Pick a side

Okay, so you've seen the initial comparison, and truly, the E.L.F. Lip Oil and NYX Fat Oil are everywhere right now! As someone who's constantly on the hunt for the best affordable beauty finds, I felt compelled to dive even deeper into this popular lip oil battle. My initial thoughts were just the tip of the iceberg, and after weeks of testing both the NYX clear lip oil and the E.L.F. clear lip oil extensively, I have even more insights beyond just texture and applicator. The image showed 'What team are you on?' and I'm here to help you pick yours! Let's talk about what makes the E.L.F. Lip Oil truly stand out. While I noted its gloss-like consistency earlier, it’s more than just that. It gives this beautiful, cushiony feel on the lips, almost like a plush balm but with the shine of a gloss. It’s incredibly comfortable and doesn’t feel sticky at all, which is a huge plus for me. I've found it lasts a decent few hours before needing a reapplication, especially if I'm not eating or drinking heavily. The slightly larger, softer applicator isn't just a comfort thing; it really helps to coat the lips evenly in one swipe, delivering that perfect, full-looking pout. It’s definitely my pick when I want that juicy, high-shine finish that screams 'healthy lips.' Now, onto the NYX Fat Oil. The original review mentioned it being 'more oily,' and I want to expand on that. It truly feels like a nourishing oil treatment for your lips. It's thinner in consistency than the E.L.F. and glides on effortlessly, almost melting into the lips. If you're someone who dislikes any hint of stickiness, this one might be more up your alley. It provides a lovely, natural sheen that looks incredibly hydrated and soft, rather than overtly glossy. While the applicator is smaller, it's still quite effective at distributing the product. I've noticed the NYX Fat Oil tends to absorb a bit more quickly into the lips, leaving them feeling deeply moisturized even after the shine has faded. This makes it a fantastic option for daily wear, especially if you're dealing with drier lips and need that constant boost of hydration. The name 'Fat Oil' really fits the luxurious, conditioning feel it provides. Beyond the clear shades, both brands offer an array of beautiful tints that are worth exploring. The E.L.F. Lip Oil often comes in shades that give a subtle plumping effect or a hint of color, perfect for a natural look. The NYX Fat Oil also boasts a variety of sheer, juicy colors that add just a wash of tint, enhancing your natural lip color. So, if you're looking to graduate from the clear versions, there’s a whole world of options! So, who wins the great E.L.F. vs NYX lip oil debate? It honestly boils down to personal preference and what you're looking for in a lip product. If you crave that luxurious, cushiony, high-gloss finish that makes your lips look fuller and juicier, the E.L.F. Lip Oil is your champion. It’s amazing for adding that extra 'oomph' to any look. However, if you prefer a more lightweight, deeply hydrating, and natural-looking oil that truly feels like a treatment for your lips, the NYX Fat Oil is an absolute gem. It excels at keeping lips soft and moisturized throughout the day with a subtle, healthy sheen. Both are fantastic, affordable choices that deliver on their promises. You might find yourself, like me, needing both for different occasions. So, when it comes to deciding which team you're on – Team E.L.F. or Team NYX – why not just try both and see which one becomes your everyday go-to?