Multiple Replacement Effects in MtG

Wisconsin
2024/12/10 Edited to

... Read moreHey everyone! If you've ever played a game of Magic: The Gathering and found yourself scratching your head over how to resolve multiple replacement effects, you are definitely not alone. I've been there countless times, staring at the board, trying to figure out if that damage doubles before it gets an extra two, or vice versa! It can get really tricky, but I've found a way to break it down that makes it much clearer. First off, what exactly are replacement effects? They're effects that say 'instead' or 'prevent' or 'as' – they modify how an event would happen. For example, if a spell 'would deal damage,' a replacement effect might change that to 'deal that much damage plus 2' or 'deal double that damage.' The real head-scratcher comes when you have two or more of these effects trying to modify the same event. The key rule to remember is the 'choosing player' rule (CR 616.1 for those who love specifics!). When multiple replacement or prevention effects try to apply to the same event, the affected player or the controller of the affected object chooses the order in which they apply. If the event doesn't directly affect a player or object (e.g., drawing cards), then the controller of the source causing the event chooses. Essentially, someone gets to pick the order! Let's look at some common scenarios, similar to what you might see on cards. Imagine a source would deal X damage to an opponent. You have two replacement effects: "If a source would deal damage to an opponent or a permanent an opponent controls, it deals that much damage plus 2 instead." "If a source would deal damage to a creature or player, it deals double that damage to that creature or player instead." If that damage is going to you, *you*, as the affected player, get to choose which effect applies first. Option A (You choose to apply +2 first): X damage becomes X+2. Then, that (X+2) damage is doubled, resulting in 2*(X+2) = 2X+4 damage. Ouch! Option B (You choose to apply Double first): X damage becomes 2X. Then, that 2X damage gets +2, resulting in 2X+2 damage. Better! As the affected player, you'd almost certainly choose Option B to take less damage. This choice matters a lot! Another great example involves counters. Let's say an effect would put one or more +1/+1 counters on a permanent you control. What if you have these two effects? "If an effect would put one or more counters on a permanent you control, it puts twice that many of those counters on that permanent instead." "If an effect would put one or more counters on a permanent you control, it puts that many counters plus one instead." (This is a hypothetical similar to what might exist) If you're putting N counters, as the controller of the permanent, you'll choose the order: Option A (You choose to apply Double first): N counters become 2N. Then, that 2N receives +1, so you get 2N+1 counters. Option B (You choose to apply +1 first): N counters become N+1. Then, that (N+1) is doubled, so you get 2*(N+1) = 2N+2 counters. In this case, you'd likely choose Option B to get the most counters! The key takeaway here is *player choice*. Don't forget it! When you encounter these situations, pause, identify all the relevant replacement effects, and then determine who gets to choose the order of application. It makes all the difference. I hope this breakdown helps you navigate those complex MTG rules and makes your games smoother. Happy playing!

Related posts

3 Replacement For Chicken
Have you ever struggled with peeling garlic? Let me show you this quick hack to make it easy to enjoy fresh garlic in all your recipes! Invest in a garlic roller, available on Amazon or at select stores. This handy tool will revolutionize your cooking experience, making garlic peeling a breeze a
Turnip Vegan

Turnip Vegan

18K likes

Multiple Replacement Effects Entering
Here is what happens when multiple replacement effects enter at the same time. Enjoy! 🧙‍♂️🐉⚔️ #mtg #mtgcommunity #mtgcommander #wizardsofthecoast #mtgrules
RipPullRepeat

RipPullRepeat

1 like

Non toxic wax melt replacement?
I do the simmer pots… and now this. What else are we using for non toxic smell good for the house? I don’t want overly fragrant, but I do like it to be warm and inviting or at least smell clean ❤️ #nontoxicliving #nontoxiccleaning #nontoxicfragrance
Farm & Table

Farm & Table

614 likes

A hand holds a clear glass bowl of avocado salad, featuring mashed avocado, black beans, chickpeas, and diced tomatoes. Text overlays indicate it's an "Avocado Salad Meal Replacement" with "1 cup = <300 Calories and packed with Protein."
Avocado Salad Meal Replacement
For 2 Meals 3-Avocados 1-Lime 3Table spoons of Olive Oil 1/4 - Shopped onions 1- Shopped Tomato 1 can of black beans 1 can of Garbanzo Bean Feta cheese if you want , not necessary Salt and Pepper 🇲🇽 Tajin if you want to be a bad girl 🤭 #avocado #salad #highproteinmeal
Eisaacs_

Eisaacs_

693 likes

A NEW HENNY REPLACEMENT? … no way WE STILL HAVENT
A NEW HENNY REPLACEMENT? … no way WE STILL HAVENT tried it….(IMMA FIND IT 😩) #kava #k áva #cocktail #mocktail #foodlover @kavahana grills by @customgoldgrillz
AuthenticTeecee2.0 ™

AuthenticTeecee2.0 ™

558 likes

Leak proof replacement lid for Stanley’s!
Linked in my bio on my LTK! #stanleyhack #stanleycup #stanleytumbler #stanleygirly #cupcollection #stanley
Brittany Loye

Brittany Loye

382 likes

Subaru back glass replacement
#fyp #asmr #autoglass #DIY
LimitlessAutoGlass

LimitlessAutoGlass

335 likes

3 Replacement For Chicken - Part 2✨✨
3 Replacement For Chicken - Part 2 🍗🚫 Who needs chicken when you got these fire plant-based swaps? 🌱🔥⁠ 1️⃣ Artichoke Tacos – tender, juicy, and taco-ready! 🌮⁠ ⁠ 2️⃣ Chicken of the Woods – Nashville Hot Mushrooms for that spicy kick! 🍄🌶️⁠ ⁠ 3️⃣ Heart of Palm – serving up a fresh Chick’n
Turnip Vegan

Turnip Vegan

2109 likes

Ross send me a replacement pair pls
So disappointed 😩😩😩 #ross #rossshoes #rossfinds
Vanessa Barreto

Vanessa Barreto

142 likes

Fur replacement and coat resizing
Michelle Cleaners Inc #mackage #tailor #fur #resize #replacement
Michelle Dry Cleaner

Michelle Dry Cleaner

138 likes

window replacement
that really enhanced the window #kitchenrenovation #kitchendiy #kitchendecor #kitchenideas #kitchengoals
kolterwinton

kolterwinton

1688 likes

Waterpump, valve cover gasket replacement
#ford #focus #manual #mobile #mechanic
juncodiesel

juncodiesel

27 likes

MEAL REPLACEMENT MIXED BERRY SMOOTHIE
Drink this before/after your next workout as meal replacement. It was so quick & good to make. It left me so full & fit #postworkoutsmoothie #healthyfood #healthyrecipes #summerbod
Lauren A💗🫶🏽

Lauren A💗🫶🏽

26 likes

Guess lets see how tiktoks replacement goes
#f150 #sliding #bubbatruck #fyp
Freakyonefiddy

Freakyonefiddy

23 likes

How to replace the replacement tape at home
All you need is a little adhesive remover and a piece of paper done in a snap #hairfactory #tapeinhairextensions #humanhair #hairextensiontools
lislahair_factory3

lislahair_factory3

140 likes

Vren, the Relentless and Sacrifice Effects
Let’s talk about Vern’s replacement effect and cards being sacrificed! Enjoy! 🧙‍♂️🐉⚔️ #mtg #mtgcommunity #mtgcommander #wizardsofthecoast #mtgrules
RipPullRepeat

RipPullRepeat

1 like

💚🍌 PCOS Friendly Meal Replacement Shake
If you’re like me and can’t stomach real food in the mornings, but still wanna fuel your body + balance your hormones—this shake right here? A GAME-CHANGER. She’s quick, affordable, gentle on the belly, and packed with nutrients that support PCOS healing, energy, and digestion. I’ve been drinking
Sophija

Sophija

14 likes

A glass of pink breakfast smoothie with strawberry and banana icons, next to a lit frosted vanilla scented candle, labeled as a meal replacement.
A green bowl containing several washed and cut strawberries, some resting on a white paper towel, ready for a smoothie.
Ingredients for a smoothie: a container of yogurt, a pink measuring cup with ice cubes, and another pink measuring cup with 1/2 cup of milk.
Breakfast replacement smoothie 🍓🍌
#smoothieideas #smoothieforbreakfast #bodytransformation #healthylifestyle2024
Dibbs

Dibbs

181 likes

Looking for an replacement for meat?
Banh Mi Chalupa w/ Snow Oyster Mushrooms 💜 Let’s reimagine food together with purpose. I’ve taken one of my favorite sandwiches, added chalupa shells, and combined it with one of my favorite meat replacements, adding an old-school twist. I’ve revamped my mushroom meat for this recipe, infusing B
Turnip Vegan

Turnip Vegan

398 likes

Four black plastic pump dispensers with clear tubes are shown against a white background. The image features text indicating these are replacement pumps for liquid cosmetic bottles, with information about their popularity.
Sand & Fog replacement pumps
If you’re looking to change your sand and fog perfume oils from droppers to pumps. This is where you can find them. #sandandfogoils #replacementpumps #perfumeoils #amazonfinds #marshallsfinds
Annamarie

Annamarie

290 likes

Alternator replacement
#diy
Drew Fagon motor’s

Drew Fagon motor’s

4 likes

This will be my TikTok Replacement
#motorcycle #mototok #bikertok #motovlog
OJ - Good Life Riders

OJ - Good Life Riders

3 likes

Cooling Tower Replacement in downtown Los Angeles
David_SoCal626

David_SoCal626

4 likes

Performance brake replacement
#gettoknowme #mobilemechanic #mobileautorepair #orlando
Johnny on the Go

Johnny on the Go

3 likes

Toyota back glass replacement
#autoglass #backglass #tempered #asmr #fyp
LimitlessAutoGlass

LimitlessAutoGlass

55 likes

A gaming setup with a monitor displaying a Sims 4 character, overlaid with a pink heart with wings and the text "Sims 4 Plumbob Replacement." The room is illuminated with pink and purple lighting.
Two images of a Sims 4 character in a pink gaming room, with a pink heart plumbob. Text states, "You can only have one replacement at a time," emphasizing customization options.
A Sims 4 character with a pink heart plumbob, alongside a standalone pink heart shape. Text reads, "There is many replacements to choose from," highlighting variety.
Sims 4 Plumbob Replacement CC 💗🪽
I got tired of the same plumbob and wanted something much cuter to match my sims. There are so many plumbobs to choose from. But it’s super easy to swap out the CC. But this replacement does need some tweaking before you can use it. Or else your plumbob will be green, since that’s the default s
enchanted._.luna  ≽^• ˕ • ྀི≼

enchanted._.luna ≽^• ˕ • ྀི≼

15 likes

Hormone Replacement Therapy saves lives #HRT
Althea Gobble

Althea Gobble

7 likes

A silver Hyundai Sonata is jacked up on concrete, with its front wheel removed for a tire replacement. The removed tire, a jack, an impact wrench, and other tools are laid out on the ground, indicating mobile tire service.
Tire Replacement
Tire Replacement on a Hyundai Sonata.. #mobiletirerepair #tireservice #roadsideassistance #mobiletireservice
Edgar’s Roadside Service

Edgar’s Roadside Service

5 likes

A collection of ingredients for an anti-inflammatory coffee replacement drink, including chai concentrate, reishi mushroom powder, golden milk blend, ceremonial matcha, and almond creamer, displayed on a kitchen counter.
A clear glass containing ice, a liquid base, and distinct layers of green matcha powder and an orange-yellow powder, illustrating the step of adding powders before blending.
A finished, light-colored beverage with ice and a metal straw in a clear glass, indicating the final step of adding non-dairy creamer to the anti-inflammatory drink.
Coffee Replacement Anti-inflammatory
For my hoshimotos and auto immune girlies. This drink has been my saving grace going through Hoshimotos. The best thing I did was cut out coffee all together as it is a huge aggravator for the inflammation we already deal with. I have this drink every morning and it gives me the boost of energy nee
Nicole

Nicole

29 likes

Kalyn Siebert neck to deck harness replacement
GabePicciolo

GabePicciolo

9 likes

See more