Magnolia Banana Pudding NY🚕

2025/8/20 Edited to

... Read moreMagnolia banana pudding is a signature dessert from the famous Magnolia Bakery in New York City, renowned for its rich, creamy texture and perfect blend of flavors. Made with layers of fresh bananas, silky vanilla pudding, and soft vanilla wafers, this dessert offers a delightful balance of sweetness and freshness. Since its debut, Magnolia Banana Pudding has become one of the city's culinary icons, often praised for its homemade taste and nostalgic appeal. The secret behind Magnolia’s success lies not only in the quality of the ingredients but also in the careful preparation process. The pudding is made fresh daily, ensuring every bite delivers maximum flavor. The bananas used are ripe and sweet, complementing the smooth pudding base, which is crafted from scratch rather than using pre-packaged mixes. The addition of crunchy vanilla wafers adds a contrasting texture that captivates the palate. For visitors to New York, experiencing Magnolia’s banana pudding is almost a rite of passage. Many locals consider it a go-to comfort dessert, celebrating both its history and taste. Beyond simply enjoying this treat in-store, Magnolia Bakery has expanded their offerings online, and in some cases through delivery apps, making it easier than ever to indulge in this iconic New York dessert. This pudding fits perfectly into the broader landscape of classic American confections, with Magnolia Bakery leading the trend in elevating such traditional recipes to gourmet status. Whether enjoyed as a quick snack or a celebratory dessert, the Magnolia Banana Pudding remains a must-try, a vivid example of New York’s rich culinary culture.

11 comments

kimberlejarvis's images
kimberlejarvis

Looks great.

Related posts

A large glass bowl of homemade banana pudding, partially served, revealing layers of creamy pudding, sliced bananas, and vanilla wafers. The dessert is topped with banana slices and wafer crumbs, and partially covered with plastic wrap. The image includes the text "Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding made at home".
A close-up of homemade banana pudding in a glass bowl, showing its layered texture. Sliced bananas and crushed wafers are visible on top, with creamy pudding and softened wafers forming the layers below. The dessert is partially covered with plastic wrap.
A spoonful of creamy banana pudding, containing pieces of softened wafers, is lifted from the large glass bowl. The background shows the remaining pudding, topped with banana slices and wafer crumbs, partially covered with plastic wrap. The image includes the text "it tastes EXACTLY like theirs!!".
The absolute best!!
Recipe: One 14-ounce can sweetened condensed milk 1½ cups ice cold water One 3.4-ounce package instant vanilla pudding mix (preferably Jell-O brand) 3 cups heavy cream One 12-ounce box Nabisco Nilla Wafers (no substitutions!) 4 cups sliced ripe bananas In a small bowl, on the medium spe
athena

athena

4552 likes

A close-up of Magnolia Bakery style banana pudding, topped with whole vanilla wafers and crushed crumbs, with a red spoon partially visible. The text overlay reads 'MAGNOLIA BAKERY STYLE BANANA PUDDING'.
Sweetened condensed milk is being poured from a can into a clear glass bowl, with a text overlay indicating '7oz can of sweetened condensed milk'.
Water is being poured into a clear glass bowl containing sweetened condensed milk, with a text overlay stating 'Add 3 cups of water'.
✨Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding Recipe at Home 😋🤍☀️
Magnolia Bakery - Grand Central #NY #baking #foodie #dessert #Lemon8Diary #home #pudding #bananas #vanillascent
E N E S S A

E N E S S A

8156 likes

A collage showcasing four New York desserts: Milk Bar cereal ice cream, Grace Street Cafe milk tea boba toast, Alimama mochi donuts and taro balls, and Magnolia Bakery banana pudding. The image is titled 'Sweets to eat In New York #PART 1'.
A hand holds a cup of Magnolia Bakery's classic banana pudding, featuring layers of creamy pudding, vanilla wafers, and fresh bananas, with the bakery's storefront visible in the background.
A hand holds a cup of Milk Bar's cereal milk soft serve ice cream, topped with crunchy cereal pieces, set against a vibrant red neon 'milk' sign.
WHAT DESSERTS / SWEETS TO EAT IN NEW YORK🍭🍦🍩part 1
Haiii lemonaders🍋🍬 back with mee again!!😍 kali inii i wanna share my favorite desserts in new york city😍🫶🏻 buat kalian” yang deket” ini bakal/ada rencana liburan ke nyc, bisa di save duluu yaa hehehe🫶🏻 •Magnolia bakery🍌: let me tell you guys, this is the OG BANANA PUDDING yaa😋🍌!! bener bener tas
delphi27

delphi27

9 likes

$10 Ice Cream Flight at NYC Top Ice Cream Spot
I don’t care how cold it is, I will always want some ice cream! And this ice cream spot is perfect for that! They have such unique flavors and they’re all made in their Brooklyn! They have locations in: 📍Astoria 📍Upper West Side 📍Brooklyn Some of the creamiest ice cream with unique flavo
Jaylynn Cardona

Jaylynn Cardona

329 likes

Magnolia bakery banana pudding🍌🍰✨ (with a few minor tweaks) Recipe: Ingredients -14 oz can sweetened condensed milk (I only added about 3/4 of the can) -1 cup ice-cold water -1/2 cup cold milk -3.4 oz box instant vanilla pudding mix -3 cups h
Jen

Jen

232 likes

Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding🍌
Creamy pudding, fresh bananas, and layers of vanilla wafers 🍌✨ This Magnolia Bakery-inspired banana pudding is rich, nostalgic, and impossible to stop eating 🤍 Full recipe 👇 Follow @weekendwhiskkitchen for more such recipes.❤️ #bananapudding #magnoliabakery #dessertreels #f
weekendwhiskkitchen

weekendwhiskkitchen

75 likes

If you love Magnolia Bakery’s famous banana pudding, this homemade copycat is about to become your new obsession. It’s creamy, fluffy, perfectly sweet, and honestly? Even better the next day. Layers of vanilla pudding, fresh bananas, and Nilla wafers come together perfectly… no baking, no fuss. Thi
Caterina - Easy & Fast Recipes

Caterina - Easy & Fast Recipes

160 likes

A vibrant array of intricate French pastries, topped with various fruits and garnishes, displayed on a tray, with the title "Where to Get the Best Dessert in NYC" overlaid.
A display window at Sweet Rehab featuring numerous small, intricate French pastries, two bottles of champagne, and a large pastry under a glass cloche. Pastries range from $10-$25.
Two gourmet ice cream sundaes from Caffé Panna, generously topped with sauces, cookies, and other treats, with one being drizzled from above. Scoops start at $7 and pints are $13.
BEST DESSERT SPOTS IN THE CITY 🍰🍪🍦
Sweet Rehab: Chic dessert and champagne bar serving intricate French pastries, teas, and caviar. Caffé Panna: Italian inspired gourmet ice cream spot with daily changing flavors and specials. Mah-Ze-Dahr: Bakery with 3 locations across Manhattan with highly acclaimed and luxurious treats, hot
Lex in the City

Lex in the City

385 likes

Sweet Stop in the Loop: Magnolia Bakery Chicago 🍰
#ThingsToDo #lemon8challenge 🍰 Famous for its legendary banana pudding, decadent cupcakes, and melt‑in‑your‑mouth cheesecakes, this cozy spot brings NYC‑style charm right to the Loop . Stone‑cold proof: Tripadvisor reviewers call the banana pudding “extraordinary” and “some of the best in
Dear Cravings

Dear Cravings

18 likes

Magnolia bakery nyc
Magnolia Bakery hits DIFFERENT during the holidays. If you haven’t tried the banana pudding… run, don’t walk 🍌✨ #magnoliabakery #nyceats #nycfoodie #bananapudding #nycspots
LifeThroughLau

LifeThroughLau

7 likes

Banana Pudding 🥰
#lemon8diarychallenge I have been dreaming about banana pudding for days, I keep seeing the banana pudding in a bag and it looks so good. I’ve also wanted to try the famous Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding so bad 🥲 but am nowhere near one! If anyone has a good banana pudding recipe please
EarthySoulx

EarthySoulx

243 likes

A display case filled with various crepe cakes, including a purple yam cake dusted with powdered sugar, and other flavors like matcha and chocolate, highlighting scrumptious desserts in NYC.
Two slices of Lady M crepe cake, one with green matcha and chocolate layers, and another with purple layers, showcasing the neat and clean layers of these famous desserts.
A Dominique Ansel cronut with white icing on a plate, alongside a dessert featuring watermelon, chocolate chips, and red swirled topping, representing iconic NYC treats.
scrumptious desserts in nyc 🍰 🥐
this list is for my sweet-tooth peeps. i have been to each of these places more than once. so, it’s a guarantee that they will not fail you 🫶🏻 Lady M Cake Boutique - New York City • the best crepe cake in the world. • the layers is so neat and clean. • cream / crepe layers are so perfect
Ticha U.

Ticha U.

101 likes

Banana Pudding Recipe
Follow for more easy fun recipes 🪩⬆️ Scrumptious Magnolia Bakery style banana pudding, finished off with a crispy caramelized banana layer 🍌❤️‍🔥 Ingredients: — 1 14 oz. can of condensed milk — 1 packet of instant vanilla pudding — 1 1/2 cups water — 3 cups heavy whipping cream — van
Madison

Madison

892 likes

Magnolia Bakery located in many neighborhoods around New York City was established in 1996 & has grown to what it is today! Best known for their world famous banana pudding following with their many delicious cupcakes, cookies, puddings, cakes, and pies! Their motto: make today sweeter than yesterd
NicoleMWilson

NicoleMWilson

0 likes

🍌 Magnolia Bakery’s Banana Pudding is to DIE for, but unless you’re in a few major cities, you won’t be able to get your hands on theirs. Luckily, this is the recipe from Magnolia Bakery’s cookbook (what can I say — I know a few people 😉) and it is one that will not disappoint. With a few simple in
Caterina - Easy & Fast Recipes

Caterina - Easy & Fast Recipes

28 likes

Magnolias Bakery 🎂🧁
No matter how much Pilates I do I will always find myself here! Some of my favorites are the original whipped banana pudding and a Large Cappuccino with Oatmeal (no sugar) 🤍 What’s some other cute desert places in NYC ? #magnoliabakery #explorepage #nyc #sweettreats
A.Casanova

A.Casanova

1 like

A white bowl of Magnolia Bakery banana pudding, topped with crushed cookies, sits on a woven placemat. The background features a white vase with green foliage and a small decorative container. The image includes the text "Magnolia bakery Banana pudding."
Magnolia bakeryBanana pudding
My all time favorite dessert that don’t require much . Magnolia bakery famous banana pudding All you need is One 14-ounce can sweetened condensed milk 1 1/2 cups (360 grams/12.7 ounces) ice-cold water One 3.4-ounce package instant vanilla pudding mix (preferably Jell-O brand) 3 cups (72
Monica h nyc

Monica h nyc

16 likes

Magnolia Bakery’s Famous Banana Pudding Recipe 🍌
INGREDIENTS: 1 (14 oz) can sweetened condensed milk 1 ½ cups ice cold water 1 (3.4 oz) box instant vanilla pudding mix 3 cups heavy cream 3-4 sliced bananas 1 (12 oz.) box Vanilla Wafers INSTRUCTIONS: In a large bowl, beat together the sweetened condensed milk and water about 1 minute, un
Adventures with Tia

Adventures with Tia

43 likes

Si con algo soy picky, es con los postres… porque no vas a conocer alguien más ad!cto al dulce que yo! Así qué lo siento pero no, ese pudding es manteca con sabor a banana 🍌 No pierdas tu tiempo ahí! #magnoliabakery #nyc #bananapudding #foodie #dessert
Mily Roso

Mily Roso

0 likes

Delayed flight means exploring more of the city! And true story, our banana bread pudding from @Magnolia Bakery got taken from us by security at the airport so we never got to try it 😭😩 @RadioCityMusicHall @NBC #radiocitymusichall #newyork #nyc #magnoliabakery #nbcstudios
Joanne L. Sato

Joanne L. Sato

0 likes

For our banana pudding lovers!! 🍌 #bananapudding #nyc #newyorkcity #upperwestside #nycfood #magnoliabakery
Sistersnacking

Sistersnacking

3 likes

MUST TRY PLACES TO EAT IN NYC
These are *some* of my recs in NYC! There are some typical ones you have to try such as levain and magnolia! There is more but saw these pics and thought I’d make a post 🫢 Follow me if you like this and want to see more posts like this! #nycburger #nycfoodrecommendations #nycfood #food
Jaylynn Cardona

Jaylynn Cardona

216 likes

Caramel Toffee Desserts of NYC
The last few days was like - hey did someone forget the May = Spring memo? We got tons of rain and fog instead 🥲 what happened to the spring blooms and sunny breezy weather? Well, the sun is finally out today for a change so let’s celebrate - starting with this round up of warm toasty caramel/
Netgonenutsforfood

Netgonenutsforfood

38 likes

A hand holds a yellow candle labeled "BANANA PUDDING" by Boy Smells x Magnolia Bakery, alongside a matching yellow rollerball perfume. The candle label details its scent notes and brand information. Decorative elements are visible in the background.
✨Boy Smells Banana Pudding & Scent Combo 🍌
Boy Smells x Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding #candlesoflemon8 #perfumecombo #bananapudding #bananaperfume #hempzlotion
Kris Major

Kris Major

498 likes

gave birth to @daccai.atx this week🤭 Daccaí is a dessert shop for American Bangladeshi fusion desserts! I love mixing my culture with my favorite foods, hope you will too!! Currently in testing with a few taste testers, will be open for orders soon! #smallbusiness #austintexas #studen
zen 🐈

zen 🐈

0 likes

Per Leah, the banana pudding was AMAZING. #magnoliabakerybananapudding #bananapudding #pudding #fyp
Erica

Erica

22 likes

Best Banana Pudding in NYC
Spoiler Alert 🚨 it’s NOT Magnolia Bakery 😬 While it’s a classic for many, I’m one of the few who think there’s better versions of the old school banana pudding elsewhere! My favorite is hands down the one from Claude Bakery (NYC) ♥️ Visit this little bakery + cafe on a rainy day so you c
Netgonenutsforfood

Netgonenutsforfood

19 likes

Magnolias copycat banana pudding
If you love all things Magnolia, you’ll really be a fan of our copycat Magnolia banana pudding which is a heavenly dessert filled with banana and creamy layers of vanilla pudding. You’ll need: 1 (14-ounce) can of sweetened condensed milk ½ cup of water, very cold 1 cup of milk, very cold 1
LetsBeBestieBoos

LetsBeBestieBoos

62 likes

I promise you want to save this because yummmm #fyp #bananapudding #magnolia #magnoliabananapudding #recipe
Maddison Charnstrom

Maddison Charnstrom

1 like

BEST SURPRISE TO WAKE UP TO!! @Glossier #magnoliabakery #bananapudding #glossierbananapuddingbalmdotcom #newlippie #lipbalm #makeup #glossier #newlaunch
ally

ally

460 likes

My favorite eats in NYC!
#nyfoodsharings #nycfoodreview
Veronnica Houck

Veronnica Houck

10 likes

Things to do in New York City for first timers
If it’s your first trip to NYC, there are a few quintessential things to do that you don’t want to miss!!! Go to an Observation Deck Check out the views from one of the skyscrapers at the observations decks in the city! Each one offers something special/unique. SUMMIT One Vanderbilt - be
Brooklyn Guide

Brooklyn Guide

41 likes

A collage featuring the Magnolia Bakery logo, a blue box for J-Hope's Sweet Dreams cupcakes with an image of J-Hope, a yellow cupcake top with 'Sweet Dreams' text, and a cup of swirled banana pudding.
A single cupcake with white frosting and sugar sprinkles, topped with a blue circular disc featuring 'Sweet Dreams' in yellow text.
A single cupcake with white frosting and sugar sprinkles, topped with a circular disc depicting a vintage car driving through clouds against a blue and yellow sky.
Best Banana Pudding in New York! J-Hope 3/12~3/15
#cafereview #lemon8challenge #cake #lemon8partner #nycfoodreview Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center 🗓️ Date: March 12 to 15, 2025 Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center is always an exciting experience, and my recent stop there was no exception! The line was busy yet move
Ellie K

Ellie K

29 likes

✨The Ultimate Banana Pudding Guide✨
If you’re a dessert lover, this is your ultimate cheat sheet! From the iconic Magnolia Bakery style to a decadent Banana Pudding Poke Cake, there is a version here for every craving. 🍰💛 🍌 The Lineup: • Not Yo Mama’s: The Chessmen cookie classic. • Banana Pudding Cookies: Soft, chewy, and full of
Life with Niesha ✨

Life with Niesha ✨

72 likes

MAGNOLIA BAKERY🎂🍰🧁
Magnolias is always a must stop when we are in the city! We never leave without at least getting a cupcake. WHAT WE GOT ⬇️ • Vanilla Cupcake with Vanilla Frosting 9/10 my favorite cupcake to get at any bakery! They do it so well and it is delicious every time. • Vanilla Cupcake with Choco
Jes

Jes

14 likes

Cookie pudding cause I don’t like bananas in mine
#bananapuddingnobananas #cookiepudding #fypシ゚viral #magnoliabananapuddinginspired #good I went off hers https://pin.it/45GtDIqTY
Portia Diggs

Portia Diggs

28 likes

Matcha Ice Cream & Banana Pudding
Omg this matcha soft service ice cream with banana pudding on top was DELICIOUS! Found this hidden gem while in SoHo 📍Location: Matcha cafe Maiko (Bowery NYC) Overall rating: /10: 10/10 💚 #matchacafemaiko #matchaobsessed #nycmatcha #matchagirlie #sohoshopping
Lovely🌹

Lovely🌹

622 likes

Magnolia Table: After School Banana Bread
If banana bread and dessert had a baby, THIS would be it. And yes, it stays this soft for days (but let’s be real, it won’t last that long). Who needs cake when you’ve got THIS? 📌 SAVE this for later & tag me when you make it! #magnoliatable #bananabread #recipeideas #comfortfood
LifestyledbyAsha

LifestyledbyAsha

10 likes

Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding
Banana Pudding is one of my favorite desserts! #magnoliabakery #bananapudding #dessert #sweets #foodreview
Anidas | Foodie

Anidas | Foodie

407 likes

See more