... Read moreOkay, let's dive into the world of e.l.f. setting sprays, because honestly, who isn't looking for that perfect product to lock in their makeup all day? I put two of e.l.f.'s most talked-about setting sprays to the test: the Power Grip Dewy Setting Spray (you know, the one in the clear bottle that everyone's raving about!) and their classic Makeup Mist & Set in the black bottle. My goal? To see if these popular sprays actually work and if they're truly good for keeping your look fresh.
First up, let's talk about my absolute favorite, the e.l.f. Power Grip Dewy Setting Spray. From the very first spritz, I was impressed. This spray delivers a genuinely *fine mist*, which is crucial for an even application without disturbing your makeup. I’ve tried setting sprays that feel like you’re getting splashed in the face, but not this one! It settled onto my skin beautifully, giving me a lovely, natural dewy finish without making me look greasy. The best part? It truly *keeps my makeup on all day*. I tested it during a busy day with errands, and even after hours, my foundation, blush, and concealer looked just as fresh as when I first applied them. I also noticed how incredibly well it *works with a primer*, especially the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer – they're a dynamic duo! My makeup felt locked in, almost immovable, which is exactly what I need for long wear. For anyone asking, "is the e.l.f. setting spray good?" – if you're talking about the Power Grip Dewy, my answer is a resounding YES! It’s become my go-to for ensuring my look stays put.
Now, let's move on to the e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set, the one in the black bottle. I had higher hopes for this one, given its popularity, but my experience was quite different. The first thing I noticed was the spray itself – it wasn't a fine mist at all; it felt more like rain on my face. Large droplets landed unevenly, and instead of setting my makeup, I felt like it was actually melting my makeup in certain areas, especially around my nose and chin. It didn't provide that locked-in feeling I crave from a setting spray. In fact, within a few hours, I saw my makeup fading and moving more than usual. For me, this spray just didn't deliver on its promise of keeping makeup on. While some people might have luck with it, personally, it didn't do much to enhance the longevity of my makeup, and I definitely didn't get that "finishing spray" effect I was looking for. So, when it comes to the black bottle, my verdict is unfortunately a "bye."
In conclusion, after trying both, there's a clear winner in my book. The e.l.f. Power Grip Dewy Setting Spray is a fantastic product that truly works to extend makeup wear and provide a beautiful finish. It's affordable, effective, and delivers on its promises. The black bottle, however, didn't meet my expectations and actually hindered my makeup's longevity. So, if you're wondering which e.l.f. setting spray to pick up, based on my honest review, I highly recommend going for the Power Grip Dewy – it will always be my number one!