Bought it after dad said no

My mom mentioned she wanted something (not even crazy expensive), but my dad told her he couldn’t afford it. Totally fair.

Later that week, I bought it for her as a gift—just to make her happy. She was so touched… but my dad got weirdly cold and now some family members are saying I disrespected him.

I wasn’t trying to be shady. I just love my mom and wanted to give her something she wouldn’t buy for herself. But now I’m stuck in the middle of this awkward tension.

Was I out of line?

#AskLemon8 #LetsChat #FamilyDrama

2025/8/9 Edited to

... Read moreYour story really resonated with me because navigating family dynamics, especially around money and gifts, can be so incredibly tricky. It sounds like your heart was in the right place, wanting to bring joy to your mom, and who wouldn't want to make their loved one happy? This situation where 'dad said no' can create a really uncomfortable ripple effect, and it’s completely understandable why you’d feel caught in the middle. Often, when one parent says no to a purchase, especially if it’s for financial reasons, another family member stepping in can unintentionally trigger feelings of pride, inadequacy, or even a sense of being undermined. Your dad might feel that you've bypassed his authority or implied that he's not providing enough for your mother, even if that wasn't your intention at all. It's rarely just about the object itself – like that beautiful handbag you likely chose with so much care that came in a lovely gift box – but more about what the gesture communicates within the family power structure or dynamics. Gifts, while symbols of affection, can sometimes inadvertently become entangled with issues of control, financial security, and perceived roles within the household. From your perspective, you saw a simple desire and filled it out of love. Your mom was touched, which is what anyone would hope for! But the unspoken rules and expectations within families are complex. Some might argue that respecting a parent’s 'no,' even if you disagree, is important for maintaining harmony, while others would say that spreading joy is always paramount. This isn't just about disrespecting your dad; it's also about figuring out how to communicate better within the family unit about financial boundaries and individual desires. So, what can you do when you're in this kind of awkward space? First, consider having a gentle, private conversation with your dad. Instead of defending your actions, try to understand his feelings. You could say something like, 'Dad, I never meant to disrespect you. I just saw how much Mom wanted [the item/handbag] and wanted to make her smile. I didn't think about how it might make you feel, and I'm sorry if it caused any upset.' Listen actively to his response. His 'no' might have stemmed from genuine financial stress he didn't want to burden your mom with, or it could be a matter of principle. Secondly, talk to your mom. How does she feel about the tension? She might be able to offer insight into your dad's perspective or help mediate the situation. It’s important that she doesn't feel like the cause of the conflict. Moving forward, if you want to give gifts in similar situations, perhaps involve both parents from the start. For example, if your mom mentions something she wants, you could approach both parents together and say, 'I know Mom likes this [item], how about we all chip in for it for her birthday/anniversary?' This way, your dad is included in the decision-making and doesn't feel bypassed. It creates a sense of shared contribution rather than an individual override. Ultimately, your intentions were pure. It’s a classic dilemma of good intentions clashing with complex family dynamics. Many of us have been in situations where 'dad said no' to something, and we’ve had to navigate the aftermath of stepping in or holding back. It's a learning experience, and open, honest communication, even when uncomfortable, is often the best path to healing those family rifts. Remember, family relationships are a tapestry woven with threads of love, respect, and unspoken expectations. Finding a way to honor everyone's feelings, even when they conflict, is a continuous journey.

4 comments

Lilly B's images
Lilly B

I don’t like when people don’t want to make an effort or spend the money on something and feel undermined when someone else does. Disrespectful would be if he were going to get it, you knew it and you beat him to the punch. He wasn’t doing it anyway.

See more(3)

Related posts

How I bought my car
Credit score: I made sure my credit score was at least over 650 before I got my car. If you haven’t already get a credit card and try to build up your credit. It should take you about 6 months to build up an average credit and in that time you can start saving for your car. Only used as much as you
Selena L

Selena L

1535 likes

I Bought $1,000 Worth of Food for Hungry People!🥹❤️
Josh Liljenquist | Joshlilj

Josh Liljenquist | Joshlilj

10.8K likes

I Bought a car!! 🚗😁
(My first Lemon8 Post!) Meet my 2014 Chevrolet Cruze Snowball 🌨️ So, back in May I took a leap of faith and went to a dealership to talk with someone about how to begin the car buy process. Despite having a credit score in the 690-700 range; I didn’t have enough credit history to be approved f
Angel Denise🩷

Angel Denise🩷

1032 likes

i bought my dream car🥳
i’m so excited to share with you guys that i got my dream car yesterday!! i traded in my ‘21 Subaru Crosstrek Sport that i got as a result of being t-boned by someone running a stop sign, which resulted in my very first car being totaled. i was so bummed! but honestly it was a blessing in disguise.
₊˚⊹♡𐌋𐌉𐌍𐌃𐌔 ₊˚⊹♡

₊˚⊹♡𐌋𐌉𐌍𐌃𐌔 ₊˚⊹♡

1121 likes

Here’s My Tool Kit After 2 Years of Crocheting 🧶
Here’s a look at the tools I use, as someone who’s been crocheting for a bit over 2 years! I started out with a crochet kit my mom bought for me after I said I was interested in learning (a lot of those kits are a great place to start!). Since then, I’ve been slowly collecting and trying out new to
clownkittycreations

clownkittycreations

191 likes

Make dad a breakfast sandwich. Better than bought!
Pat Hein

Pat Hein

9 likes

I bought this vintage Louis Vuitton at BookOff
I bought this vintage Louis Vuitton at BookOff in Japan for about ¥30,000 (roughly $200 USD) while we were vintage designer bag shopping. I started using it immediately, and a few months later the strap broke… which forced a decision I didn’t expect to make. When you buy secondhand designer,
Amanda | Salty Vagabonds

Amanda | Salty Vagabonds

685 likes

Two white bottles of Power Stick products are shown: a non-foaming shave gel and a post-shave cream, both in "Brazilian Mist" scent with notes of pistachio and salted caramel. They are labeled as vegan, paraben-free, dye-free, and cruelty-free, each containing 12 fl oz.
Power Stick Shaving Gel & After Shave
So I bought these a week or so ago and have been thinking about my feelings on them. I searched high and low for them. 👍Pros : •the smell for both items is just 👌🏻 chef’s kiss •the price is where it’s at $1.25 for each •the aftershave consistency is perfect. I love it. It’s between a body b
Shannon Abel

Shannon Abel

34 likes

My Man Bought Me A House For My 35th Birthday ✨🍋
Not sure if anyone knew, but we have lived in Alabama for 2 1/2 years now. I sacrificed, sold my home and moved from Texas to help raise my Fiancé Neices and Nephew after the passing of their Mother. My Man asked me 2 short Months ago what I wanted for my Birthday!? I told him I wanted a house an
Bright_3y3ss

Bright_3y3ss

2328 likes

I bought my first car (2022 jeep compass)
It took a long time to finally decide on getting a car and choosing the kind I wanted, well i finally decided and after all the hard work and commitment it took to get this I can say I am proud of this very big big girl purchase I have made this will be my baby for a while just wait till I decorate
⭐️

⭐️

20 likes

I bought the last one!!!!😆🤭
I went to coach outlet today and saw it on display and they said I could buy it and that it was the last one😆😆😆 #i bought a coach bag #fashionfinds #COACH #needthisbag
🎀

🎀

28 likes

I bought a car!
I bought my first Mazda yesterday! After my old car’s brakes gave out and sent me into a ditch (thankfully, I’m okay), I was in desperate need of something cheap and reliable. With the help of my girlfriend and her dad, I decided on a Mazda, and I’m so glad I did. A friend of mine has always raved
Andre

Andre

13 likes

A hand holds the book 'Rich Dad Poor Dad' by Robert T. Kiyosaki and Sharon L. Lechter, with other books visible on shelves in the background.
A page from 'Rich Dad Poor Dad' highlights the financial lesson: 'The poor and the middle class work for money.' and 'The rich have money work for them.'
A page from 'Rich Dad Poor Dad' highlights that an asset is defined by numbers, and understanding financial statements requires comprehending what the numbers are telling you.
Rich Dad said own assets
They taught us to get good grades. This book taught me to get financial freedom. Breaking cycles, building assets, and rewriting a new money story. One mindset shift at a time. 🔓📘🎓➡️💸 #richdadpoordad #wisdom #read #financialfreedom #lemon8bookclub
Read With Bintou

Read With Bintou

12 likes

A hand holds a pink graphic with abstract floral shapes, outlined in pink. Yellow text overlay reads "SO MY BOYFRIEND GOT ME A BOOK I ALREADY HAD 😔" and "SWIPE".
A hand holds the book "Iron Flame" by Rebecca Yarros, featuring a fiery cover with a dragon. Yellow text overlay states, "SO UNFORTUNATELY HE DID GET ME A BOOK I ALREADY HAD WHICH is SAD BUT...".
A hand holds two books, "Butcher & Blackbird" and "Beach Read," both noted as bestsellers. Yellow text overlay says, "WE WENT TODAY AND RETURNED it AND GOT tHESE tWO".
So my boyfriend bought me a book I already had🙃
My boyfriend is very thoughtful, he went to Barnes and Noble with his friend and had called me asking me if I had read this book, I responded with “no” so he took it as I didn’t have the book.(I genuinely had no clue he was buying a book for me, or that he was at Barnes and noble at the time)He the
yannely✨

yannely✨

1835 likes

i bought an ipod in 2024
ive always loved physical media and ive always loved devices that have a dedicated, distraction-less purpose (like e-readers!!) I have a HUGE cd collection. I love owning and displaying my favorite albums and looking back to see what albums I loved so much I spent money on them. That, and cd’s s
lizz

lizz

329 likes

Press-ons I bought vs. Press-ons I got 💅🏽🙄🍋
I really canceled my nail appt because I thought this was going to go differently... I just knew I was bouta to have a fresh set in 10-15 minutes. I opened the package and said SIIIIIIIIIIKE! 🤭🤣 They are paper thin and girlllll, where is the rest of my nail glue? 🤔 I'on feel like
MONICA B. ✨️

MONICA B. ✨️

269 likes

A hand holds a white Owala water bottle with a label detailing its features, including being leak-proof and insulated. The text 'Did I buy an Unreleased Owala??' is overlaid.
A screenshot of a Target receipt showing a purchase of an 'Owala 24oz FreeSip Stainless Steel Water Bottle - Tutti Frutti' highlighted, with text 'Proof that i bought it at target'.
A screenshot of the Target app displaying an error message: 'Oops, something went wrong An unexpected error occurred. Please try again.' with overlaid text 'this is what happens when I click on it on the target app'.
I accidentally bought an unreleased Owala😮😱
Okay so i originally wanted the pink one, i think it’s called candy coated but it’s sold out everywhere. I went to target and decided to walk through the back to school section and i saw this one. When i got home i was curious about the color so i tried to look it up but i couldn’t find it, when i
Avalon

Avalon

4580 likes

we bought a house togetherafter dating for 7 month
after only dating for 7 months my gf and i bought our first house together 🩵 it didn’t take long to know we were meant to spend our lives together so why wait? #lesbian #couplegoals #wellness
Isabelita

Isabelita

182 likes

My dad thinks he’s going to be a billionaire
This is something I've never heard of, but my gut tells me there's something off. This is too good to be true. My dad thinks he bought a business, and the guy to sold it said he'll 100% help him to set it up because my dad doesn't have too much knowledge in business. The benefit wa
ShaunaNow

ShaunaNow

5 likes

What I bought in Japan after visiting for 9 days
Half of my suitcase was empty when I came and it was completely full when I got back #japan #japantravels #travels #whatiboughtinjapan #japanlife #japantravel
Ellie Skarvelis

Ellie Skarvelis

31 likes

I bought 2 of the Moroccan Rose Sprays 🫶
I was shocked by how good they smell. I showed the cashier and she said she was gonna swipe some of them 🤣 💌 Brand: Personal Care 💵 Price: $1.25 👍Pros : Smells just like bath and body works no weird 🥶 smells Purchased from: DOLLAR TREE ⭐️Overall rating: 15/10 Chicago #dollartreefinds #
Cinnamon8

Cinnamon8

143 likes

Bought an IPad for my Fiance 🥹🥹
#lemon8diarychallenge said he never had the tablet experience as a kid so here you go baby 🥹🥹
Pumpkin 🇯🇲

Pumpkin 🇯🇲

10 likes

How I bought my dream car at 16
Ever since I seen a Camaro, I knew I wanted one. At first my mom was very hesitant of me buying one because she thought it was too dangerous for me. I was planning on getting a truck instead, but trucks were way more expensive. My mom ended up agreeing on the Camaro, finally after a lot of beggin
yuzzz

yuzzz

0 likes

Dad bought mom a valentine cookie
jeanineparker

jeanineparker

2 likes

A screenshot of a Home Depot 'Chat with Us' conversation showing a customer's question about delivery time, overlaid with 'WTF?', and a chat representative's message ending with the phrase 'I don't really give a fuck', underlined in red.
Home Depot chat rep said ‘I don’t give a F’
My Home Depot saga is WILD. I bought a stove, but no one showed up after a full day wait. Rescheduled, then the second crew couldn’t install (no “certified” tech). Third time, the guy RIPPED out the gas line violently, left plastic wrap on. When I begged for a refund, their chat rep hit me with
Olivia❤️

Olivia❤️

89 likes

My Husband Accidentally Bought Scented Toilet Paper & I Have Questions 😭🧻
My husband came home with some toilet paper the other day…why this man bought SCENTED toilet paper 😭🤣 Now who at the factory sat around and said, “You know what women need? Perfumed booty tissue.” Because baby… absolutely not. 😂 They clearly were NOT thinking about us sensitive girlies when they
Nicka Harper-Bohannon ✨💛

Nicka Harper-Bohannon ✨💛

11 likes

See more