Amish haystack dinner

Wisconsin
2024/12/7 Edited to

... Read moreI recently stumbled upon the concept of an Amish Haystack Dinner, and let me tell you, it's become a new favorite in my household! If you're wondering, "what is an Amish haystack dinner?" – imagine a deconstructed, build-your-own meal, served in layers, much like a haystack. It’s comforting, incredibly versatile, and perfect for feeding a crowd or just making a fun family supper. The beauty of this haystack dinner is its simplicity and adaptability. The core idea behind an Amish haystack meal is a base (often rice or crushed crackers), topped with a savory protein, a creamy sauce, and then an array of fresh, crunchy toppings. It’s a genius way to get everyone involved in customizing their plate. My first time making an Amish haystack recipe, I was surprised at how straightforward it was. No fancy cooking skills required, just good, wholesome ingredients coming together. Let's talk about the essential Amish haystack dinner ingredients. Typically, you start with a base. Cooked white rice is classic, but some people use crushed Fritos or even mashed potatoes for a heartier foundation. Next comes the protein layer. Ground beef, often seasoned with a simple gravy or tomato sauce, is the standard. However, I’ve experimented with shredded chicken and even a plant-based mince for a vegetarian twist, and both worked wonderfully. While the query mentioned "pork shoulder recipe," that's not typical for a traditional haystack, but you could certainly adapt shredded pork for a unique variation! Now for the fun part: the toppings! This is where you can truly make your haystack dinner your own. Common toppings include shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, chopped onions (green or red), black olives, shredded cheese (cheddar or Monterey Jack are popular), and a dollop of sour cream. For a little extra kick, don't forget salsa or a dash of hot sauce. You might have heard of "Hawaiian haystacks" – these are a delightful variation! Instead of the savory ground beef, they often feature a creamy chicken or turkey base, and the toppings lean towards tropical flavors like pineapple chunks, coconut flakes, mandarin oranges, and chow mein noodles for crunch. It’s a completely different flavor profile but follows the same awesome "build-your-own" concept. I tried making a Hawaiian version recently, and adding some toasted coconut really elevated it! Making your own Amish haystacks is incredibly easy. Here’s a super simple rundown for my go-to version: Cook your base: Prepare white rice according to package directions. Brown the meat: Sauté a pound of ground beef with diced onions and garlic. Drain any fat. Sauce it up: Stir in a can of tomato sauce or cream of mushroom soup (or a mix of both) with a little water or broth to create a savory, pourable sauce. Season with salt, pepper, and a pinch of garlic powder. Let it simmer gently. Prepare toppings: Chop all your desired vegetables and cheeses. Get creative! Serve buffet style: Lay out the rice, meat mixture, and all the toppings in separate bowls. Everyone can then build their perfect Amish haystack food masterpiece. It’s truly an interactive and delicious meal that encourages everyone to eat their veggies without even realizing it. Whether you're looking for a quick weeknight meal or something fun to serve guests, the Amish haystack dinner is a winner. It's so much more than just a dish; it's an experience! I haven't tried making "rivel soup amish" yet, but that's next on my list if it's as comforting as this haystack meal!

13 comments

Luckeyred's images
Luckeyred

Looks delicious

BakerMama's images
BakerMama

Good stuff!! 👍

See more comments

Related posts

Exploring Amish Country 🐴🥨😱
Everything I did in Amish Country. I’m still thinking about that pretzel I had—seriously, it was amazing! 🤤Most of what I did was in the little town of Intercourse, which is super cute and has that peaceful, old-school feel. I checked out some local shops where they sell handmade quilts, candles, a
Savannah Vinson

Savannah Vinson

3554 likes

Amish Hamburger Steak Bake
Ingredients 🛒: 1 ½ lbs ground beef 🥩 ½ cup breadcrumbs 1 egg, beaten 🥚 ½ tsp salt 🧂 ½ tsp black pepper ½ tsp garlic powder 🧄 ½ tsp onion powder 1 tbsp Worcestershire sauce 1 medium onion, sliced 🧅 2 tbsp butter 2 tbsp flour 2 cups beef broth 1 tbsp ketchup 🍅 ½ tsp paprika ½ tsp dri
foodandrecipes

foodandrecipes

44 likes

Haystack Cookies (No Bake)
Ingredients: - 1 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips - 1 cup butterscotch chips - 2 cups chow mein noodles - 1 cup unsweetened shredded coconut - 1/2 cup chopped walnuts or pecans (optional) - 1 teaspoon vanilla extract - Parchment paper or wax paper for lining Directions: 1. Begin by prepari
Mariela Madrigal

Mariela Madrigal

48 likes

oregon photodump #1!
#oregon #cannonbeach #haystackrock #ecolapark
Charlie ☻

Charlie ☻

2 likes

You’re making this for dinner tonight 😉
#easyrecipes #easydinners #cookingideas #enchiladacasserole #dinnerideas
Bri

Bri

112 likes

Amish Hamburger Steaks Recipe
If you’re craving a delicious, hearty meal that’s easy to prepare- look no further! Perfect for a weeknight meal or even family gatherings.😋 🤍Steaks: 1 1/2 lbs ground beef 1/2 C breadcrumbs 1 egg 1 tsp garlic powder 1 tsp onion powder Salt and pepper, to taste 🤍Gravy: 1 can cream of mushro
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

504 likes

Haystack Recipe
My father in law asked for this constantly because he loves it so much and I didn’t mind making it because this is such a easy quick recipe! Also who doesn’t love No-Bake Recipes!! Ingredients - •3/4 cup dry-roasted, salted peanuts 1 (11-ounce) bag butterscotch chips (about 2 cups) 1/2 cup c
Emma 🌷🐣🌱🌸

Emma 🌷🐣🌱🌸

46 likes

A pan filled with creamy lemon chicken pasta, featuring penne noodles and diced chicken, with a wooden spoon. The image is titled 'Creamy Lemon Chicken Pasta' and indicates a swipe for more content.
Several breaded chicken tenders are placed inside an air fryer basket, ready for cooking. The text overlay instructs to 'Grill or fry some chicken'.
A white cutting board shows diced white onion, lemon zest next to a grater, and lemon juice in a measuring cup. The image instructs to 'Zest & juice lemon' and 'Dice onion'.
Creamy Lemon Chicken Pasta 🍋🍝
✨Ingredients -1lb chicken breast or frozen breaded tenders -1lb penne pasta -4 tbsp butter -1/2 cup diced white onion 🧅 -1 1/2 tbsp minced garlic 🧄 -1 cup heavy cream -1 cup chicken broth -1 1/2 cups shredded Parmesan cheese 🧀 -1 tbsp lemon zest, 3 tbsp lemon juice (fresh, about 2 lem
gracie🧁

gracie🧁

501 likes

A top-down view shows several no-bake haystack cookies, made from chow mein noodles coated in a light brown, sweet mixture, arranged on a dark baking sheet. Text overlays read 'Cozy Desserts: Suzanne's Haystack Cookies' and 'No Baking Required'.
Cozy Desserts:Suzanne’s Haystack Cookies
#cozyrecipes #lemon8challenge #dessert #easyrecipe #nobakerecipe #haystacks #cookies As a little girl, my Moma and I made these every Thanksgiving and Christmas. I always felt so special getting to be in the kitchen with her! Ingredients: ▢ 12 ounces white chocolate disks , (
RebeccaAnderson

RebeccaAnderson

328 likes

HomemadeMac-N-Cheese 🤌
#homemademacandcheese #mac and cheese. #dinnermadeeasy #dinneridea💡
Kayla Gutierrez

Kayla Gutierrez

458 likes

Haystack cookies - No Bake
Ingredients • 1 (11-oz) bag butterscotch chips (about 2 cups) • 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter (not natural) • 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt • 3/4 cup dry-roasted salted peanuts, roughly chopped • 1 (12-oz) can fried chow mein noodles Instructions &#
wendycutkomp

wendycutkomp

9 likes

A scenic coastal view of the Oregon coast with a dirt path, lush greenery, and the ocean, featuring the title 'OREGON The ULTIMATE pacific coast roadtrip & best viewpoints to stop at'.
A collage showing Haystack Rock at Cannon Beach, Arcadia Beach Rec Site, Short Sand Beach, and Devil's Cauldron at Oswald West State Park, highlighting key Oregon coast road trip stops.
A collage featuring Neahkahnie Viewpoint, Lighthouse & Sea Lion Beach Vantage Point in Florence, Natural Bridges in Brookings, and Battle Rock Wayside Park in Port Orford, showcasing diverse Oregon coast attractions.
Ultimate OREGON Coast Roadtrip & Best Viewpoints
The Oregon coastline is such a unique place & the best way to see everything is by doing a great american road trip! Start your trip on the northern coast near Astoria or Cannon Beach and take US 101 down to Brookings, OR. Here are some of the most memorable stops to make along the way: 1. H
sydneyblandford

sydneyblandford

326 likes

This soup seriously never misses. My cookbook is available on my website ➡️
Lovina

Lovina

49 likes

Visit Oregon🌲🌊
Newport, OR 7/10 Newport - GREAT place to visit if you love fishing or crabbing, it sits in the bay so it’s great for those activities. You’re also able to walk the bay front with super cute shops and of course watch the seals. Jackelope Jamboree 10/10 Pendleton - give me a music festiv
morganne

morganne

409 likes

There’s is nothing more romantic than a home cooked meal// a tried a true love language made easy - when in doubt- a Bolognese will always do - SAVE this for Valentines Day or anytime you want to make a hearty feel good meal - recipe below xx #dishonamish 💋 Ingredients: 2-3 cloves of garlic
Tara Carver

Tara Carver

1 like

Visit Cannon Beach, OR. (Haystack and the needles)
#ThingsToDo #lemon8challenge #haystackrock #beachyvibes #oregoncoast Cannon Beach Haystack Rock ⭐️Overall rating: /10:10 perfection 😘
Sheldo 🫶🏼

Sheldo 🫶🏼

46 likes

SWEET AMISH MACARONI SALAD
Sweet Amish Macaroni Salad Classic Creamy Macaroni Salad with Hard-Boiled Eggs, Celery, Bell Pepper, Sweet Relish, and a Sweet Tangy Dressing Ingredients: 2 cups uncooked elbow macaroni 3 large eggs, hard-boiled and chopped 3 celery stalks, chopped 1 small onion, finely diced 1 small red
marybowling698

marybowling698

2 likes

For all my home farmers that grew lots of eggplant
Here's some recipes that you can make from your garden to your dinner table 😋 😉...enjoy friends 🧡
Rolinda Martes Reyes

Rolinda Martes Reyes

15 likes

Vacation Eats 🫶🌸Amish
Amish Country Vacation Eats 🍴 BOYD & WURTHMAN Restaurant Amish Style foods & dessert . Roast beef sandwich with gravy 🥪 & 🍟 french fries I regretted not getting the chicken dinner. so indecisive 😂 What would you have ordered ? 🍽️ Berlin Boyd & Wurthmann Rest
Livs Life ✨SAHM

Livs Life ✨SAHM

3 likes

Loving All These Holiday Treats
Which one are you baking? #Recipe #recipes #holidaydessert #christmas #deliciousfood
bountifulmamas.com

bountifulmamas.com

2 likes

Haystack Rock
Haystack Rock on canyon beach. Oregon coastline Cannon Beach #canonbeach #oregon #beauty #explore #travel
Mike Ⓜ️

Mike Ⓜ️

26 likes

A scenic view of Haystack Rock and other sea stacks on an Oregon beach. Waves crash on the sandy shore, which is scattered with driftwood, under a bright blue sky with white clouds.
Haystack Rock
Felt like I needed to be on a treasure hunt! 🤪 #haystackrock #oregon #goonies #beachyvibes #ocean
haileyybrooke15

haileyybrooke15

5 likes

Recipe for thought
#recipe #recipeidea
Chantel Johnson

Chantel Johnson

4 likes

Oregon Haystack Rock
It’s a blessing I live in Oregon. Comment below your favorite state to live in. Haystack Rock #oregon #travel #lifestyle #nature #explore
Mike Ⓜ️

Mike Ⓜ️

41 likes

Haystack Rock
Located in Oregon on Canon Beach Haystack Rock #oregon #lemon8creator #travel #beauty #beautiful
Mike Ⓜ️

Mike Ⓜ️

21 likes

🌻LYNN🌻💜

🌻LYNN🌻💜

7 likes

A recipe card for 'Haystack Cookies' featuring a pile of the no-bake cookies made with chow mein noodles and a butterscotch mixture. It lists ingredients like butterscotch chips, peanut butter, salted peanuts, and chow mein noodles, with a cartoon Santa Claus and product images.
No Bake Haystack Cookies
✨ No-Bake Haystack Cookies (Mama-Approved + So Easy!) These little bundles of chocolatey-crunchy goodness come together in 10 minutes flat. No oven, no stress — just melt, mix, scoop, and let the magic happen. Perfect for last-minute treats, kid-friendly baking days, or when you just want somethin
bountifulmamas.com

bountifulmamas.com

33 likes

Haystack Rock-Oregon
Cool places in- Oregon 📍Location: Cannon Beach 📝Description: Beautiful beach in Cannon Beach where you can see Haystack Rock known for being in movies like The Goonies (my childhood favorite) Need To Note: Bring sweaters!! It’s cold even in July on the beach #cannonbeach #travel #travelre
NatureBoundTravels

NatureBoundTravels

19 likes

Cannon Beach, Oregon
Elk enjoy a sunrise walk in front of Haystack Rock on Cannon Beach! Cannon Beach #cannonbeach #oregoncoast #lemon8travel #oregon
JillyBean

JillyBean

153 likes

A black sand beach with two prominent sea stacks rising from the ocean under a clear blue sky. The image has text overlay "Instead of... ICELAND", suggesting a travel alternative.
A wide sandy beach with a large sea stack, Haystack Rock, in the distance, under a bright sky. People are walking along the shoreline. The image has text overlay "Try... CANNON BEACH OREGON".
A scenic coastal view from a grassy hillside, showing a sandy beach, several sea stacks in the ocean, and lush green mountains under a partly cloudy sky.
INSTEAD OF ICELAND…
Instead of Iceland…Try Cannon Beach, Oregon!! Now obviously Oregon doesn’t have any glaciers or volcanos 🤪, but it does have rugged beaches with stunning rock formations, similar to those of Iceland (especially Reynisfjara Beach!). If Iceland is on your bucket list, you are sure to love Cannon Beac
Niki ◡̈ global guru

Niki ◡̈ global guru

1125 likes

A sage green aesthetic collage featuring various items like a typewriter, macarons, a cake, and a phone, with a light green brushstroke overlay stating 'GAMER MUST HAVE Buy or Bye'.
A light green gaming chair with a headrest and lumbar support cushion, featuring a black logo and armrests, presented against a white background.
A large gaming mouse pad featuring a whimsical illustration of green frogs in a plant-filled greenhouse setting, with various potted plants and mushrooms.
SAGE GREEN: DREAM GAMER SETUP!
#gamergirl #lemon8challenge #storytime #aestheticgaming #cutegamingsetup #sage #sagegreen this would be my dream set up or something similar to it if i was about to start a proper setup for myself with my games. here is some inspiration too for anyone who wants a cute theme of green
bree 🤍

bree 🤍

530 likes

Amish steak bake for dinner! One of our faves 😋 #dinnerwithme #Recipe #fyp #foryoupage #steakbake
Alli Morua

Alli Morua

6 likes

Soulful Fall Soup Season Episode 1
Cooking thru life’s moments Warm bowls 🥣 Cozy hearts.🧡 Fall Soup Series begins Episode 1 🍁 #cookingthruit #yadadiscovery #midlifewomen #soupseason #dinnerideasblackpeople #foodandemotions #cookingthrulifesmoments #cookingthroughit Raleigh
kimyada919

kimyada919

2 likes

Relaxing Drinking my Favorite
White Russian.📍Location: The Club Car . While eating dinner.
Amish Mormon Author Winter.

Amish Mormon Author Winter.

2 likes

Amish Apple Fritter Bread
https://www.allrecipes.com/amish-apple-fritter-bread-recipe-11859335?hid=089239e3a6031784c653257bcc40e98bed3a2e55&did=20897946-20251225&utm_campaign=alrcom-dinner-tonight_newsletter&utm_source=alrcom&utm_medium=email&utm_content=122525&utm_term=recipe-of-the-day&lctg=089
Jan Verschoor 🟨⬜🟪⬛

Jan Verschoor 🟨⬜🟪⬛

15 likes

A study desk with a tablet displaying images, a water bottle, and a glass. Overlay text reads '5 Free Resources You Probably Haven't Tried Yet,' introducing study tools.
A screenshot of the Perplexity AI interface, showing a search bar and options. The accompanying text describes it as a tool for direct answers and cited sources for research papers.
A screenshot of the Connected Papers interface, illustrating a visual graph of academic papers. The text explains its function in creating a visual map of related research articles.
5 game-changing study resources that cost you $0
🧠1. Perplexity AI: I used to get so lost in endless search results when starting a research paper. Perplexity saves me time by giving me a direct summary of any topic while citing all its sources, so I know the information is reliable. 🗺️2. Connected Papers: Writing literature reviews felt lik
emilie.studygram

emilie.studygram

912 likes

A close-up of a savory dish with green onions, featuring the title "SAN FRANCISCO'S 25 TOP RESTAURANTS, BAKERIES, BARS, CAFES, & DESSERTS 2025" from Beli, indicating a curated list of top establishments.
A dish topped with caviar and green slices serves as the background for a list of San Francisco's top 12 restaurants for 2025, including Noodle in a Haystack, Lazy Bear, and Californios, with their respective neighborhoods.
A cross-section of a burrito forms the background for a list of San Francisco's top restaurants 13-25 for 2025, featuring establishments like Hwa Mi Won, Cotogna, and Kokkari Estiatorio, with their neighborhoods.
The Top Rated Restaurants, Bakeries, Bars, Cafes, and Dessert Spots in SF
Based on over 90 million ratings from the Beli community. This list represents some of the city’s most beloved establishments—across cuisines, neighborhoods, and price points.  See the full SF restaurant list on Beli. Rank the ones you’ve been to. Bookmark the spots you still need to try.
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

1 like

Some things I learned in the book of Proverbs 🩷🌸
#womenbiblestudy #fyp #biblestudyforwomen #biblestudy #christiantiktok
Morgan❣️

Morgan❣️

86 likes

See more