One Dark Window Book Review

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Oh my gosh I could not put this book down! It was so different, but in a good way! I typically read the same kinds of fantasy type books so sometimes they can blur a bit together and feel same old same old. This book had such a refreshingly new magic system that made the book irresistible and hard to put down and the characters felt like they had so much development and were so easy to love!! 10/10, would read again!!

2024/12/24 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so you've heard my initial excitement about Rachel Gillig's 'One Dark Window,' but let's dive a little deeper into why this gothic fantasy gem completely captivated me. As someone who reads a lot of fantasy, it's rare to find a magic system that feels truly fresh and inventive, but this book really delivered. Instead of the usual elemental powers or intricate spell-casting, the magic here is tied to an ancient, eerie deck of cards and a terrifying shadow sickness. It's dark, gritty, and the consequences of using magic are genuinely chilling, which just added so much depth and tension to every single page. Beyond the magic, the world-building itself is exactly what I crave in a gothic fantasy. Think atmospheric, mist-shrouded landscapes, ancient superstitions, and a constant undercurrent of dread. The book cover, with its dark, gothic castle, perfectly captures this vibe. When I saw it on my e-reader, I knew I was in for something special – that mysterious, blurred gothic building in the background just hints at the secrets held within. It’s not just a pretty cover; it’s a promise of the dark, enchanting journey inside. And the characters! Oh my goodness, the characters. They felt incredibly real and complex. The protagonist, Elara, is such a compelling figure, burdened by a secret that makes her both vulnerable and incredibly strong. Without giving too much away, the relationships in this book are incredibly layered. If you’re a fan of the 'enemies to lovers' trope, or just enjoy dynamic, morally grey characters navigating a perilous world, you'll find plenty to love here. Their development felt earned and organic, making you root for them even when they're making difficult choices. For anyone wondering what 'One Dark Window' is truly about, it's a story of survival, hidden powers, and challenging a corrupt system, all wrapped in a rich, dark fairy-tale aesthetic. It kicks off a duology, so if you, like me, get completely hooked, there’s another book to look forward to! Whether you pick up the paperback or a deluxe edition, this is a series that deserves a spot on your shelf if you're into unique magic, dark romance, and a truly immersive gothic fantasy experience. It’s certainly not a run-of-the-mill fantasy; it's a standout that will linger with you long after you've turned the final page.

Related posts

A book review graphic for "One Dark Window" by Rachel Gillig, featuring the book cover surrounded by arrows pointing to keywords like "Tarot cards magic system," "Gothic fantasy romance," "Completed duology," and a five-star rating, all set against open book pages.
Book review: One Dark Window
"First book in February ☑️ and it's a WINNER! 🏆 Started the month with this gothic gem featuring tarot magic (where each card comes with a blessing AND a curse 🎴✨), mysterious voices, and a heroine with secrets to spare. The best part? It's a completed duology - no more waiting ga
StitchStorySip

StitchStorySip

16 likes

A stack of books on a white bedspread, with the text "TOUCH HER & YOU DIE" and "BOOK RECS" overlaid, introducing a list of book recommendations.
The book cover for "Powerless" by Lauren Roberts, featuring a skeletal figure and vines. Overlaid text praises its fantasy genre and banter, with a knife emoji and four and a half stars.
The book cover for "One Dark Window" by Rachel Gillig, depicting a gothic castle. Overlaid text describes it as amazing with a monster in her head, accompanied by a joker card emoji and three and a half stars.
“Touch her & you die” book recs
One of my favorite tropes is enemies to lovers and not only that, it is top tier when it has a “touch her & you die” microtrope in there. Here are just some of the books that I love that has this trope. POWERLESS: less of an enemies to lovers and more of unlikely pairing to high tension. It
Hannah Pilgrim

Hannah Pilgrim

13.4K likes

An audiobook interface for 'One Dark Window' by Rachel Gillig, featuring the book cover with a dark castle, a bridge, and a figure in red with smoke. The image is overlaid with the text 'Audio Book Review' and displays details like 'Included in Premium' and a star rating.
One Dark Window Book Review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I absolutely loved this book! The romantic interest, the unique magic system, the dark setting… Have you read One Dark Window?? Tell me your thoughts below! #fantasybooks #lemon8bookclub #audiobooks #onedarkwindow #fantasyreader
Kayteigh🌹🖤

Kayteigh🌹🖤

6 likes

Books Like One Dark Window ✨
Here are my top 3 book recs for you if you’ve recently finished One Dark Window and are looking for something that will fill the void in your heart now 💖 #fantasyromancebooks #romantasy #onedarkwindow #bookrecommendations #bookrecommendation #bookrecs #readersoflemon8
Loren📚

Loren📚

125 likes

Spilling Book Tea 🫖 - Underrated Edition
📚Calling all my dark academia lovers!!! If you want a gloomy, misty, tale that give you the best fall vibes... "One Dark Window" by Rachel Gillig is for you!  📚If you enjoy a good enemies to lovers trope... this is for you! 📚If you wish to be immersed into a mystical land with the fai
Dani

Dani

106 likes

One Dark Window - Book Review📚💕
✨ One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig is a romantasy you won’t be able to put down! 😱🌙 Dark magic, unexpected twists, and a romance that’ll have you dying for more. Who’s ready to fall into a world full of secrets and riddles? 🖤🔮 Trust me, this one will leave you questioning everything long after t
Mariahkathleen_reads

Mariahkathleen_reads

1 like

📚 One Dark Window-Blew Me Away 📚
Just finished One Dark Window and wow, it was absolutely amazing! If you love dark fantasy, thrilling plots, and unforgettable characters, you NEED to read this. Highly recommend!! #OneDarkWindow #BookTok #BookRecommendation #DarkFantasy #FantasyBooks #BookLover #MustRead #Thrill
Karma Lies Designs

Karma Lies Designs

9 likes

A hand holds an e-reader displaying the cover of 'One Dark Window' by Rachel Gillig. Annotations point to themes like 'Magic,' 'Secrets,' 'Gothic,' and 'Fantasy.' A torn paper cutout above reads 'One Dark Window By Rachel Gillig.' A bookshelf is in the background.
Book Review🥀🖤
One Dark Window Review: Overall rating: 5/5⭐️ Quick summary: One Dark Window is a dark gothic fantasy that centers on Elspeth Spindle who carries a rather “Nightmare-ish” secret. She lives in a world where an infection can lead not only to magic, but death if one is found infected. One day as
Alex🍒

Alex🍒

13 likes

An e-reader displays the cover of 'One Dark Window' by Rachel Gillig, featuring a gothic castle and smoky imagery. Overlay text reads 'POV: your book ends on a cliffhanger,' reflecting the article's theme of cliffhangers.
An e-reader shows a screen indicating 'Book complete' and 'The story continues in... Two Twisted Crowns.' It's leaning against a purple 'IGLOO' bag, with exclamation and question mark emojis highlighting the cliffhanger.
A person with light brown hair looks surprised or exasperated, with their hand on their forehead. The background shows a ceiling decorated with international flags. Overlay text says 'HELLO?!?'.
Just Finished One Dark Window 📖
When you’re stuck at work and can’t start the sequel but the first book ends on a cliffhanger 😭😂 have you read One Dark Window yet? I totally recommend it! #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #currentlyreading #bookreview #onedarkwindow
bri ⸆⸉

bri ⸆⸉

9 likes

A book review graphic featuring two book covers side-by-side. The left cover is 'One Dark Window' and the right is 'Two Twisted Crowns,' both by Rachel Gillig. Overlay text reads 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW' and 'Rating: 4/5', with a Lemon8 watermark.
One Dark Window book review
Finished up these two books and wanted to share my review. 👍Pros:First I hadn’t seen much about this series but was drawn to it. I loved the story and the world building. The characters are like able and the story is fast paced. It kind of has a Bridgerton vibe to it with the clothing descripti
Bookgirlie

Bookgirlie

4 likes

A dark fantasy mood board for 'One Dark Window' by Rachel Gillig, featuring the book cover, gothic imagery like castles, crows, hands, and intense eyes, alongside quotes related to the story's themes of monsters, shadows, and cleverness.
A hand holds the physical copy of 'One Dark Window' by Rachel Gillig, with numerous colorful page flags marking various sections. The book is displayed against a blurred background of bookshelves filled with other books.
A white page with black text titled 'BOOK DESCRIPTION' provides a summary of 'One Dark Window'. It introduces Elspeth Spindle, her monster the Nightmare, a mysterious highwayman, and their quest to cure the kingdom of Blunder.
One Dark Window 🖤🐺🐦‍⬛✨
📖 BOOK REVIEW 📖 ODW Rating: 5 / 5 ⭐️ Spice Level: .5 🌶️ (closed door) Just finished One Dark Window by @rmgillig and ahhhhh, I LOVED it! This was such a refreshing and gripping fantasy read with a unique magic system that completely drew me in. The story follows Elspeth Spindle, the elde
thecampbellbookshelf

thecampbellbookshelf

33 likes

One Dark Window ✨
#currentread #lemon8bookclub #Lemon8 #fyplemon8 #explore
sincerely_chrys

sincerely_chrys

11 likes

A hand holds two fantasy books, 'One Dark Window' and 'Two Twisted Crowns' by Rachel Gillig. Handwritten text on the image includes 'Good read.', 'ROMANCE', 'MYSTERY', and 'FANTASY'. A Lemon8 watermark with '@mimistiktokvidz' is visible.
Booktok Review: One Drake Window
I picked up this book after my husband recommended it and because it was everywhere on my feed as a must-read. Here’s my honest take: The story started off slow, with the pace only picking up toward the end of the first book. The second book followed the same pattern. It’s more of a mystery an
Mimi’s Posts

Mimi’s Posts

12 likes

A hand holds the hardcover book "One Dark Window" by Rachel Gillig. The cover features a gothic castle, a figure in red on a bridge, and a smoky element, with text indicating it's a New York Times Bestselling Series.
One dark window🖤
#mydarkdesire was such an amazing book now to get into something darker. I’ve heard such amazing thing about this duet that I even bought the special edition hardcover copies from #barnesandnoble as book trophy’s 🤭 #onedarkwindow #twotwistedcrowns
Sincere🥰👑

Sincere🥰👑

21 likes

The book cover for J.T. Geissinger's 'Pen Pal,' featuring a tattooed man, with a 5/5 star rating and a chili pepper rating, indicating a dark romance novel.
A minimalist graphic for 'Pen Pal' by J.T. Geissinger, detailing its author, dark romance genre, 320 pages, and starring Aidan & Kayla, with a quote and scattered handwritten letters in the background.
A collage featuring handwritten letters, intertwined hands, a ring, and portraits of a woman (Kayla) and a tattooed man (Aidan), representing characters and themes from 'Pen Pal.'
Pen Pal Book Review!
WOW!!! This book was not what I expected! 🤯🤯🤯 What a twist!!! Absolutely loved it! Read it in a days time! Highly recommend reading it! It’s no where near what you think it will be AT ALL!!!!! 5/5⭐️ #penpal #bookrecommendations #BookReview #goodreads #darkromance
Squarebear

Squarebear

851 likes

The book cover for "The Dark One" by Nikki St. Crowe is displayed on a blue floral patterned surface. The cover features a skull-like face with one visible eye and the text "NEVER, NEVER LET HIM CHASE YOU." A Lemon8 watermark with "@bookedbykirstenn" is at the bottom left.
📕📖The Dark One Book Review📖📕
Author: Nikki St. Crowe ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ # of pages 226, Ebook Reading Goal: 13/70 ⚠️Check Trigger Warnings⚠️ Review: This one was sooo good we got to learn more about Vane and watch Winny finally get in. He wanted not to want her, but she finally figured out the key to get him to let her in. Ther
Bookedbykirsten

Bookedbykirsten

2 likes

An e-reader displays the cover of 'One Dark Window' by Rachel Gillig, featuring a dark, gothic illustration with towers and mist. Text overlays read 'Currently Reading' and 'One Dark Window'. The device is on a brown textured surface.
One Dark Window 🌙👑🌫️
Just started reading One Dark Window after finishing Middle of the Night and I’m enjoying it so far! It feels so lyrical at some points it’s very intriguing. Although it is moving quite slow so far i’m interested to see where this goes. Will update later! Have you read this book? #lemon8bookclu
bri ⸆⸉

bri ⸆⸉

15 likes

Immortal Dark Digital Book Review 🧛🏼‍♀️🖤
Digital Book Review Book name: Immortal Dark Author: Tigest Girma Genre: YA/ Dark Academia/ fantasy My rating: 5 ⭐️ #lemon8bookclub #reading #bookrecommemdations #digitalbookreview #bookjournaling
Jthebookworm

Jthebookworm

17 likes

A book review image featuring the cover of "The Knight and the Moth" by Rachel Gillig. The cover shows a woman, half in armor and half in a dress, with moths and flowers. The image includes a quote, a "Book Review" title, and a 4.5-star rating, along with Lemon8 branding.
Book Review 📚
The Knight and the moth ⭐️Overall rating: 4.5/5 I didn't think I was going to be emotionally destroyed by this book but here we are. The beginning was a bit slow, but once you get into the story more it gets so good! I really enjoyed Sibyl's interiority. She grapples with intense top
isla

isla

2 likes

A book titled '14 Ways to Die' by Vincent Ralph, featuring a cover with dried rose petals, '1 Killer. 13 Victims. A Million Views.' and a 20% off sticker. It's presented as a thriller book review with a four-star rating and a cartoon book sticker on a textured blanket.
14 ways to die book review
In “14 Ways to Die,” the gripping narrative follows a young woman named Jess who becomes entangled in the chilling memories of her mother’s unsolved murder. As she navigates the complexities of grief and the pressure of social media fame, Jess decides to confront her past by investigating the circu
🍂🌵Shantel🌿🍄

🍂🌵Shantel🌿🍄

54 likes

A person holds the book "One Dark Window" by Rachel Gillig, featuring a gothic castle, a figure in red, and swirling smoke on its cover. The image is taken inside a car, showing parts of the steering wheel with a Kia logo and car controls. An overlay reads, "Starting the year off with this book."
One Dark Window
Has anyone read this?? #onedarkwindow #lemon8bookclub #books #bookclub #Lemon8Diary
sl.book.ut

sl.book.ut

6 likes

Haunting Adeline by H.D Carlton book review! ❤️‍🔥
Haunting Adeline by H.D. Carlton. Let's talk about it.... ⚠️Trigger warnings for this bad boy are essential. The whole series was some dark scenes that can be triggering.⚠️ Other than that words really can't portray now good this is, haunting Adeline is by far my favorite dark romance. Z
Ke

Ke

36 likes

📖 One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig
✨ Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5/5 🗂 Genre: Fantasy 📚 Vibe: gothic, little spooky, mysterious What it’s about: In a kingdom where magic is forbidden, Elspeth hides a dark secret—a monstrous voice in her head. As she’s drawn into a rebellion, she must navigate deadly magic, eerie forests, and the truth abou
savmarietravel

savmarietravel

6 likes

One Dark Window
Can’t wait to start Two Twisted Crowns #lemon8bookclub #rachelgillig #bookrecommendations #books #BookReview
Books.just.wanna.have.fun

Books.just.wanna.have.fun

7 likes

Book review
Book
Lazylu

Lazylu

1 like

A collage promoting a 5-star book review for 'One Dark Window' by Rachel Gillig, featuring a Kindle, gothic imagery, thorny branches, and text like 'MAGIC COMES WITH A PRICE' and 'BEWARY. BE CLEVER. BE GOOD.' A hand with dark nails and rings is also visible.
Book Review📚 One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig
One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig ⭐ 5/5 Wow. Just wow. I can’t believe I waited so long to pick this up—but better late than never! This book completely captivated me from the very first page and didn’t let go. The writing is stunning, and the story is as dark and mesmerizing as the eerie mist tha
🩷🫧Shea☕️📖🎀

🩷🫧Shea☕️📖🎀

4 likes

The cover of the book 'Knot Magic' by Sarah Bartlett, featuring a dark design with gold lettering and a central knot emblem. Text overlay reads 'Witchy Book Review'.
An open page from the book displaying a 'Magical Association Chart' with categories like Love, Prosperity, and Protection, listing associated deities, planets, elements, colors, crystals, and plants.
An open page detailing the 'Five-knot Enchantment to Attract Romance' spell, including instructions, required items, and an illustration of a braided ribbon with five knots and a crescent moon.
Witchy Book Review
Knot Magic by. Sarah Bartlett This was a books I was truly hoping to get something more out of. Unfortunately, for me, this books just didn’t give me as much as I had hoped it would. With that being said it’s a beautiful book, the illustrations are wonderful and I personally feel like the knots
JustaWitchandHerDog

JustaWitchandHerDog

61 likes

A hand holds the book 'The Butterfly Garden' by Dot Hutchison, featuring a white butterfly on a dark cover. Text overlays read 'Book Review' and 'As someone new into the book world'. Blurred bookshelves are in the background, with a Lemon8 logo.
📖 Book Review: The Butterfly Garden 🦋
Fun Fact: This was the initial book that peaked my interest in reading! If you love dark thrillers with a poetic touch, The Butterfly Garden is definitely a must-read! This chilling yet beautifully written novel follows a twisted collector who keeps “butterflies”—young women trapped in his hidde
𝔹𝕣𝕚𝕥 ♥︎

𝔹𝕣𝕚𝕥 ♥︎

26 likes

One Dark Window - Rachel Gillig
I need to stop procrastinating reading the books I know I’m absolutely going to love. This was so good. I loved the Nightmare. The romance was the perfect amount of slow burn. And who can pass up treason against a tyrant king? I’m excited for book two! 5/5⭐️ #onedarkwindow #theshepherdkingd
Liss.readsbooks📚🐉

Liss.readsbooks📚🐉

7 likes

A book titled "One Dark Window" by Rachel Gillig is displayed on a light-colored surface. The book cover features a dark, gothic design with castle towers and a smoky, red element. Overlaid text reads "my next READ," indicating it's the user's upcoming book. A Lemon8 watermark is visible at the bottom left.
Starting One Dark Window!
What is y’all’s current read? #books #newuser #booktok #rachelgillig #currentread #booklover Random Thoughts 💭What's on my mind: Just finished “Funny Story” by Emily Henry Current Mood: Excited for new read ⭐Rate: TBR
Madison

Madison

13 likes

Two fantasy books, "One Dark Window" and "Two Twisted Crowns" by Rachel Gillig, are displayed with a "BOOK REVIEW" overlay. A review slip shows a 5-star rating and positive notes for the series.
one dark window & two twisted crowns
#lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge #fantasybookreview #bookrecommendations #bookrevieweroflemon8
Hays 🤎

Hays 🤎

8 likes

A hand holds a tablet displaying a book review ticket for 'Two Twisted Crowns' by Rachel Gillig, rated 5 stars. The ticket notes it's 'Part 2 to One Dark Window' and 'A book I wish I could read again.' A bookshelf is in the background. Text overlays read 'BOOK REVIEW' and 'Reading enriches the mind.'
Book Review🖤🥀
⭐️Overall rating: 5/5 Book name: Two Twisted Crowns Author: Rachel Gillig Genre: Gothic Fantasy My review: I absolutely adored this duology. It’s easily my top reads of 2024 so far! This second book had a number of unexpected moments for me and lord have mercy Elm… can I get him on Amazon or s
Alex🍒

Alex🍒

8 likes

🌟Book Review🌟
💜Hello Bestie! I hope you are having a wonderful Sunday morning! It’s spring break for our household so lots of spring chores lie ahead! We are planting our first ever veggie garden this year 😬 so we are doing a lot of prep to get it ready for planting! I’ve never had a garden before so hopefully I
bestiejais_reads

bestiejais_reads

0 likes

Anime: One Piece ☠️ Book: One Dark Window 📖
When I'm trying to read and watch One Piece at the same time doesn't work but I can't stop watching or reading 🙃 #Anime #onepieceanime #book #onedarkwindow
Alba 🎃

Alba 🎃

15 likes

The cover of Niki Smith's graphic novel, 'The Deep & Dark Blue,' featuring two characters, one in a blue dress and one in a white shirt. Text overlays highlight it as a 'gorgeous fantasy' with a 'Trans protagonist' and '256 pages' for a book review.
Book Review: The Deep and Dark Blue
📖 Book: The Deep and Dark Blue by Niki Smith 📚 Genere: YA Fantasy Adventure, graphic novel 🌈 LGBTQ rep: Transgender main character. Story is hinges her positive transition and the support she receives. 🎭 Story: Two young boys are forced into hiding by a tragedy. They find sanctuary in an all-w
AmoodyBun

AmoodyBun

2 likes

A book review image featuring the cover of 'One Dark Window' by Rachel Gillig, rated 4/5. The cover shows a dark castle scene with a figure on a bridge. Overlay text reads 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW'. The background consists of stacked books, and the image includes the Lemon8 logo and user handle.
One Dark Window
“One Dark Window" by Rachel Gillig is a dark and atmospheric fantasy novel set in a world shrouded by mist and ruled by ancient magic. The story follows Elspeth Spindle, a young woman who harbors a dangerous spirit within her, granting her mysterious powers. As she navigates a treacherous w
Adrienne Marie

Adrienne Marie

2 likes

A smiling woman holds up the book "Knight and the Moth" by Rachel Gillig, a Barnes & Noble exclusive edition, in front of a bookshelf. Text overlay reads "book review time!".
A hand holds the "Knight and the Moth" book, highlighting its cover. Text overlays describe it as "gothic fantasy," "enemies to lovers," "first book of a duology," "duty meets desire," and "yearning."
A close-up of the "Knight and the Moth" book shows its decorative sprayed edges. Text overlays praise its "great world building," "interesting premise," and the "gargoyle" character, with five stars indicating a 5-star rating.
the PERFECT romantasy book for fall! ⚔️✨🍁
BOOK REVIEW TIME! i first fell in love with rachel gillig when she released “One Dark Window” and was immediately hooked on her writing and the way she can build a gothic and whimsical feel in her book. so when this book was announced, i was SO EXCITED! going into this book, i did have high
Grace 📚💖

Grace 📚💖

20 likes

A person holds the book 'Here Lies a Vengeful Bitch' by Codie Crowley, featuring a tombstone on its cover. An overlay reads 'BOOK REVIEW', and a Lemon8 BookClub ticket shows a 4-star rating and notes about the fast-paced murder mystery with ghoulish characters.
BOOK REVIEW: Here Lies a Vengeful Bitch ❤️
Book Review: Here Lies a Vengeful Bitch by Codie Crowley 📚 Just finished Here Lies a Vengeful Bitch, and wow, what a ride! This book was super fast-paced and kept me hooked from start to finish—I devoured it in just three days. 😍 The story was full of twists, and I loved the fierce energy of the
Mirielys

Mirielys

21 likes

A book cover for 'Love Letters to a Serial Killer' by Tasha Coryell, featuring a pink background and cut-out letters. Overlays indicate a 'Thriller Romance Book Review!' with 4 stars and a 'SWIPE' prompt.
love letters to a serial killer: book review 💌
“Love Letters to a Serial Killer” by Tasha Coryell is a captivating blend of romance and suspense that keeps readers hooked from the start. The unique premise of a woman exchanging letters with a convicted serial killer adds an intriguing layer to the narrative. Coryell expertly explores themes of
🍂🌵Shantel🌿🍄

🍂🌵Shantel🌿🍄

43 likes

See more