Book Review and Discussion: The Rachel Incident

QOTD: How was your weekend? Bonus points if you can use a gif to show me how it was!

Happy Monday, friends! ☕️🌸

I hope you had a good weekend! Not going to lie, I took the weekend off from bookstagram, so I didn’t see much of what was happening here or on Threads. After the funk of last week, it honestly felt so nice to unplug and just focus on reading for a bit.

And with that extra reading time, I made some solid progress on a few books! I’m still very invested in the Red Rising series by Pierce Brown, and I just checked out the second book in Fredrik Backman’s Beartown series through the Libby app from my local library. I haven’t started it yet, but I’m really looking forward to jumping back into that world soon. 💕📖

In the meantime, I wanted to share a snippet from my latest book club pick, The Rachel Incident by Caroline O’Donoghue. As some of you know, I’m in two book clubs. One I lead for work, and one where we rotate who picks and leads each month. My friend picked this one, and even though she couldn’t make it to the meeting, we still got together to discuss it.

Here’s a little piece of my review 👇

✨ “Rachel is absolutely the creator of her own chaos. She falls for her married professor, comes up with a ridiculous plan to get his attention, and then sits back while her friend gets tangled up in the mess instead. It’s one of those plots where you just keep wanting her to pause and make a better choice, but she never quite does.” ✨

⭐️ 3/5 stars

Messy friendships, questionable choices, and early twenties chaos in Cork.

If you want to read the full review and see all the book club discussion questions I created, it’s up now on my blog, which is linked right on my page. 💻📚

💬 Would you ever pick a book like this for your book club? Or do you avoid messy main characters entirely?

#booktok #bookreview #bookclub #bookrecsoflemon8 #booksoflemon8

2025/11/10 Edited to

... Read moreAfter diving into 'The Rachel Incident,' I found myself with so much to unpack, especially alongside my book club! The original post just scratches the surface, but if you're like me, you'll want to dig even deeper. This book offers a goldmine for discussion, from its messy characters to its vibrant Cork setting. Sparking Conversation: Discussion Questions for 'The Rachel Incident' If you're picking up 'The Rachel Incident' for your own book club, get ready for some lively debate! Here are a few questions my group and I found ourselves pondering, designed to really get into the heart of Caroline O'Donoghue's story: Rachel's Choices: Rachel's actions are certainly... interesting! She's described as "the creator of her own chaos." What specific choices did she make that you found most frustrating or relatable? Do you think she ever truly learns from her mistakes? The Friendship Dynamic: How would you describe the friendship between Rachel and James? In what ways do they enable each other, and where do you see true loyalty or manipulation at play? Did their dynamic feel realistic for people in their early twenties? The Professor & Consequences: The relationship with the married professor is a major catalyst. How did this storyline impact your view of Rachel? What are your thoughts on the societal implications and power dynamics at play in such a situation? Cork as a Character: The setting of Cork, Ireland, plays a significant role. How did the atmosphere of the city contribute to the characters' experiences and the overall tone of the novel? Could this story have unfolded the same way in a different location? Themes of Adulthood: 'The Rachel Incident' captures the chaos of early adulthood. What themes of independence, responsibility, and finding one's identity did you notice throughout the book? How do these resonate with your own experiences? These questions are just a jumping-off point, but they really helped us dissect the book and understand the characters' motivations (or lack thereof!). Creating the Perfect Vibe: Easy Book Club Decor Ideas Beyond just great discussion, I love making our book club meetings feel special. It doesn't take much to transform your space and create an inviting atmosphere that encourages cozy chats and deep dives into literature. When I'm setting up, I often think about making it a comfortable reading nook, similar to the vibe of having my Kindle handy on a comfy sofa. Here are a few simple decor ideas to elevate your next book club gathering: Cozy Lighting: Ditch harsh overhead lights! Think soft lamps, fairy lights, or even candles (safely, of course!). A warm glow instantly makes everyone feel more relaxed and ready to share. Themed Touches: If your book has a strong setting or motif, lean into it! For 'The Rachel Incident,' you could subtly incorporate Irish elements, like a green throw or some simple shamrock decorations. You don't need to go overboard; even a small nod can be fun. Display Your Books: Show off the star of the show! Place copies of the current book (or even your favorite Kindle displaying the cover) prominently. I've even seen people use small easels or book stands. It reminds everyone why they're there. Comfort is Key: Arrange seating so everyone can see and hear each other easily. Throw pillows and blankets can add an extra layer of comfort. My space even has a playful touch with a Mickey Mouse outline on the wall, adding to the relaxed, personal ambiance. Snack & Drink Station: While not strictly 'decor,' a beautifully arranged snack and drink station is an integral part of the atmosphere. Use pretty serving dishes, label items, and make it easy for people to help themselves. Remember, the goal is to create a space where everyone feels comfortable enough to share their thoughts and enjoy the company. A little effort in setting the scene can go a long way in making your book club meetings truly memorable!

Related posts

Books For The Messy Girls
*Trying to share my book recs here and on tiktok* Books: • my year of rest and relaxation • ordinary human failings • berlin • death valley • the rachel incident • night shift #hotbooks #Lemon8Diary #book recommendations #readersoflemon8
monica

monica

778 likes

The book cover for Lynsay Sands' 'The Highlander's Return' features a muscular man in a kilt holding a sword, with 'BOOK REVIEW AND DISCUSSION!' overlaid. It is identified as a New York Times Bestseller, set against a rainy, outdoor backdrop.
Book Review and Discussion!
This romance takes place in the Older times. I'm unsure if it's considered the medieval times. Annella had hoped for a happy marriage when she marries the Laird of the Gunn Clan, however, after the ceremony he abandons her and she has no choice but to learn to run the Clan on her own. Her m
Kyodji2

Kyodji2

4 likes

Book Review: 100 Years of Lynchings by Ralph Ginzb
If you’re serious about understanding the brutal realities of American history and the institutionalized terror inflicted on Black people, 100 Years of Lynchings is an essential read. Ralph Ginzburg compiles real newspaper articles spanning from the late 19th century to the 1960s, documenting the h
Kendrick Bush453

Kendrick Bush453

99 likes

A flat lay shows the book covers for Sophie Lark's 'There Are No Saints' and 'There Is No Devil,' featuring intertwined snakes. They are surrounded by dark roses, snake chains, crystals, a candle, and a crumpled paper with a quote.
The book cover for 'There Are No Saints' by Sophie Lark is displayed, with text indicating 'Chapter 9, 19, 22, 29' at the top. Ratings of 4/5 stars and 5/5 chili peppers are shown below.
The book cover for 'There Is No Devil' by Sophie Lark is displayed, with text indicating 'Chapters 1, 7, 9, 14, 19' at the top. Ratings of 4/5 stars and 5/5 chili peppers are shown below.
The Sinners Duet by Sophie Lark
Book 1 - There Are No Saints #therearenosaints Review - Imagine the show “You” but instead of killing the girl (Mara), Joe ( Cole) starts to have felling for her. Spicy Chapter - 9, 19, 22, 29 Book 2 - There Is No Devil #thereisnodevil Review - The Character Growth!!!!! The Character Dev
Torre

Torre

32 likes

The image shows the cover of the book "Cowboying Up" by USA Today Bestselling Author Delores Fossen, featuring a man in a cowboy hat and open shirt leaning on a fence. Overlaid text reads "Book Review and Discussion!" and "Lemon8 @kyodji".
book ReviewandDiscussion!
Welcome! Please rest a moment and reminisce of a simpler time. Going outside and playing tag with the neighborhood kids, family gatherings with fact to face communication... The early years were far from perfect but we had hoped that as we aged that society as a whole would be leaps and bounds ahea
Kyodji2

Kyodji2

2 likes

A bottle of liquid supplement labeled 'GERITOL B-Vitamins & Iron' with two brown capsules and one white pill. Text overlays include 'Geritol', 'The baby maker?', 'My Review', and 'SWIPE', indicating a personal review of the supplement.
A bottle of liquid supplement and three pills, identified by text overlays as 'One A Day Advanced Prenatal', 'One A Day Advanced Prenatal Choline', and 'CoQ10', alongside the Geritol bottle, suggesting a daily supplement regimen.
A bottle of liquid supplement and three pills, with a text overlay asking 'Any Geritol Baby Mamas out there?', inviting community engagement about experiences with the supplement.
Geritol: My Review
Geritol….(READ ALL THE THROUGH) The baby maker…social media has been going crazy over this bottle for about a year or so now. My family has sworn by it for generations. It is believed that it can aid and help in fertility and women are/were falling pregnant while taking it. Since I am apart o
🐞 LadyBug

🐞 LadyBug

1172 likes

A breakfast meal with a burrito, potatoes, and fruit, alongside two books, *A Little Luck* and *The Dark Side of Skin*, on a table by a window overlooking an outdoor patio. An overlay says 'Read these'.
Book Review: A Little Luck & The Dark Side of Skin
// BOOK NOTES // Last week I finished A Little Luck by Claudio Piñero, translated from the Spanish by Frances Riddle and The Dark Side of Skin by Jeferson Tenório, translated from the Portuguese by Bruna Dantas Lobato. Both were incredible reads and honestly so emotional and heartbreaking in di
Bookladyreads

Bookladyreads

19 likes

A white bookshelf filled with various books, featuring a stack of books on a shelf and the title 'my favorite book from each month of 2024' in a blue text box.
A white bookshelf displaying 'Fruit of the Dead' by Rachel Lyon as the favorite book for January, described as a Persephone & Demeter reimagining about mother-daughter dynamics.
A white bookshelf displaying 'The Rachel Incident' by Caroline O'Donoghue as the favorite book for February, described as a coming-of-age story about friendship, desire, and secrets.
my favorite book from each month of 2024
What a year it’s been! All of these books deeply affected me. They made me feel seen and captured feelings I’ve never been able to put into words. The characters are vivid and memorable, and the writing is exquisite. Some of these are funny, some are poignant, but all of them are written honestly.
dakota bossard

dakota bossard

55 likes

My first tabbed book. 📖
I’m officially starting this lovely a couple days ago and I am loving it… plus there’s some humor in it too?? Say less. 😂📖 I’m always here for emotional damage and funny moments. Also… I finally decided to enter my annotation era. 🙌🏻🖤 I’ve been wanting to tab my books for sooo long but have been
📚xreadingwithkrisx🖤

📚xreadingwithkrisx🖤

59 likes

October’s Theme For My Bookclub✨Fantasy
✨This month our book club explored fantasy with Blood at the Root which follows Malik, a boy just tryna mind his business until life hits him with a whole legacy of magic, secrets, and an HBCU full of gifted folks 🩸✨. Now he’s gotta figure out who he is, where he comes from, and how to handle all t
SheCozy&Lit

SheCozy&Lit

15 likes

Walk through Barnes and Noble with Me✨ 🫶
I have been taking a much-needed “me” break from social media because I was planning, getting married, having a wedding, and so much more! I can't wait to share with you all the life transitions I am currently in. I took myself to Barnes and Noble to see what they had in store and ran into the
Hannahwillard

Hannahwillard

52 likes

My first book release + author event ✨
This was such an incredible experience and I’m still on cloud 9. I still can’t believe I got to meet these amazing authors! 🥹💕 Huge shout out to my sweet friend Susie for bringing me along. #bookevent #booklover #readersoflemon8 #alihazelwood #susanlee
Rachel 📖🎀✨

Rachel 📖🎀✨

182 likes

Brandy and Monica have a discussion
#trending #relatable #explore #celebrity #fyp
The Real Yvette Rants

The Real Yvette Rants

1041 likes

BLACK MODERATED BOOK CLUBS PT. 1 💕🌟
you asked and i heard — here is a list of all of the book clubs i am currently in; preferably black moderated ✊🏾, please understand i am going to support anything that is FUBU 💗 . . majority of these are virtual / discussion based for me since they are out of state, but take a look, you may fi
LEXI 💓

LEXI 💓

16 likes

A futuristic, broken clock face structure with bright light in a dark city, overlaid with the title "Events That Broke The Laws of Time."
A black and white image of a man in a suit with a serious expression, surrounded by blurry figures, illustrating "The Taured Man Border Anomaly" and its description.
A hooded figure in a dark setting looks down at a glowing, intricate pattern, illustrating "The Chronovisor Release" and its alleged ability to view past events.
⏰ Events That Broke The Laws of Time
#time #chronovisor #creepyfacts #fyp Sources: 1. The Chronovisor Hidden in the Vatican • Wikipedia – article on the Chronovisor claims https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_travel_claims_and_urban_legends #The _Chronovisor • Guardian overview of the Ernetti story and alleged deathbe
ThinkLoop

ThinkLoop

615 likes

A copy of the book 'Crash Into Me' by Robinne Lee, featuring a beach scene cover with waves and sand. The cover indicates it's an 'ADVANCE READERS EDITION' on sale 7/7/2026. Seashells and a starfish are arranged around the book on a wooden surface.
6 readers, 1 book, and a LOT of opinions!🍿📖
Our book club just finished Crash Into Me by Robinne Lee and let’s just say… we are still unpacking the emotional damage. ❤️‍🩹✨ Here’s the tea from the group: ❤️ The Romantic: Hooked by the messiness and that 20-year reconnection. 😭 The Emotional Reader: The chemistry was undeniable but the se
The Page Ladies Book Club

The Page Ladies Book Club

5 likes

If you loved Fourth Wing, you might like this series!
⭐️ Rating: 4/5 🌶️ Spice: 2/5 🗺️ Plot: 4.5/5 The Aurelian Cycle series was written by Rosaria Munda, and Fireborne was actually published in 2019 (before Fourth Wing!). Think of Game of Thrones combined with Fourth Wing, and you have this wonderful series. The children of a brutal revolution
Alex

Alex

2 likes

Book Review ✨
Just finished With Love from Harlem and this book had me thinking the entire time. 📚✨ The discussions it opens up about love, sacrifice, and self-worth were impossible to ignore. While I could never sacrifice my well-being for a man, I know so many people who have—and that's what made this stor
🍒🎀ImJustTee🎀🍒

🍒🎀ImJustTee🎀🍒

0 likes

My honest book review 🫣
The story follows Jordyn Monroe, a first‐year student who defers her acceptance at Yale University to attend the HBCU Frazier University in Washington, D.C. She and her three suitemates welcome Devonte—her friend’s older brother, recently released from prison—into their dorm under the guise of ment
Mimi

Mimi

115 likes

A phone screen displays app icons, some with notification badges, under a speech bubble titled 'BLACK MODERATED BOOK CLUBS PT. 2'. The bottom shows 'Lemon8 @itsliterarylexi'.
A book club named 'Black to Front' celebrates books by Black women, moderated by TikTok creator SabiesBooks with 3,033 members. They are currently reading 'Seven Days in June' by Tia Williams.
The 'Ebony Page Turners' book club, for ladies of color to read together, is moderated by LeTaraWrites with 34 members. They are currently reading 'All the Sinners Bleed' by S. A. Cosby.
BLACK MODERATED BOOK CLUBS PT. 2
hey friends, here is PT2 of the black moderated #bookclubs i am currently in 💗 all of these are discussion/virtual based and moderated through the FABLE app. #read #explorepage #club #Lemon8Diary
LEXI 💓

LEXI 💓

6 likes

The image displays the cover of the book 'Sleep No More' by Greg Iles, featuring a dark, eerie scene with a figure walking towards a gate. Overlaid in blue text are the words 'BOOK REVIEW! AND DISCUSSION!'. A Lemon8 watermark with '@kyodji' is visible in the bottom left corner.
Book Review! and Discussion!
Sleep No More by Greg Iles is a thriller novel that combine elements of suspense, mystery and psychological drama. It features intricate plots and intense character development. The main character, John Waters is a well-to-do businessman with a wife and child. one day his world instantly came crash
Kyodji2

Kyodji2

1 like

lesbian book club starting today on fable!
my book club is starting our first book today! we are going to be reading lesbian sci fi and fantasy books, both young adult and adult. our first book is a dark and hollow star by ashley shuttleworth! #book #books #bookwormsoflemon8 #wlw #wlwbooks #wlwbookrecs #lesbian #lgbt #lgbtb
dana! 🍓

dana! 🍓

36 likes

The image displays the book cover for 'Dead in the Water' by John Marrs, featuring a person's head and shoulders in dark water with a bright sky. Overlay text highlights themes like 'Secrets revealed', 'Digging up the past', 'Heartbreaking discoveries', 'Plot twists', 'Dual POV', and 'Traumatic events'.
Book Review Pt. 26🌊
John Marrs newest release was definitely a success! Damon experiences a close call with death, sees his life flash before his eyes! Soon after the incident, he begins seeing this little boy, who he can’t recall ever meeting. At first, he thinks it’s just after shocks from the accident but the hallu
🩵Shelbs🩵

🩵Shelbs🩵

8 likes

The Weight of Blood by Tiffany D Jackson
📚: The Weight of Blood by Tiffany D Jackson Genre: thriller Rating: 5/5 Triggers: racism, bulling, white privilege, micro-aggressions and bulling Where do I begin, first thank you to everyone who voted on this book! I will be reading Blood in the Water soon. I gave this book 5 stars be
Georgi | BookTok 📚

Georgi | BookTok 📚

15 likes

A book titled "The Paris Apartment" by New York Times bestselling author Lucy Foley, a Reese's Book Club pick, lies on a light wooden surface. Overlay text reads "BOOK CLUB Preparation" and a small book club icon is visible.
How Do You Prepare For a Book Club? 🤔
Preparing for a #bookclub - The Ultimate Guide to a Fun and Engaging Meeting 📓🩵📖🤸🏼‍♀️ Are you ready to dive into the world of books and lively discussions? Whether you’re a seasoned book clubber or a newbie, preparing for a book club meeting can make all the difference. Here’s a cheerful and e
Marmalade

Marmalade

37 likes

A Stranger in the House 📖 by Shari Lapena
Just finished reading **"A Stranger in the House"** by Shari Lapena and it was an absolute page-turner! 📚✨ From the author of the bestselling "The Couple Next Door," this thriller takes suspense to a whole new level. The story begins with a shocking incident that leaves you question
The Wild & Woven Life

The Wild & Woven Life

4 likes

Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I loved *Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow* by Gabrielle Zevin. Two childhood friends reconnect in college and make video games together. The portrayal of their friendship, their work as coworkers, and the ups and downs of their relationship is real and inspiring. Even though there
Cait Griffin

Cait Griffin

2 likes

✨ Calling All Book Lovers! ✨
✨ Calling All Book Lovers! ✨ Are you ready to take your book club to the next level? 📚 Introducing: Book Club Blueprint: A Beginner’s Guide! 📚 Turn ordinary meetings into unforgettable experiences with: ✅ Engaging activities that bring stories to life ✅ Thought-provoking discussion prompts ✅
mckenna 📚🤍🩰

mckenna 📚🤍🩰

4 likes

A person wearing a black glove holds the book "Baby Teeth" by Zoje Stage against a snowy background. The book cover features the title in black letters with red, broken candy pieces, and a quote from Entertainment Weekly.
⛔HUGE SPOILER BOOK REVIEW: FULL DEEP DIVE⛔
🚨I read "Baby Teeth" 7 months ago and now I'm revisiting it. Reading this book was like reading a movie script — with the right director and cast, this would be exceptional on the big screen. I also love how the title itself is a metaphor for the loss of innocence-something you really h
⛓⛓YÉE⛓⛓

⛓⛓YÉE⛓⛓

20 likes

A hand holds a Kindle e-reader displaying the cover of 'Binding 13' by Chloe Walsh, from the 'Boys of Tommen #1' series. The image is overlaid with text reading '5/5 STAR READ' and 'Absolutely. Obsessed.', set against a background of artificial ivy vines and string lights.
Binding 13 Review ✨No Spoilers✨
I absolutely cannot believe how captivated I was with this book. I went from being at 40% done with this book to finishing it in 2 days. FAIR WARNING: once you start…you cannot stop. It DOES end on a cliff hanger and I am already cracking open Keeping 13 on my kindle. It was a little bit slow
Kbenzinger2230

Kbenzinger2230

18 likes

The Darwin Incident:Deep Masterpiece or Fever Drem
I just started The Darwin Incident on Prime Video and I have so many thoughts. I wanted to like the "Humanze" concept, but the execution? The vibes are a little rancid, besties. 💀 ​From the bizarre backstory to the voice acting that sounds a little too much like Siri, I’m struggling to fin
Bunny

Bunny

0 likes

For the book besties
#booktok #bookbesties
ghostie_girl17

ghostie_girl17

1 like

Book Recommendations📚
personal growth is essential to self- improvement. In order to begin understanding yourself, tackling toxic habits/triggers, and heal trauma you have to first start from within. I’m so excited to start reading thisss💫 #growththroughreading #lemon8bookclub #bookrecommendation #Lemon8Diary
☆ ☆ ☆ ☆ ☆

☆ ☆ ☆ ☆ ☆

19 likes

A BOOK YOU NEED TO READ ASAP!!
Plsssssss pick this one up if you haven’t already !! Just For the Summer is that perfect summer romance to get you in the mood for the warmer months. The fake dating is set up SO WELL (it’s not cheesy) and the character growth between these two is insane I also love the found family aspect an
KENNEDY ♡

KENNEDY ♡

49 likes

The image features the book "History Lessons" by Zoe B. Wallbrook, highlighted as the January book club pick. It's described as a debut cozy mystery with elements of humor, romance, dark academia, and themes of racism and misogyny.
January Book Club Pick
History Lessons by Zoe B. Wallbrook If you love mysteries, this one's for you. I'm hosting an in-person book club in the DMV for Black women, femmes, and nonbinary readers who want: 📚intentional reading 📚thoughtful (but not stuffy) discussion 📚real community offline/in-person Ju
Tye

Tye

56 likes

A book titled "The Gift" by #1 bestselling author Freida McFadden is displayed on a yellow fluffy surface. Above the book are three cut-out letters spelling "Omg". A Lemon8 watermark is visible in the bottom left corner.
Book Discussion/Review: The Gift 🎁
‼️Spoilers Ahead‼️ 📖 Omg… literally what did I just read. 📖First off I was so surprised the old lady wasn’t dead. I probably would have had a panic attack if something like that happened to me. Imagine you’re working in a diner late at night and it’s almost time to close. You notice a customer st
HasiahW

HasiahW

1 like

A flat lay shows a Kindle displaying "UNSTEADY" by Peyton Corinne, featuring a hockey puck and ice skates on its cover. Also present are a "WATERFELL UNIVERSITY" pennant and patch, and a "HOT SHOT" hockey puck, all on a white fluffy blanket. The image is captioned "Book Review - 4/5".
Book Review/Recommendation🏒⛸️
This story and these characters were so real, raw, and heartfelt and I just loved them all. I wanted to give them so many hugs! Tropes/themes; ⛸️ Dual POV 🏒Hockey captain MMC ⛸️ Grumpy black cat energy figure skater FMC 🏒 He falls first ⛸️ Found family Sadie is just trying to provide and tak
Chey🩵

Chey🩵

5 likes

When you publish your book 🥹
Literally cannot thank you all enough for your support in my publishing journey ♥️ #newauthor #publishingjourney #publishingabook #militarylife #miltok
The Army Poet

The Army Poet

3 likes

See more