Automatically translated.View original post

The "round finger" points society better without the "power man."

Round Finger-Saravudh Hengdai, a famous writer and thinker, a Facebook post reflected the role of "heroes" in Thai society, questioning the responsibility of the public sector to care for the people, and proposing the idea that instead of relying on selfless individuals, we should create a transparent, efficient and cost-effective tax system to solve sustainable problems.

---

"German comedian Henning Wehn once said thoughtfully, 'At Germany, we don't donate. We pay taxes. Donation exposure is a failure of government responsibility.'

Personally, I think that donations are socially viable, but in any society where donations or recipients are "powerful," it's also worth questioning what government agencies are doing when they're collecting taxes to do these things. They've been talking to their brothers and sisters who are doing social enterprises. They say that the job is not done if the government is doing its job well, but it's not.

In a society with a lot of 'suffering villagers', it is possible that he started with the intention of solving social problems, which is a good thing, but after a while, the popularity of the people will start to stack up with the benefits of the hero, which is credited with his' doing good 'by receiving donations from the people, which, in fact, should be able to expect government duties without the need to donate money to help the people together often and often as another form of' tax '.

When a hero becomes famous and a fan, fame is what he gets while 'sacrificing' for the people. In the social media age, fame and followers are like 'votes', which varies into 'power' or 'influence'. According to ordinary people, that person has the opportunity to become a 'power man'. If he takes that power to do good things, it's probably good. But as Spider-Man says, 'great power comes with great responsibility.' And when someone starts to be 'influ', there may be people. Let's use his' power 'to empower each other back and forth.

A society that should expect and be a more lasting solution is that no one has to be transformed into a "powerful man" to manage bad people or solve the problems of the villagers by accepting donations from time to time, but to question the duties of the public sector and to pressure people to devise policies that will solve problems in a serious, sustainable way.

If the solution is caused by the public sector, no one will be a hero, but the people will be in a system that uses transparent, effective, and expected health care. If donations are made, it is because we have friends, not support any hero, because the system that should do those jobs does not do their own job.

Instead of having a powerful man, we need a powerful man system: a democratic, verifiable, transparent, corruption-reducing system, optimizing the use of public taxes to care for the people, and an effectively coordinated bureaucracy.

Perhaps being in a society that expects too many individuals or 'heroes' makes us accidentally lower our expectations of government and government agencies. We want to see a 'powerful system' emerge in our home. We believe that the city can be much better, and that the suffering of the villagers will be reduced without any good people sacrificing themselves, tired, sweaty and sympathetic tentacles as they are. "

# TheStructure

# TheStructureNews

# Round fingers # Welfare state

2025/10/21 Edited to

... Read moreบทบาทของ "จอมพลัง" หรือฮีโร่ในสังคมไทยที่นิ้วกลมสะท้อนไว้นั้น สะท้อนปัญหาที่ลึกซึ้งของระบบการบริหารจัดการภาครัฐและสังคมที่ยังขาดประสิทธิภาพในการดูแลประชาชนอย่างทั่วถึงและยั่งยืน ในบริบทของสังคมไทย การที่ยังคงมีฮีโร่หรือ "จอมพลัง" ผู้เสียสละทำงานช่วยเหลือชุมชนและสังคมอย่างเหน็ดเหนื่อย อาจบ่งชี้ถึงช่องว่างของระบบสาธารณะ ที่ไม่สามารถตอบสนองความต้องการของประชาชนได้อย่างเต็มที่ และยังต้องพึ่งพาการบริจาคจากประชาชนเองเพื่อแก้ไขปัญหาต่างๆ ดังนั้น สิ่งที่สำคัญคือการพัฒนาระบบราชการและบริการสังคมให้เป็น "ระบบจอมพลัง" ที่โปร่งใส ตรวจสอบได้ มีประสิทธิภาพ และสามารถจัดสรร uso ภาษีอย่างเหมาะสมเพื่อตอบสนองการดูแลสุขภาวะและคุณภาพชีวิตของประชาชนอย่างครบถ้วน นอกจากนี้ การสร้างระบบที่ดีควรมุ่งเน้นการมีส่วนร่วมของประชาชนในกระบวนการกำกับดูแล และการเลือกสรรผู้แทนที่มีความสามารถและมีวิสัยทัศน์ในการวางนโยบายเพื่อสังคมที่ยั่งยืน การลดทุจริตคอร์รัปชันและการสร้างวัฒนธรรมความรับผิดชอบร่วมกันในสังคมจึงเป็นหัวใจสำคัญของการสร้าง "ระบบจอมพลัง" สุดท้าย การลดความคาดหวังที่มีต่อ "ฮีโร่" รายบุคคล และหันมาเรียกร้องการพัฒนาโครงสร้างและนโยบายสาธารณะที่เข้มแข็ง จะช่วยลดภาระความเหน็ดเหนื่อยและความกดดันต่อคนดีในสังคม และพัฒนาคุณภาพชีวิตของประชาชนโดยรวมอย่างแท้จริง

Related posts

Become a Healthcare Worker without a Degree💉👀✨
Hey Girls💉✨ After reading you comments on my last post on healthcare careers that do not require a degree I realized that I missed a few, so here are 10 careers only for you✨ These roles typically need a certification, training, or a high school diploma, making them accessible entry points in
Emilyyy

Emilyyy

2401 likes

A Quick Guide for getting Slim Thick 🍑 ⏳🥵💪
Building a "slim thick" body—characterized by a slim waist, a toned upper body, and a well-defined booty—requires a strategic approach that blends exercise, nutrition, and lifestyle adjustments. Here's my quick step-by-step guide to help you achieve your goals, backed by research an
Chalie_Baker

Chalie_Baker

2804 likes

Free Anatomy & Physiology PowerPoints!!
Are you currently struggling in anatomy?? I have the respiratory labeling powerpoint that helps you practice and memorize all the parts /terms for A&P 1 & 2!! :) #anatomyandphysiology #anatomyandphysiologyhelp #anatomystudy #lemon8partner #nursingstudenttips
Na

Na

810 likes

How I turn my Powerpoints into Quizlets
This feature helps me a lot. You might have to tweak it and add some depending on how you study. Keep in mind, this is an AI product so it is not perfect but it works. It turns into flashcards, quizzes, outlines and essay questions. I believe that you can make 2 sets of Magic Notes with regular Qui
barbie

barbie

174 likes

Try the 100 points game!!!
If you and your friends are bored this summer try it!!!
KL8866

KL8866

137 likes

HOW I TURN MY POWERPOINTS INTO QUIZLETS
Quizlet is my holy grail! It’s literally getting me all the way through nursing school and I love it! I create a Quizlet for EVERYTHING. #quizlet #nursingstudent #nursingschool #college #collegelife #Lemon8
Dajee Haskins

Dajee Haskins

44 likes

👩🏽‍⚕️📚10 Points to Help you Ace Pathophysiology📚👩🏽‍⚕️
Stressed about patho? You’re not alone! But don’t panic—these are 10 things that helped me ace pathophysiology, break it down, study smarter, and actually understand the material. 1️⃣ Start with a Concept Map (next slide) 🗺️ • Break down diseases into manageable sections: manifestations (sympt
🤍alisha🤍

🤍alisha🤍

154 likes

How to have straight A’s without a straight A life
I definitely found out exactly how my brain works this semester 😝 - Do you find yourself struggling to get the grades you know you are capable of achieving? That was me all throughout highschool, I often went through phases of doing really well nd then falling off and having to do catch up unti
ahw04

ahw04

738 likes

How to Blend Into Elite Circles (Without Faking It
⚜️Observe First Elite rooms are quiet, strategic, and measured. Watch before you speak. ⚜️Speak With Intention Short sentences, clear points, and no oversharing. Precision reads as power. Do not be loud or abrasive. ⚜️Don’t Name Drop — Skill Drop Mention what you do, not who you know. Com
Becoming High Class

Becoming High Class

20 likes

TEAS YOU NEED FOR A BETTER LIFE!
If you're anything like me, tea isn't just a drink—it's a lifestyle. Here are my must-have teas to boost your life: + Spiced Blackberry Focus Tea by Yogi: For alertness and concentration. This tea helps me stay focused and get stuff done without distractions. Whether I'm writing,
Lushie Club 💖

Lushie Club 💖

11.1K likes

secret tapping points
Discover the secret EFT tapping points on your fingers that you can use anytime, anywhere for discreet stress relief. Perfect for those moments when you need to calm your nerves in public, during meetings, or on the go. Learn how to tap without anyone noticing! #EFTTapping #EmotionalFreedom
Jstewartcoaching

Jstewartcoaching

3 likes

Let’s play a round of HARASS YOUR BFFFFFFFF !!!!!👨‍❤️‍👨
@Michelle thank you for the concept idea. Her post was way more realistic and useful tbh plus she’s gorgeous so like. Go look at that HEY GUYS QUICK MESSAGE- this post is not a rule book from god. It was just for fun. But also these are absolutely my preferences for *dating* people to an exte
Breanna wieneke

Breanna wieneke

1358 likes

The Body Keeps The Score Key Points
1. The Impact of Trauma on the Brain and Body: Dr. van der Kolk explains how traumatic experiences can fundamentally alter brain function, affecting areas responsible for stress regulation, emotional control, and memory. Trauma can leave lasting imprints on both the mind and body, manifesting in p
Brendan

Brendan

30 likes

Bible Study points of the week
This is only a little bit of what I studied this week but there are some good nuggets here✨ MATTHEW: Chapters 10-14 LUKE: Chapter 7 PSLAMS: Chapter 119 Let me know what you learn 🫶 #studying the bible #bibleready #jesusisgood #giveittogod
MK

MK

17 likes

Become Elegant ✨Save this!!
30 ways to dress and cultivate a more elegant, feminine presence, including how to use your feminine allures and communicate with grace: Dressing Elegantly and Femininely 1. Choose Classic Styles: Opt for timeless pieces like tailored blouses, pencil skirts, and elegant dresses. 2. Opt for Sof
Purple Flower

Purple Flower

237 likes

Too Tired to Sleep? Reset with Finger Points
#NapRelief #ShixuanPointsHelp #QuickSleepAid #AcupuncturistAdvice #FingertipAcupressure
ChrisWeiTCMExpert

ChrisWeiTCMExpert

0 likes

These Exam Day Mistakes Could Cost You Points🚨
Exams can be stressful, and sometimes, it’s not about what you know—it’s about how you take the test. I’ve learned the hard way that small mistakes can cost you big on exam day. Looking back, these are the three most common pitfalls I wish I had avoided sooner: ⏳ Mismanaging Time – One of my big
river

river

26 likes

Doll Eye Cluster Lashes for Round Eyes😍
"Why choose a doll eye lash map?" 🚨 -For round eyes lash extensions may sometimes have a "droopy" effect, and a doll eye follows the exact layout of the natural lashes to preserve the high and low points of the a round eye shape🤍 1. Choose the longest length at the end, and ver
Kianna Morae🇯🇲

Kianna Morae🇯🇲

27 likes

How Many Aura Points Did I Lose?
Can i be vulnerable for a min? Imagine your crush sending this to you, this was the first a man had said anything like that to me. It’s very slim pickings out here especially for a dark skinned plus size girl. #vulnerablediaries #newtolemon8 #plussizeoutfitideas #darkskinmakeup
Ajah🍀

Ajah🍀

921 likes

there’s pain points even in great relationships
a relationship is the joining of multiple people’s realities. we all have our own beliefs, trauma, preferences, tendencies, strengths, weaknesses and so on. even a very compatible partner will occasionally do things that push your buttons, cross your boundaries, make you feel sad, do things tha
allison wetig

allison wetig

106 likes

Weight Watchers 7 points-KFC BOWL
🛒Sam’s Club pre-portioned Chx breast pieces 0 pts 🛒Corn 0 pts 🛒McCormick Chicken Gravy (1/4 c) 1 pt 🛒Good & Gather reduced fat pre-sliced cheddar 2 pts 🛒Members Mark Yukon pre-made mashed (1/2 c) 4 pts 👍Pros :5 min prep ➡️Prep in containers ➡️Heat in microwave for 2 min when rest to
Tia Hawkins-Tea Talks with Tia

Tia Hawkins-Tea Talks with Tia

134 likes

Tap 3 points before bed to sleep through the night
#acupoint #acupressure #healthtips #wellness #dailywellness
Caseyhealthtips

Caseyhealthtips

36 likes

double points if the "random dude" is your crush
#iamjordi
BbyPatatoGrayce

BbyPatatoGrayce

16 likes

✨📑 Résumé Editing TIPS That Got Me HIRED ASAP ✍🏾✨
✨ I’ve seen SO many strong candidates get overlooked, not because they weren’t qualified, but because their résumé didn’t present them in the best light. Your résumé is often your first impression, and in a competitive job market, it has to shine before you even walk into the room. 📝 Here are my
Margarita

Margarita

28 likes

I Made My Own Digital Magazine Using Canva?! 🤯
I had way more fun making this magazine than I expected. There’s something wildly satisfying about taking a bunch of loose ideas in your head and slowly watching them turn into real pages. Picking the vibe, playing with fonts, rearranging layouts, and seeing it all come together felt like creative
a neurospicy girl + her ipad🎀

a neurospicy girl + her ipad🎀

6 likes

🌿 Beginner’s Guide to EFT Tapping Points
Curious about EFT tapping? ✨ This simple map shows the main points to tap for stress relief, emotional release, and grounding. Save this for daily practice and feel calmer in just minutes. #efttapping #thecalmminute #emotionalhealing #WeeklyChallenge #ThingsToDo
The Calm Minute

The Calm Minute

15 likes

Single 30 points. Full diamond ring arrangement.
✨**Lab-Grown Elegance**✨ Experience the brilliance of sustainability with our custom-designed diamond ring. Featuring a stunning 0.30ct lab-grown diamond as the centerpiece, surrounded by an elegant halo of sparkling diamonds, this masterpiece is set in luxurious PT950 platinum. 💎 **Key Feat
张昌国

张昌国

1 like

Put a finger down
Helaman 13 roasted me ngl #lds #christiangirl #scriptureoftheday #scripturestudy #utah
Isi

Isi

13 likes

Hot Girls Save Money and Live Better 😍
Hey loves! These are my daily makeup products 💋 I buy these from Ulta Beauty for reward points, but I’ve listed more affordable prices from Walmart! #beautytips 💋always start with a clean and moisturized face 💋minimize blemishes with concealer before applying foundation 💋blend concealer
Yanna

Yanna

123 likes

How To Cheat Your Time 2x More Efficient With AI👩🏻‍💻⏱️
No matter how much we want to deny it, we are now officially living in a time with AI💡Instead of rejecting its existence, we should turn it into our best friend and navigate it to go through our busiest days💻 I’m currently a Senior in college WITH a Part-time job which I need to go 20hrs/week🥲I de
Ruoqiqi

Ruoqiqi

69 likes

How I Ace College as a Business Student! 📚
Hey everyone! 😊 As a Business Administration major at Villa Maria College, I'm proud to be on the Dean’s List and recently got nominated to join the National Society of Leadership and Success (NSLS). 🎉 I’m sharing some study strategies that help me stay on top of my game and maintain A’s and B’
Nejha❤️

Nejha❤️

275 likes

Study Essentials I Can’t Live Without 📚✨
When they say PA/Nursing/Med school is like drinking water out of a fire hose 💦🔥 - they weren't lying! It took me until the end of our 2nd didactic semester to really figure out a study plan that worked for me, and even then, it changes depending on what the exam is. These are my go to resource
Sabrina

Sabrina

66 likes

Savor Slow Moments
My life is stressful as most people are these days. Up at the asscrack of dawn rushing to work to sit at a desk job - overworked; underpaid for an employer who doesn't give a shit about his employees. It's emotional and mentally draining. I get to points now where I come over and crash in
Megan

Megan

10 likes

Spray points for the girlies 🫶🌸
I hit almost all these points and then I definitely spray on my clothes for even longer lasting results Photo form: Fragrance X
Tyra Edmonson

Tyra Edmonson

529 likes

Unlock the power of perfect notes 🔓
Not all notes are created equal! Find the note-taking method that works best for you and improve your study sessions. Here are the top methods to help you remember more and study smarter. #NoteTaking #StudyTips #Productivity #StudyHacks " Note-Taking Methods to Display on Screen:
Grayson_Rosa

Grayson_Rosa

8 likes

Obx Character’s aura points
Obx character’s decreasing aura points (may or may not have chose not very flattering pictures of some kooks on purpose 😅) #obx #outerbanks #sarahcamron #summeraesthetic #johnb #fyp #aurapoints #jjmaybank #P4L #bigjohn
JustJulie33

JustJulie33

201 likes

Auditing check points
Small bits and pieces of life I’ve noticed.
The Three 👙

The Three 👙

1 like

The Moon’s Teaching
The Nile Delta- Three Days After First Blood The spiral path had been easy. Too easy, perhaps. Nin-Bar had expected challenge, difficulty, some test that would push her abilities to their limit. Instead, she’d walked the blindfolded path with the same calm precision she brought to everything—
Myria

Myria

2 likes

How I Spend Steam Points 💙
When I randomly remember my Steam Points, I love searching through the Steam Points Shop to find ways to spend the virtual reward money. Customization in any form is so fun to me and I love using them to aesthetically enhance my online gaming profile. Steam Points are digital coins that are give
Kelsey

Kelsey

151 likes

all the views without the hike in the grand tetons
Even if you're not an avid hiker, you can still enjoy stunning views from high in the tetons with the Jackson Hole Resort Gondola. The $50 ticket includes access to three gondolas that land you at various points throughout the mountains. From the highest and most popular, you can see 360 de
Marisa • Travel

Marisa • Travel

10 likes

avp scar finger and my predator collection
#predator #avp #alienvspredator #scarpredator #predatorcollection
scorpion199337

scorpion199337

1 like

✨Pediatric Test Respiratory Disorders: Key Points🫁
Pediatric respiratory conditions can escalate FAST, so early recognition and intervention are critical! Here’s a breakdown of the most common respiratory disorders in children and how to manage them! 🏥💨 ⸻ 🦠 1. Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) – “Winter Baby Virus” ✅ Cause: Viral infection
Nurse Radiance

Nurse Radiance

91 likes

How to elevate your life into high society
Elevating your life into high society isn’t about chasing luxury, status, or pretending to be someone you’re not. It’s about refinement from the inside out. True elevation begins with self-discipline, emotional intelligence, and quiet confidence—the kind that doesn’t need validation. It’s learn
Becoming High Class

Becoming High Class

5 likes

STOP writing your resume bullet points like this ❌
Your resume is precious real estate for you to utilize to show your accomplishments, not list out your job responsibilities! In order to make the most of this space, restructure your bullet points to ensure you include quantifiable results / success metrics wherever possible. Even if that mea
hannah | career success 🎯

hannah | career success 🎯

11 likes

🥜 🧈 💣 2 weight watcher points
✨Overall rating: 🔟/10 #cravings 🥹😩 #weightlossandfatloss #weightwatchers #lowcaloriemeals #lowcaloriesnack
Tia Hawkins-Tea Talks with Tia

Tia Hawkins-Tea Talks with Tia

228 likes

Good vs Bad resume points: Tips!
Hello everyone! I wanted to share some insights on crafting effective resume points. Instead of vague descriptions, focus on quantifiable achievements and specific outcomes. Highlighting concrete results, like increased sales or improved customer satisfaction, showcases your impact and effectivenes
Yun Jung

Yun Jung

18 likes

Bible study - Matthew 5 and 6
Jesus begins with the Beatitudes, which highlight the blessings found in traits such as meekness, mercy, and purity of heart. He affirms the importance of being "the salt of the earth" and "the light of the world," urging followers to influence society through their actions and righ
Lola, 🌸

Lola, 🌸

9 likes

See more