If you’re planning a summer trip to Montauk, trying the local lobster roll is an absolute must. From my experience, there’s a unique charm in visiting a seafood spot run by locals where freshness is guaranteed by 17 generations of fishermen heritage. The $20 lobster roll is not only affordable but also packed with fresh lobster meat that melts in your mouth. One important tip: this place is cash only, so be sure to carry enough to avoid any inconvenience. Besides the lobster rolls, you can also enjoy oysters and sashimi, making it an excellent choice for seafood lovers looking for variety and quality. What sets this spot apart is the combination of fresh, sustainable seafood with a laid-back atmosphere. Pair your food with a drink from Montauk Brewery to complete the authentic local experience. Don't forget to try the kettle-cooked potato chips, which complement the lobster roll perfectly. Overall, this hidden gem is a fantastic way to savor the best of The Hamptons’ seafood without the usual high prices. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or enjoying a casual meal by the beach, this spot delivers unbeatable taste and value.