One Dark Window Review

⭐️Overall rating: 5/5

Synopsis:

Elspeth contracted a magical sickness and now she has another entity giving her feedback and occasionally strength when she asks for it. However, not everybody is as lucky as she is, despite the nightmare she now carries. Everything that has to do with magic comes with a price, some heavier and faster acting than others.

When Elspeth has a run in with a highwayman, her life changes trajectory. Joining on the dangerous quest to set the magic right and committing treason, can she help with retrieving the cure?

Thoughts:

I really liked the character growth, subplot romance, and the magic system. How the magic was described and the politics around magic felt really unique and I was intrigued by how viewpoints around this may change as the story progresses. Overall, I was invested in the mystery, the challenges, and the interpersonal relationships. The ending left me needing the second book, I’m just waiting for it at this point.

#onedarkwindow #duologyrecs #BookReviews #lemon8bookworm #autumnvibes🍁

2024/10/25 Edited to

... Read moreBeyond the compelling plot, what truly sets 'One Dark Window' apart is its undeniable aesthetic appeal, deeply rooted in its gothic fantasy elements. From the moment you see the book cover, with its haunting gothic castle and a mysterious figure often depicted in red, you know you're in for a treat. This visual perfectly encapsulates the mood of the story: dark, enchanting, and full of secrets. The entire world-building has this wonderfully atmospheric 'one dark window aesthetic' that just pulls you in, making it a standout in the fantasy genre. It's not just the cover; the descriptions within paint vivid pictures of ancient, shadowed landscapes, foreboding magical practices, and a kingdom steeped in lore and danger. Even the 'back cover' synopsis hints at the deep, intricate world you're about to enter, promising curses, royal families, and dangerous magic – and it absolutely delivers. The 'gothic magic system' is another aspect that utterly fascinated me. It’s not your typical flashy magic; instead, it's intrinsically linked to curses and consequences, where every use demands a heavy toll. Elspeth's unique connection to her own magical illness and the entity within her creates a deeply personal and often terrifying exploration of power. This nuanced approach makes the magic feel real, dangerous, and incredibly unique, diverging from many standard fantasy tropes. If you're searching for a magic system that’s both intricate and impactful, this book truly delivers. The way magic is intertwined with the politics and history of the realm adds so many layers, making every magical encounter feel significant. Many readers, including myself, have given 'One Dark Window' glowing reviews, and its strong presence on 'Goodreads' with an impressive average of 4.29 stars is well-deserved. My own 5-star rating comes from the seamless blend of a thrilling narrative, well-developed characters, and that captivating 'gothic' atmosphere. It’s the kind of book where you constantly wonder about the next twist and turn, especially with its exciting subplot romance and political intrigue. I was completely invested in Elspeth's quest and the challenges she faced, making it an utterly binge-worthy read. The thematic elements of fate, curses, and the struggle against an oppressive magical system also strongly evoke imagery often found in 'nightmare card' or even 'tarot card' readings. The idea of drawing a 'nightmare card' perfectly aligns with the dangers and moral dilemmas Elspeth faces, where every choice has profound, often dark, repercussions. This isn't just a story; it's an immersive experience that delves into the shadows, making you ponder the true cost of power and survival. Whether you pick up the 'one dark window paperback' or e-book, prepare to be completely immersed in a world where magic is both a gift and a terrifying burden. It truly is a duology that deserves all the hype!

Related posts

Books With Dark Gothic Atmospheres
#bookrecommendations #booksoflemon8 #spooky #gothic #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #bookwormsoflemon8
Keeks 📖🏹

Keeks 📖🏹

8596 likes

Book review: One Dark Window
"First book in February ☑️ and it's a WINNER! 🏆 Started the month with this gothic gem featuring tarot magic (where each card comes with a blessing AND a curse 🎴✨), mysterious voices, and a heroine with secrets to spare. The best part? It's a completed duology - no more waiting ga
StitchStorySip

StitchStorySip

16 likes

Books Like One Dark Window ✨
Here are my top 3 book recs for you if you’ve recently finished One Dark Window and are looking for something that will fill the void in your heart now 💖 #fantasyromancebooks #romantasy #onedarkwindow #bookrecommendations #bookrecommendation #bookrecs #readersoflemon8
Loren📚

Loren📚

126 likes

One dark window🖤
#mydarkdesire was such an amazing book now to get into something darker. I’ve heard such amazing thing about this duet that I even bought the special edition hardcover copies from #barnesandnoble as book trophy’s 🤭 #onedarkwindow #twotwistedcrowns
Sincere🥰👑

Sincere🥰👑

21 likes

One Dark Window Book Review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I absolutely loved this book! The romantic interest, the unique magic system, the dark setting… Have you read One Dark Window?? Tell me your thoughts below! #fantasybooks #lemon8bookclub #audiobooks #onedarkwindow #fantasyreader
Kayteigh🌹🖤

Kayteigh🌹🖤

6 likes

Book Review🥀🖤
One Dark Window Review: Overall rating: 5/5⭐️ Quick summary: One Dark Window is a dark gothic fantasy that centers on Elspeth Spindle who carries a rather “Nightmare-ish” secret. She lives in a world where an infection can lead not only to magic, but death if one is found infected. One day as
Alex🍒

Alex🍒

13 likes

One Dark Window 🖤🐺🐦‍⬛✨
📖 BOOK REVIEW 📖 ODW Rating: 5 / 5 ⭐️ Spice Level: .5 🌶️ (closed door) Just finished One Dark Window by @rmgillig and ahhhhh, I LOVED it! This was such a refreshing and gripping fantasy read with a unique magic system that completely drew me in. The story follows Elspeth Spindle, the elde
thecampbellbookshelf

thecampbellbookshelf

31 likes

One Dark Window Book Review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Oh my gosh I could not put this book down! It was so different, but in a good way! I typically read the same kinds of fantasy type books so sometimes they can blur a bit together and feel same old same old. This book had such a refreshingly new magic system that made the book irresistib
トカゲ🌸📖

トカゲ🌸📖

1 like

Halloween Dark Romance review🧡
Book name: Pounded in the Patch🎃🖤 Author: Dana Leeann Genre: Dark Romance Dedication: For those who want their pumpkin spice with a side of being absolutely ruined by a masked man My rating: 5/5 My review: a great read to start off the spooky season🎃 it’s fairly short so it was a quick read, t
Kayla 🖤📚

Kayla 🖤📚

542 likes

One Dark Window
A maiden harboring a dark spirit must embark on a perilous quest to save her kingdom from a sinister magic, while battling her own inner demons. Currently 47% off on Amazon! $9.98 https://amzn.to/4kTb9Rm #romantasy #romance #fantasyromance #bookrecommendations This is the book
Brianna Martin

Brianna Martin

5 likes

Just Finished One Dark Window 📖
When you’re stuck at work and can’t start the sequel but the first book ends on a cliffhanger 😭😂 have you read One Dark Window yet? I totally recommend it! #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #currentlyreading #bookreview #onedarkwindow
bri ⸆⸉

bri ⸆⸉

9 likes

One Dark Window
This book got me out of a reading slump!!! I was unsure at first about the magic system, I was a little confused but after the first 50 pages I was locked in. Some points were almost thrilling to read. Definitely recommend for a fall/spooky read! I am excited to start the second. Let me know your t
Kiana Cirillo

Kiana Cirillo

12 likes

📚 One Dark Window-Blew Me Away 📚
Just finished One Dark Window and wow, it was absolutely amazing! If you love dark fantasy, thrilling plots, and unforgettable characters, you NEED to read this. Highly recommend!! #OneDarkWindow #BookTok #BookRecommendation #DarkFantasy #FantasyBooks #BookLover #MustRead #Thrill
Karma Lies Designs

Karma Lies Designs

9 likes

One Dark Window Special Edition
Waited forever for these! #onedarkwindow #twotwistedcrowns @rmgillig they are beautiful!!
Mystical Crow

Mystical Crow

16 likes

One Dark Window
Can’t wait to start Two Twisted Crowns #lemon8bookclub #rachelgillig #bookrecommendations #books #BookReview
Books.just.wanna.have.fun

Books.just.wanna.have.fun

7 likes

One Dark Window 🌙👑🌫️
Just started reading One Dark Window after finishing Middle of the Night and I’m enjoying it so far! It feels so lyrical at some points it’s very intriguing. Although it is moving quite slow so far i’m interested to see where this goes. Will update later! Have you read this book? #lemon8bookclu
bri ⸆⸉

bri ⸆⸉

15 likes

One Dark Window
One Dark Window special edition set
Yayazbooks

Yayazbooks

21 likes

One Dark Window 🖤
#specialeditionbooks #books #onedarkwindow #bookish #sprayededges
Romary

Romary

8 likes

Starting One Dark Window!
What is y’all’s current read? #books #newuser #booktok #rachelgillig #currentread #booklover Random Thoughts 💭What's on my mind: Just finished “Funny Story” by Emily Henry Current Mood: Excited for new read ⭐Rate: TBR
Madison

Madison

13 likes

One Dark Window - Rachel Gillig
I need to stop procrastinating reading the books I know I’m absolutely going to love. This was so good. I loved the Nightmare. The romance was the perfect amount of slow burn. And who can pass up treason against a tyrant king? I’m excited for book two! 5/5⭐️ #onedarkwindow #theshepherdkingd
Liss.readsbooks📚🐉

Liss.readsbooks📚🐉

7 likes

One Dark Window - Book Review📚💕
✨ One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig is a romantasy you won’t be able to put down! 😱🌙 Dark magic, unexpected twists, and a romance that’ll have you dying for more. Who’s ready to fall into a world full of secrets and riddles? 🖤🔮 Trust me, this one will leave you questioning everything long after t
Mariahkathleen_reads

Mariahkathleen_reads

0 likes

One dark Window 🖤
Finally starting this duology! Have you guys read it? What are your thoughts?! #theshepherdking #duology #bookish #booktok #readreadread
𝚊𝚗𝚗𝚊 𐙚

𝚊𝚗𝚗𝚊 𐙚

12 likes

One Dark Window
“One Dark Window" by Rachel Gillig is a dark and atmospheric fantasy novel set in a world shrouded by mist and ruled by ancient magic. The story follows Elspeth Spindle, a young woman who harbors a dangerous spirit within her, granting her mysterious powers. As she navigates a treacherous w
Adrienne Marie

Adrienne Marie

2 likes

One dark window/Two twisted crowns
Haven’t read this duo but the covers were beautiful. Update- these are my new favorite reads ❤️
Mimz

Mimz

93 likes

📖 One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig
✨ Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5/5 🗂 Genre: Fantasy 📚 Vibe: gothic, little spooky, mysterious What it’s about: In a kingdom where magic is forbidden, Elspeth hides a dark secret—a monstrous voice in her head. As she’s drawn into a rebellion, she must navigate deadly magic, eerie forests, and the truth abou
savmarietravel

savmarietravel

6 likes

Steamy Dark Fantasy: Read in Kindle Unlimited
📖EVERY THREAD OF LIGHT by Sarah Zimm — a dark fantasy romance sequel about a realm divided by wár and a fugìtive who faces an alliance with an enemŷ to free her kingdom. For fans of Rebecca Yarros and Christopher Paolini, and readers who love the prose and mood of One Dark Window and the dragon
Sarah Zimm Fantasy

Sarah Zimm Fantasy

16 likes

One dark window duology🐦‍⬛
One dark window-⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Gothic fantasy Curses Romantic subplot Secrets Two twisted crowns-⭐️⭐️✨ Triple pov Mysterious gothic Romance Went back and forth with starting this duology. It sounded interesting but not enough to start yet one day I just needed something to read and was
Nic

Nic

2 likes

✨Immortal Dark Book Review✨
✨✨✨✨Book Review✨✨✨✨ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️ 📖Immortal Dark by Tigest Girma ♦️Fantasy Romance ♦️Check TWs ♦️Vampires ♦️Magic System ♦️Enemies to Lovers ♦️Slow Burn ♦️Bully Romance Vibes ♦️Academia ♦️Suspenseful/Mystery ♦️Forced Proximity 💭I want to know why we aren’t hearing more about this on
EscapeThroughABook

EscapeThroughABook

27 likes

One Dark Window 🖤
#books #booktok #reader #reading #summer
Jayden Alvarado

Jayden Alvarado

13 likes

One dark window
A maiden harboring a dark spirit must embark on a perilous quest to save her kingdom from a sinister magic, while battling her own inner demons. Paperback currently $9.98 on Amazon! https://amzn.to/4aVQRTZ #dark #romantasy #bookrecommendations #amazon #fantasybooks
Brianna Martin

Brianna Martin

5 likes

One Dark Window 🃏
I just finished reading One Dark Window and Two Twisted Crowns by Rachel Gillig & they were SO GOOD!!! 🤩 Have you heard of this series? Have you read this series?? If you love romantasy, enemies-to-lovers, and societal hierarchies then you will LOVE this duology!!! 🤭💔🪄🃏 #onedarkwindow
merryn

merryn

2 likes

One Dark Window
5🌟 Oh my gosh. Rachel Gillig gave me everything I never knew I needed in a fantasy book. I ate this up. Absolute favorite book. I didn't think I was going to like it at first, but it pulled me in. I can't wait to start book 2
bookgirly🫶

bookgirly🫶

1 like

Booktok Review: One Drake Window
I picked up this book after my husband recommended it and because it was everywhere on my feed as a must-read. Here’s my honest take: The story started off slow, with the pace only picking up toward the end of the first book. The second book followed the same pattern. It’s more of a mystery an
Mimi’s Posts

Mimi’s Posts

12 likes

One Dark Window
Has anyone read this?? #onedarkwindow #lemon8bookclub #books #bookclub #Lemon8Diary
sl.book.ut

sl.book.ut

6 likes

Anime: One Piece ☠️ Book: One Dark Window 📖
When I'm trying to read and watch One Piece at the same time doesn't work but I can't stop watching or reading 🙃 #Anime #onepieceanime #book #onedarkwindow
Alba 🎃

Alba 🎃

14 likes

🌟Book Review🌟
💜Hello Bestie! I hope you are having a wonderful Sunday morning! It’s spring break for our household so lots of spring chores lie ahead! We are planting our first ever veggie garden this year 😬 so we are doing a lot of prep to get it ready for planting! I’ve never had a garden before so hopefully I
bestiejais_reads

bestiejais_reads

0 likes

One Dark Window book review
Finished up these two books and wanted to share my review. 👍Pros:First I hadn’t seen much about this series but was drawn to it. I loved the story and the world building. The characters are like able and the story is fast paced. It kind of has a Bridgerton vibe to it with the clothing descripti
Bookgirlie

Bookgirlie

4 likes

One dark window
“Nothing is free nothing is safe. Magic is love, but it’s also hate. It comes at a cost. You’re found and you’re lost. Magic is love, but it’s also hate.” overall rating:3/5 #onedarkwindow #cards #booktok
Abby Katz

Abby Katz

0 likes

One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig
I’m so happy I gave this book another chance. Tbh I was not really focusing any energy on it due reading two other books at the same time. I fell in love with Elspeth, the Nightmare, and their symbiotic relationship. I can’t wait to read the second book! #lemon8dairychallenge #lemon8boo
kay_trixie

kay_trixie

3 likes

One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig 🃏✨🐦‍⬛
One Dark Window follows Elspeth Spindle, cursed with a 500-year-old monster trapped inside her, instead of the magical powers others in her kingdom have—many of whom are also infected. The kingdom of Blunder is shrouded in a mist that can only be lifted by uniting the 12 Providence cards. Those inf
Ninoska

Ninoska

5 likes

One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig
Maybe a hot take but it did take me quite a while to get into this. I was actually really worried this was going to be a “peer pressure made me read and it sucks” kinda situation BUT there was a turn and then I was hooked! Loved the little quips. The relationship that develops is just swoon worthy.
Miranda Baker

Miranda Baker

3 likes

One Dark Window 📚
One Dark Window — Rachel Gillig 5/5 stars ★★★★★ I’m on a roll with the fall-theme books, this one was an easy 5 stars. Moody, dark (but not evil) and captivating!! I read it in one day even though it’s not a one-day-read book 🙃 The storyline is just so good and different, I wasn’t the least bit
shara ♡

shara ♡

6 likes

One Dark Window is EVERYTHING
I’m so obsessed honestly. I don’t remember having this feeling for a book since ACOTAR 👀 #onedarkwindow #reading #booktok
Elaina 📚🍁☕️

Elaina 📚🍁☕️

6 likes

Book review
Book
Lazylu

Lazylu

1 like

Book Review 📚🖤
I adored this book! I loved One Dark Window and Two Twisted Crowns, so I knew I had to read this one. Rachel delievered another unique magic system, and her writing style is one of my favorites! And who knew a Gargoyle could be my favorite character 🥹🖤 Overall rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Spice: 🌶 • Gothi
Kendra Haring

Kendra Haring

6 likes

Let me in your Window!!
Let me in your window by Adam Ellis 3.5⭐️ Artwork gruesome but very good. Favorite story Don’t Look, the one with the creepy af clown. #graphicnovel #BookReview #horrorbook
singe97

singe97

26 likes

one dark window 🩶
this books gave all the right vibes #booktok #fyp #onedarkwindow
Kenz ❤️‍🔥⚔️📖

Kenz ❤️‍🔥⚔️📖

1 like

One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig
Intrigued to see where this fantasy book will go. #lemon8bookclub #bookclub #readingchallenge #fantasybooks #onedarkwindow
Hearing Heaven

Hearing Heaven

3 likes

Exclusive One Dark Window and Two Twisted Crowns🖤
Treated myself to the Barnes and Nobles Exclusive One Dark Window and Two Twisted Crowns set! I am OBSESSED! 😍 🖤 #onedarkwindow #twotwistedcrowns #books #booksoflemon8 #bookaesthetic
paigeishere17📚💕

paigeishere17📚💕

4 likes

Orebella Perfume Review ✨
For a long while, I’ve been on the hunt for a new fragrance. I’m not a big fragrance girl, however, I have been trying to support brands that align with values that are important to me. So when I heard that Bella Hadid came out with her own fragrance brand, I was intrigued. Although I’ve never
mahi

mahi

522 likes

See more