DOM by S.J Tilly Review 🫣

⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 (3.5/5 stars)

Dom hooked me right away—I actually loved Dom in the beginning and thought I was in for a swoony ride. But then he made a series of dumb, frustrating choices that quickly had me hating him for most of the story. Thankfully, his redemption arc in the last quarter turned everything around, and by the end I was rooting for him again.

Valentine, though, was a little harder for me to connect with. I usually love a strong, bad-ass female lead, and I just didn’t get those vibes from her. Instead, she felt very broken and sad, which was heartbreaking. I cried multiple times for her, and it made me so happy when she finally got the family and love she had always deserved.

One of the best parts for me was when Dan stood up for his wife and called out her family. That moment was powerful and so validating after everything Valentine had gone through.

Overall, this book was cute and emotional. The pacing frustrated me in the middle, but the ending was worth it—Dom redeemed himself, Valentine got her happy ending, and I was left satisfied. 💁🏼‍♀️😏

#BookReviews #unfiltered #lemon8bookclub #bookreccomendation

2025/8/30 Edited to

... Read moreOne aspect that really stood out to me was the portrayal of a "soft dom" in the character of Dom. Unlike traditional dominant figures, Dom’s journey explores vulnerability and growth, making his story far more relatable. For readers curious about what a "soft dom" means, this book offers a nuanced perspective that balances strength with emotional sensitivity. Valentine’s character arc also deserves deeper appreciation. Although she initially appears fragile and broken, her resilience shines through as she navigates complex family dynamics and personal trauma. The moment when Dom defends her against her family felt particularly empowering and added a layer of authenticity to their relationship. Fans of redemption plots might find DOM both challenging and rewarding, as it dives into the messy process of making mistakes and seeking forgiveness. The author, S.J. Tilly, skillfully combines emotional turmoil with moments of tenderness, creating a realistic and engaging love story. For those interested in exploring character-driven romance with themes of protection, empowerment, and emotional healing, DOM provides a compelling read. Additionally, the artistic side of the fandom, including fan art inspired by Dom and Valentine, speaks to the impact of these characters beyond the pages. If you’re intrigued by layered characters and transformative relationships, DOM by S.J. Tilly is worth your attention.

Related posts

A hand holds four black books from 'The Alliance' series by S.J. Tilly, titled 'Nero,' 'King,' 'Dom,' and 'Hans,' featuring gold lettering and emblems, against a gray furry background.
A dark image shows multiple hands holding various firearms in a circular arrangement, pointing towards the center, where the text 'THE ALLIANCE' is displayed.
A collage of images representing 'Nero: Alliance Book One' by S.J. Tilly, featuring a man in a suit, a woman, a beagle, money, a city skyline, and intimate scenes.
The Alliance by S. J. Tilly
Our series of the week is the Alliance series by S.J. Tilly. It’s a mafia dark romance series that has four interconnected solo books that feature some of the hottest men in book history. Nero, The first time I took a man’s life, I knew there’d be no going back. No normal existence in the cards f
Book Bliss and Chicks

Book Bliss and Chicks

8 likes

The book cover for "DOM" by S.J. Tilly features a man in a suit embracing a woman in a dark, strapless, high-slit dress. The background is dark with blue floral patterns. Text on the cover includes the title and author, along with phrases like "VALENT" and "protect you."
Book Review: DOM - S.J. Tilly
DOM by S.J. Tilly is another reason I’ll never recover from fictional men. Mafia? Check. Obsession? Check. A man who’d burn the world for her? Absolutely. Was it toxic? Yes. Did I love every second? Also yes. DOMINIC the man that you are!! #BookTok #DarkRomanceBooks #MafiaRomance #SJTil
Chrissy's Kindle Reads 📚🤍

Chrissy's Kindle Reads 📚🤍

3 likes

📕 Nero By SJ Tilly
I don’t even need the big red bow this year! Just drop him off Santa! #mafiaromancereaders #darkromancereads #darkromance #alliwantforchristmas #kindleunlimited
XoChanReads

XoChanReads

1 like

Latte Darling by SJ Tilly
A cute refresh from dark romance! SJ Tilly is quickly becoming my favorite author for AMAZING plus size representation. The MMCs always love and are so deeply attracted to the FMCs in her books without any discussion of changing them or losing weight. Pure lust and attraction to plus size women is
Becks

Becks

9 likes

An advertisement for S.J. Tilly's book "Mountain Daddy," featuring a rugged, bearded man in an open plaid shirt. The image displays two book covers, one physical and one on a tablet, with text "RELEASE WEEK" and "JULY 31." The background has faded "MOUNTAIN DADDY" text.
Mountain Daddy by SJ Tilly Release Week
IT’S MOUNTAIN DADDY WEEK!!! 🥳🤩😍 Daddy is out Thursday, July 31st - in all formats. Preorder to get it asap and have him drop onto your kindle after midnight on Wednesday. https://a.co/d/f25aKFt ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥 #sjtilly #sjtillyauthor #sjtillymountainmen #mountainda
Payton Holloway

Payton Holloway

2 likes

The alliance series by SJ Tilly
#booktok #readersoflemon8 #books #recommendations #romancebookrecommendations
Courtney 📚

Courtney 📚

1 like

The audiobook cover for 'Dear Rosie, love letters book two' by S.J. Tilly, narrated by Andi Arndt & Christian Fox. It features a man with a beard and an unbuttoned white shirt, revealing his chest. The bottom shows 'End Credits' and 'Lemon8 @beccamari39'.
Dear, Rosie by SJ Tilly
I've been on an SJ Tilly kick and I'm absolutely in love with her writing and characters. The fact that all her FMCs are unapologetically plus sized is so refreshing. I loved the dynamic between Rosie and Nathan, they were so funny and flirty and actually laughed out loud a couple times. Th
Becks

Becks

1 like

Tilly bagel review 🥯
Yummmm! Have you tried Tilly bagel yet? #bagelreview #bagels 🥯 #foodie
JENNIFER 🖤 | CHICAGO 🏙️

JENNIFER 🖤 | CHICAGO 🏙️

24 likes

The book cover for "Mountain Daddy" by S.J. Tilly features a rugged man with a white beard, open plaid shirt revealing a hairy chest and abs, against a misty forest background. The title "MOUNTAIN DADDY" is in large orange letters.
Mountain Daddy by S.J. Tilly is now live!

Mountain Daddy by S.J. Tilly is now live! Kendra Moving into my dad’s house at age thirty-two because my roommate scammed me out of my rent… not exactly what I’d call winning at life. So on my drive to Colorado, I decide I need one more night of freedom, and the cute motel on the side of the r
Payton Holloway

Payton Holloway

3 likes

Mother Newborn Exam 1 Review
CherryCheckups

CherryCheckups

34 likes

Jennifer Tilly sits at a poker table with a pair of aces, surrounded by chips, looking at the camera in a casino setting.
Jennifer Tilly sits at a poker table, holding food, with a drink and can nearby, looking intently to her side.
Jennifer Tilly, wearing sunglasses, plays poker against Harman, with a screen showing a $3,900 pot and current hand probabilities.
Jennifer Tilly 💗
Y2k_exotica💋

Y2k_exotica💋

4 likes

The book cover for 'Hans' by S.J. Tilly, featuring a man in a tuxedo embracing a woman in a sparkly dress, set against a dark background with fiery butterfly wings.
Book Review: Hans - S.J. Tilly
He watches. He waits. He burns for her. Hans is the kind of obsessive, protective hero you don’t recover from. Final book in the Alliance series and it did not hold back. I WAS OBSESSED! 🤍 #BookTok #DarkRomance #RomanceBooks #TheAllianceSeries #SJTillyBooks
Chrissy's Kindle Reads 📚🤍

Chrissy's Kindle Reads 📚🤍

3 likes

Denim review for pear-shaped body type🍐✨
📍Location: Tilly’s 💌 Brand: Miss Me 💵 Price: $69.99 USD *currently 40% off* 👖Size: 26x32 US 🛍️Style: WEST OF MELROSE x Miss Me Womens Studded Bootcut Jeans 🔎Item #: 521329825 ⭐️ Overall rating: 9/10 👍Pros : -good quality -good amount of stretch and durability -perfect mid-rise len
aly mae

aly mae

8 likes

Coffee & Tilly❤️
The ube starbies drink is soooo good #starbuckorder Tilly girl posing for the camera 🥰🥰 #fyp #puppylovers #STARBUCKS #coffee
Harli 🩵

Harli 🩵

3 likes

Tiffany Valentine (Jennifer Tilly) Is Gorgeous
#tiffanyvalentine #jennifertilly #chuckysbride #horror #foryoupage
KINGWOLVEN

KINGWOLVEN

3 likes

Fun on Miss Tilly!
SawltyC and me, heading to dinner at Jimmy Guana's! 📍 City/Country: Indian Rocks Beach/USA #summerbod #sandycheeks #dolphinshow
ReelDealOutpost

ReelDealOutpost

9 likes

Follow TailsandTilly
Follow us on all social Medical’s TailsandTilly! Hang with us!
Tails & Tilly 🥰🐒🐒🥰

Tails & Tilly 🥰🐒🐒🥰

6 likes

A spiral notebook displays the book cover for 'KING S.J. TILLY'. The cover features a man in a suit embracing a blonde woman, with a golden crown above the title. Blurred background elements include a marriage certificate and money.
Book Review: King - S.J. Tilly
You thought Nero was a red flag? Meet King. 🔥 This book? Murder, marriage, and mafia-level obsession. I inhaled it. 5 stars. 4.5 spice. I fear I'm into criminals now. 😮‍💨📖 #booktok #darkromance #bookreview #king #sjtilly
Chrissy's Kindle Reads 📚🤍

Chrissy's Kindle Reads 📚🤍

2 likes

A hand holds a pink Nintendo Switch displaying the Super Mario Odyssey title screen with Mario and Cappy. The image is titled 'MARIO ODYSSEY REVIEW' and features a pink-themed desk background with cute accessories.
A pink Nintendo Switch shows Super Mario Odyssey gameplay where Mario has captured a frog. The image is titled 'summary' and includes a text block detailing the game's plot and Cappy's abilities.
A pink Nintendo Switch displays Super Mario Odyssey gameplay with Mario in a vibrant, colorful world. The image is titled 'my thoughts' and features a text block praising the game's addictive gameplay and beautiful worlds.
cozy gamer review of mario odyssey 💕💭🌷
hi friends! since the start of the new year, i’ve really been trying to dive into my extremely large backlog of games. i finally found myself playing super mario odyssey and i am completely addicted! this game is the most fun game i’ve played in a very long time. i highly recommend this game t
cait

cait

78 likes

A Kindle displays the book cover for "Highest Bidder" by Lauren Landish and Willow Winters, featuring a rose. The image includes a book review title, an overall series rating of 4.5 stars, and tags like auction, bdsm, master/slave, dom/sub, trauma, and very smutty.
A Kindle displays the book cover for "Highest Bidder: Bought" by Lauren Landish and Willow Winters, featuring a man. The image includes a rating of 4 stars and tags like bdsm (dom/sub), past trauma, and auction, indicating a book review.
A Kindle displays the book cover for "Highest Bidder: Sold" by Lauren Landish and Willow Winters, featuring a man. The image includes a rating of 4.5 stars and tags like master/slave, kidnapping, and past trauma, indicating a book review.
highest bidder series review
read all 5 in one day. very easy reads with all the smut. #darkromance #highestbidder #bookreviewsoflemon8 #booksummary
Hallie📖💓

Hallie📖💓

17 likes

A scenic landscape features a winding road through rolling hills with dry grass, under a dramatic sunset sky displaying orange and pink hues. Text overlays read "Let's Be FRIENDS ON SNAPCHAT ADD ME!" with a Lemon8 logo and username @tillymueller1.
tilly.mueller - Lets be friend’s
add the snapppp - tilly.mueller #findyourfriends #snapchat #unfiltered #Lemon8Diary #snapchat
T I L L Y

T I L L Y

0 likes

DADDY DOM🥰
Lexi’s Books 📚

Lexi’s Books 📚

3 likes

Tilly Talk
#tillynorwood #tilly #ai #random #actress
MedicineCabinetCartoon

MedicineCabinetCartoon

2 likes

Going to the arcade and tillys!
#arcade #funtime #tillysclothing
❄️ 𝕣𝕚𝕣𝕚 ❄️

❄️ 𝕣𝕚𝕣𝕚 ❄️

8 likes

My Baby Tilly. Doberman Pitty mix.
#gettoknowme #puppy #tilly #dog #love
Mrs.Steal_Ya_Girl

Mrs.Steal_Ya_Girl

3 likes

A book cover for 'RIDE THE LINE BOOK TWO' by Tilly Ridge and C. S. Silverne, featuring three tattooed men, two wearing motorcycle helmets. The image is an ARC review announcement for a March 5th release, with 'lemon8 @nats2004_booktok' branding.
ARC Review
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 I just finished Ride the Line, and wow! 😍 This book masterfully weaves a tale of grief, love, and unexpected connections. Marley, Maddox, and Zander's journey is raw and electrifying—one night changes everything! 🔥 The chemistry and tension between these characters are off the char
books_go_crazy

books_go_crazy

12 likes

A hand holds a Kindle displaying the eARC cover of Lucy Score's book, "Mistakes Were Made." The screen shows the title, author, and "Disaster is her middle name." Bookshelves filled with books are blurred in the background.
🪩ARC review of Mistakes Were Made By Lucy Score 💼
I thought this was a 4 star read and then I wrote my review and had nothing but love and good things to say so 5 stars!! Stats ⭐️5 🎧4 🧠2 🌶️3 Target Audience 🎯 -small town (stars hallow like) shenanigans -opposites attract -adhd rep -feeling all the emotions -beautiful character
just.here.for.book.inspo📚

just.here.for.book.inspo📚

4 likes

A book review graphic for 'Bound to the Beasts' by Ari Wright, featuring the book cover with a woman and three men. It lists tropes like 'Fairy Tale Retelling,' 'Omegaverse Romance,' and 'Why-Choose,' with a 4.5-star and 4.5-chili pepper rating.
A blurb for 'Bound to the Beasts,' describing Briar Rose's arranged marriage to Cillian Blackwood and the presence of other 'monsters' like Dane and Rhys, hinting at a reverse harem romance.
The beginning of a book review for 'Bound to the Beasts,' detailing Briar's father selling her into marriage and Cillian Blackwood's ruthless character. It includes a 4.5-star and 4.5-chili pepper rating.
ARC Review: Bound to the Beasts by Ari Wright
🌹🥀 ARC Review 🥀🌹 📖 𝐁𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐝 𝐓𝐨 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐁𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐭𝐬 by Ari Wright Story: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 / 5 Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ / 5 🥀Modern-day fairytale retelling 🌹RH/why-choose 🥀Arranged marriage 🌹Enemies-to-lovers 🥀Forced proximity 🌹Only soft for her 🥀Morally grey MMC 🌹Masked cinnamon roll MMC 🥀 Touched-starved al
FavoriteSaintReads

FavoriteSaintReads

79 likes

Gemdom Reusable Food Pouches Review
I recently went apple picking and one of the foods I made was applesauce! I wanted to have an easy to access snack for my 2 year old so I wanted to get into reusable pouches. Those applesauce packets can get expensive and have ingredients I don’t want to give my kiddos so I was excited to get these
Mel Mel

Mel Mel

5 likes

A desaturated image of a woman with wet hair and a light top, standing by the ocean or a large body of water.
𝐁𝐎𝐎𝐊 𝐑𝐄𝐕𝐈𝐄𝐖
One Last Rainy Day by Kate Stewart ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 𝐦𝐲 𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬— I loved seeing the Ravenhood trilogy through Dom’s eyes. Hated reliving the heartbreak. Getting the behind the scenes to the brotherhood and what they were planning was cool. Loved the different POVs at the end. Can’t wait to finish
lenasbookishcorner

lenasbookishcorner

0 likes

A physical copy of the book "Mountain Boss" by S.J. Tilly, with a dark green cover featuring light green illustrations, placed on a wooden surface next to a potted plant and a small figurine. The text "Book Review" is overlaid.
Book Review
Mountain Boss by S.J. Tilly (Workplace Romance) I was a little skeptical on if I was going to like this book at first and about how short the chapters were, but both got better and better as the book went on for me. Courtney getting caught talking to herself was entertaining so was how she was w
Robyn

Robyn

4 likes

Tilly Chowing Down On Christmas
My girl Tilly chowing down for Christmas. Know the fellas will appreciate this! Can we get some jingle bells in the chat for Tilly girl! #goat #farm #fyp #trending #HelloLemon8
G Swade

G Swade

2 likes

Book Review: Freelance Your Way to Freedom
In case you don't know, I'm obsessed with the concept of freedom and am hard at work on my own personal journey to FIRE (Financial Independence / Retire Early) and I love learning about personal finance, investing, and entrepreneurship. So obviously this book was immediately on my list as s
Andie💛

Andie💛

9 likes

See more