Best gelato in NYC✨

During a casual Manhattan stroll, I decided to check out TGTG (Too Good To Go) and scored an $8 chocolate mystery box! 😍 Naturally, I had to go pick it up, and it led me to a chocolate and handmade gelato shop: Venchi!

I ended up trying their Pistachio Gelato, and wow, it was incredibly rich and creamy! The flavor was so deep and satisfying, I couldn’t stop eating it! 👏

The chocolate here is also super decadent, and the store offers a variety of unique flavors like black truffle and rum. The $8 chocolate blind box was a great deal, and I’m already planning my next visit to explore more flavors! 🍫

📍 Venchi

#lemon8partner #nycdesserts #nycfoodreview #nycguide #nyccafe

2025/5/9 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so after my incredible find at Venchi Soho, I just HAVE to share more insights for anyone else looking for truly amazing gelato in NYC. What really sets Venchi apart, beyond that mind-blowing pistachio I raved about? First off, the atmosphere. It's not just a quick stop; it feels like a little slice of Italy right in Manhattan. The scent of chocolate and fresh gelato hits you the moment you walk in – it's pure bliss! I noticed they have a fantastic selection of classic Italian gelato flavors, not just adventurous ones. While my original post highlighted pistachio, I’ve heard their hazelnut (nocciola) and dark chocolate (cioccolato fondente) are absolute game-changers too. Next time, I'm definitely eyeing the strawberry gelato – the image from my last visit with the strawberry and pistachio cone looked divine! Speaking of my discovery, that Too Good To Go (TGTG) app is seriously a lifesaver for finding hidden gems AND scoring deals. My $8 chocolate mystery box was such a fun surprise! It was packed with a mix of their exquisite pralines, truffles, and even some chocolate squares. It's like a sweet treasure hunt, and it’s a brilliant way to try out Venchi's premium chocolate selection without breaking the bank. If you're into sustainable eating and love a good surprise, definitely check out TGTG – you never know what amazing spots like Venchi you might uncover! For those new to the gelato world, don't confuse it with regular ice cream! Gelato typically has less fat, less air churned into it, and is served at a slightly warmer temperature, which makes its flavors much more intense and its texture incredibly smooth and dense. That's exactly what I experienced with Venchi's pistachio – it wasn't overly icy or airy, just pure, concentrated pistachio goodness. It’s a whole different level of dessert indulgence. A little tip for visiting Venchi Soho: it can get busy, especially on weekends, but the line moves fast. Don't be afraid to ask for a sample or two if you're torn between flavors – the staff are usually super friendly and happy to help you find your perfect scoop. And don't forget to check out their vast array of chocolates and spreads; they make fantastic gifts or just a treat for yourself! Whether you're a local or just visiting, adding Venchi to your NYC dessert crawl is an absolute must-do. You won't regret experiencing what many consider NYC's best gelato!

11 comments

Shelby D's images
Shelby D

I love this place! In the colder months, their hot chocolate is also incredible and rich!

Related posts

A hand holds a waffle cone with two scoops of gelato, one pink/red and one brown with chocolate drizzle, against a blurred brightly lit storefront at night. The image has a text overlay "NYC's BEST GELATO".
A hand holds a waffle cone with three scoops of gelato (white, light brown, dark brown) in front of a storefront. The word "GELATERIA" is illuminated above the entrance of the shop.
A hand holds a waffle cone with two scoops of gelato (white and brown) in front of a gelato shop at night. The word "GELATERIA" is illuminated above the entrance, with people visible inside.
Best Gelato in NYC
Revolving Flavors. Creamiest. Freshest. Gelato. This has easily become my FAV gelateria in NYC! And it’s open late! Different location have different flavors! Gelateria Gentile #nycdesserts #food #foodrecommendations #nyc #nycrecs
Ramizah Salim

Ramizah Salim

5 likes

A close-up of soft-serve ice cream or gelato in a clear cup, topped with sauce and sliced fruit, garnished with a green leaf. Text overlay reads "top 14 ICE CREAM in NYC, ranked" and "as ranked by Beli members."
A map of New York City showing numerous ice cream cone icons with numerical ratings, indicating locations and scores. An overlay states "based on over 100 million ratings on beli."
A collage of six images featuring green and brown scoops of gelato in cups and cones, with "Triple gelato" text. A central overlay identifies it as "14. Eddie's Sweet Shop."
Top 14 ice cream and gelato shops in NYC, ranked
Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. Let us know what you think should have made the list! 🍦 #icecreamshop #nycdesserts #nycicecream #icecreamlovers #nycfoodie
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

0 likes

A collage showcasing four different frozen treats: a slushie from Edith's, two scoops of gelato from Anita, Fior di Latte soft serve with passion fruit from Crevette, and soft serve with green toppings from Lilia, against a NYC harbor backdrop.
A white cup filled with creamy Fior di Latte soft serve, generously topped with vibrant yellow passion fruit and seeds, presented on a white plate with a candle in the background.
A clear glass bowl containing vanilla soft serve, drizzled with honey and olive oil, and sprinkled with green fennel pollen, served on a white plate on a wooden table.
More Scoops | Slushies for Summer in NYC 🍦🍨
It’s sunny out! Quick! Goooooooo~ Here’s a round up of some scoops and slushies I’ll be enjoying on repeat to keep cool 😎 Crevette The Fior di Latte soft serve is wonderfully creamy and milky but is contrasted by the super tart passion fruit so this dessert also acts like a palate cleans
Netgonenutsforfood

Netgonenutsforfood

70 likes

Must Try Desserts In NYC✨🧁
✨🍭NYC is a dessert-lover’s dream! Do not miss these iconic desserts: 1️⃣ Ci Siamo hazelnut gelato ($11) 10/10 - they have so many magnificent flavors of gelato from espresso stracciatella to goats milk lemon BUT I can’t stop getting the hazelnut !! 🌰 2️⃣ Saint Theo's tiramisu ($17) 8/10 -
chef.slick

chef.slick

1458 likes

3 NYC Restaurant Desserts I Am Not Skipping
After every meal I need a little something sweet - here are my top 3 restaurant desserts that I am definitely not skipping in NYC: 1. Profiteroles at QUATORZE on the UES ($19) Pastry filled with creamy vanilla ice cream and a rich chocolate sauce poured on top 9/10 2. Oishii strawberry shortca
chef.slick

chef.slick

762 likes

A white Italian Gelato truck with 'Gelato Italiano' branding is parked in Germany, featuring images of people enjoying ice cream under a blue sky. The text overlay reads 'Italian Gelato Truck in Germany'.
The side of a white gelato truck with its serving window open, displaying menus of various gelato sundaes and options. A yellow sun emoji is visible on the truck, with text 'Look at all these yummy options!'.
A hand holds a 5 Euro bill and several Euro coins, ready to pay for a fruity gelato banana split. The gelato truck is partially visible in the background, with text '•I ordered a fruity gelato banana split!'.
Gelato Truck in Germany! 🍦🍨
#shopwithme Shop some Gelato with me! When I heard the music I was THRILLED! I honestly didn’t know there would be Ice Cream trucks in #germany but when I saw it was a Gelato Italiano Truck I almost cried of happiness! 🥹🥹 I got to speak with the driver and gelatiere itself! Those fruit
Kim🪷

Kim🪷

18 likes

Cover image for 'NYC's Best Desserts Part 1' featuring a bowl of grain ice cream with caramel sauce and cookie crumbles, from ODRE.
A hand holds a waffle cone with a scoop of yuzu strawberry ripple ice cream from Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream, against an urban background.
A serving of bread pudding topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and drizzled with caramel sauce, from Alligator Pear.
BEST desserts in NYC - pt. 1 💛
💞 best desserts in NYC - part 1! - Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream - loved their yuzu strawberry ripple ice cream, but they have so many flavors to choose from. you can't go wrong! - Alligator Pear - a bread pudding i haven't been able to stop thinking about. it was SO GOOD. -
cass • nyc food

cass • nyc food

225 likes

A purple spoon scoops bright green Baja Blast Gelato from a branded cup, set against a purple background. The text overlay reads 'Baja Blast Gelato'.
A hand holds a white cup of Baja Blast Gelato with a purple lid. The cup features 'Mtn Dew Baja Blast GELATO' branding and indicates 3.6 FL OZ (106ML).
A close-up view of the nutrition facts and ingredients label on the Baja Blast Gelato cup, showing 70 calories per serving and listing ingredients.
Baja Blast Gelato 🍧
Taco Bell and Mountain Dew have launched Baja Blast Gelato to celebrate Baja Blast’s 20th birthday! I paid 3.99 for 3.6 oz and I think it was a good sized portion! It has a light Baja flavor and is extremely refreshing and cooling for a hot day. It was very soft and easy to eat immediately.
Sage.Fart🌙

Sage.Fart🌙

3594 likes

only matcha gelato spot in NYC✨
Aoko Matcha is one of the newest addition the lower east side and it is already gaining a lot of popularity. This is the first ever matcha gelato spot in nyc! When you go there, definitely try their triple matcha gelato scoop. The fun part is you can choose the intensity level as well! Loca
eat.feast.repeat

eat.feast.repeat

75 likes

🌸 largest Japanese festival in NYC
🎏 NYC’s largest japanese food festival👇🏼 💖 follow @casserolebites for more good eats & food recs in nyc! 🔖 save this and share with someone you want to go here with 😋 JapanFES is BACK this year and they’ve made it somehow even better than ever with so many great vendors 🇯🇵🍡✨ i brough
cass • nyc food

cass • nyc food

2297 likes

A soft-serve ice cream in a clear cup with yellow sauce, cherry tomatoes, and a green leaf, with text 'top 14 ICE CREAM in NYC, ranked' and 'as ranked by Beli members'.
A map of NYC showing numerous ice cream cone icons with ratings, indicating locations and scores, with text 'based on over 100 million ratings on beli'.
A collage featuring various sundaes and ice cream desserts from Eddie's Sweet Shop, including a banana split, banana royal, and vanilla fudge ice cream.
Top 14 ice cream and gelato shops in NYC, ranked
Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. Let us know what you think should have made the list! 🍦 #icecreamshop   #nycdesserts   #nycicecream   #icecreamlovers   #nycfoodie
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

0 likes

A display case filled with various flavors of gelato, including pistachio, milk chocolate cream, chocolate almonds caramel, and macadamia cream, with a text overlay stating 'my top ice cream spot in nyc'.
Two cups of Anita gelato, one with two waffle cookies, on a table in a cafe setting, with a text overlay describing 'anita rich and creamy gelato with unique flavours'.
Two hands holding ice cream cones from Van Leeuwen, one with a light-colored scoop and the other with a green and pink scoop, with a text overlay describing 'Van Leeuwen iconic gelato spot with very sweet flavours'.
found my fav ice cream spot in nyc
Found my fav ice cream spot in nyc and it’s… Anita ($8.50 for a regular, up to two flavours) - rich and creamy gelato with unique flavours Anita La Mamma del Gelato But here’s some other solid ice cream spots: 1. Van Leeuwen - popular ice cream palour with seasonal flavours ($5.50 for sin
nessie

nessie

606 likes

ADD NOW these restaurants to your NYC Buckets List
🍭 From one sweet tooth to another, here are my favorite desserts of 2023, and I won't gatekeep them! Make sure to try at least one of these places on your trip to New York ! 1. Le Miel - Sweet Rehab Champagne Bar 2. Anything from here: Dominique Ansel Bakery - but def try the cronut!
Your City Gal | NYC

Your City Gal | NYC

91 likes

A hand in a black glove holds a light blue cup of Anita Pistachio gelato, topped with nuts and a drizzle, with a black spoon. A pink napkin is wrapped around the cup. The background shows a blurred shop interior.
Anita Gelato Miami 🍨
The best Gelato you can buy , everything here so delicious but my favorite is the Pistachio it's just the best. Definitely try it 😍😍 ! #Gelato #wheretoeat #miami 💰Price : $-$$ Rating: 1000/10 😍! #miamivibes #miamicontentcreator
Lina In Bloom🪸

Lina In Bloom🪸

19 likes

KayAli Yum pistachio gelato 🫶🏾🙂‍↔️
#kayali vanilla 28 #kayaliperfume #kayali #Fragrance
Vicky 🍒

Vicky 🍒

452 likes

gelato & italian food in culver city
if you’re looking for the perfect summer treat, checkout Ugo Cafe in Culver City. they have the best gelato to cool down with and so many flavors to choose from! also they have a lounge and restaurant if you want to check out their drinks and Italian food like pizza and pasta and more! #Gelato
tiff 🍦✈️

tiff 🍦✈️

46 likes

A hand holds a beautiful gelato flower cone with white, pink, and tan flavors, topped with a white chocolate piece, against a brick wall. The image has a text overlay "NYC'S PRETTIEST GELATO FLOWER."
A hand holds a gelato flower cone with white, pink, and tan flavors, topped with a white chocolate piece, inside what appears to be a gelato shop with stone walls.
A hand holds a gelato flower cone with white, pink, and tan flavors, topped with a white chocolate piece, against the blurred background of a gelato shop's interior.
NYC Gelato Just Leveled Up✨🥰
New York never fails to surprise — even with gelato! 💕 This little spot in Greenwich Village instantly became my No.1 gelato in NYC. Imagine a giant gelato flower on a chocolate-dipped cone, stacked with five different flavors — all for just $10! 🌸🍦 I went for pistachio, hazelnut, and coconut,
YiweiinNY🤯

YiweiinNY🤯

25 likes

A hand with pink nail polish holds a white cup of Botolino gelato, featuring two scoops of different flavors, one light brown and one dark brown, with a wooden spoon. The cup sits on a bright yellow surface, and the text 'Best gelato' is overlaid.
Best gelato in Dallas 😋🍨
Tried Botlino gelato for the first time and I would argue that it’s some of the best gelato in Dallas if not the best gelato. I got the regular size which comes with two flavors and I chose pistachio for one and some hazelnut/nutella flavor for the other one. Omg it was heavenly. Felt like I was ba
Hannah 💕

Hannah 💕

3 likes

A person holds a large yellow alcoholic gelato cone with a waffle disc in an ice cream parlor in Dublin. The background shows a menu board listing gelato flavors like Strawberry, Ferrer, and Caramel, with other customers and display cases visible.
Alcoholic gelato In Dublin!
#lemon8diarychallenge #ireland #dublin #travel #icecream #Gelato #europe #summer #european summer #Lemon8Diary
emily🌸

emily🌸

32 likes

See more