464 followers

Follow

Follow

Follow

1/2

9 saved

77

10

🍂🥧 What’s your favorite pie for Thanksgiving?

I can never choose between creamy pumpkin and warm apple… but let’s be honest, pie season is elite. 😍✨

Drop your favorite below 👇 — are you team pumpkin, pecan, apple, or something totally unique?

#ThanksgivingDessert #PieSeason #FallBaking #CozyEats #VeganBaker

2025/10/13 Edited to

Thanksgiving is synonymous with delicious pies that bring warmth and comfort to the table. While pumpkin, apple, and pecan pies top the list, the variety of pies enjoyed during this season is truly vast. Many people also enjoy sweet potato pie, cherry pie, or even chocolate cream pie as part of their holiday tradition. Beyond classic recipes, the pie community has seen a rise in vegan and gluten-free options, making it easier for everyone to indulge in cozy eats during the #PieSeason. When choosing your favorite pie, consider what makes it special. Is it the creamy texture of pumpkin pie, infused with spices like cinnamon and nutmeg? Or the tart juiciness of warm apple pie, often served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream? Pecan pie offers a rich, buttery crunch, perfect for those who love a nutty dessert. Some bakers like to experiment with unique fillings like cranberry, maple, or even salted caramel to put a personal twist on tradition. Fall baking is not only about the flavors but also the shared moments preparing and enjoying these desserts with loved ones. Whether you prefer baking your pies from scratch or picking up a seasonal favorite, pie season represents a celebration of heritage and heartwarming memories. Don’t forget to consider dietary preferences too! Vegan bakers have crafted delicious plant-based pies using ingredients like coconut cream, cashew nuts, and flaxseed, making their versions just as indulgent. Sharing your favorite pie and recipes on social platforms tagged with #ThanksgivingDessert or #CozyEats can inspire others to try new treats and keep the pie tradition alive in diverse and exciting ways. So, what’s your favorite pie for Thanksgiving? Pumpkin, apple, pecan, or something totally unique? Drop your tasty favorites and enjoy the elite pie season vibes!

Related posts

A collage showing a dark roasted turkey, potato salad, mac and cheese with diced tomatoes, and stuffing. The image has overlaid text that reads "WORST Thanksgiving Foods" and includes a green face emoji with a disgusted expression and a red thumbs down emoji.

A close-up of mac and cheese in a red pot, topped with sliced tomatoes, breadcrumbs, and chives. Overlaid text reads "Mac & Cheese (with veggies or breadcrumbs)".

A close-up of a casserole dish with a golden-brown, crumbly topping containing cranberries, over green beans and chicken. Overlaid text reads "Casserole (of any kind)".

What’s the WORST Thanksgiving food?🤢

1. Mac & Cheese (with veggies or breadcrumbs) Now if your family likes it like this, then I love it!🙌🏾 But I personally don’t want peppers, onions, tomatoes, or breadcrumbs in my Thanksgiving Mac!❌ 2. Casserole I didn’t grow up in a family that makes casserole for any occasion. So it’s jus

661 likes

Let’s make Pumpkin Pie 🥧🫶✨

There’s nothing like the cozy aroma of pumpkin pie baking in the oven! Here’s my go-to simple recipe for a classic, flavorful dessert: Ingredients: • 1 can pumpkin purée • 2 tsp apple pie seasoning • 1/4 tsp ground cloves • 1/2 tsp ground ginger •&

25 likes

WHAT IM MAKING FOR THANKSGIVING 🦃

Comment if you have any questions!! I thought some quick easy treats would be perfect for Thanksgiving this year! What is your favorite Thanksgiving food(s)? 👀 #thanksgivingrecipeideas #thanksgivingideas #thanksgivingprep #food #lemon8diarychallenge

30 likes

Holiday Hacks Pt 9 Ultimate Pecan Pie Upgrade

You will regret nothing 🤩 🥧 Because The solution is delightfully simple! 🎃🥧 Get ready to elevate your holiday dessert game with our fun twist on pumpkin pie! In this video, we reveal how to add Ozark Nut Company’s cinnamon spiced pecans to your classic pumpkin pie for an irresistible ble

75 likes

Turn your apple into Apple Pie Ice Cream! 🍎🍨✨

Apple Season calls for this life changing dessert! 🤯🍎🥧🍨 follow me for more healthy recipes! Truly one of my favorite classic desserts turned into ice cream form is my version of heaven 🥰 completely dairy free/vegan & gluten free! 📲 Get the recipe by simply Googling “Justine cooks vegan a

1424 likes

Favorite Pie✨

Alright y’all… what’s the favorite pie at your house for Thanksgiving? Pumpkin? Pecan? Chocolate? Or are you team “I’ll take a slice of ALL of them?” 🥧😂 Drop your household favorite below — bonus points if you have photo evidence! #HomemadeGoodness #thanksgivingtraditions #explorestay

1 like

A partially eaten Hershey's chocolate crème pie in an aluminum pan, showcasing its creamy white filling, chocolate crust, and whipped topping with chocolate drizzle. Text overlays indicate it's a "Thanksgiving Recipe Dessert Edition."

An overhead view of a whole Hershey's chocolate crème pie in an aluminum pan, topped with white whipped cream and chocolate syrup drizzles, featuring a whipped cream heart in the center.

A close-up of a single slice of Hershey's chocolate crème pie on a white plate, revealing its distinct layers of chocolate crust, creamy white filling, chocolate pudding, and whipped topping with chocolate drizzle.

HERSHEY’S CHOCOLATE CRÈME PIE

Have you had the chocolate pie from Burger King?? This is it! 🔥 its my moms favorite and it’s on our Thanksgiving menu this year. Except I’m going to do an Oreo crust this time! what you’ll need: For the crust: • 1 Chocolate Graham Cracker pie crust ( or you can make your own, lmk if you

44 likes

do you have plans for thanksgiving?

thanksgiving is practically today, what are your plans? do you have a favorite dish or dessert? whats your favorite part about thanksgiving? Today i’m going to my tías house, we usually all cook together and help out throughout the day. My fav dish is either mashed potatoes or stuffing, for des

10 likes

A close-up, overhead view of a pumpkin cream cheese pie in a white ceramic dish, featuring a light-colored topping over a pumpkin-colored filling and a textured graham cracker crust.

A slice of pumpkin cream cheese pie on a white plate with a gold fork. The slice clearly shows distinct layers of graham cracker crust, pumpkin filling, and a creamy white topping.

A recipe card titled "PUMPKIN CREAM CHEESE PIE" listing ingredients for the graham cracker crust, pumpkin filling, and a sour cream topping.

Pumpkin Cream Cheese Pie!

I make this EVERY year for Thanksgiving #myfavoritepie #sooodelicious

38 likes

Home for thanksgiving from College outfit inspo

Just got home from School and decided to try putting together some of my outfit choices for Thanksgiving! And I love them! It tried to create a trendy Fall cool girl vibe with some of my favorite pieces! Here’s what’s in the slides: 1. Peppermayo top with cut out sides, garage leather skort, St

209 likes

Pumpkin Pie for Thanksgiving ✨🥧

Libby's Pumpkin Pie 🥧 This is a simple and easy pumpkin pie recipe to make. Just follow the recipe on the Libby's Pumpkin Can and then you'll have a fresh baked pie. I'll list the recipe and ingredients below. Enjoy!! #pumpkinrecipes #pumpkinpierecipe #baking #pies #tha

17 likes

The Best Apple Pie Crisp

1 pie shell (I get mine from Whole Foods, but you can use your favorite one) Topping 1 cup all-purpose flour ½ cup brown sugar packed ½ cup granulated sugar 1 teaspoon cinnamon 1 teaspoon of nutmeg ½ cup unsalted butter melted Filling 8 granny smith apples ⅓ cup granulated sugar 3

1602 likes

Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie

This is an absolute favorite for my family. I even have friends of family offer to pay for me to make these for them. It’s the best peanut butter pie recipe I’ve come across, I’ve been making it for years now. I made multiple yesterday for Thanksgiving so everyone could take one home with them.

85 likes

Things I’m Grateful For This Thanksgiving 🎀

Thanksgiving isn’t just about the food (though, hello, mashed potatoes 🥔😋)—it’s about pausing to reflect on the blessings in our lives. Today, I’m taking a moment to share the things I’m most grateful for: 🎀My Family – For their love, laughter, and constant support. They are my anchor 🎀My Healt

0 likes

What books would be on your Thanksgiving plate?📚

I saw this Booksgiving trend posted a few times on Instagram and thought it was so cute. I wanted to make my own spin on it with my reads of 2025. 2025 may have been a slow year for me, reading-wise, but I still got to read quite a few books that have easily become favorites. And some books tha

27 likes

Tell me what you like to eat/make at Thanksgiving

Sometimes I stick to traditional fixings. And some years, we do things completely different. This year my family is going to my brother’s house for Thanksgiving. We are all making something to bring. My brother is smoking a turkey and a ham!! 😋 I am bringing homemade mash potatoes, green bean casse

15 likes

A list titled "Fun Thanksgiving Traditions" features ten humorous and absurd traditions, such as "Yelling at each other" and "Wrestling a sword away from grandpa." A cartoon turkey in a pilgrim hat is depicted alongside Thanksgiving food.

What’s your Favorite Thanksgiving Tradition!!!

This Year my home will be Full of Scents of Food of every kind! Family, ,love , Laughter, Moments for Memories and A Football Standoff 😂😂😂 #lemon8diarychallenge #thanksgivinggratitude #thanksgivingspecial #thanksgivingthankful #Lemon8Diary

5 likes

A smiling woman in an apron is shown next to a recipe for "Mama's Soulful Cornbread Dressing - Just Like Sunday Supper," listing ingredients like crumbled cornbread, white bread, celery, onion, butter, chicken broth, eggs, and various seasonings.

This image displays four Thanksgiving dessert recipes: Pecan Pie Cheesecake, Crustless Pumpkin Pie, Caramel Apple Pie, and Vintage Custard Pie, each with a photo of the dessert and its ingredients.

A cast iron skillet holds a golden-brown cornbread with a slice cut out, accompanied by a recipe for "Cornbread (Dolly's Favorite with Soup)" listing ingredients and instructions.

Thanksgiving recipes, ingredients, instructions

save it today and try it friend 🧡

28 likes

Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie 🥧 🥰

#lemon8diarychallenge Yummy Pumpkin Pie Recipe **Ingredients:** - 1 pie crust (store-bought or homemade) - 2 cups pumpkin puree - 1 can (14 oz) sweetened condensed milk - 2 large eggs - 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon - 1/2 teaspoon ground ginger - 1/4 teaspoon ground cloves - 1/2 teasp

37 likes

A recipe card for 'Non-Toxic Puerto Rican Thanksgiving Arroz con Gandules (Rice & Beans)' listing ingredients, alongside a photo of a plate of yellow rice with pigeon peas and a side of salad and chicken.

A recipe card for 'Non-Toxic Puerto Rican Thanksgiving Arroz con Gandules (Rice & Beans)' detailing five steps of cooking instructions.

A collage of 'Non-Toxic Ingredients' for Arroz con Gandules, featuring various organic and clean-eating products like avocado oil, sofrito, ham, garlic paste, green bananas, chicken bouillon, tomato paste, olives, and rice.

Better for you Rican Thanksgiving

Puerto Rican Thanksgiving just hits different 🇵🇷🦃 The traditions, the flavors, the family vibes… it’s honestly one of my favorite meals of the entire year. But let’s be real — a lot of our classic ingredients weren’t made with wellness in mind. I’ll never tell you to skip the foods you love, bu

68 likes

Fun Thanksgiving Traditions to Start This Year! 🦃

Thanksgiving is more than just a meal—it's about making memories with loved ones! Here are a few fun traditions you can start this year to make your holiday extra special! What are some of YOUR favorite Thanksgiving traditions? Share them below—I’d love to add new ideas to my list!🤎 #Tha

53 likes

A white background with a light grid pattern features the question 'What is your favorite pie for Thanksgiving?' in brown text, with 'favorite pie' and 'Thanksgiving' highlighted. 'Lemon8 Q&A' is at the top, and 'Let's chat' with an arrow is at the bottom.

considering lemon pie this year, don't @ me

What is your favorite pie for Thanksgiving? pumpkin apple pecan sweet potato what else?

4 likes

A white scalloped plate holds nine small, golden-brown apple pies with lattice crusts. The text "What's your favorite Kind of pie?" is overlaid on the image, with "Lemon8" and "@emilyrachelhayden" in the bottom left corner.

What’s Your Favorite Kind of Pie?

#pieideas #letschat #lemon8contest #lemon8challenge #thanksgiving

21 likes

What’s your favorite dish: Thanksgiving Edition

Considering the history of this holiday, idk how happy you are about it, however, I’m happy to spend time with family and eat GREAT food. I’m actually up cooking right now! What’s my favorite dish?! It’s the baked Mac&cheese, sweet potatoes, and cornbread dressing combo for me! Like I ne

12 likes

Thanksgiving Pie: Chocolate Buttermilk Pie

If there’s one thing you should know about me, it’s that I’m a total fiend for pies. My favorite part of the holidays is definitely baking—whether it’s cookies, pies, or quirky little desserts. I love it all. Usually, my creative energy goes toward knitting, crochet, sewing, or some form of art, bu

14 likes

What are your favorite Thanksgiving foods?

#GirlTalk #lemon8challenge #thanksgiving🦃 #meals #food With Thanksgiving approaching, I wanted to know what your guys favorite Thanksgiving foods are. For me personally I love, collard greens, baked mac & cheese, pumpkin pie and anything potato like potato salad, or mashed potatoe

2 likes

Homemade turkey pot pie

When you have left overs use them !! I also used a can of cream of chicken soup to the mixture , you can add or not both ways are great! Comforting and irresistible, pot pies have a flaky pastry top and bottom crust, filled with chunks of poultry or meat and veggies slathered in a rich gravy o

1 like

What’s your favorite thanksgiving side?

✨ Thanksgiving 🦃🍽️🫶🏻

1 like

What Does Your Thanksgiving Look Like?✨

I look forward to Thanksgiving every year! In the morning before Thanksgiving prep I put the live macys Thanksgiving day parade on the tv and I watch some of it with my kids! One day we will go lol! Then at like 4 or 5 We have a tradition to have a huge Thanksgiving feast with all of the things wit

11 likes

What’s your favorite thanksgiving side?

6 likes

A wooden bowl holds raw apple slices mixed with cinnamon and sugar, with a spoon inside. Overlay text says "DONT THROW THiS OUT! INSTEAD SWIPE".

Apple slices with cinnamon and sugar are cooking in a square copper pan on a stovetop. Overlay text says "Cook on medium heat till it gets gooey swipe Then...".

A decorative white bowl is filled with cooked, soft cinnamon apples in a thick, gooey sauce. Overlay text says "Easy Cinnamon Apples! PERFECT FOR THANKSGIVING".

🍎Leftover Apple Pie Filling?

🍎Did you make too much filling and don’t want to throw it out? Do this instead! 🍎Add some extra sugar and flour if your filling got watery in the fridge over night and stir. 🍏Heat your pan (I suggest nonstick) on medium heat and add your apples. 🍎 Stir constantly so it doesn’t get clumpy. 🍏On

3 likes

Four Thanksgiving pies are displayed on a light-colored countertop. These include a cherry crumble pie, a pumpkin pie, a pecan pie, and a chocolate cream pie with a white meringue topping. The text overlay asks, 'What pies do you eat on Thanksgiving?'

What pies do you eat on Thanksgiving?🦃🧡

What kind of pie do you and your family eat on Thanksgiving? And which is your favorite?! This year my family had 4 different pies: pumpkin, pecan, cherry crumble, and chocolate cream. My favorite one is the chocolate cream! #letschat #lemon8contest #thanksgiving #thanksgivingrecipes

38 likes

What’s YOUR Thanksgiving Role❓Let’s Chat!‼️🦃✨

Thanksgiving is just around the corner, and I’m curious—what’s your role on the big day? Are you the hostess with the mostess, whipping up a feast from scratch? 🧑‍🍳 Maybe you’re the store-run queen, snagging last-minute goodies, or the potluck pro who nails the perfect side dish every time. 🌽🍗 Pers

61 likes

See more