An alternative to Paula’s Choice BHA Toner

2024/6/9 Edited to

... Read moreAfter years of religiously using Paula's Choice 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant, I found myself wondering if there was a more budget-friendly option that could deliver similar, impressive results. That's when I stumbled upon the Naturium BHA Liquid Exfoliant, which also proudly boasts 2% salicylic acid. My initial interest was immediately piqued by the significant price difference – Paula's Choice typically runs around $35, while Naturium is a much more appealing $18 for a 4.0 fl oz bottle. As someone always on the lookout for effective skincare that doesn't break the bank, this comparison was hard to ignore. So, what's my take after incorporating it into my routine? The Naturium BHA Liquid Exfoliant comes in a sleek, minimalistic dark blue bottle, just like the one I'm holding in my picture, containing 2% salicylic acid and a blend of bioactive fruit acids. The texture is quite similar to Paula's Choice – a lightweight, watery liquid that absorbs quickly without leaving any sticky residue. I typically apply it after cleansing and before my serums, either by gently sweeping it across my face with a cotton pad or simply patting it directly onto my skin with clean hands. I find this method ensures good absorption and minimal product waste. One of the core reasons I rely so heavily on a BHA toner is its incredible ability to tackle congested pores, stubborn blackheads, and overall uneven skin texture. Salicylic acid is uniquely oil-soluble, which means it can effectively penetrate deep into the pores to dissolve excess sebum and dead skin cells, making it an absolute powerhouse ingredient for those prone to breakouts, or with oily and combination skin types. I’ve noticed that both products have been instrumental in helping to keep my skin clear, smooth, and less prone to unwelcome surprises. While I can't definitively say yet if Naturium's version is as potent as Paula's Choice in the long run – only time and consistent use will tell – my skin has certainly responded positively to it. I haven't experienced any irritation, redness, or unexpected breakouts since making the switch, which is always a huge relief when introducing a new active ingredient. It feels gentle yet thoroughly effective, and I appreciate the added benefit of bioactive fruit acids, which contribute another layer of gentle exfoliation and skin brightening. If you're currently using Paula's Choice and are considering making a switch for cost-effectiveness, or if you're simply in the market for an effective, affordable BHA treatment, the Naturium BHA Liquid Exfoliant is definitely worth checking out. Remember, consistency is absolutely key with chemical exfoliants! I personally use mine a few nights a week, but it's crucial to listen to your skin's needs and adjust frequency accordingly. And a non-negotiable tip: whether you're using Paula's Choice, Naturium, or any other BHA, please, please don't forget your daily broad-spectrum SPF during the day. Exfoliated skin is more sensitive to sun exposure, and protecting it is paramount. For anyone curious about finding high-quality alternatives to cult favorites, this Naturium toner stands out as a strong contender. It delivers on the core benefits of salicylic acid – clarifying pores and refining skin texture – at a significantly lower price point, making effective skincare more accessible to a wider audience. It's truly encouraging to see more brands offering quality ingredients and formulations without the hefty price tag. Give it a try; you might just discover your next holy grail product!

Related posts

A person sits on a beach at sunset, looking back at the camera. The image is overlaid with the text "Feminine Glow Up Phase 2 - Beauty & Self Care."
A list of morning skincare routine steps: cleanser, toner/mist, antioxidant serum, hydrating serum, eye cream, moisturizer, and sunscreen. Several skincare product bottles and tubes are shown below the text.
A list of nighttime skincare routine steps: oil-based cleanser, water-based cleanser, toner/mist, targeted serum, eye cream, retinol, and moisturizer. A pink silk eye mask is shown below the text.
Enter your glow up era! Step-by-Step Glow Up Plan
Glowing up is an exciting journey that encompasses self-care, grooming, and beauty routines. Here's my in-depth guide part two of a larger series, that includes products, routines, and tips to help you look and feel your best. I’ll be making a larger post with links on my blog too! I’ll post it
Chalie_Baker

Chalie_Baker

3647 likes

A woman in a grey sports bra and pink tie-dye leggings poses, indicating a 'FLAT TUMMY TONER WORKOUT'. She stands in front of white shutters, with text overlay and Lemon8 branding.
A woman in athletic wear lies on a mat, demonstrating the 'Dead bugs' exercise. Her knees are bent, arms extended, with text overlay indicating 30 seconds x2. Lemon8 branding is visible.
A woman in athletic wear performs a side plank on a mat, viewed from behind. Her right hand is on her hip, with text overlay 'Side plank: 30 seconds both sides'. Lemon8 branding is present.
FLAT TUMMY TONER WORKOUT
Activate your core effectively during workouts by engaging key muscles such as the transverse abdominis, obliques, and rectus abdominis. Focus on proper breathing, drawing the belly button towards the spine, and maintaining a neutral spine position. Incorporate exercises like planks, bridges, and v
Ava

Ava

5207 likes

A collection of various toner pad containers of different colors and sizes, arranged on a marble surface, with text indicating a rating of toner pads.
Three different toner pad containers, rated 6/10, 7.5/10, and 6/10 respectively, displayed on a marble surface.
Three different toner pad containers, rated 7.5/10, 8/10, and 8/10 respectively, displayed on a marble surface.
brutally rating all my toner pads
when i say its super hard for me to find toner pads that work for me, I MEAN IT !!!! i def have more in my collection that i have not opened yet and will open soon (as soon as i finish these)! 👀 products mentioned: - NEEDLY daily toner pad - TORRIDEN balanceful toner pads - ABIB heartleaf spot
stephanie🧖🏻‍♀️

stephanie🧖🏻‍♀️

2158 likes

The image displays various skincare products, including a spray mist, tubes, and jars, arranged on a light surface. Overlay text reads "choosing skincare a guide" with a pink ribbon emoji, and "SWIPE" in the top right corner.
This image outlines a recommended morning and evening skincare routine, listing steps like cleanser, toner, serum, moisturizer, eye cream, and sunscreen. It also suggests starting with cleanser, moisturizer, and sunscreen for those on a budget.
The image provides guidance on choosing a cleanser based on skin type. It lists specific ingredients for oily, dry, combination/sensitive, and midway skin to address concerns like oil control, hydration, and gentleness.
choosing skincare, a guide🎀.
a guide to skincare! products & ingredients to look for🎀. comment what you’d like to see content-wise💓. follow for more skincare, makeup, & lifestyle posts💓. ————————————————————————————— my personal favorite , affordable, skincare products, with combo skin (more on the dry side): ———
˚ʚ♡ɞ˚mads ˚ʚ♡ɞ˚

˚ʚ♡ɞ˚mads ˚ʚ♡ɞ˚

8549 likes

Mediheal toner pad 🛍
Which Mediheal toner pad is right for your skin concern? #koreanskincare #korea #skincare #skincareroutine #skincareproducts #pad #pads #mediheal toner pad #mediheal #skincaretips
Yasuan Vega

Yasuan Vega

5837 likes

A hand holds a container of toner pads, with text indicating an "HONEST REVIEW" of the product. The container label shows it contains AHA, BHA, Panthenol, Allantoin, and Sodium Hyaluronate.
A person with a pink headband applies a pad to their face in a bathroom, with text stating they use the product once a day as twice was too much for their skin.
A hand holds a round pad, illustrating its textured side, with a smaller image showing its flat side. Text indicates the pad has both a textured and a flat side.
my honest review: medicube toner pads 💙
swipe to the end for the rating!!⭐️ the only cons i have had with this product is the first time i used it, i noticed my skin gained more texture. i have never used toner before so i believe my skin was just reacting to the exfoliation and new product. but i love how this makes my skin feel
hi! im reis 🤍

hi! im reis 🤍

448 likes

A close-up image of a person with blonde hair and natural makeup, featuring glossy lips. The text overlay reads "important makeup tips" with decorative sparkles.
A guide titled "SKIN PREP HOW-TO" with bullet points detailing steps like cleansing, exfoliating, toning, applying eye cream, and moisturizing. Various skincare product containers are displayed at the bottom.
A section titled "EYEBROW TIPS" providing advice on shaping brows, using foundation and concealer, applying brow gel, and creating hair-like strokes with a liquid pen. Various brow products are shown below.
makeup tips, w pics 🎀.
important makeup tips, with pictures ! comment what else you’d like to see content-wise 🎀. follow for more makeup/skincare/lifestyle content🎀. ————————————————————————————— my personal favorite skin prep / makeup products with prices! skin prep⬇️. ————————————————————————————— cleanser: cera
˚ʚ♡ɞ˚mads ˚ʚ♡ɞ˚

˚ʚ♡ɞ˚mads ˚ʚ♡ɞ˚

11.6K likes

DIY Face Toner/Brightening ✨🤍🫶
This helps with decorations on any part of the body . . #skingoals #skincare #skin #DIY #glassskin #face #tumeric #honey #lemon8contentcreator
Fatimatu

Fatimatu

296 likes

Sephora sale recs next? Got kicked out but we kept it moving—Deinfluencing the Sephora sale before you waste your $$$ Products mentioned: @loréal paris usa everpure glossing hair mask @Naturium barrier bounce serum Naturium 2% BHA toner @Remedy Science cleansing balm L’Oréal infallible
Sarah Palmyra✨

Sarah Palmyra✨

112 likes

A grid displaying various skincare products for an AM & PM routine for oily/combo skin. Products include cleansers, toners, serums, moisturizers, and a sunscreen, arranged on a white background.
This image shows three cleansers. A tube cleanser is for morning use. Two pump bottle cleansers, one oil-based and one gel-based, are for night use.
This image displays two toners. A clear liquid toner in a tall bottle is for morning use. A liquid exfoliant in a black bottle is for night use.
Morning/Night skincare routine for oily skin🫧
Staying consistent with this routine has helped minimize the appearance of my pores and oil production, without damaging my skin barrier and drying out my skin. It’s important to have a balance of hydrating and exfoliating products in your routine which is why these have been my go-to products! 1.
Melanie

Melanie

664 likes

A flat lay of various skincare products, including bottles and jars, on a textured white surface. A text overlay asks, 'which toner pad is right for you?'.
Six different containers of skincare pads are displayed on a textured surface, with a text overlay indicating they are for 'acne prone skin'. The containers vary in color and shape.
Six different containers of skincare pads are shown on a textured surface, with a text overlay indicating they are for 'redness'. The containers vary in color and design.
Toner Pad ✨
which toner pad is right for you?... product mentionned: Mediheal madecassoside blemish pad medicube super cica pad skin 1004 centella quick calming pad abib heartleaf spot pad anua heartleaf clear pad torriden balenceful cica toner pad april skin carroten instant calming serum pad
Yasuan Vega

Yasuan Vega

2703 likes

✨DIY Flaxseed, Aloe Vera, & Witch Hazel Toner🌿✨
Transform your skincare routine with this easy-to-make, all-natural toner! Combining the power of flaxseeds, aloe vera, and witch hazel, this DIY toner will leave your skin feeling hydrated, refreshed, and soothed. #skincare #SkincareTips #naturalskincare #DIY #Toner
Terri 💛🌻✌🏾

Terri 💛🌻✌🏾

821 likes

DON’T Do This With Your Toner!
#dermreacts #skincare #dermatologist #reaction #reactionvideo #dermangelo
DermAngelo

DermAngelo

320 likes

A hand holds The Ordinary Saccharomyces Ferment 30% Milky Toner. Text highlights its benefits: skin smoothing, exfoliation, hydration, skin softening, supporting the skin barrier, evening skin tone, brightening, and correcting dark spots.
The ordinary milky toner 🥛✨
New to my skincare routine. As an acne prone girly, i take my skincare seriously. After years of trying and testing out products, I finally have my routine tailored just right. Most of what i use today have been in my skincare collection for years. I've been using this tonner for 3-4 we
Noble Lately

Noble Lately

722 likes

A person's legs in a bubble bath with a blue loofah and rubber duck, illustrating a post-workout routine for preventing and treating acne, and achieving glowy, hydrated skin.
Text outlines post-gym shower steps: rinse immediately and use active ingredient body wash for acne-prone areas, applying with hands or a silicone brush. A yellow rubber duck is visible.
Instructions for gentle face cleansing, recommending specific cleansers for oily/acne-prone or normal/dry skin, and ending with a cool water rinse. A pink loofah is shown.
QUICK Post Gym GLOWY SKIN & Acne-Free Routine🫧✨🧼🛁
POST-GYM SHOWER ROUTINE 🫧1. Rinse Off Immediately The faster you shower after a workout, the less time sweat, bacteria, and oils have to clog pores and cause acne. If you can’t shower right away, use body wipes with antibacterial or acne-fighting ingredients (e.g., Bravo Sierra Antibacterial
Chalie_Baker

Chalie_Baker

757 likes

A white bottle of a milky toner is presented on a textured white surface. The image introduces this new skincare product, emphasizing its milky texture.
the ordinary milky toner 🥛✨
this toner is very affordable and definitely some thing I would recommend. the consistency is a little bit thinner than the rhode glazing milk and gives a little less of a glow on the skin, but it is still a great affordable option! 💰price: $14.00 💰price: (rhode) $30.00 #the ordinary prod
Rylee Guillory

Rylee Guillory

534 likes

🫧DIY Cucumber Toner 🥒🫧
Check out this simple DIY Cucumber Toner. Only using 3 simple ingredients meant to hydrate and cleanse your skin ☺️ Have you tried this DIY toner or any others?? #DIY #Toner #naturalskincare #skincare #skincareroutine #skincareproducts #skin #Lemon8 #summerdiary #blackgirlc
Terri 💛🌻✌🏾

Terri 💛🌻✌🏾

393 likes

the last one might be my favorite hehe let me know if any questions! products in vid: @Paula’s Choice Skin Perfecting 6% Mandelic Acid + 2% Lactic Acid AHA Liquid Exfoliant @EADEM Cashmere Peel Gentle AHA + PHA Exfoliating Toner @Cetaphil US Gentle Skin Cleanser & Moisturizing Lotion @dermalo
Dr. Madalyn

Dr. Madalyn

9 likes

A person wearing a black satin bonnet takes a selfie, with text overlay indicating a skin smoothing journey over two weeks.
A close-up of a person's forehead shows bumpy, textured, and congested skin, labeled as 'BEFORE' with arrows pointing to the texture.
A close-up of a person's forehead appears smoother and clearer, labeled as 'AFTER', showcasing improved skin texture.
3 PRODUCTS THAT CLEARED MY SKIN TEXTURE IN 2 WEEKS
My forehead was bumpy, congested, and textured — and I fixed it in two weeks. I know how frustrating skin texture can be, especially when you feel like you’ve tried everything. These three products completely changed my skin and I need to share them with you. No complicated 10-step routine,
siren.🦋

siren.🦋

62 likes

@Paula’s Choice aha bha toner @dermalogica eye cream @The Ordinary niacinamide @Neutrogena hydro boost moisturizer #lazygirlskincare #nighttimeskincare
Ushumusu

Ushumusu

8 likes

An image comparing two toner bottles: a rice ceramide moisturizing toner and a milky toner. Overlay text highlights rice toner for brightening, hydration, and skin barrier support, suitable for dry/sensitive skin, and milky toner for exfoliation, smoothing, and hydration, ideal for normal to combination skin.
Rice vs Milk (toner edition)
Hola beautiful! Milk and rice are really big in the market right now. But is it really great for you? I have both of them and I personally prefer rice cuz that is what my skin needs. But skin can vary from person to person. **Choose Rice Ceramide Toner for hydration, brightening, and skin barrie
Nina

Nina

690 likes

Can we talk about these toner pads?!
"I’ve tried three different kinds of toner pads, and these MEDIHEAL Madecassoside Cotton Facial Pads are a game changer! 🌿 From soothing redness to improving uneven skin tone, they've been a lifesaver for my sensitive skin. Packed with Centella Asiatica and completely vegan, they're gen
Naffy🤗

Naffy🤗

404 likes

Vanilla Gym Aftercare:Post-Workout Glow-Up Routine
Hey besties!! So you already know I’m all about matching sets, pre-workout vibes, and feeling like ✨THAT GIRL✨ in the gym—but can we talk about what happens after the gym? Because babyyyy… your aftercare routine is just as important as your workout. And today we’re diving into something I’m obsesse
Chalie_Baker

Chalie_Baker

299 likes

A brown shipping box with the text 'RESTOCK MY NONNEGOTIABLES WITH ME' overlaid, featuring yellow flower graphics and a shipping label.
A collection of skincare essentials including a toner, an exfoliant, eye masks, and a cream, arranged on a textured surface under the title 'Skin Care Must Haves'.
Body care products, including a body lotion, a body scrub, and a shaving gel, displayed on a speckled countertop with the text 'Body Care'.
RESTOCK MY NONNEGOTIABLES WITH ME
these are my #nonnegotiables for my self care routine🧖🏼‍♀️☁️ ✨🪞 #skincareproducts : 1. Acwell: hidden gem but my ABSOLUTE favv skincare product|| hydrates&refines skin texture to leave your skin feeling so smooth 2. Paula’s Choice: i have major blackheads so this product helps to redu
Candace| SAHM

Candace| SAHM

219 likes

DIY face toner with aloe gel and rose water
#selfcare #selflove
Rubii

Rubii

118 likes

Sephora Sale!! 🚨
Sephora Sale is HERE! As a Derm NP, you know I had to stock up. 😉 My basket (realistically) has a mix of tried-and-trues and new things I'm genuinely excited about. No spon, just an honest look at what's actually worth it. First up, the Paula's Choice 2% BHA. My holy grail. I've
derm.jinelp

derm.jinelp

1 like

5 Step Morning Skincare Routine🫧🤍
Medicube Pink Pdrn Milky Toner Paula’s Choice BHA Seoul Ceuticals Vitamin C Cerave SPF ALL ON AMAZON☺️💕💗🩷🤍 #morningskincareproducts #morningskincareroutine #morningbeauty #skincareroutine #easyskincare
Ceairra🌸

Ceairra🌸

4 likes

Morning Skincare for Sensitive Skin🧴🫶
✨My favorite products for my sensitive skin: ➡️ Vanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser / this water based cleanser is so gentle and nourishing and feels so creamy when it lathers. My skin always feels so clean and soft after using it! ➡️Paula's Choice Nourishing Milky Toner / I decided to get t
natalie

natalie

86 likes

Clean girly Shower routine✨
Shower time: These products will help you maintain healthy skin while addressing various skin types and concerns. ### Shower Routine: 1. **Pre-Soak**: - Start with warm water to help open up your pores. 2. **Cleansing**: - Use a body wash or cleansing gel to remove dirt and sweat.
Purple Flower

Purple Flower

807 likes

How I cleared my skin!🌸
I use to really struggle keeping my skin clear but this is the first routine I found to finally work for me! I am not an expert but these are things that worked for me! #beautyhaul #lemon8challenge #beautyfinds #skincare #skincareproducts
Mia

Mia

104 likes

@Paula’s Choice you are really that girl #ahabhatoner #paulaschoice #skincare
Ushumusu

Ushumusu

15 likes

My current skincare must haves
#Lemon8Box #lemon8challenge These are my current skincare must haves! ☺️ Every morning I use the CeraVe cleanser. I’ve been using it for about three years now and I honestly can’t imagine using a better face wash. I have sensitive and very acne prone skin, so this gentle face wash is a mus
Cami :)

Cami :)

121 likes

A person applies a milky toner to their face, with the product visibly dripping down their cheek. Text highlights that milky toners are currently popular.
A hand holds a white bottle of milky skin toner, described as refreshing, moisturizing, and soothing. Text mentions the user's preferred types of milky toners.
A hand displays a swatch of a clear, hydrating product on the skin, with text emphasizing its light yet moisturizing quality.
Essential part of winter skincare: Milky Toner
TBH the title said it all. If I had to give an award for the best skincare product for the winter it would be a Milky toner. I never thought that I would need one in my life but here I am bowing down to the best skincare invention yet. #lemon8partner #skincare #koreanskincare #kbeauty
Naomi 🍓✨

Naomi 🍓✨

54 likes

Where do toner pads go in your routine? 💜
Dear, SweeTees 💜 I used to be confused about where toner pads actually fit into a routine… like before toner? after? both?? 😭 So here’s how I’ve been using mine and what’s been working for my skin ✨ What’s shown: • Avocado Cleanser • LHA + AHA Toner Pads • Watermelon Glow PHA + BHA Tone
SincerelyTee

SincerelyTee

32 likes

✧Honest Review of the Viral Anua Heartleaf Toner✧
anua heartleaf toner reviewミ★ #anua #anuaheartleaftoner #kbeauty #koreanskincare #skincare #Toner #glassskin
Hwa-Young Kim

Hwa-Young Kim

50 likes

A hand with red nails holds a bottle of The Ordinary Glycolic Acid 7% Toning Solution. Text overlays indicate benefits like reduced strawberry skin, body acne reduction, and lighter dark knees and elbows.
Glycolic Acid toner
Glycolic Acid offers several benefits for the skin, including exfoliation, which helps remove dead skin cells, unclog pores, and improve skin texture. Remember to use sunscreen, especially when using exfoliating products, to protect your skin. #Lemon8Diary #lemonskincare #skincareroutine #dun
D U N I Y A T

D U N I Y A T

36 likes

Homemade Rose Water 🌹: Can be used as a toner.
#RoseWater #SKINCARE #DIY #Lemon8
LovelyC 🌸

LovelyC 🌸

80 likes

Fav Korean Toner? 💦
How would you describe your fav Korean Toner? 💦 Mentioned: - ROUND LAB - 1025 Dokdo Toner - Anua - Rice 70 Glow Milky Toner - numbuzin - No. 3 Super Glowing Essence Toner - HEVEBLUE - Salmon Caring Centella Toner - numbuzin - No.5 Vitamin Boosting Essential Toner - Pyunkang Yul - Essence T
diego 🌙

diego 🌙

153 likes

A collection of various skincare products, primarily toner pads and creams, arranged on a dark background, with the title 'Rating ALL of my toner pads'.
Three skincare products in tubs: a red peeling pad, a blue pore pad, and a brown vitamin C pad, each with a numerical rating and brief comments.
Two skincare products in tubs: a green heartleaf spot pad and a white carrot calming water pad, each with a numerical rating and brief comments.
Rating ALL of my toner pads
#skincare
Divine Feminine

Divine Feminine

194 likes

Acne Girl to Skincare Girlie — Let’s Talk Healing!
This space is for skincare, softness, and slow healing — because glowing skin starts with peace of mind 🤍✨ Skincare Sharing, I’ll start you off with a lil routine ✨ Skin type: acne prone to normal 🧴 Cleanser: COSRX Salicylic Acid Daily Gentle Cleanser 🧴 Toner: Paula’s Choice 2% BHA Exfoliat
Mul | Skincare & M.H

Mul | Skincare & M.H

22 likes

A hand holds a light-colored bottle of a skincare product. The label indicates it is a milk toner with oatmeal and snow mushroom ingredients. The image features a 'Buy or Bye' overlay and decorative floral elements.
Dermasil Oatmeal Milk Toner ✨🍋
I made a quick stop at Dollar Tree for some toner that was not unavailable except for this oatmeal milk toner. Anyone familiar with this toner? 🤔 #dollartreeskincare #skintoner #dermasiltoner #fyplemon8 #beautyfinds
Bella Smooches 💋

Bella Smooches 💋

123 likes

well i am running low on my fav products soo heres the list @rhode skin lip liner in stretch @VEGAMOUR dry shampoo @Hourglass Cosmetics vanish primer @Oribe hair oil @Paula’s Choice aha bha toner @medicube US Store collagen jelly @CYKLAR sacred santal body lotion @dermalogica eye cream
Ushumusu

Ushumusu

21 likes

🌸☀️Morning routine for acne-prone skin. 🫧🚨
Taking care of acne-prone skin isn’t just about applying products it’s about following a mindful, effective, and gentle routine. Here’s my morning skincare routine, focused on hydrating, protecting, and keeping breakouts under control. 🤞🏻 💆🏻‍♀️Cleanser: PanOxyl Acne Foaming Wash This cleanser c
Dani🤎

Dani🤎

26 likes

which toner pad should you buy?
which mediheal toner pad is best for ur skin? 🤍 collagen ampoule pad - plumps, hydrates, and firms skin for glow! - perfect for dry or aging skin vitamide brightening pas - evens out skin tone and boosts radiance with vitamin-infused ingredients - gives brighter skin madecassoside b
haylee

haylee

56 likes

See more