This Thriller Had Me Shook 😳 | Book Review

Book Review: The Island by Natasha Preston

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I finally see what the hype was about — and wow, it did not disappoint. This book was phenomenal! Natasha Preston has officially earned a spot on my must-read author list. 👏🏽

The plot of The Island is gripping, fast-paced, and everything a good thriller should be: intense, twisty, and completely unpredictable. Just when I thought I had it figured out… plot twist. And then another one. And another. 😳

What really got me was the ending — so much feels unfinished in the best way. It left me wanting more, and I genuinely hope there’s a continuation or spin-off because the story is not over in my eyes.

If you love thrillers with high stakes, secrets, and suspense that keeps you flipping the pages late into the night — this one’s for you.

📚 10/10 would recommend.

💬 Have you read The Island? Let’s talk about that ending!

#BookReviews #mostanticipatedread #bookreadratedandreviewed #readthisnow

2025/7/3 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, seriously, if you're looking for a thriller that will genuinely keep you up all night, 'The Island' by Natasha Preston is it. I mean it when I say I was glued to every page, from the moment I picked it up – and can we talk about that cover for a second? The abandoned roller coaster on an island, those eerie pink water lilies, and that moody sky? It instantly sets the perfect, unsettling tone for what's inside. It’s not just a pretty cover; it perfectly encapsulates the mysterious and dangerous vibe of the story. For those who are curious about the plot beyond just "a gripping thriller," let me give you a little more without any spoilers. Imagine a group of teenagers, promised a thrilling, exclusive island getaway – sounds like a dream, right? Well, it quickly turns into a nightmare as they realize they're trapped, and someone is hunting them. It’s a high-stakes survival story woven with deep, dark secrets that unravel at a breakneck pace. Preston masterfully builds tension, making you question everyone’s motives and loyalties. Each chapter leaves you on a cliffhanger, practically begging you to read just one more. That's why it's such a phenomenal escape, especially if you love psychological thrillers mixed with a bit of a classic 'locked room mystery' feel, but on a whole island! What makes this book a 10/10 for me, and why I genuinely think it warrants all the hype, is how Natasha Preston handles the twists. Just when you think you’ve connected the dots or figured out the villain, she throws another curveball that completely changes your perspective. It’s not just one big twist; it's a series of reveals that keep the narrative fresh and utterly unpredictable. And that ending? Oh my goodness. As I mentioned in my initial thoughts, it left so much unfinished, but in the best possible way. It’s the kind of ending that stays with you, prompting endless discussions and theories. It doesn't neatly tie up every loose end, which, for a thriller of this caliber, feels incredibly authentic and unnerving. It really makes you hope for a sequel or at least a spin-off to explore what happens next because the possibilities are endless. If you're a fan of thrillers that combine survival, suspense, and a constant sense of dread, you absolutely need to add 'The Island' to your reading list. It’s a perfect read for a cozy night in, or if you’re looking for something to devour on vacation – just maybe not on an actual island! Seriously, give it a read and then come back here to discuss that ending with me. I'm still processing it!

21 comments

Christine D's images
Christine D

I am going to put this on my list to be read! Thanks for suggesting!

Honor Your Process's images
Honor Your Process

I couldn’t get into it. I forced myself to finish it because I really wanted to like it!!!

See more comments

Related posts

This Book Had Me Shook!!! 🫶
#booksummary #bookreccomendations #darkromancebook #darkromancegirlies 📚 Title and Author: Lights Out by Navessa Allen 🌟 Genre: Dark Romance - Masked Man 🤤 - Mafia connections - amazing plot twists!
✨ L I N D S A Y ✨

✨ L I N D S A Y ✨

62 likes

A white table with a book titled "Pachinko" by Min Jin Lee, a pastry, and a glass of water. Red text overlay reads "THIS BOOK WAS WRITTEN BY A DYING MAN (and you should really read it)".
A hand holds the book "When Breath Becomes Air" by Paul Kalanithi. Overlaid text describes it as "Thought-provoking," "Inspiring," "Heartbreaking," and "Life-affirming," urging readers to give it a read.
A close-up of the book "When Breath Becomes Air" on a textured surface. Overlaid text highlights its "Raw & Honest" nature, describing it as heartbreaking yet beautiful, wise, and a reminder to cherish life.
This book was written by a dying man
Recently, I finished a book that shook me to my core. It was written by someone facing their own mortality, and their words carried a weight that's hard to describe. It made me confront my own fears and priorities in a way I hadn't before. There were moments of intense sadness, reading a
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

2889 likes

The image displays the front cover of the psychological thriller novel "Behind Closed Doors" by B.A. Paris, featuring the title in red and a dark keyhole design. Overlay text indicates "BOOK REVIEW" and a "10/10" rating.
Book Review✨🖤 Psychological Thriller
Book Review 🪻🌾✨ Book name: Behind Closed Doors Author: B.A Paris Genre: Psychological Thriller My rating: honestly.. 10/10, I’m hoping to find this thrill in another book. My review: I had no idea going into this book exactly what I was getting into. The words and details used made me picture
RM

RM

639 likes

A hand holds a book on a white sheet, with an image of Zuko and Katara from Avatar: The Last Airbender, surrounded by fire and water effects. Text reads 'Zutara inspired romantasy book'.
A book titled 'Broken Flames' by MK Ahearn lies on a white sheet. Text overlays indicate a 4-star rating and themes like 'forced marriage,' 'water/fire bending,' and 'enemies to lovers.'
An open book on a white sheet displays pages 148 and 149. A blue graphic highlights a quote: 'The moment her foot hit that first step the world stopped... I would burn the world for her.' Text reads 'favorite quote:'.
Zutara inspired book ❤️‍🔥
Zutara-inspired romantasy book rec! If you are a fan of Avatar the Last Airbender, you will LOVE Broken Flames. I have been a Zutara (Zuko & Katara) shipper since I was a little kid (maybe this is where my love for enemies to lovers stems from???) and the dedication in this book reads “Fo
mikalasreads

mikalasreads

3264 likes

a book that had me shook.
The Glass Castle - A memoir by Jeanette Walls This story was truly an emotional roller coaster. This had beautiful and happy moments but lots of heart breaking, jaw dropping moments. This is a life story of Jeanette written from her earliest childhood memories all the way through some of her ad
Alli Beachy 🤍

Alli Beachy 🤍

423 likes

books that shook me to my core
A list of books that had me on the edge of my seat while I simultaneously dreaded reading more. Kind of like a train crash in slow motion, I just couldn't look away. Let me know what books evoked that feeling for you and add them in the comments! #lemon8partner #lemon8bookclub #unsett
bookrvws

bookrvws

1484 likes

A collage of fragmented black and white portraits of various people, overlaid with the text "6 books so dark I wandered my house in shock for an hour after." The Lemon8 logo and username are visible at the bottom left.
A book cover for "The Butterfly Garden" by Dot Hutchison, featuring a white butterfly on a dark background, is superimposed on fragmented portraits. A text review describes the book as "Disturbing from the start."
A book cover for "Pretty Girls" by Karin Slaughter, featuring a gold locket on a dark blue background, is superimposed on fragmented portraits. A text review calls it a "rare thriller that earns its darkness."
Books that shook me
These dark thriller books were shocking and soooo good! #thrillerbooks #crimefiction #thrillerbooktok #crimebooks #mysterybooks
Thriller Book Recs 2025

Thriller Book Recs 2025

26 likes

Books that shook me
Here are some elite mystery thriller books for your TBR! #crimefiction #thrillerbooks #thrillerbooktok #mysterybooks #bookrecommendations
Great Thriller Books

Great Thriller Books

314 likes

A hand holds the book "The Perfect Marriage" by Jeneva Rose, featuring two intertwined rings with blood splatters on the cover. The cover highlights it as a psychological suspense with over 1 million copies sold. Overlay text reads "BOOK REVIEW."
A book page displays the synopsis for "The Perfect Marriage," detailing a defense attorney defending her husband accused of murdering his mistress. It includes praise from other authors and an image of two intertwined rings at the bottom.
A book page shows the "PROLOGUE" section, featuring text that describes a man's feelings for a woman and ends with the suspenseful question, "The question is... did he kill her?"
Book Review- Im Back !
Hey guyssss!!! Long time no speak 😭💕 I have been reading but have not had time to update you all 🥲. But anywho! Let’s get to this review!!!!! 📖 Name of the Book: The Perfect Marriage 📖 Genre: Suspense, Psychological, Thriller ⭐️ Star Rating: 10/10 💭 My Thoughts: ok…. The ending had me sho
Miya

Miya

16 likes

Psychological Thriller is my middle name
#booksummary #lemon8challenge “Her Perfect Revenge” by Lesley Sanderson had me absolutely shook! My summary: The story begins with Alex and Felicity on their wedding night. You slowly meet Caroline, Alex’s sister, as well as their group of swim friends ( Tania, Miranda, ) and the rest
Bexlynn

Bexlynn

8 likes

Thriller Book that’ll leave you shook!
I haven't read a Freida McFadden book in a while but OH EM GE i forgot how good her books are and how fast I am able to read them! Freida and her team kindly sent me this book and i was so excited when I received it that i started it right away and I finished it in 2 DAYS! I would definit
Daniella Marie

Daniella Marie

115 likes

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Psychological Thriller Book Review
I’m a Therapist and My Patient Is Going to Be the Next School Shooter is a gripping and unsettling read that pulls you directly into the psychological mindscape of both patient and therapist. The format—told through a series of therapy files—makes it feel raw and clinical, as though you’re peeking
Kae

Kae

473 likes

An overhead shot of several dark romance book covers, including "Lights Out," "The Mindf*ck Series," "God of Wrath," and "Sin of a Sinner," with the title "SPICY DARK ROMANCE BOOKS THAT HAD ME IN A CHOKEHOLD" overlaid.
The book cover for "Lights Out" by Navessa Allen, an "Into Darkness Novel," featuring a masked figure and a woman looking at each other against a dark city background.
The book cover for "God of Wrath" by Rina Kent, part of the "Legacy of Gods" series, featuring a dark background with ornate gold details and stone pillars.
Spicy dark romance books that shook me
yall these dark romance books had me in a CHOKEHOLD they were so good Comment some of ur favorite dark romance books that have you in a chokehold #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #spiciestbooks #booktok #bookrecs
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

618 likes

A thriller I could not put down
Book Review Book name: The Silent Patient Author: Alex Michaelides Genre: Thriller My rating: 5/5 My review: WOW! And then some more Wow! The ending just shook me and completely unexpected. Who I thought it was, I was soooo far my off! This book takes a twist and then another twist! The autho
Brie

Brie

1 like

Don’t read this book… 🫣
Okay… after reading this, I don’t think I trust my own child anymore 😭. Baby Teeth is WILD. Like, “my eight-year-old might be trying to end me” kind of wild. This book had me questioning everything—parenthood, motherhood, little girls with big eyes and bigger secrets. Zoje Stage really went THER
settleherewellwithtee

settleherewellwithtee

9 likes

A hand holds a Kindle e-reader displaying the cover of "Ward D" by New York Times bestselling author Freida McFadden. The cover shows the title in large white letters against a dark, tiled room with a chair. White sparkle graphics and a Lemon8 watermark are also visible.
First book of 2024 - My Honest Review
Book name: Ward D Author: Freida McFadden Genre: Mystery/Thriller Intro: A medical student spends a night in a locked psychiatric unit. My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ My review: This book is one of the best so far! The plot twists had me SHOOK! Absolutely gripping from the very beginning! This is goin
Cassidy

Cassidy

22 likes

He was shook
#straykids #skz #bangchanstraykids #kpopedit #fyp
Ashley Roosevelt⁷⟭⟬ (Keira)

Ashley Roosevelt⁷⟭⟬ (Keira)

14.3K likes

The book cover for 'The Woman In The Cabin' by Becca Day, featuring a rustic cabin at dusk with illuminated windows. Steps lead up to the cabin, and text reads 'He was your first, You won't be his last'. A Lemon8 watermark is visible.
Book review✨🖤 psychological thriller
Book Review Book name: The Woman In The Cabin Author: Becca Day Genre: Thriller My rating: 5/5⭐️ My review: I could not put this one down! If you love psychological thrillers, this one is for you! Trigger Warning: SA, captivity, self cancel, traumatic birth #thrillerbookreview #thrill
Chrissy 📚🧶🎀🩺

Chrissy 📚🧶🎀🩺

75 likes

A book review for 'The Only One Left' by Riley Sager, featuring an ominous house on a hill against a red sky. The review gives it 4.5/5 stars, praising its good plot twists, suspense, and atmosphere, stating it kept the reader locked in and scared.
Plot Twists Had Me Shook
The twists just kept coming and I did not see half of them. I was stressed, scared, and fully locked in from beginning to end. 4.5 ⭐️ and I need more ASAP! Have you read this? What did you think?
Erika ❤️📚

Erika ❤️📚

9 likes

A hand holds the book 'A Dead Draw' by Robert Dugoni, featuring a dark house under a starry sky. Overlays read 'Another day, another book review' and 'Legal thriller version'.
An open book page displays the quote 'Man is the cruelest animal. -Friedrich Nietzsche' followed by five gold star emojis, indicating a 5-star rating.
An open book, 'A Dead Draw' by Robert Dugoni, rests on a lap with hands holding it. An overlay states 'The most underrated thriller I've read this year'.
📚 Book Review: A Dead Draw by Robert Dugoni
Genre: Legal Thriller | Crime | Suspense Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (10/10) 🧠 Neurodivergent rep ⚖️ Legal drama 💥 Suspense you can feel in your bones I picked this one up knowing absolutely nothing (my favorite way to read), and WOW. From the very first chapter, I was glued. Think: a fierce, traum
Author A. Miracle 📚🌸

Author A. Miracle 📚🌸

6 likes

Book Review | My New Favorite Thriller🎀
❗️ NO SPOILERS❗️This is book is now on the list of thrillers that I’m OBSESSED with!! I can’t even express how good this book was!❤️ (jk i actually can LOL) Book name: They’re Watching You Author: Chelsea Ichaso Genre: Fiction, Thriller, Suspense, Romance, YA, Mystery, Dark Academia My rating
Bri Bri🎀

Bri Bri🎀

481 likes

A hand holds 'The Housemaid' book by Freida McFadden, featuring a keyhole with an eye on the cover. A 'Lemon8 BookClub' ticket is visible, with a Christmas tree in the background. Overlay text reads 'BOOK REVIEW' and 'Reading enriches the mind'.
A hand holds 'The Housemaid' book, with its keyhole cover visible against a Christmas tree background. Overlay text highlights genres and features like 'Mystery', 'Suspense', 'Fast paced', 'Plot twist', and 'Psychological thriller'.
An open book displays quotes from 'The Housemaid', including 'I could scream & yell all I wanted, & nobody would hear.' A Christmas tree is in the background, with overlay text 'Convincing you to read this book with quotes..'.
The housemaid review!!! 📖🔍😲
The housemaid by Freida McFadden 📖🔍 Genre: Psychological thriller Star rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ *no spoilers* This story follows Millie, who is down on her luck & desperately needs a job. She lands a job working as a housemaid for a wealthy family, the Winchesters. Nina Winchester doesn&#3
yariibabyy

yariibabyy

19 likes

A hand holds the book "The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo" by Taylor Jenkins Reid. The cover features a woman in a green dress. "BOOK REVIEW" is written in green at the top, and "Lemon8 @gisellelyzettee" is at the bottom left.
I could not put this book down
I loved this book! It had me hooked. I loved hearing all about Evelyn’s life and love life! I got this book recommended to me by a friend and I’ll be recommending it to others. The plot twist about why she chose Monique had me SHOOK! 4 ⭐️ #lemon8bookclub #Lemon8Diary #letschat #booksumma
Giselle ✨🖤🌿📸

Giselle ✨🖤🌿📸

33 likes

📚 My honest book review 🫣
She’s Not Sorry - Mary Kubica 🚨 The ending will have you shook this is a must read thriller with so many layers - 5 Stars ⭐️ #thrillerbookreview #honestbookreview #lemon8reading #bookrecsoflemon8
Jionni Bleu

Jionni Bleu

20 likes

Had the whole house shook
Nickwilkins

Nickwilkins

4800 likes

First Day of LPN School Got Me SHOOK 😭🩺
Day 1 of LPN school… and my class is literally next to the ER 🥶😭 The cold in that hallway and class ?? Not just the AC… it’s the reality check i was on my summer wear 😭 New books. New faces. New systems. I walked in feeling like a tiny dot in a huge hospital. You can’t be late. You have to clo
Kenny Ather

Kenny Ather

566 likes

The image displays the book cover for Jeneva Rose's 'You Shouldn't Have Come Here,' a New York Times Bestseller. The cover depicts a dark, atmospheric scene with a house and road, highlighted as a 'MUST READ SHOCKING THRILLER' with a Colleen Hoover quote.
A MUST READ BOOK! 😧
jeneva rose has a way of creating the most visual and thrilling novels out there. my most recent read from her shocked me at the ending, taking a turn I never saw coming from the beginning!!!! a week spent in Wyoming, Grace and Calvin slowly fall in love during her stay at his Airbnb. slowly the
ganna sumar

ganna sumar

66 likes

The book cover for Freida McFadden's 'The Boyfriend' features a red tie with blood splatters on white bedsheets. The title is in red, and the author's name is in black. A tagline asks, 'Is he the man of your dreams or your worst nightmare?'
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Review
⚡ When I say The Boyfriend by Freida McFadden shook me… I mean it! ✅ Thought I had it figured out? Nope. ✅ Expected the ending? Not even close. ⏳ Finished in 2 days flat. If you want a thriller that keeps you guessing until the last page—this is it! #ThrillerBooks #MustRead #BookTokMade
Jessica Lynn

Jessica Lynn

3 likes

A book review image for 'Truths We Bury' featuring a blood-stained, patched teddy bear on a dark, smoky background. Overlaid text includes 'We Bury,' 'Book review,' 'The truth isn't just shocking... it's deadly,' and a four-star rating, indicating a thriller.
Thriller Book review
Truths We Bury by Hiliary Amanda #thrillerbooks #arcreader ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Detective Brooks is searching for missing mothers and their children. Zara and her baby are running from someone. Think you have it figured out? You’re wrong! I INHALED this book in less than 2 afternoons. The twists k
Jordyn Leann Howe

Jordyn Leann Howe

44 likes

This. Is. A. True. Story. A real life thriller.
#shook #tbr #thrillerbooks #truecrime #books
Heidi

Heidi

22 likes

You’re NOT ready for this THRILLER 🚨🔥
Just finished Behind Closed Doors by B.A. Paris and… I. Am. SHOOK. 😭💀 I don’t even know where to start. This book had me on the craziest emotional rollercoaster—rage, panic, hope, despair… and then back to rage again. I was screaming at the pages, gasping, clutching my chest, pacing the room… it
jolieeggs_Books

jolieeggs_Books

125 likes

A thriller book that is a must read ♥️
Jar of Hearts by Jennifer Hillier had me absolutely SHOOK. The twists, the trauma, the chaos — I couldn’t breathe 😩 If you love dark psychological thrillers that mess with your mind and heart, this one delivers every single page. #BookTok #ThrillerTok #JenniferHillier #JarOfHearts #Mus
They call me Mrs Martin ❤️❤️

They call me Mrs Martin ❤️❤️

1 like

A thriller I could not put down - 5🌟 Book Review
Shanora Williams will always be one of my favorite thriller authors! this new one from her is my favorite and is going to be tough to beat! what is your favorite domestic thriller?!🖤 #thrillerbookrecommendations #thrillerbooks #thrillerbookreview #thrillerbooksaddict #books
caralinemreads

caralinemreads

4 likes

A hand holds a Kindle displaying the cover of the psychological thriller "DON'T LET HER STAY" by Nicola Sanders, featuring a house under a dark sky. The image has overlay text "BOOK REVIEW" and "Lemon8 @gannasumar", with a plant in the background.
THRILLER BOOK REVIEW!
started this book a few weeks ago in hopes to finish it before february ended but I forgot my kindle in another state over the weekend & didn’t get it back until today! LOVED this book but the ending definitely throw me for a curve ball…let’s just say the tables had turned! this book is abou
ganna sumar

ganna sumar

98 likes

A book review title for "Colleen Hoover Book Review" and "Verity by Colleen Hoover" overlaid on a rumpled white bedspread, featuring the book cover for "Verity" by Colleen Hoover with a golden, intricate design.
A book review section titled "my rating: 8/10" explaining the rating for "Verity" by Colleen Hoover, mentioning overcoming a reading slump, overlaid on a bedspread with the book cover.
A book review section titled "a quick summary:" describing "Verity" as a psychological thriller/romance set in NYC, overlaid on a bedspread with the book cover.
COLLEEN HOOVER BOOK REVIEW: Verity
My HONEST review about Verity by Colleen Hoover To be honest I had very low expectations when starting this book. After seeing how you either love or hate Colleen Hoovers books, I thought it was worth a try. At this point I had been in a book slump for over year and this book…I finished it in tw
lily

lily

28 likes

A book cover for Tarryn Fisher's 'The Wrong Family' is overlaid on a blurred outdoor scene with a white picket fence. The image also features 'Book Review Thriller' text and 'lemon8 @plusthebooks' branding.
Thriller book review
Book Review Book name: The Wrong Family Author: Tarryn Fisher Genre: Thriller My rating: 3⭐️ #thrillerbookreview #thrillerreviews #mysterybookreview #bookrecommendations
Plusthebooks

Plusthebooks

74 likes

Crown Me Dead book review (gods, that twist!)
Crown Me Dead book review: Ya’ll, I am shookith! I thought I saw the plot twist coming, but it twisted more than a plate of spaghetti in a tornado. And now I’m sitting here, mouth agape and…NOT OKAY! First, let’s talk about how amazingly, deliciously dark this Gothic tale is. Liv Zander alw
Julia 📚✍️👩🏻‍�🏫

Julia 📚✍️👩🏻‍🏫

3 likes

This book completely shook me and took me by surpr
This was my Saturday read, it hooked me from the beginning and kept me sucked in all day! The end completely shocked me because it took a turn I absolutely did not expect, throughout the book I was almost positive I knew exactly what was going to happen but I was so wrong the whole time! If you are
Tori Pierce

Tori Pierce

8 likes

The book cover for 'The Broken Girls' by Simone St. James, featuring the title and author in white and black text, respectively. The background shows a blurred, dark building, overlaid with a cracked glass effect and small orange leaf-like elements.
Book Review Thriller
Book Review Book name: The Broken Girls Author: Simone St James Genre: Thriller My rating: 3/5 🌟 My review: This was book was meh. It has murder, holocaust survivors, ghosts, and many forms of trauma. Trigger Warning: SA, self cancel, war survivors #BookReview #thriller #thrillerboo
Chrissy 📚🧶🎀🩺

Chrissy 📚🧶🎀🩺

17 likes

BOOK REVIEW
SYNOPSIS: Her Biggest Fan... When she wakes up, she's very cold. Colder than she's ever been in her life. She can't move or speak. And then she sees him. The one who took her. And before she dies, she wishes she could scream... Is About To Become... Former movie star Jenna Hughes le
Julia11092930

Julia11092930

2 likes

See more