Chicago’s Best Pizza? 90+ People Voted 🍕

Chicago
4/25 Edited to

... Read moreHaving lived in Chicago for several years and indulged in countless pizzas from deep-dish to thin crust, I can say the city’s pizza scene is truly diverse and competitive. What makes Chicago pizza special isn’t just its iconic deep-dish style but also the passionate debates among locals about which spot offers the best slice. In my experience, trying pizza from well-known places alongside hidden gems is key to understanding the full spectrum of Chicago’s pizza culture. Many pizzerias bring something unique to the table—whether it’s the rich buttery crust, fresh homemade sauce, or innovative topping combinations. The mention of a “Chicago pizza debate” perfectly captures the enthusiasm people have over their favorite spots. It’s common to hear arguments over whether thin crust or deep dish deserves the city’s crown. What’s interesting from the poll’s results is that lesser-known places sometimes rank surprisingly high, showing how diverse tastes can be. If you want to join the conversation, I recommend going beyond the tourist favorites and visiting neighborhood pizzerias that locals swear by. Keep an eye out for the freshness of ingredients, crust texture, and balance of flavors—these elements often define the best pizza experiences in Chicago. Overall, the community’s input is invaluable and offers a richer perspective than any single review. Whether you prefer thick, hearty slices or a crispy thin crust, the Chicago pizza debate is a delicious adventure waiting to be explored by every food lover in the city.

Related posts

Chicago’s Best Pizza? Real People Voted 🍕
I asked real people in Chicago one question… who has the best pizza? 🍕 Everybody had a different answer 😳 From Italian Fiesta to Lou Malnati’s, the debate is real. Here are the most mentioned spots so far 👀 Who do you think is #1 ? #ChicagoFood #ChicagoPizza #FoodFinds #Pi
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

37 likes

Incredible Chicago Pizza Spot 🍕
This is one of my favorite spots for Chicago Pizza! This Neapolitan style is so good that it’s certified in Italy! Check out Coda di Volpe in Southport Corridor 🍕 #chicagofood #chicagopizza #chicagorestaurant #chicagofoodie #chicagocontentcreator
Kayleejochicago

Kayleejochicago

134 likes

Best Pizza in Chicago? I Asked over 80 People
I went around Chicago asking over 80 people who has the best pizza in the city 🍕 Every answer was different… Who’s your number 1 spot? #ChicagoFood #ChicagoPizza #FoodFinds #FoodReview #PizzaLovers
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

38 likes

This Chicago pizza spot got the most votes 🍕
I asked over 100 people who has the best pizza in Chicago… and this spot got the most votes 🍕 So I pulled up to see if it really lived up to the hype. Italian Fiesta (71st & Jeffery) Definitely a solid spot. Where should I go next? #chicagofood #chicagopizza #foodreview
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

168 likes

A woman sits on a boat on the Chicago River, surrounded by city buildings, with the text overlay "Actual HIDDEN GEMS IN CHICAGO" highlighting the article's theme.
A person plays a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles pinball machine at Neon Gardens in Lincoln Park, showcasing the hidden arcade gaming experience mentioned in the article.
An assortment of colorful sushi rolls is neatly arranged inside a pizza box, illustrating the unique "sushi in a pizza box" offering from Tanuki Sushi & Grill in Lakeview.
Hidden Gems in Chicago ✨
Here are some ACTUAL hidden gems in Chicago people don’t know about! 1. Neon Gardens - This place has been open for about 2 months and it is such a VIBE! Pizza and wings are crazy good and such good cocktails ! Perfect spot for a night out or pregame! Prices range from $12-$20 for food and
Millie Britt

Millie Britt

273 likes

Taylor Bennett Picks Chicago’s Best Pizza 🍕👀
I asked Taylor Bennett who has the best pizza in Chicago… and his answer might start a debate 😂🍕 Did he get it right? #ChicagoPizza #TaylorBennett #ChicagoFood #Foodie #JovanApproved
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

46 likes

A day in: Chicago, IL
Tried to make a fun itinerary, hitting all the cool spots, as well as tips to save money when visiting the city 🍕Ⓜ️🚆 #chicago #travelrecommendations #museum #chicagoitinerary #illinois
V 🦋

V 🦋

293 likes

Chicago Pizza Debate 🍕 Deep Dish or Thin Crust?
Chicago has been going back and forth on this forever… Deep dish or thin crust? 👀🍕 I went out and asked people across the city, and the answers were split. Some are loyal to that cheesy deep dish, others swear thin crust is the real Chicago pizza. So now I gotta ask you… Which one ar
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

43 likes

Who Really Has The Best Pizza In Chicago? 🍕👀
Part 12 of asking real people who has the best pizza in Chicago 🍕 The rankings keep changing and Pequod’s is making a serious run toward the top. I’m trying to find the true fan favorite in the city 👀 #ChicagoPizza #ChicagoFood #PizzaTok #ChicagoEats #JovanApproved
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

36 likes

A slice of Chicago deep-dish pizza with a thick crust, rich red sauce, and melted cheese, garnished with herbs, served on a white plate.
A screenshot displaying the ingredients list for Chicago deep-dish pizza, including items for the dough and pizza sauce.
A screenshot showing the fillings and toppings ingredients for Chicago deep-dish pizza, followed by the first step of the dough preparation directions.
Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza
#easyrecipes #quickmeals #pizza #Recipe #chicago
Just another mom

Just another mom

20 likes

BEST NEAPOLITAN PIZZA IN CHICAGO 🍕
Gallucci: 8.9/10 & $249.12 🍕 Food: 9.4/10 Quality: 9.4/10 Service: 8.5/10 Price: 8.4/10 OVERALL: 8.9/10 1551 N Wells St, Chicago, IL 60610 #galluccichicago #chicagopizza #chicago
SERGELATO

SERGELATO

39 likes

Best Pizza in Chicago? Part 4 🍕
Part 4 🍕 I asked real people in Chicago who really has the best pizza in the city… And somehow nobody agrees 😭 Who do you think has the best pizza in Chicago? #chicagofood #chicagopizza #chicagoeats #foodreview #foodcontent
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

77 likes

A travel budget dashboard for a 3-day Chicago trip for two people under $350 for activities, showing total costs, flight, accommodation, and a detailed list of activity expenses like museums and tours.
A detailed list of activity expenses for a Chicago trip, showing costs per person for attractions like the Field Museum, Centennial Wheel, Wendella Boat Architecture, Big Bus Tour, and food spots.
A daily itinerary for a 3-day Chicago trip from October 31 to November 3, 2024, outlining hourly activities such as museum visits, boat tours, park explorations, and dining experiences.
Chicago Must See 3 Day Full Itinerary under $350
WARNING! This itinerary is not for the weak. We did tons of walking all 3 days averaging about 28,000+ steps a day, so definitely wear comfy and warm shoes if you plan to follow my #chicago itinerary to the tea!! I shared earlier my flight and hotel cost, so this post focuses on activities
TheHappyPlanner

TheHappyPlanner

72 likes

Best Pizza In Chicago 🍕
MekaVuitton

MekaVuitton

69 likes

Who Has the Best Pizza in Chicago? 🍕 (Part 1)
I asked people in Chicago one simple question… Who has the best pizza? 🍕 From Giordano’s to Lou Malnati’s to Pequod’s, the answers might surprise you 👀 Part 1 — more coming soon Jovan Approved ✅ Who did they miss? 👇 #JovanApproved #ChicagoPizza #ChicagoFood #FoodShorts
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

62 likes

CHICAGO SKY & ROBERT’S PIZZA COLLAB 🏀
Robert’s Pizza: 8.6/10 & $173.64 🍕 Food: 8.4/10 Quality: 8.8/10 Service: 8.6/10 Price: 8.5/10 OVERALL: 8.6/10 465 N McClurg St, Chicago, IL 60611 #robertspizzachicago #chicagopizza #chicago
SERGELATO

SERGELATO

23 likes

Chicago deep dish chocolate pizza pie. Yeah… we said it. And before anyone argu
Yeah… we said it. And before anyone argues — we’re actually from Chicago… so we can vouch for this one 😅 You’re calling this “pizza”… but it’s really a chocolate dessert pie. Chicago didn’t approve this… we just gave it the name. This is what happens when you stop treating beans like “din
Goode Foods

Goode Foods

11 likes

Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Making Class 🍕
The most iconic cooking class in Chicago 🍕 Take a deep dish pizza making course at Pizzeria Due, which is also the Chicago restaurant where deep dish pizza was invented! Sign up for their Valentine’s Day class where you’ll be making heart-shaped deep dish ❤️ #chicagofood #chicagofoodie
Kayleejochicago

Kayleejochicago

59 likes

Best Pizza in Chicago? These Picks Wild 🍕
Part 3 🍕 I asked people in Chicago who really has the best pizza in the city… Some of these picks surprised me 😂 What spot do you think has the best pizza in Chicago? #chicagofood #chicagopizza #chicagoeats #foodreview #foodcontent
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

20 likes

Did you know about Chicago Style Thin Crust Pizza?
#chicagopizza #chicagofoodscene #chicagostyledeepdishpizza #chicagofood #chicago
b.Uniqu3

b.Uniqu3

37 likes

For people who voted for Trump now regrets they vo
BlackRican808

BlackRican808

23 likes

Who Has The Best Pizza In Chicago? 🍕 Part 11
143 real votes later and Chicago’s pizza debate is still going strong 👀🍕 Italian Fiesta is still leading the rankings. Who should I ask next? #ChicagoPizza #ChicagoFood #PizzaLover #Foodie #JovanApproved
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

61 likes

Multiple hands hold slices of thin-crust pizza from Novel Pizza Cafe, featuring longanisa giardiniera and pepperoni hot honey ricotta flavors, shared among friends in Chicago.
A hand holds a breakfast sandwich with egg and sausage on an English muffin, served on a white plate from Doma Cafe, a charming Croatian cafe perfect for brunch.
A table at Doma Cafe displays Cevapi with pita and dipping sauces, a hash brown with ketchup and mustard, an olive oil cake slice, and a grain bowl.
Fav bites from Chicago!
From my trip in the summer! Save for your next trip <33 anything you get at Doma Cafe is good and it’s a great brunch spot overall. the Cevapi (grilled beef sausages) are a must!! my most recommended spot: Kasama 🇵🇭 literally waited in line at 7:55am to be first seated for their 9:00am
Vivian!

Vivian!

72 likes

OLDEST PIZZA IN CHICAGO 🍕
Vito & Nick’s Pizzeria: 8.2/10 & $41.14 🍕 Food: 7.7/10 Quality: 8.4/10 Service: 8.2/10 Price: 8.4/10 OVERALL: 8.2/10 8433 S Pulaski Rd, Chicago, IL 60652 #vitoandnickspizzeria #chicagopizza #chicago
SERGELATO

SERGELATO

43 likes

A slice of Chicago-style deep-dish pizza is lifted, showcasing long, stretchy melted mozzarella cheese. The pizza features a thick, golden crust, rich tomato sauce, grated Parmesan, and a fresh basil leaf. Another deep-dish pizza is visible in the background.
🍕 Chicago-Style Deep-Dish Pizza 🍕
Ingredients: 2 ½ cups all-purpose flour 🌾 1 cup warm water 💧 1 packet active dry yeast 🧫 2 tbsp olive oil 🫒 1 tsp sugar 🍬 1 tsp salt 🧂 3 cups shredded mozzarella cheese 🧀 2 cups crushed tomatoes 🍅 1 tbsp Italian seasoning 🌿 ¼ cup grated Parmesan cheese 🧀 Optional: P
Nykilla 🧑🏽‍🍳

Nykilla 🧑🏽‍🍳

74 likes

A narrow cobblestone street in Salzburg, Austria, lined with historic buildings and parked bicycles, under a clear blue sky. Text overlay highlights Salzburg as the 5th best small city in the world.
A woman stands smiling in front of a historic building in Salzburg, holding a coffee cup. Text describes Salzburg, Austria, as the 5th best small city, known for its stunning buildings and history, including being Mozart's home.
An expansive aerial view of Salzburg, Austria, showcasing the city's historic buildings, the Salzach River, and distant mountains under a partly cloudy sky. The caption suggests visiting Fortress Hohensalzburg for this view.
Voted 5th best small city in the 🌎!
Salzburg was one of my favorite parts of my travels in Europe last year 🤍 the buildings are beautiful, it felt super safe and had plenty to do and see. I definitely think it deserves to be on this list ✨ here are some things I think you should do in Salzburg👇 🏰Visit the Fortress Hohensalzb
Sarah Close

Sarah Close

29 likes

Chicago voted best big city 8 years in a row
Chicago has been voted Best Big City in the U.S. by Condé NastTraveler readers choice awards for an astounding 8 years in a row! #shenaniganstravel #theliveitfoundation #livingthedashlife #chicago #uninsurance #vacation #travel #golevarti #discounttravel
Shenanigans Travel

Shenanigans Travel

3 likes

Chicago pizza is unmatched !
#chicagopizza #chicago #foodie #lemon8 #fyp
Bqueen Posey

Bqueen Posey

7 likes

Viral Pasta Cones at Anto Pizza in Chicago, IL📍
went to Anto Pizza & Pasta in Chicago, IL for their viral pasta cones. I loved the calamari and their pasta. Would you give them a try? #chicago #food #lunchideas #lemonchallenge #ThingsToDo Anto Pizza & Pasta
LaLa | Food & Travel

LaLa | Food & Travel

148 likes

A close-up of a vegan deep dish pizza with a slice removed, revealing chunky tomato sauce, black olives, green peppers, and vegan cheese. Text overlay identifies it as vegan deep dish pizza.
An overhead view of a sliced vegan deep dish pizza, topped with tomato sauce, olives, and green peppers. Text overlay provides location details for a pizza establishment.
A close-up of a sliced vegan deep dish pizza, showing its thick crust, tomato sauce, olives, and green peppers. Text overlay discusses carry-out and cost considerations.
Vegan deep dish pizza in Chicago
you know what they say!! when in rome!!! this vegan chicago style deep dish pizza was bomb 📍Location: Mi Pi Pizza Chicago ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 / ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ #vegan #chicagofood
aliyah

aliyah

14 likes

A line of people waiting outside Prince St. Pizza in Chicago, featuring a brick building with a yellow and green striped awning and outdoor heaters. The sign reads 'THE ORIGINAL Prince St. PIZZA EST. 2012'.
An indoor neon sign on a brick wall at Prince St. Pizza, reading 'You can't buy HAPPINESS But you can buy PIZZA And that's kind Of the same thing', with 'HAPPINESS' and 'PIZZA' in yellow.
Three slices of pizza in a box, including a large triangular slice with basil and two square slices, possibly 'Spicy Square' or 'Green Machine', with cheese, sauce, and herbs, on branded paper.
Prince St. Pizza - Chicago
✨Super Viral Food Place You Should Never Miss! 📍Chicago ⭐️Overall rating: The Green Machine (vegetarian Friendly) 10/10
Chi city life

Chi city life

26 likes

Chicago Pizza
superjulie1

superjulie1

87 likes

Who voted for this guy?
#jbpritzker #chicago #president #chicagoans
90s Kid

90s Kid

0 likes

Zachary’s Chicago Pizza ✨
Zachary’s Chicago Pizza ✨ #pizza #dinner #family #sahm #bayarea
yayareahousewife

yayareahousewife

0 likes

BEST NY STYLE PIZZA IN CHICAGO 🍕
Zaza’s is having a one night only fundraiser for shelters in need with @doughnatepizza & cassazzahousepizza on June 16th, 6-8pm. Detroit style Bacon Jam slices will be served 🥓 Name: Zaza’s Pizzeria in Lakeview 📍 Rating: 9.1/10 ⭐️ 3037 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60657 #zazaspizzeria #c
SERGELATO

SERGELATO

24 likes

Chicago Pizza Debate 🍕 Deep Dish vs Thin Crust
Chicago has strong opinions when it comes to pizza 🍕 I asked real people one question… deep dish or thin crust? The results weren’t even close 👀 Part 4 Which one are you choosing? #ChicagoFood #PizzaDebate #DeepDish #ThinCrust #FoodFinds
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

19 likes

Chicago style pizza
Chicago style pizza: It’s like a hug, but for your taste buds. TOO GOOD NOT TO SHARE!!! #chicagopizza #Lemon8 #fyp #satisfying Y’all the cheese pull was so crazy with these pizzas it was amazing! Don’t forget to like,comment &subscribe! ✌️
No Pork’ N Round

No Pork’ N Round

31 likes

People who voted for Trump
#trump #democrat #voteblue #liberal
Christie

Christie

16 likes

Chicago Deep Dish Pizza at Home 🍕🏡✨
Storytime: I was feeling extra homesick last week, so I enjoyed a night in with my Chicago Homesick candle from my sister & bought a frozen deep dish pizza for dinner. Honest review, love the candle she’s so nostalgic, it reminds me of the chocolate lip smackers from back in the day. The pizza
Kenzie Taylor

Kenzie Taylor

18 likes

Is This The Best Pizza 🍕 in Chicago?
#pizza #chicago #ricobenes Ricobene's Chicago 252 w 26th st Chicago IL
StevieEats

StevieEats

10 likes

Chicago… you voting or just scrolling? 👀
Illinois Primary Election is TODAY 🗳️ Polls close at 7PM — go make your voice count. Find your location ⤵️ https://ova.elections.il.gov/PollingPlaceLookup.aspx #Chicago #Vote #Illinois #WTW #ElectionDay
WHATS THE WORD

WHATS THE WORD

0 likes

Dill Pickle Chicago Pizza in West Loop
If you’re looking for some amazing pizza with a unique twist, I highly recommend trying the dill pickle pizza from Ranalli’s! This is a great sports bar with a nice sidewalk patio in the summertime ☀️ #chicagopizza #chicagofood #chicagofoodie #chicagorestaurant #chicagoeats
Kayleejochicago

Kayleejochicago

21 likes

See more