If He Had Been With Me - Book Review ✨

📄 Plot:

Autumn and Finny grew up side by side as best friends, but over time they drifted apart. Still, Autumn never stopped wondering what could’ve happened if things were different if she had told him how she felt, if they had stayed close, if she had just spoken up. The book follows her internal world, the quiet longing and tension between them, and ends in a way that breaks your heart but also makes you think deeply about love, loss, and timing.

📖 Genre:

YA Contemporary Fiction / Romance / Tragedy

📄 My Favorite Quotes:

• “There are no words for the happiness I feel when I’m with him.”

• “It’s the knowing that kills me. The knowing of what could have been.”

💭 My Thoughts:

This book wrecked me emotionally. The slow build-up, the quiet tension, the feeling of being on the edge of something beautiful, and then losing it all ; it hit so close to home. I felt Autumn’s grief like it was my own. It made me think about all the missed chances in life and how sometimes love doesn’t get the ending it deserves. I cried. I sat in silence. I wished it could have ended differently… but maybe that’s what makes it unforgettable.

⭐ Star Rating: ★★★★.2

#if he had been with me #lastread #nevertheless #lemon8bookclub #fyp

2025/6/1 Edited to

... Read moreIn 'If He Had Been With Me', Laura Nowlin crafts a tale that resonates deeply with anyone who has experienced the bittersweet nature of unexpressed feelings. The novel, which became a #1 New York Times Bestseller, brings to life the complexities of friendship turned romance and the haunting realization of what could have been. Readers will relate to Autumn's anguish as she navigates her internal conflicts and the palpable tension in her relationship with Finny. The book beautifully captures the essence of youthful love amidst the pains of heartbreak and regret. The genre blends contemporary fiction with elements of tragedy and romance, primarily appealing to teens and young adults. As the narrative unfolds, it becomes a powerful reminder of the importance of honesty and communication in relationships. Not only does this book tug at your heartstrings, but it also encourages reflection on personal experiences and the moments we wish we could rewrite. Perfect for fans of emotional storytelling, 'If He Had Been With Me' is a must-read that leaves a lasting impression and sparks introspection about the profound connections we share throughout our lives.

Related posts

A hand holds the book 'If he had been with me' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a dark cover with two lollipops. Overlays include 'BOOK REVIEW', 'Reading enriches the mind', and a Lemon8 Book Club ticket with the book's title, author, a 4-star rating, and a note: 'If you want to feel something pick this book up'.
If he had been with me book review
I picked up this book wanting to feel something and now I can’t stop feeling. I knew getting into this book could be traumatic but I loved every second of it. I am not much of a slow burn lover but this one right here made me want to pick up another slow burn. I will say you will go through
Alana Harden

Alana Harden

8 likes

A hand with red and black spider-themed nails holds the dark cover of the book 'If He Had Been With Me' by Laura Nowlin. The cover features two lollipop sticks, one with a broken red lollipop and the other with a heart-shaped one. Overlays read 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW' and 'Rating: 4/5'.
IF HE HAD BEEN WITH ME- Book Review
Oh my gosh. Where do I start? I started this book MONTHS ago and I really, really struggled to get into it. It felt like it was just dragginggg on. Around chapter 37 or so, I decided I’m going to finish it but NOT reading the sequel. Well, I’m going to buy the sequel tomorrow😭 The e
Uhlaynuh

Uhlaynuh

10 likes

An aesthetic flat lay of multiple open books with aged pages, featuring 'Book Review' text overlayed on the central book. The scene suggests a cozy reading atmosphere for a book review.
The cover of 'if he had been with me' by Laura Nowlin, featuring two lollipops, rests on a grey blanket. Overlays indicate a 4.5-star rating, themes of 'Childhood Best Friends' and 'Highschool', and trigger warnings for 'Pregnancy, Suicide, Death'.
An open book displays a 'Fav Quote' overlay: "'This is friendship, and it is love, but I already know what they have not learned yet; how dangerous friendship is, how damaging love can be.'" (Nowlin). Other open books are in the background.
Book Review | if he had been with me
#BookReview #bookrecommendations #books #book #bookaesthetic #booktok #reading #readersoflemon8 #ifhehadbeenwithme #lauranowlin
Aubrey

Aubrey

22 likes

A hand holds the book 'If Only I Had Told Her' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a red rose on the cover. Overlays include 'Book Review', 'His POV', 'Friends to lovers', and a three-star rating, all on a light-colored bedsheet background.
Book Review: If Only I Had Told Her
You guyssss! I randomly decided to read if he had been with me two weeks ago and zoomed through it in two days without knowing there was a second on the way! Obviously I had to grab it to read Finnys - I’m half way through and right now I’m preferring the first over this. Thoughts? 📖🥀 #Lemon8Di
MarySylvia Fain

MarySylvia Fain

220 likes

A book review featuring two books by Laura Nowlin: 'If He Had Been With Me' and 'If Only I Had Told Her'. A bouquet of red roses with gold crowns is next to them, labeled with 'School setting', 'Romance subplot', and 'Found family'. A Goodreads rating of 4.5/5 is also shown.
Book Review : If he had been with me
Book Review Book name: if he had been with me Author: Laura Nowlin Genre: young adult My rating: 4.5 /5 💰Price: 10.99 at Barnes and Noble My review: What I think about this book it’s good in point of view of Autumn one of the main characters. The setting is high school drama . It’s a fr
Ashley

Ashley

8 likes

The image displays the book cover for "The Power of the Pussy" by Kara King, featuring a black cat silhouette. Overlaid text indicates a review, stating "I Finally Read It" and "Here's My Review," along with the Lemon8 handle.
This image presents a book review for "The Power of the Pussy," highlighting its benefits for women with low self-esteem and confidence. It includes a rating of 8.5/10 and testimonials, along with the book's ISBN.
The image shows an open book with text, overlaid with instructions to get a paper copy online or an Ebook off Amazon Kindle. A sticky note encourages followers for more reviews, recipes, life hacks, and DIY ideas.
MY BOOK REVIEW ON THE POWER OF THE 🐈‍⬛
I saw this book all over this app & decided to give it a read! This is my review & rating #books #BookReview #booksoflemon8 #bookshelf #reading #readingrecommendations #thoughts
ImTheLoveWitch777

ImTheLoveWitch777

1574 likes

🤯 BOOK REVIEW
So I had to take a break from my normal book readings lol, and pick me up a good thriller that I really enjoyed… I been eyeing this one all over KU but kept passing it by until today and it did not disappoint.. pretty much wish i read this sooner 🥴… A must read if you like suspense/ psychologica
💕✨TATIANA✨💕

💕✨TATIANA✨💕

155 likes

Book Review Pt. 1📖
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 : I loved the plot line in this book! The overall story is VERY easy to follow! Lots of emotions, family/friend drama, high school journey, love and heartbreak. Short chapters (which I love) and it was hard to put this book down! I definitely recommend this book! Can’t wait to read the s
🩵Shelbs🩵

🩵Shelbs🩵

12 likes

BOOK REVIEW: Moth To A Flame 🔥❤️‍🩹
Yalllllllll….. OH MY GODDDDDDD THIS BOOKK… THIS BOOOOOOK GOT ME IN SHAMBLESSSSSSS I Have never hated a book character more than I hate Mizan like put me in the book because somebody need to box him fr 😂😭😭, Raven my girl why couldn’t you just listeeeeeeeen to ya momma and daddy 💔💔, at this point
˚ ꕥ Catera ꕥ˚

˚ ꕥ Catera ꕥ˚

82 likes

Book Review
Book Review Book name: if he had been with me Author: Laura Nowlin Genre: YA My rating: 4/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ My review: i read this book in less than 24 hours. I found the beginning really slow. But I can see why this book is so hyped up. The ending totally broke me. Autumn is so relatable and I love
Hasina

Hasina

6 likes

A hand holds the white cover book "A Love Letter to Whiskey" by Kandi Steiner, featuring gold script. Overlays read "My Honest BOOK REVIEW" and "Rating: 5/5", with small heart emojis. The book is a 5th Anniversary Edition, with a quote from Penelope Ward.
My Honest Book Review 📖🥹🫶🏻
Book name: A Love Letter To Whiskey 🥃 Author: Kandi Steiner Genre: Romance Good Reads Rating ⭐️: 4.36 My rating⭐️: 5 My review: Where should I even begin???? The main character B? Oh I hated her .. every chapter the hate grew bigger .. and JUST WHEN I THOUGHT I LIKED HER ! Boom .. she di
Martha

Martha

263 likes

A book review title card for 'Credence by Penelope Douglas' set against a misty forest background with evergreen trees. Stars and a dashed arrow decorate the text.
Credence Book Review 🏔️🧣🏍️
⭐️Overall rating: 4.5/5: This was my first book that I’ve read from Penelope Douglas and it was very interesting. If you can get past the trigger warnings that are listed below then you’ll be just fine. This book had me making so many faces because of what was going on. I was quite surprised abo
Kenderella

Kenderella

7 likes

The book cover for 'Divine Rivals' by Rebecca Ross, featuring dark blue flowers and text 'No God No Creature No War Can Come Between Them'. Overlaid text reads 'Book Review:'.
An illustrated cover of 'Divine Rivals' with two characters, showing the book was started on 01/18/24 and finished on 01/20/24. A five-star rating is displayed below an illustration of two characters.
A collage of images creating a 'BOOK AESTHETIC' for 'Divine Rivals', including hands writing, a couple embracing, a typewriter, and text 'Gods & Goddesses' and 'Rivals To Lovers'.
Book review: Divine Rivals
My whole life I have never been one for fantasy books; luckily for me, my book club decided to choose Ruthless vows for our months read (which is the second book in the duology) forcing me to read the first one. I am SO happy that that was chosen bc it forced me to read fantasy, and this YA boo
saighey

saighey

27 likes

Book Review Pt 8
Book Review Pt 8 Dreamers and Deceivers by Glenn Beck ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ This so full of such intriguing and interesting stories and things that as a history buff i had t heard much about! I love learning the “ugly” side of history and this book took you into those moments and told you who when and wh
Joey Mc

Joey Mc

27 likes

A hand holds the book 'If He Had Been with Me' by Laura Nowlin, featuring a dark cover with two broken lollipops forming a heart. A pink text overlay reads 'Book Review: 10/10'.
Book Review:
If He Had Been with Me by: Laura Nowlin Personally, I absolutely adored this book.🫶🫶 The character development in this book is amazing. I felt like I grew to personally know the characters. Your favorite character will be Finny! It is definitely an easy read. WARNING: the ending is truly heart b
MattieGrace🩷🫶

MattieGrace🩷🫶

13 likes

A hand holds three white-spined books against a blurred bookshelf background, with text overlay "LET'S CHAT! Books that lived up to the hype? SWIPE" and Lemon8 branding.
Four book covers are displayed: 'The Whisper Man,' 'The Perfect Marriage,' 'The Boyfriend,' and 'Gone Girl,' all shown with five-star ratings and held by a hand with star-patterned nails.
Four book covers are displayed: 'The Shadows,' 'The Obsession,' 'A Flicker in the Dark,' and 'The Maidens,' all shown with five-star ratings and held by a hand with star-patterned nails.
✨Book Review✨
Sometimes I stay away from books that I see everywhere because I have been disappointed quite a few times, but these books did not disappoint me! I have read “The Silent Patient” because I was curious, although it was a good read I ended up loving “The Maidens” a lot more! In my opinion that bo
DAËON

DAËON

314 likes

✨ Book Review+Moodboard ✨
💜YASSS SIS GOT IT RIGHT! A fantasy novel featuring two Black main characters that doesn't leave me questioning if the author is a lifetime member to the cookout or hell at least been invited lol. This story was both comforting and thrilling, with unexpected plot twists, engaging fight scenes, a
SheCozy&Lit

SheCozy&Lit

57 likes

The image features the book 'We Were Liars' by E. Lockhart, with its cover showing people in water. Overlaid text reads 'Book Review', accompanied by a color palette, decorative flowers, and the Lemon8 logo with a username.
We were Liars Book Review 🌊🐚
I just finished reading this book yesterday and I honestly think it was pretty good . I thought the ending was a real shocker and I honestly didn’t expect it . I think I would rate this book a 8 out of 10 since it was very interesting but I just think it had a lot of chapters that could’ve been lon
Nicole Denise 🃏

Nicole Denise 🃏

6 likes

A hand holds the book "Why Women Grow" by Alice Vincent, featuring a dark cover with vibrant floral illustrations. Overlaid text reads "My Honest BOOK REVIEW" and "Rating: 5/5," indicating a positive review of the gardening and empowerment book.
🌱 Book Review: Why Women Grow by Alice Vincent 📖🌸
Hey Lemon8 fam! 🌼 Just wrapped up "Why Women Grow" by Alice Vincent, and OMG, I am obsessed! 🌿✨ Alice takes us on this wild, wonderful journey through gardens and personal growth, showing how digging in the dirt is more than just a hobby—it's a whole vibe. 🌱💚 Her writing is this magi
Candyce

Candyce

222 likes

A hand holds a Kindle displaying the cover of 'Done and Dusted' by Lyla Sage, with a river and mountains in the background. Text overlays indicate a book review and a 4/5 rating.
A hand holds a Kindle showing 'Done and Dusted' against a backdrop of a road and mountains, reflecting a move to Wyoming. The image includes the Lemon8 username.
A hand holds a physical copy of 'Swift and Saddled' by Lyla Sage in a bookstore. Text indicates it's the second book and the reader is excited to finish it.
BOOK REVIEW & SUMMARY
📚 Title and Author: Done and Dusted by Lyla Sage 🌟 Genre: Romance 💬 Short Summary: It starts out enemies to lovers (and brothers best friend👀) but quickly morphs into something more when Emmy moves back home after living far away for years. Andddd he falls first. 🙈😍 Thoughts and opinions:
Loralynne🤎☕️📖

Loralynne🤎☕️📖

20 likes

See more