Chicago Pizza Debate 🍕 Deep Dish or Thin Crust?

Chicago has been going back and forth on this forever…

Deep dish or thin crust? 👀🍕

I went out and asked people across the city, and the answers were split.

Some are loyal to that cheesy deep dish, others swear thin crust is the real Chicago pizza.

So now I gotta ask you…

Which one are you choosing? ⬇️

#ChicagoFood #FoodFinds #PizzaLovers #FoodDebate #JovanApproved

Chicago
3/26 Edited to

... Read moreHaving lived in Chicago for several years, I can truly say the debate between deep dish and thin crust pizzas is one of the city's most passionate discussions. The deep dish pizza, with its thick buttery crust, layers of gooey cheese, tangy tomato sauce, and a generous heap of toppings, offers a hearty and comforting meal that many locals and visitors love for a sit-down experience. On the other hand, thin crust pizza in Chicago carries its own legacy. Often baked in a cracker-thin style with a crispy, slightly charred base, it provides a lighter, crunchier option ideal for grabbing a quick slice on the go without feeling overly full. Many Chicagoans refer to this as 'tavern style,' noting the perfect balance between sauce, cheese, and toppings. What’s great is that each style showcases Chicago’s diverse food culture—deep dish is like a savory pie, perfect for sharing and savoring slowly, while thin crust offers convenience and a different texture that pizza purists appreciate. If you ask me, the choice depends on your mood and appetite. Personally, I recommend trying both at some point, perhaps pairing deep dish with a Chicago-style craft beer to complement its richness, or enjoying a thin crust slice alongside a salad or appetizer. Both embody Chicago's vibrant food scene and reveal why the city continues to celebrate its pizza traditions. Whether you lean toward cheesy, filling deep dish or the crisp, lighter thin crust, Chicago’s pizza debate invites everyone to join the conversation and experience the flavors that define this iconic city.

1 comment

Related posts

Chicago Pizza Debate 🍕 Deep Dish vs Thin Crust
Chicago has strong opinions when it comes to pizza 🍕 I asked real people one question… deep dish or thin crust? The results weren’t even close 👀 Part 4 Which one are you choosing? #ChicagoFood #PizzaDebate #DeepDish #ThinCrust #FoodFinds
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

19 likes

A slice of Chicago-style deep-dish pizza is lifted, showcasing long, stretchy melted mozzarella cheese. The pizza features a thick, golden crust, rich tomato sauce, grated Parmesan, and a fresh basil leaf. Another deep-dish pizza is visible in the background.
🍕 Chicago-Style Deep-Dish Pizza 🍕
Ingredients: 2 ½ cups all-purpose flour 🌾 1 cup warm water 💧 1 packet active dry yeast 🧫 2 tbsp olive oil 🫒 1 tsp sugar 🍬 1 tsp salt 🧂 3 cups shredded mozzarella cheese 🧀 2 cups crushed tomatoes 🍅 1 tbsp Italian seasoning 🌿 ¼ cup grated Parmesan cheese 🧀 Optional: P
Nykilla 🧑🏽‍🍳

Nykilla 🧑🏽‍🍳

74 likes

Chicago-style deep dish
Chicago-style deep dish, leveled up with chickpea power. 🍕✨ Not your average pizza. The crust? Made from Goode Foods Garbanzo Chickpeas. It’s crispy, golden, protein-packed—and honestly? Regular crust could never. 📌 SAVE this recipe — you’re gonna crave it again and again. Chickpea Deep Dish P
Goode Foods

Goode Foods

72 likes

A slice of Chicago deep-dish pizza with a thick crust, rich red sauce, and melted cheese, garnished with herbs, served on a white plate.
A screenshot displaying the ingredients list for Chicago deep-dish pizza, including items for the dough and pizza sauce.
A screenshot showing the fillings and toppings ingredients for Chicago deep-dish pizza, followed by the first step of the dough preparation directions.
Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza
#easyrecipes #quickmeals #pizza #Recipe #chicago
Just another mom

Just another mom

20 likes

Did you know about Chicago Style Thin Crust Pizza?
#chicagopizza #chicagofoodscene #chicagostyledeepdishpizza #chicagofood #chicago
b.Uniqu3

b.Uniqu3

37 likes

Chicago deep dish chocolate pizza pie. Yeah… we said it. And before anyone argu
Yeah… we said it. And before anyone argues — we’re actually from Chicago… so we can vouch for this one 😅 You’re calling this “pizza”… but it’s really a chocolate dessert pie. Chicago didn’t approve this… we just gave it the name. This is what happens when you stop treating beans like “din
Goode Foods

Goode Foods

11 likes

First Timers Guide to Chicago 🏙️
Here's a handy guide to make the most of your trip to Chicago . Things to Do: Millennium Park : Explore this vibrant urban park featuring art, architecture, and landscaping. Don’t miss the outdoor concerts and events. Cloud Gate : Visit the iconic "Bean" sculpture in Millenn
itsmarianavelez

itsmarianavelez

91 likes

Rotolo’s Craft & Crust 📍Mansfield,TX
Tried Rotolo’s in Mansfield TX🍕✨ The Corona126 stole the show! fresh, flavorful, crust was my favorite . The Big Apple was another favorite, loaded with flavor and perfectly crisp. The Pig & Fig was a nice different touch to round out the meal. The garlic parm fries had great flavor, but
eatwithmetx

eatwithmetx

8 likes

A collage featuring various Chicago food items like deep dish pizza, a hot dog, a green latte, and cocktails, set against a restaurant interior with neon lights, with the text "Where to eat in... CHICAGO."
A collage showcasing the interior of Portillo's restaurant with an American flag and industrial decor, alongside images of a hot dog, fries, and an Italian beef sandwich, with the text "Portillo's."
A collage displaying the bustling interior of Sawada Coffee with numerous string lights and patrons, featuring a green latte with latte art and a pastry display, with the text "SAWADA COFFEE."
Where to eat in CHICAGO!🌭🏙️🍴
During my most recent trip to Chicago I had the opportunity to try many new restaurants! Here’s some recommendations on where to eat or grab coffee in Chicago! Portillo's & Barnelli's Chicago is a family friendly chain that has Chicago staples but also pasta in a fast-casual atmo
emily jo’elle

emily jo’elle

189 likes

Debate Ignites Over Draft vs. Voting Access in America.
Debate Ignites Over Draft vs. Voting Access in America ⸻ A political debate is gaining traction online after a controversial comparison between mandatory draft registration and voter registration laws sparked strong reactions across the country. Supporters call it a matter of national respon
King media Roof Llc

King media Roof Llc

78 likes

Multiple hands hold slices of thin-crust pizza from Novel Pizza Cafe, featuring longanisa giardiniera and pepperoni hot honey ricotta flavors, shared among friends in Chicago.
A hand holds a breakfast sandwich with egg and sausage on an English muffin, served on a white plate from Doma Cafe, a charming Croatian cafe perfect for brunch.
A table at Doma Cafe displays Cevapi with pita and dipping sauces, a hash brown with ketchup and mustard, an olive oil cake slice, and a grain bowl.
Fav bites from Chicago!
From my trip in the summer! Save for your next trip <33 anything you get at Doma Cafe is good and it’s a great brunch spot overall. the Cevapi (grilled beef sausages) are a must!! my most recommended spot: Kasama 🇵🇭 literally waited in line at 7:55am to be first seated for their 9:00am
Vivian!

Vivian!

71 likes

A large, sliced deep-dish pizza with chunky tomato sauce and melted cheese is presented on a metal stand in a restaurant. One slice is being pulled, showing long strings of cheese. The image includes text overlay: 'stereotyped food for Chicago, but really nobody eats...'
Hot Take: Deep Dish Isn’t Chicagoans Everyday Meal
When people think of Chicago, the first thing that comes to mind is deep dish pizza. I love a good deep dish. That buttery crust, the insane amount of cheese, the chunky tomato sauce on top… it’s basically a lasagna in pizza form. But here’s the thing: most locals I know don’t eat it every w
carsick

carsick

311 likes

Chicago! A City That Captivated My Heart! 🌆🍕
Hey everyone! I just got back from my first trip to Chicago, and oh boy, I'm already itching to return! Being a previous Boston girl who practically lived in New York City every weekend, Chicago felt like a refreshing yet familiar embrace of urban excitement. Let me start by saying, Chicago
DestinyK

DestinyK

45 likes

what @Karissaeats thinks of pizza!
what Karissa eats thinks of pizza in general! #pizza #pizzatime #nycpizza #lemon8food @Lemon8 Food
jeremyj

jeremyj

475 likes

Chicago’s Best Pizza? 90+ People Voted 🍕
I’ve been asking people all over Chicago who has the best pizza… and these are the results so far. Some of these might surprise you 👀 Who do you think deserves the top spot? #chicagopizza #chicagofood #chicagoeats #foodie #pizza
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

26 likes

A person poses among the large, dark, headless and armless iron Agora Statues in Grant Park, Chicago, with city buildings in the background.
A person stands in front of a large cherry blossom tree in full bloom at Jackson Park, Chicago, surrounded by other visitors enjoying the spring season.
A person stands on stone steps leading up to the John Alexander Logan Monument, a large equestrian statue, under a cloudy sky in Chicago.
Things to do and Places to visit In Chicago Part 1
As a foreign tourist from Savannah, Georgia who visited Chicago , these are the places that we visited … #thingstodo @Lemon8 Travel 📍 City/Country:: Chicago 1. Agora Statues( Headless and armless Iron Sculptures) -1135 S Michigan Ave, Chicago 2. Cherry Blossoms in Jackson Park (Spr
Hermione

Hermione

3 likes

Okay Ladies, Time to Settle this Debate
👩🏾‍⚖️FRAGRANCE COURT IS IN SESSION! Which scent is the best? If you’re not saying #40 we gotta talk…..😒😂and yes I’ve smelled the new one. #Fragrance #debate #soldejaneiro #sephora @Lemon8 Beauty
AllThingsBeauty

AllThingsBeauty

2001 likes

🚨 Breaking News: Heated Debate Over Government Spending Priorities.
Public debate continues to grow over how government funds should be allocated and what priorities should come first. Discussions around healthcare, education, public benefits, and government spending remain highly divided across the country. Opinions vary widely, and many Americans continue to expr
King media Roof Llc

King media Roof Llc

4 likes

Just had the ultimate Chicago deep-dish pizza experience 🧀🍅 The cheese pull was unreal, and the crust was buttery perfection. 👉 Tell me—are you Team deep dish or Team thin crust? #ChicagoEats #DeepDishPizza #FoodieTalk
Lily Tan

Lily Tan

25 likes

Taylor Bennett Picks Chicago’s Best Pizza 🍕👀
I asked Taylor Bennett who has the best pizza in Chicago… and his answer might start a debate 😂🍕 Did he get it right? #ChicagoPizza #TaylorBennett #ChicagoFood #Foodie #JovanApproved
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

46 likes

Chicago-Style Deep-Dish Pizza 🍕
Need Gluten-free Cornmeal Crust? TAKE 2 🎬:  OK, sooo for my 2nd attempt, I made hubby's deep dish pizza 🍕 tonight and his pizza is definitely throwing out Chicago-Style Deep-Dish Pizza 🍕 🙌🏽😍.  My 1st attempt was more like Detroit-Style pizza 🍕 with a cornmeal crust.   They were both absolute
Nicky's Savory Vegan Eats

Nicky's Savory Vegan Eats

4 likes

A pizza spot with huge portions 🫶✨
📍Old World Pizza Eggplant parm was the star 👏 Huge portions + classic neighborhood spot 🍕 What we ordered: 🍴 Combo platter – fried mushrooms, zucchini, onion rings, cheese sticks, garlic bread + fries 🍝 Lasagna & eggplant parm 🍕 Cheese thin crust, veggie thin crust & veggie deep
DineWithPooj

DineWithPooj

44 likes

A shower head with water running, a caddy holding various bath products, and text asking "HOW LONG IS YOUR SHOWER??" with options "5-10 MIN", "15-20 MIN", and "UHHHHHHH", prompting users to comment.
A shower head with water running and bath products on a caddy. Overlay text states, "Random question, but I feel like everyone's answer is wildly different. Some people are in and out. Some people turn it into a whole experience."
A shower head with water running and bath products. Text asks "which one are you?" and lists options: "5-10 minutes", "15-20 minutes", "I lose track", with a "NO JUDGEMENT" message.
Can you help settle the debate??
this came up recently at a girls night and it was a heavily debated question and it actually got pretty heated 😂😅 SURPRISED ME!!! haha i feel like people either have a strict shower time… or they completely lose track once they’re in there. No explanations needed I just want to see the spli
brittany

brittany

803 likes

Chicago Bean Pie Recipe
Chicago Bean Pie Recipe: A delicious and culturally rich treat, the Chicago-style Bean Pie is a favorite in many Black households, especially among the Nation of Islam community. It’s a sweet, spiced pie made with navy beans, a creamy filling, and a buttery crust. Perfect for any occasion! I
The Original Black Review

The Original Black Review

10 likes

📍 Joe’s On Higgins Found another vodka sauce that is top tier 🤤 Definitely a hidden gem for Italian in Chicago 🍝 Favorites: ✨ Rigatoni Vodka – the sauce is everything!! ✨ Eggplant Stack What we tried: ✨ Bruschetta ✨ Thin crust pizza ✨ Rigatoni Vodka with Burrata ✨ Eggplant Stack D
DineWithPooj

DineWithPooj

12 likes

Crust 54 - 8th St. Holland
Pie in the sky! EatGR pizza throwdown, stop no. 10 ! Judge's notes: Crust 54- The Sawzall Crust: The Chicago style deep dish is made with fresh dough, made in house daily. The dough is vegan, made with a butter alternative, and applesauce for color and sweetness. They let the dough fermen
MeanMugginMarz

MeanMugginMarz

2 likes

A Trip Back Home: Chicago
My recent trip back home to Chicago was everything I hoped it would be and more. As soon as I landed at O'Hare Airport on my favorite airline, Delta, I felt an overwhelming sense of nostalgia and excitement. There’s something about that city skyline that feels like a warm hug. I decided to k
Karen Renee

Karen Renee

18 likes

Pineapple on Pizza Debate 😂🍕🍍
When pineapple and sausage don’t want to be on the same pizza but pepperoni says, “Enough” 😭😂🍕 Listen… I love pineapple on pizza and I’m standing on that 😌🍍✨ Judge me if you want, it’s still good. Team pineapple or nah? 👀👇🏽 #PizzaDebate #FoodComedy #RelatableSkits #FunnyVideo
Keysho Ann

Keysho Ann

22 likes

Chicago’s Best Pizza? Real People Voted 🍕
I asked real people in Chicago one question… who has the best pizza? 🍕 Everybody had a different answer 😳 From Italian Fiesta to Lou Malnati’s, the debate is real. Here are the most mentioned spots so far 👀 Who do you think is #1 ? #ChicagoFood #ChicagoPizza #FoodFinds #Pi
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

36 likes

Who Has The Best Pizza In Chicago? 🍕 Part 11
143 real votes later and Chicago’s pizza debate is still going strong 👀🍕 Italian Fiesta is still leading the rankings. Who should I ask next? #ChicagoPizza #ChicagoFood #PizzaLover #Foodie #JovanApproved
JovanApproved

JovanApproved

61 likes

Deep dish pizza
**“Had to stop by Labriola Chicago to try their deep dish pizza and baby… it did NOT disappoint 😮‍🔥🍕 The crust, the cheese, the sauce… everything was amazing. Chicago might really have the best pizza! Now be honest… is deep dish your favorite or are you a thin crust person? 👀👇”** #explorepage
Theearieledit

Theearieledit

0 likes

“My value isn’t up for debate.”
#wwe #ajlee #fyp #Lemon8 #viral
WWWE SUPERSTAR AJ LEE

WWWE SUPERSTAR AJ LEE

30 likes

Chicago 1 day bucket list!
Here are my non-negotiables for a fun day in Chicago! 1. Willis Tower Chicago’s iconic skyscraper. At 1,450 feet, its Skydeck offers stunning views of the city and beyond. 2. Starbucks Reserve Roastery The largest Starbucks in the world! Even if you don't like coffee, it's a c
Andie

Andie

6 likes

John 7:45-52 | Debate Over Jesus’s Claims 📖
Weekend Bible reading & notes 📖 John 7:45-52 | Debate Over Jesus’s Claims 📖 ♥️ Today’s Heart Check: Do I approach Jesus with a humble and open heart or do pride and assumptions keep me from fully receiving His truth? #i love reading my bible #readingthroughmybible #biblereading🥰 #
MAE ♡

MAE ♡

50 likes

Controversial Quote About Trump Sparks Online Debate.
Controversial Quote About Trump Sparks Online Debate ⸻ A bold anonymous quote comparing Donald Trump’s leadership style to Tiger Woods’ driving is going viral online. Some call it satire, others call it harsh criticism. The internet is divided — what do YOU think? ⸻ Is this quote fair criticism
King media Roof Llc

King media Roof Llc

4 likes

Lets have a healthy debate.
Unpopular opinion: Organic doesn’t always mean healthy. Organic cheese puffs are still cheese puffs. Organic “natural flavors” are still lab-made. Organic seed oils? Still wrecking your hormones. Just because the label says “organic” doesn’t mean it belongs in your body. #hottake #
pragmatic.plantlady

pragmatic.plantlady

363 likes

Trump’s Daycare Comments Ignite National Debate on U.S. Priorities.
Trump’s Daycare Comments Ignite National Debate on U.S. Priorities ⸻ Donald Trump sparks controversy after claiming the U.S. cannot support daycare and major social programs while dealing with global conflicts. The statement is fueling a nationwide debate about what America should prioritize
King media Roof Llc

King media Roof Llc

3 likes

Bridgeview’s Halal Pizza Haven: Brama La Pizza
#ThingsToDo #lemon8challenge This halal-friendly pizzeria serves fresh dough daily, offering crisp thin crust, specialty pies like Brama (sausage, peppers, mushrooms, onions), BBQ Chicken, and the indulgent Meat Lovers 🍕🔥 Staff are praised for their friendly, welcoming vibe—one review said,
Dear Cravings

Dear Cravings

8 likes

Stuffed crust pizza
What are your favorite pizza toppings? The best part of the pizza is the crust! And when you stuff it with cheese it’s even better!😋 Just place your pizza dough into a sheet pan then place string cheese all around the edges roll the dough over and seal it shut. Then build your pizza as normal
Genie

Genie

72 likes

Union Pizza Company in Manhattan Beach is your post flight-LAX bite to eat. This is a perfect spot if you want pizza or you need a spot to hang out with your friends. #ManhattanBeach #Pizza #ChicagoStylePizza #NewYorkStylePizza #thincrust #DeepDish @Mustard Food App #foodie #losangeleseat
Jaaaaaymomma

Jaaaaaymomma

0 likes

Nancy's Chicago Style Thin Crust Pizza Home Editio
#nancys #chicago #style #thincrust #pizza
Nick's Happy Place

Nick's Happy Place

2 likes

See more