades.
A collage centered on bronzer, featuring models with bronzed skin and drugstore bronzer products from Physicians Formula, Essence bronzing sticks, and NYX Butter Melt Bronzer.
Fall Makeup (drugstore edition) 💋🍂
Scroll for some of my favorite recommendations for fall makeup options that WON’T break the bank! Keep reading caption below for the list of all the products! ⬇️ There are so many great options in the drugstore price range that work just as well (if not better) than the high end. I use these myself
Anna June

Anna June

1142 likes

BUY or BYE - E.L.F Edition
I love Elf but some products didn’t really work for me! Daily Song: ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5: Today’s song is “The 30th” by Billie Eilish. This song is about a car accident that someone close to Billie got into. It hits hard. Did you know that Billie Eilish is releasing her new album “Hit Me Har
n

n

1257 likes

A top-down view of a white drawer filled with various makeup products, including tubes, compacts, brushes, and sponges, organized in clear plastic trays. The image has text overlays indicating a makeup review titled 'BUY OR BYE! * MAKEUP *' and 'my opinion!!!!'.
A boxed face makeup product, with an inset image showing the open compact containing a pink highlighter. The text overlay expresses a positive opinion, stating an obsession with this highlighter.
A pink spray bottle of mattifying waterproof setting spray standing on a white surface. The text overlay gives a positive review, noting its effectiveness for oily skin and its ability to keep makeup in place.
BUY OR BYE?! makeup edition🥰👋🏼
this is all based on my personal opinion, and every product works differently for everyone!!🩷🩷 #buyorbye #makeup #beautyfinds #ViralBeauty #viralmakeup #Lemon8
myra

myra

1098 likes

Makeup ideas summer edition
Summer makeup just hits different. Glossy lips, golden skin, sunkissed blush, and looks that make you feel pretty even in 90° weather ☀️💄✨ This summer I’m trying new makeup ideas, stepping out of my comfort zone, and finding looks that give effortless, glowy, beachy vibes every single time 🌺🤍 #su
🐆🤍Bella🤍🐆

🐆🤍Bella🤍🐆

253 likes

A person with dark skin wears a black furry hat and a light-colored top, looking at the camera. Text overlays read 'BLACK GIRL MAKEUP PRODUCTS High end edition'.
A light pink bottle of primer is shown against a white background. Text above identifies it as a primer.
Two foundation bottles, one white and one brown, are displayed with swatches. Text highlights their award-winning status and features like coverage and shade range.
BLACK GIRL MAKEUP ESSENTIALS (high end edition)
Hey guys! These are my holy grails . Let me know if you want a drugstore/affordable version . An in depth tutorial of these products will be on my tiktok @queencessa3! #darkskinwomen #darkskinmakeup #darkskinmakeuptutorial #blackgirlcreator #blackgirlmakeup #blackgirlmakeuptutorial
Queencess

Queencess

7535 likes

A hand holds three makeup pencils in a store aisle, with text overlay "Buy or bye Walmart Edition" and decorative flames, butterflies, and rainbow hearts.
A hand holds a white and yellow box for a sunscreen and makeup primer, rated as a 'BUY' for being unnoticeable, working well under makeup, giving a glow, and evening out skin.
A hand holds a light blue box for an eye cream, rated as a 'BYE' because it does nothing and a cheaper alternative is suggested as better.
BUY OR BYE DRUGSTORE MAKEUP EDITION
These are just my opinions. I have tried so many different drug store products and the buy ones are my daily users. I also rely on them for an accurate product review! For reference I am a very oily girl in the T zone and dry everywhere else. I cannot stand when my makeup separates so these are my
Abbie Stricklen

Abbie Stricklen

1877 likes

BUY OY BYE?! MAKEUP EDITION 💗
Buy or bye coming from an oily skin girly who has sensitive and textured skin. Top 10 must haves - Dior foundation - Milani conceal + perfect - Smashbox photo finish control - Elf liquid blush - Charlotte Tilbury pressed powder - Rare beauty bronzer stick - Huda beauty setting powde
noemerzzz

noemerzzz

1062 likes

THIS or THAT beauty edition
Let’s play This or That! beauty edition First up we have setting spray; Charlotte Tilbury vs milk. The winner is… Charlotte Tilbury!! I like this product better because of the product packaging, I like how the product sprays on my face better. This also makes my makeup last all day! Next up
Olivia Masullo

Olivia Masullo

9 likes

A flat lay of various pink and white cosmetic products, including compacts, lip glosses, and brushes, with a text overlay asking about the value of makeup items.
Two hands holding different colored spray bottles of a cosmetic product, one green and one blue, against a bright blue sky background.
A clear tube of cosmetic primer and a clear spray bottle of setting spray, both with white text, against a vibrant teal background.
Yay or nay: Makeup Edition Part 1
🌸Milk primer / setting spray: $20-$40 love the way it feels on my skin definitely would re purchase. 🌸E.L.F. Primer / setting spray: $11-$25 if you like the milk primer / spray you’ll love this one feels the same & is cheaper. 🌸Haus Labs foundation: $52 doesn’t make my face look/feel cakey ,
Jessy 💗

Jessy 💗

54 likes

skin prep before makeup: winter edition❄️🫧
the skincare you do before applying makeup is so important if you want flawless makeup that doesn’t cake, crease, or melt off by the end of the day - ESPECIALLY in the winter!! here’s my skin prep routine (on dry, acne-prone skin) for hydrated, glowy makeup!! ⭐️ 🥛 rhode glazing mist + byoma milk
taylor nicole🎀

taylor nicole🎀

49 likes

A person's face with text overlay indicating "MY TOP 3 MAKEUP PRODUCTS BASE EDITION SWIPE !" and a Lemon8 username. The image serves as a title slide for a makeup product review.
Three primer products are displayed on a wooden surface, including a tube, a pot, and a smaller tube. Quilted makeup bags are visible in the background. Text labels identify each product as a primer.
Three skin tint products are shown on a wooden surface, consisting of two pump bottles and one tube. Quilted makeup bags are in the background. Text labels identify each product as a skin tint.
top 3 makeup products: base edition 🎀
My top 3 holy grail makeup products in every base category ✨ I’ve played with and tested SO many different makeup products and found some that work great and others… not so much😅 So here are my current faves for my dry, acne-prone skin: 🧴 PRIMER: Refy Glow and Sculpt, E.L.F. Poreless Putty Pr
taylor nicole🎀

taylor nicole🎀

36 likes

A flat lay of various makeup products on a light fabric, including concealers, mascaras, blushes, a lip oil, a highlighter stick, and a pressed powder. The image is titled "Buy or Bye Makeup Edition" and includes a "SWIPE" indicator.
A tube of concealer is shown with a "Bye" rating. Text highlights negative attributes such as not being long-lasting, looking patchy, drying too fast, and creasing. Price information is also displayed.
A bottle of concealer is shown with a "Buy" rating. Text highlights positive attributes such as not creasing, high coverage, long wear, and a creamy texture. Price information is also displayed.
Buy👍 or Bye👎 (makeup edition)
⭐️ Elf Matte Camp Concealer / Overall rating: 0/10 I personally do not like this concealer because it dries too fast, it is patchy and it creases. I got beef with this concealer, it is a no for me! Price: $7.00 ⭐️Born This Way Concealer / Overall rating: 100/10 I love this concealer! It is t
Vale Mejia 🎀

Vale Mejia 🎀

531 likes

COLLEGE EDITION: easy and simple makeup routine
Here is my college easy + simple makeup routine for days that I want a little more coverage. Most of these items (aside from the Fenty contour stick) are affordable and last a lifetime. This makeup is great for when you want a little refresh before an interview or before class. Nothing too heavy-bu
mallory

mallory

15 likes

Yay or Nay? Makeup Edition part 2
🌸Nivea Moisturizer: $1-$13 Love how soft this lotion leaves my face and body *I buy the big bottle* 🌸Cerave Moisturizer: $5-$19 would say it works about the same as the Nivea one , i usually buy the small bottle when i’m traveling. In the end I would recommend either of depending on your budget b
Jessy 💗

Jessy 💗

56 likes

8AM Class Makeup Routine (College Girl Edition) 🌸📚
College mornings are usually almost always a rush for me so I needed makeup that I can throw on fast and that actually stays on through long lectures and walking to class in the Florida heat. These are the products I’ve been using forever and they NEVER fail me. If you struggle with looking awake a
victoria esposito

victoria esposito

239 likes

No Gatekeeping: Fav Drugstore Makeup Edition ✨
Good makeup doesn’t have to be expensive! The price of makeup these days is just insane. I go to Sephora and I spend $50 on one item. 😭 here are some of my favorite drug store dupes that I feel like do the same job if not better than their more expensive counterpart. What is your favorite dupe?
Mayarenecampos

Mayarenecampos

133 likes

A person wearing a green cap and a light cardigan stands in front of a mirror, with text overlay indicating a beauty edition comparison.
Two contour products are displayed: a golden tube and a small white stick. Text describes one as a warm shade with easy application, also usable as bronzer.
Two red blush products are shown: a small bottle of stain and a bottle of dewy blush. Text highlights the stain as natural-looking, long-lasting, and enduring.
THIS or THAT beauty edition
Let’s play: This or That Beauty Edition!!! First up we have Contours. Our contenders are Charlotte Tilbury’s contour wand and milk makeup’s contour stick. The winner… Charlotte Tilbury!!! I like the shade better on Charlotte’s it’s more of a warm shade as opposed to Milk’s cool shade and it jus
Olivia Masullo

Olivia Masullo

8 likes

How to look good at school 🌸NO makeup edition🌸
I’m obsessed with makeup but sometimes I just wanna rock a bare face. I’ve noticed that I feel more put together whenever I have a glossy lip balm on and my lashes curled. It does make a difference! I feel more confident with my bare face and acne scars this way. Let me know if I should go more
Salomé Alvarado

Salomé Alvarado

316 likes

Makeup buy or bye - elf edition 💌💄
I wanted to share my makeup buy or byes with you! Buttt this one is all about elf products! I just want to put this out there that all of the “high end” makeup buys I initially got as a gift but would definitely repurchase with my own money 🫶 💌 contour BUY - Charlotte Tilbury Contour wand BYE
Sophia 🤍🧸

Sophia 🤍🧸

47 likes

Love Island Makeup: Sephora Haul Edition 🥥✨
Laneige Glaze Craze Tinted Lip Balm 🫐 ∘ keeps lips hydrated for so long and the color is so nice and subtle! One/size On ‘Til Dawn Setting Spray 🍋 ∘ this is going to keep your makeup in place ALL DAY, won’t budge, and is waterproof! Dae Cactus Fruit 3-in-1 Styling Cream 🫐 ∘ keeps hair styl
Nat🎀

Nat🎀

165 likes

A collage showcasing various makeup palettes found at Marshalls, including BT21, Urban Decay, Pat McGrath Labs, and ABH Norvina, with text overlays 'Marshalls Finds! Makeup Edition' and a 'Swipe' indicator.
Six 'The Crème Shop BT21 Color Palettes' are displayed, each featuring a different BT21 character and a unique 9-shade eyeshadow collection, such as 'Mauve with Me' and 'Cocoa Crunch'.
A 'Morphe 2 Ready for anything 12 pan Eyeshadow Palette' is shown, featuring a range of neutral and warm-toned eyeshadows in circular pans within a white compact.
Marshalls Finds‼️ Makeup Edition
💋Hey everyone! I hope you’re all having a wonderful day. If you’re new here WELCOME 🤗 If you’ve been here before I’m glad you’re back 🥰 💋I check out my local Marshalls every now and then and I ALWAYS run into some hidden high end and drugstore gems 💎 A lot of high end items I own I’ve gotten i
HeyItsAshleyK1

HeyItsAshleyK1

21 likes

Boujee on a Budget!!! Makeup Edition✨
Why spend $$$ when you can get the same glam for less? 💄✨ Here are my fave high-end makeup dupes that give you luxury vibes without the luxury price tag🏷️ #luxurybeautyforless #makeup #lemon8beauty
tiannalakiesha

tiannalakiesha

3348 likes

A collection of various skincare products arranged on a bathroom counter, including cleansers, serums, toners, and creams, with decorative doodles and text indicating a 'BUY OR BYE: Skincare Edition' theme.
A hand holding a blue healing balm stick, recommended for lips and chapped skin, with text indicating a positive review and multiple uses.
A hand holding a small bottle of niacinamide serum, described as affordable and beneficial for minimizing pores and achieving a glassy skin glow.
BUY OR BYE: Skincare Edition🫧✨💗
1. Aquaphor healing balm stick: I originally bought this bc I saw a tik tok about how you can use it under your eyes before applying concealer to help creasing! I usually use the aquaphor tube for my lips so I was intrigued and wanted to try this on my lips. LIFE CHANGING. Now I need to buy an ext
𝐄𝐯✿

𝐄𝐯✿

522 likes

Buy or Bye? (make up edition)
These are the products that I bought for daily use. But some of them are bye for me. 👇🏼 First would be the elf primer neutralizing green, i tried this to reduce my redness before putting make up but i don't really like the texture of the result in my skin everytime i'm using this. While
Ira Diocson

Ira Diocson

437 likes

Spring makeup (animal edition)
If you said avatar, I’m so sad 😭 Those are mythical creatures. This is a blue giraffe. I know something you’ve never seen probably won’t ever see again , but I thought it’d be really cool because I was doing a makeup Collab with some of my fellow makeup girlies and we did an animal theme liv
Nyxslyfe🪷

Nyxslyfe🪷

533 likes

calculating my makeup routine - college edition
I just calculated my daily makeup routine and I’m in between “Wow that actually isn’t that bad” and “Wow that’s more than I thought, considering most of it is drugstore makeup.” To be fair, these products have lasted me a long time, and I know I won’t have to repurchase most of these products for a
julie lui

julie lui

107 likes

See more